Microsoft to Botmasters: Abandon Your Inboxes

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
In its ongoing effort to crush botnets into the dirt, Microsoft has employed a variety of tactics, which apparently now includes subpoenaing Google for the crook's info. :eek:

  • Hello,

    Google has received a subpoena for information related to your Google account in a case entitled Microsoft Corp., FS-ISAC, Inc. and NACHA v. John Does 1-39 et al., US District Court, Northern District of California, 1:12-cv-01335 (SJ-RLM) (Internal Ref. No. 224623).

    To comply with the law, unless you provide us with a copy of a motion
    to quash the subpoena (or other formal objection filed in court) via
    email at google-legal-support@google.com by 5pm Pacific Time on May 22, 2012, Google may provide responsive documents on this date.
 
I hope people read the entire article because it's not clear that Microsoft's actions are going to be helpful long-term and may in fact be harmful.
 
Summarizing the article:

MSFT has leaked information that was being shared among trusted groups working with law enforcement to get to the sources.

A couple things have happened in response to this: the information has been leaked, sinkholes have been compromised, and the potential offenders have been notified that their information is being sought after.


I'll construct an analogy that may help understand some of the negative repercussions:
let's say your next door neighbor is dealing dope
your DEA buddy comes divulges to you that he understands your concern over why the police aren't acting immediately but to be patient because they're currently ferreting out the entire cartel's network.
After a year, you get tired of waiting and take the information you know and file a civil case against your neighbor.

you successfully obtain an injunction against the neighbor dealing dope but the suppliers flee the country because they were tipped off by the subpoenas that were sent out. I hope it's clear why law enforcement may not appreciate what you did.


As an aside, the article points out that much of the information MSFT used in their filings was outdated. It's a point that people concerned about privacy and the government might want to consider.
 
In order for him to file an injunction, he would need to come forward. Jon Doe cant file injunctions! Sure he can fight it, but only by giving up his identity. Something MS clearly WANTS. Maybe MS wants him to fight it?
 
Since my analogy wasn't very helpful to you I encourage you to read the entire article.
 
In order for him to file an injunction, he would need to come forward. Jon Doe cant file injunctions! Sure he can fight it, but only by giving up his identity. Something MS clearly WANTS. Maybe MS wants him to fight it?

Actually you can file a motion to quash a subpoena anonymously.
 
Summarizing the article:

MSFT has leaked information that was being shared among trusted groups working with law enforcement to get to the sources.

A couple things have happened in response to this: the information has been leaked, sinkholes have been compromised, and the potential offenders have been notified that their information is being sought after.


I'll construct an analogy that may help understand some of the negative repercussions:
let's say your next door neighbor is dealing dope
your DEA buddy comes divulges to you that he understands your concern over why the police aren't acting immediately but to be patient because they're currently ferreting out the entire cartel's network.
After a year, you get tired of waiting and take the information you know and file a civil case against your neighbor.

you successfully obtain an injunction against the neighbor dealing dope but the suppliers flee the country because they were tipped off by the subpoenas that were sent out. I hope it's clear why law enforcement may not appreciate what you did.


As an aside, the article points out that much of the information MSFT used in their filings was outdated. It's a point that people concerned about privacy and the government might want to consider.

You are missing the big picture. Litigation encourages (for better or worse) stricter terms and conditions and self-policing. If Microsoft is doing such a terrible, anti-civil injustice, then Google should fight tooth-and-nail and never let the subpoena even get to the end-user.
 
If they fight the subpoena, they're outed. If they don't want to be outed, they jump ship out of fear and have to abandon the botnet until they can set it up again from somewhere else. If Google obstructs then Microsoft can paint them as supporting the botnet operators and then involve law enforcement. Google doesn't want that kind of publicity, so Google is more than likely going to cooperate with Microsoft. Microsoft comes out looking like the good guy for a change, and if the botnets start shutting themselves down to dodge scrutiny then it's still achieving the desired goal of fewer botnets - all without involving taxpayer dollars. It's a brilliant strategy. :)
 
a brilliant strategy?

it's a PR move, that part of your statement is true.

in terms of actually reducing botnets it's a horrible strategy
 
Summarizing the article:

MSFT has leaked information that was being shared among trusted groups working with law enforcement to get to the sources.

A couple things have happened in response to this: the information has been leaked, sinkholes have been compromised, and the potential offenders have been notified that their information is being sought after.


I'll construct an analogy that may help understand some of the negative repercussions:
let's say your next door neighbor is dealing dope
your DEA buddy comes divulges to you that he understands your concern over why the police aren't acting immediately but to be patient because they're currently ferreting out the entire cartel's network.
After a year, you get tired of waiting and take the information you know and file a civil case against your neighbor.

you successfully obtain an injunction against the neighbor dealing dope but the suppliers flee the country because they were tipped off by the subpoenas that were sent out. I hope it's clear why law enforcement may not appreciate what you did.


As an aside, the article points out that much of the information MSFT used in their filings was outdated. It's a point that people concerned about privacy and the government might want to consider.

Yeah, right, as if the police are actually working at anything. Cops are nothing but bullies given some legitimacy with badges. In fact, they are no different in most actions than street gangs. They push around good people for fun while leaving other bullies alone.

Like it or not, the police, FBI, or any other federal or state agency have not done squat about any botnets. Oh, sure, they've pushed around a few low level "hackers", but where are the real hackers? The ones that made the fake anti-virus programs? The ones that made the botnets? The ones who extorted millions from people holding their computers hostage? The ones who stole millions using stolen credit cards? They're allowed to run free. I have yet to see an arrest related to any of these things, but they sure do arrest people for defacing the CIA's public web site.
 
perhaps the reason you "have yet to see any arrests" is because you won't bother to read the article.

if you did, you'd see that the ringleaders responsible for the botnets in this topic are currently serving time in prison based on the evidence that was gathered long before MSFT used it to file the civil suit.


I know it's difficult to comprehend but when I wrote "summarize the article" that meant I was relaying the information contained *in* the article because I suspected (correctly) that no one would bother clicking on it before commenting.

You guys realize the reason these news headings get posted here is to drive traffic through the site? click on the damn links every so often ffs!
 
Back
Top