Facebook Ordered To Turn Over User Info

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Trolling is all fun and games until the courts order Facebook to hand over your info to the people you were trolling. :eek:

A spokesman for Facebook said: "There is no place for harassment on Facebook, but unfortunately a small minority of malicious individuals exist online, just as they do offline. "We respect our legal obligations and work with law enforcement to ensure that such people are brought to justice."
 
whoops! Did Facebook accidently send the whole user database instead of just the trollers?

Yeah, this isn't a good precedent. I agree that the trolling is bad and I dislike it and I feel sorry for the woman/victim, but handing over the IPs and basic identities...? I just don't think that's a good road to go down.
 
All this over X-factor? Seriously? The person did creepily chase after her from forum to forum though. What exactly are you going to do to this person legally? Take their computer away? Give him/her a fine? Given that this troll is stupid and will likely be found, but now she's become a troll magnet. There are people who are smart enough to troll without being caught, and they love publicity.

Best course of action would be to always play it safe. Lock down your Facebook by changing your privacy settings. Forum abuse will be handled by moderators. Ignoring trolls is always the best course of action. They seek attention.
 
whoops! Did Facebook accidently send the whole user database instead of just the trollers?

Yeah, this isn't a good precedent. I agree that the trolling is bad and I dislike it and I feel sorry for the woman/victim, but handing over the IPs and basic identities...? I just don't think that's a good road to go down.

Haw, why is this a bad thing? Its called joining the 21st century, and the laws are finally catching up with the internet

If you send somebody a harassing mail or phone call, you can be arrested for it, why should sending a harassing email or page message be any different?

Internet trolls have been fairly safe up to this point, mostly because up until now it was hard to get users info online, and sending court orders for IP addresses was a complete pain in the ass

Now its easy peasy, and trolls are crying outrage cause you are taking away their toys.

I'm not saying you are a troll, but I don't defend these peoples actions, and its about time they started getting busted on them
 
Haw, why is this a bad thing? Its called joining the 21st century, and the laws are finally catching up with the internet

If you send somebody a harassing mail or phone call, you can be arrested for it, why should sending a harassing email or page message be any different?

Internet trolls have been fairly safe up to this point, mostly because up until now it was hard to get users info online, and sending court orders for IP addresses was a complete pain in the ass

Now its easy peasy, and trolls are crying outrage cause you are taking away their toys.

I'm not saying you are a troll, but I don't defend these peoples actions, and its about time they started getting busted on them

What the FUCK are you smoking? If I call someone a fattie, does that constitute legal troubles? Only on the internet apparently. People like you need help :rolleyes:
 
"Don't feed the trolls." Sue them instead. Teach them that it isn't acceptable thing to do. This isn't someone posting a stupid comment to "troll" people into responding, this is someone going well beyond anything that most people would even consider "for the lulz."

I can understand being anonymous on the internet for, let us say, reporting to the media since information is classified or protecting the names of minors. I cannot understand the same protections being extended to trolls that go out of their way and beyond all scope to be malicious jerks.
 
Huge difference between calling someone a fattie and claiming they're a pedophile. So I have to ask did you read the article? She said she liked someone on Xfactor. For that people accused her of heinous crimes and created a false site to harass her and others.

I am glad that people that cross the line on the internet are being called on it. These pussies would not dare to do something like this in real life, but give them the illusion of anonymity and they go bat shit insane.

I am sick and tired of people refusing to recognize simple courtesy because they think they can get away with it.
 
What the FUCK are you smoking? If I call someone a fattie, does that constitute legal troubles? Only on the internet apparently. People like you need help :rolleyes:

I believe he meant only people who persistently harass others or stalk them online should have any sort of recourse. Not people who throw out a random insult here or there.
 
What the FUCK are you smoking? If I call someone a fattie, does that constitute legal troubles? Only on the internet apparently. People like you need help :rolleyes:

Did you even read the article? This was well beyond and nothing remotely close to someone being called "fattie." There is a threshold bewteen talking smack and slander, and in the words of Justice Potter Stewart, "I know it when I see it."
 
Did you even read the article? This was well beyond and nothing remotely close to someone being called "fattie." There is a threshold bewteen talking smack and slander, and in the words of Justice Potter Stewart, "I know it when I see it."

Yes everyone - I DID read the article. The article is about trolling. Trolling is undefined in that there is no line drawn other than pissing someone off on the internet. I can piss someone off by saying LeBron James is the worst player in the NBA. People get butt-hurt over everything these days.

There is a simple question - WHERE DO YOU DRAW THE LINE as to what is illegal and what is not? Calling someone a pedo vs. calling them a fattie is no different. It's an INSULT. Pedophile would be no different than calling someone gay since both have to do with sexuality.

Nevertheless, this is why the US is a nation of pussies... worrying SOOOO much if someone gets their feelings hurt... Someone call the WAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAMBULANCE!
 
It's a VERY amazing concept of... UNPLUGGING your computer. Crazy concept, I know! :rolleyes:
 
Facebook, Google and other major internet companies receive subpoenas weekly (if not daily) from city, state and federal law enforcement and the courts. Additionally, stupid stuff you do can come up in searches later by private investigators hired by future employers, ex-wives, etc.. Teh internets has the same rules as real life.

(And: harrassing wimmenz is lame.)
 
What the FUCK are you smoking? If I call someone a fattie, does that constitute legal troubles? Only on the internet apparently. People like you need help :rolleyes:

It does if you follow that same person about everywhere and keep calling them abusive names.
 
It does if you follow that same person about everywhere and keep calling them abusive names.

Following people on the internet... You really need some help :rolleyes:

Stay at home mother isn't surprising either. Besides the Maury show, what else is she do other than Facebook all day?!?!?!?!?!??!? OH NOEZ!!!
 
Yes everyone - I DID read the article. The article is about trolling. Trolling is undefined in that there is no line drawn other than pissing someone off on the internet. I can piss someone off by saying LeBron James is the worst player in the NBA. People get butt-hurt over everything these days.

There is a simple question - WHERE DO YOU DRAW THE LINE as to what is illegal and what is not? Calling someone a pedo vs. calling them a fattie is no different. It's an INSULT. Pedophile would be no different than calling someone gay since both have to do with sexuality.

Nevertheless, this is why the US is a nation of pussies... worrying SOOOO much if someone gets their feelings hurt... Someone call the WAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAMBULANCE!

You know you come across as an immature jerk when you spout stuff like this. If its not ok to post something in the newspaper or on a billboard you should not be putting it on the internet. I am sure that is what most of us are saying.

I don't care if you disagree with me, I don't care if you want to be an asshole about it. But if you think you can say and do things on the net that you are not legally aloud to irl then you are about to receive a real wake up call.
 
Yes everyone - I DID read the article..this is why the US is a nation of pussies...

Actually, this particular event is happening across the pond in the UK, not the US. You should go read the article.
 
You know you come across as an immature jerk when you spout stuff like this. If its not ok to post something in the newspaper or on a billboard you should not be putting it on the internet. I am sure that is what most of us are saying.

I don't care if you disagree with me, I don't care if you want to be an asshole about it. But if you think you can say and do things on the net that you are not legally aloud to irl then you are about to receive a real wake up call.

...That's the point Mr. Coolio. You ARE allowed to say those things in real life. You aren't yelling "FIRE!" in a crowded theater. The fact that people read them online and get depressed and commit suicide doesn't make it illegal.
 
IMO the line WAS crossed when (according to the article) they created a fake profile in her name, and used it to send shit to girls. Sounds to me like the troll is the pedophile not her. Using the identity of another person to act out some perverse pedo urges. Im all for privacy and freedom of speech and what not, but I would wanting legal recourse as well if somebody was risking my personal safety like that.
 
She said she suffered a barrage of abuse and one online bully created a fake profile in her name, which was used to send explicit messages to girls.

This seems more like identity theft or something than simple trolling, and I can see why they went this route.
 
Honestly, I have no real problem with Facebook or anyone else giving the info out in cases like these where someone is being defamed or stalked.

There is a simple question - WHERE DO YOU DRAW THE LINE as to what is illegal and what is not? Calling someone a pedo vs. calling them a fattie is no different. It's an INSULT.

Go look up the definition of libel/slander. That should answer your questions. There IS a difference and can get you sued.
 
...That's the point Mr. Coolio. You ARE allowed to say those things in real life. You aren't yelling "FIRE!" in a crowded theater. The fact that people read them online and get depressed and commit suicide doesn't make it illegal.

I now see you are being deliberately obtuse (that means you are acting stupid on purpose). This is not about trolling this is about harassment (I know big word) and in this case the person (or troll) should not receive protection from prosecution. See when you troll you don't have to be abusive or foul you can also do it thru belittlement, feel better now?
 
Wow, fail troll is fail. You must be used to forums where you can edit posts.

...That's the point Mr. Coolio. You ARE allowed to say those things in real life. You aren't yelling "FIRE!" in a crowded theater. The fact that people read them online and get depressed and commit suicide doesn't make it illegal.

Defamation—also called calumny, vilification, traducement, slander (for transitory statements), and libel (for written, broadcast, or otherwise published words)—is the communication of a statement that makes a claim, expressly stated or implied to be factual, that may give an individual, business, product, group, government, or nation a negative image. This can be also any disparaging statement made by one person about another, which is communicated or published, whether true or false, depending on legal state. In Common Law it is usually a requirement that this claim be false and that the publication is communicated to someone other than the person defamed (the claimant).
 
Lines were crossed, yet anyone with brains would've been behind 7 proxies...
 
I don't know; these laws applying to the Internet rub me the wrong way for reasons which aren't clear to me. I have a bad feeling about enforcing this kind of thing.
 
best advice- get off the damn computer, go do some garden work, learn how to cook something new.

or post on hardforum.

there is a ton of shit you can do instead of facebook.
 
Yes everyone - I DID read the article. The article is about trolling. Trolling is undefined in that there is no line drawn other than pissing someone off on the internet. I can piss someone off by saying LeBron James is the worst player in the NBA. People get butt-hurt over everything these days.

There is a simple question - WHERE DO YOU DRAW THE LINE as to what is illegal and what is not? Calling someone a pedo vs. calling them a fattie is no different. It's an INSULT. Pedophile would be no different than calling someone gay since both have to do with sexuality.

Nevertheless, this is why the US is a nation of pussies... worrying SOOOO much if someone gets their feelings hurt... Someone call the WAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAMBULANCE!

Wow, can we say idiot anyone? They didn't call her a pedo, they setup a facebook profile IN HER NAME and then sent lewd messages to young girls, basically portraying her AS a pedophile! Read the damn article and not glance at it next you twat.

The line was crossed when it becomes targeted harassment. I could call you a twat faced brainless idiot on here and its just name calling. But if I were to follow you to other forums you visit and start stuff, create a hardforum account with your info and post really nasty stuff, then it becomes targeted harassment, which people should be held accountable for.
 
Back
Top