Mozilla to Kill Firefox 3.6 by Auto-Upgrading Old Browser

CommanderFrank

Cat Can't Scratch It
Joined
May 9, 2000
Messages
75,399
If you are still clinging to the 3.6 version of the Firefox Browser, get ready for a surprise in early May. Firefox will be switching you over to Firefox 12 automatically. Although this shouldn’t come as a complete surprise to any 3.6 user, undoubtedly there will still be some confusion when the switch takes place.

Mozilla has given Firefox 3.6 users plenty of warning, telling them several times over the last months that they need to upgrade because of the impending retirement.
 
Heh, my machine at werk is still on 3.6...wonder if IT locked the version or not.
 
When I used FF 3.6, I never got 'auto' upgraded to anything. Everything was selected by me after I read what it did. The same way I update windows. So I'm not entirely certain how they're gonna be forcing people to update. Maybe I had a setting changed on it, and hopefully anyone that's still using it and wants to knows about that setting. Can't be too hard, though. I figured it out.
 
From what I've seen in past threads, the reason people stick with 3.6 is two-fold: the interface changed with version 4, and some people just can't abide interface change (these are the sort of people that force Windows 7 to look like Win98); certain plug-ins do not work post-3.6. Can't do anything about the first category. I don't care too much about the second category; using Firefox 12 I do not feel the lack of whatever those plug-ins might be.
 
Why are so many people sticking with 3.6?

Unlike Chrome and IE, Firefox is can be heavily customised via extensions, about:config, userChrome.css and userContent.css. While Mozilla have totally messed up the default Firefox UI, I've had no problems getting everything back to how I like it.

Since it can be so easily customised to your preferences, I don't understand why people are sticking with 3.6. Is there something I'm missing?
 
I'm sure everyone has a reason for keeping old software around, even if it's lame. But with something as security critical as a web browser, it's pretty much essential to upgrade at least periodically. There's no excuse.
 
There is only one place I stick with 3.6 and for that place I open up a crap ton of tabs (sometimes over 200) and leave the browser open for days. Since 4 and up this can no longer be done without tricks like loading the tab on focus only. AT work I can still leave it up for weeks but at home, there seems to be a memory leak and it crashes about every other day.


This one place I have 3.6 I do not want to have an issue with. I need to look for ways to stop this change over.
 
Older versions of firefox were terrible with memory the newer versions are much better at not going crazy with using memory.
 
I always disable auto updates. I rather do updates at my own leisure, not be forced into it when I'm in the middle of something or I just rebooted and badly need to check something NOW not in 10 minutes.

That said there's not not much danger to upgrading from 3.6. Most extensions should work by now, or at least work in an earlier version like 10. I always lag a few versions behind to ensure the extensions I use got coded/fixed to work in the next version.
 
Older versions of firefox were terrible with memory the newer versions are much better at not going crazy with using memory.

Actually now that you mention it, that's true. Mine is "only" using 148MB and has been opened for a few days. Normally it would be using like 500MB by now. They still need to work on it, but it's definitely getting better.
 
FF 4 and above does not scale with high windows DPI settings. To use 12, I set the layout.css.devPixelsPer setting to 2. Also at 125% dpi and above with full screen flash like youtube the taskbar stays on top and covers part of the video. To fix this, I had to disable ignore DPI setting in FF under the compatibility tab since FF doesn't listen to that setting anyways. Then to make it look like 3.6, I loaded an aero theme. Then add ghostery, adblock plus, noscript, my homepage, https-everywhere, super start, and donottrackplus. Seems to be working fine now, but the stock browser is a piece of shit.
 
Actually now that you mention it, that's true. Mine is "only" using 148MB and has been opened for a few days. Normally it would be using like 500MB by now. They still need to work on it, but it's definitely getting better.

Only 500MB? When I leave FF running on my laptop (~150 tabs open), the memory usage creeps up to about 3GB after a while, at which point the browser is so sluggish I have to close it then re-open. And that's JUST firefox.exe...plugin-container goes for another 300-500MB and I don't have that many plug-ins installed. :(
 
I never understood why they didn't auto-upgrade people from 3.6 to 4. They had people do a manual upgrade or something, which of course almost nobody did.
 
There is only one place I stick with 3.6 and for that place I open up a crap ton of tabs (sometimes over 200) and leave the browser open for days. Since 4 and up this can no longer be done without tricks like loading the tab on focus only. AT work I can still leave it up for weeks but at home, there seems to be a memory leak and it crashes about every other day.
The "Don't load tabs until selected" setting seems to be the default now, so you don't have to configure anything. I haven't noticed any memory leak since version 7 or so, I also tend to leave Firefox and Windows running 24/7 without rebooting.

I am on the x64 nightly build since last year (it's at version 15 now,) so I have to reboot Firefox almost every day for the self-updates and can't really tell how Firefox fares on a long session. I wish they'd switch the main build to x64 and reserve the x32 build for like the enterprise ESR or some other compatibility build. The nightlies are a great way to check a few months ahead if your sites and add-ons will still be working and report issues or fix the problem preventively.

I like the nightly very much, although there's the occasional bug, like some display issues a few weeks back, and currently some Google Reader disconnect issue, but it might have nothing to do with Firefox, investigating...
 
Only 500MB? When I leave FF running on my laptop (~150 tabs open), the memory usage creeps up to about 3GB after a while, at which point the browser is so sluggish I have to close it then re-open. And that's JUST firefox.exe...plugin-container goes for another 300-500MB and I don't have that many plug-ins installed. :(

Oh yes if I had it open for like a week (even with a few tabs or only one) it would eventually make it into the GB range. The issue with FF is when you close a tab it does not actually release the memory. At least, it did not. Now I think it may release it or at least most of it.

When I played Evony it was worse, it would only take a few hours to get into the GB range. I only have 4GB, or more like 3.5GB as that is XP's limit.
 
I've been using nosquint to solve the 125% dpi issue. But some sites nosquint doesn't scale the video sizes.
 
Oh yes if I had it open for like a week (even with a few tabs or only one) it would eventually make it into the GB range. The issue with FF is when you close a tab it does not actually release the memory. At least, it did not. Now I think it may release it or at least most of it.

When I played Evony it was worse, it would only take a few hours to get into the GB range. I only have 4GB, or more like 3.5GB as that is XP's limit.

It only takes 6 or so hours before memory usages has crept up over 2GB. Once it's past ~2.5GB, I have to close FF because it lags in response. Guess I'll have to dig up a FF optimization guide once I get an SSD drive in my laptop and clean install everything. Running 7 Home Premium 64-bit with 8 GB RAM.
 
Kaplan uses a video plugin that doesn't work with any newer version of IE, Chrome, or Firefox. Firefox 3.6 is the only browser I've been able to use that actually works. I have IE9, is there a way to install an earlier version of IE after it has been upgraded? Granted I hardly ever use the videos (I wish my school would stop buying us all subscriptions).
 
FF3.6 needs to be 'retired' why? was Mozilla actively doing ANYTHING with it? Plugins don't work? Oh no!! Guess I'll just use the same plugins that do work that really don't need to be upgraded at all.

I'll probably be uninstalling firefox sometime in May
 
FF3.6 needs to be 'retired' why? was Mozilla actively doing ANYTHING with it? Plugins don't work? Oh no!! Guess I'll just use the same plugins that do work that really don't need to be upgraded at all.

I'll probably be uninstalling firefox sometime in May

Here, let me fix that for you :

IE6 needs to be 'retired' why?

Ok, I am putting words in your mouth, but there you go. Browser is an evolving piece of software. If you want to use the latest web standards - you have to upgrade. Things will soon start breaking for you otherwise.

People who think that they can stick with an old browser make the whole web experience much less pleasant for everyone. It is hard to accommodate older browsers. I work as a web developer, "fixing" websites for older browsers is horribly painful.
 
Ok, I am putting words in your mouth, but there you go. Browser is an evolving piece of software. If you want to use the latest web standards - you have to upgrade. Things will soon start breaking for you otherwise.

People who think that they can stick with an old browser make the whole web experience much less pleasant for everyone. It is hard to accommodate older browsers. I work as a web developer, "fixing" websites for older browsers is horribly painful.

Then here's what you do, you let those people who use the old standards fade away as the web standards evolve, you don't force them to change my forcibly changing their software for them. When I NEED to upgrade then I will. Developers don't need to fix website for old browsers at all, they simply have a load screen that says "Your current browser doesn't... etc"

I'm not saying make things work for my browser I just don't want some third party remotely removing my software whatever that software might be.

Also kind of hard to buy the "need to upgrade to..." mantra when Mozilla is upgrading their software every 2000 nanoseconds.
 
Why are so many people sticking with 3.6?

Unlike Chrome and IE, Firefox is can be heavily customised via extensions, about:config, userChrome.css and userContent.css. While Mozilla have totally messed up the default Firefox UI, I've had no problems getting everything back to how I like it.

Since it can be so easily customised to your preferences, I don't understand why people are sticking with 3.6. Is there something I'm missing?

For me 3.6 was the last good version they did, ever since moving to this quick release cycle to follow chrome FF has gone to crap.
 
Then here's what you do, you let those people who use the old standards fade away as the web standards evolve, you don't force them to change my forcibly changing their software for them. When I NEED to upgrade then I will. Developers don't need to fix website for old browsers at all, they simply have a load screen that says "Your current browser doesn't... etc"

I'm not saying make things work for my browser I just don't want some third party remotely removing my software whatever that software might be.

Also kind of hard to buy the "need to upgrade to..." mantra when Mozilla is upgrading their software every 2000 nanoseconds.

That's not how it works.

If I am given a website to make, almost all of the time the requirement is to make the website work in IE7. That means that 99% of the time I have to employ hacks to make the website work the way that it should.

I can't just say "I can't do it" or display an annoying message to all IE7 users (which is a hack in itself, as targeting browsers should neither be relied upon nor used).

Browsers don't just fade away into abyss.

I am picking on IE7 as it's the currently the worst major (desktop) browser that websites still have to work on. Firefox 3.6 is a whole lot better, but it doesn't change the fact that it's starting to show it's age.

If you don't like the new look - well, simply choose another browser. Or make your new browser look like your old browser. Or assimilate and join the new pack of users.

I support what Mozilla is doing. Kill the dinosaur.
 
That's not how it works.

If I am given a website to make, almost all of the time the requirement is to make the website work in IE7. That means that 99% of the time I have to employ hacks to make the website work the way that it should.

I can't just say "I can't do it" or display an annoying message to all IE7 users (which is a hack in itself, as targeting browsers should neither be relied upon nor used).

Browsers don't just fade away into abyss.
Wait a minute so "you" as a programmer can't write for the latest browsers because that'd be excluding browsers that presumably a very large portion of your users still use.

But it's ok for a company to forcibly delete software on your system and exchange it for new software? Why does one group of programmers get to make the call but another not?

Also. sounds awfully trojan like to change files on your computer without your consent. Hell even windows allows you to turn off auto-updates.
 
My biggest dislike with FF4+ is that you can no longer state how long it remembers links to websites you visited. Normally this wouldn't be a horrible thing, however using my work laptop at home can lead to certain websites I'd rather not accidentally press a letter and it thinks it knows what I want.

"I hit A and up pops asian anal gangbang... can't Google at least let me type a few letters"
 
My biggest dislike with FF4+ is that you can no longer state how long it remembers links to websites you visited. Normally this wouldn't be a horrible thing, however using my work laptop at home can lead to certain websites I'd rather not accidentally press a letter and it thinks it knows what I want.

"I hit A and up pops asian anal gangbang... can't Google at least let me type a few letters"

Incognito/private browsing mode, dude, both Chrome and Firefox have supported this for a while now.
 
I would agree with retiring it. But the old FF while uses a hell lot of ram, it doesn't crash on me like the new FF does.
 
I'm still using old firefox because I simply haven't had the need to upgrade. I tried 4 when it first came out and didn't really like it. Have tried a couple of the newer ones on other PCs (work and laptop) but they seem more crash prone than 3.6, so I've just stuck with it. Up until now they've been releasing security updates for it.

I'll swap to something newer now that I'm being forced, not sure what yet. Might give IE another shot.
 
I still use 3.6.24
the browser game I play allows me to use GM scripts which dont work in 4.0
now the game is updating soon and my scripts wont work so until then I will stick with 3.6
 
How?

Simplest question ever. I'm a Chrome guy but I've fiddled around with the latest versions of FF and I gotta say, I'm pretty impressed (I jumped the FF ship around 3.0.x... FF was a mess!)

I would agree with retiring it. But the old FF while uses a hell lot of ram, it doesn't crash on me like the new FF does.

crashing, slow to open flash and pdf files more often than not compared to chrome and IE. i cant say i have really used vs 11 much, tried it for about 2 weeks and ditched it after it crashed for me often or just hung across 3 different computers.
 
Excuse me, but what gives them the right to modify someone's computer without their permission ?
 
Excuse me, but what gives them the right to modify someone's computer without their permission ?
The fact that you checked the box "Keep Firefox updated to the latest version" (whatever its name) or left it set as default?
You can uncheck that setting if you don't like it.
 
Wait a minute so "you" as a programmer can't write for the latest browsers because that'd be excluding browsers that presumably a very large portion of your users still use.

Well, that depends on how much time and money you have to accommodate older browsers. That's what it boils down to.

But it's ok for a company to forcibly delete software on your system and exchange it for new software?

It's their software. Not yours. They can do whatever they want with it, as long as it's legal and in their EULA.

This is not very different from an auto upgrade feature.

Why does one group of programmers get to make the call but another not?
Also. sounds awfully trojan like to change files on your computer without your consent. Hell even windows allows you to turn off auto-updates.

Again, Firefox is Mozilla's property.
If Mozilla removed Chrome from your computer, then we would have a problem. Not in this case.
 
Again, Firefox is Mozilla's property.
If Mozilla removed Chrome from your computer, then we would have a problem. Not in this case.
I guess you have a point, however people would still have a problem with it. Similar to when GM destroyed all their EV1 electric cars, and did so by forcibly repossessing them. They were leased cars, not bought, but they squished every last one of them.
 
Then here's what you do, you let those people who use the old standards fade away as the web standards evolve, you don't force them to change my forcibly changing their software for them. When I NEED to upgrade then I will. Developers don't need to fix website for old browsers at all, they simply have a load screen that says "Your current browser doesn't... etc"

I'm not saying make things work for my browser I just don't want some third party remotely removing my software whatever that software might be.

Also kind of hard to buy the "need to upgrade to..." mantra when Mozilla is upgrading their software every 2000 nanoseconds.

i am glad they do it because of "possible" people like you (if you do in fact stick with old version) who use old software that is a security risk that can further infect others because you refuse to keep software up to date and secure.

this is why MS is forcing upgrades as well... is anyone whining about goolge updates that you dont even know happen?
 
Back
Top