Apple CEO: I Prefer to Settle Lawsuits

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Wait, did Apple's CEO just say he's rather work things out versus a legal battle? Wow, talk about being the complete opposite of his predecessor. I like this guy. :cool:

Apple CEO Tim Cook said he is interested in settling patent lawsuits, as long as everyone "invents their own stuff." "I would highly prefer to settle than to battle," he said. "But it's important that Apple not become the developer for the world. We need people to invent their own stuff."
 
I can't until the [H]'ers here have a field day with his quote: "We need people to invent their own stuff."

*steps back, and opens floodgate*
 
So basicly he's saying Apple will stop copying others as well? I guess hell just froze over!
 
Well if your company is based around taking other people's ideas and making them their own (after putting a shiny glass coating on it), then yeah, the statement "We need people to invent their own stuff." is extremely important to Apple. Without other people inventing new stuff, Apple won't be able to steal it and "innovate" themselves.
 
Apple recently lost a patent lawsuit to Motorola relating to the iCloud services in Germany. Maybe this current CEO just prefers not to take a beating once in awhile?
 
What's comical about this is that all these quotes are meant to fool the dumbest people in our society. Intelligent people would realize that smartphones weren't invented by either Apple or Google. Sure they may make MINOR refinements, but the core functionality was pre-existing to both companies. Only a moron would claim "Apple came out with the first smartphone" or "Apple Invented the smartphone", or the same about Android (which you rarely see).

Apple created a false market perception by initially releasing their phone at a grossly overpriced value of $500/600 on-contract for their phones. Thus presenting the image of "If you have an iPhone, you're rich". Then they dropped the price due to competition, but were able to retain their elite status. That's Apple's invention... marketing that makes people feel richer by owning one of their devices.
 
I can't until the [H]'ers here have a field day with his quote: "We need people to invent their own stuff."

*steps back, and opens floodgate*

See, without saying anything, you know that this is Pandora's Box when it comes to Apple inventing their own stuff. :)

I'm not going to make a comment about it, as much as I'd like to. I really want to, though.... ZIP!

Glad that Tim Cook is not for litigation, but even with Jobs at the helm, he liked to "settle" with things that he knew he couldn't win in court (San Fran "cops" searching apartment for stolen iPhone, etc.). I think that it is coming down to "Can we buy you?". Money doesn't solve anything. The law is there to protect everyone, you can't just buy people that get in your way (well, you can if you're the mob). Doesn't work well for the inventors or the consumer.

Seems like another way to strong arm the competition...
 
What's comical about this is that all these quotes are meant to fool the dumbest people in our society. Intelligent people would realize that smartphones weren't invented by either Apple or Google. Sure they may make MINOR refinements, but the core functionality was pre-existing to both companies. Only a moron would claim "Apple came out with the first smartphone" or "Apple Invented the smartphone", or the same about Android (which you rarely see).

Apple created a false market perception by initially releasing their phone at a grossly overpriced value of $500/600 on-contract for their phones. Thus presenting the image of "If you have an iPhone, you're rich". Then they dropped the price due to competition, but were able to retain their elite status. That's Apple's invention... marketing that makes people feel richer by owning one of their devices.

Personally, even though the SmartPhone was out before it, Blackberry really invented and refined the smartphone market (Crackberry). They didn't evolve, leading to the iPhone and Android gaining the foothold in the market. I won't mention Microsoft, as Windows Mobile was a SmartPhone, but like Blackberry didn't evolve until late in the game (WP7, which is amazing).
 
As for the quote by Tim Cook, I think that is just a smokescreen. It doesn't mean he won't litigate any less than Jobs, he is just saying he likes to settle. Even under Jobs, Apple settled quite a few court cases. You only really settle 'after' litigation starts. And most of their strategy to get companies to settle is to constantly sue and countersue. So really there is still a ton of litigation happening.

Personally, even though the SmartPhone was out before it, Blackberry really invented and refined the smartphone market (Crackberry). They didn't evolve, leading to the iPhone and Android gaining the foothold in the market. I won't mention Microsoft, as Windows Mobile was a SmartPhone, but like Blackberry didn't evolve until late in the game (WP7, which is amazing).

Depends on what you consider evolving? Both Microsoft and Blackberry came out with newer versions, changed things, modified. In fact Microsoft had changed quite a bit over the years in the mobile market. The iPhone wasn't as much of an 'evolution' as it was made out to be. They just trumped it up as one since it was an 'Apple' product.
 
All he's really trying to do is make Apple out to be the victim when they're actually the bully here. "I didn't want to fight, but they just kept running into my fist!! Look at the bruises on my fist! Look!"

I'm sure that this was carefully scripted and Apple's recent high profile losses in court are directly related.
 
I can't until the [H]'ers here have a field day with his quote: "We need people to invent their own stuff."

*steps back, and opens floodgate*

So Samsung are in the clear then, since they are the only company that can manufacture the screen, processor, and memory technology Apple use.
 
I'm pretty tired of all of these patent wars. Our patent system is so screwed up. I really don't see patents as creating incentive to innovate anymore. Instead they just seem to reward trying to patent obvious things which is funny because one of the requirements for getting a patent is that it is non-obvious.
 
All he's really trying to do is make Apple out to be the victim when they're actually the bully here. "I didn't want to fight, but they just kept running into my fist!! Look at the bruises on my fist! Look!"

I'm sure that this was carefully scripted and Apple's recent high profile losses in court are directly related.
I think Apple realizes that like parents with 2 whiny kids in the backseat claiming "he started it", that nobody cares, and that both kids are annoying. So Apple's just trying to get in one last shot claiming "I invented the smartphone, and I'm not the bad guy who's trying to sue everyone into oblivion". Obviously this isn't true, but as with all marketing, the truth doesn't matter. All that matters is public perception, and if you tell a lie enough times, commoners believe it's the truth.

So just more from Apple's amazing marketing team, who will never be questioned by the media, at least as long as their stock continues to rise. God help them once their stock bubble bursts... there'll be a ton of stories about how it was all a charade, and it was always overvalued, etc.
 
I think Apple realizes that like parents with 2 whiny kids in the backseat claiming "he started it", that nobody cares, and that both kids are annoying. So Apple's just trying to get in one last shot claiming "I invented the smartphone, and I'm not the bad guy who's trying to sue everyone into oblivion". Obviously this isn't true, but as with all marketing, the truth doesn't matter. All that matters is public perception, and if you tell a lie enough times, commoners believe it's the truth.

So just more from Apple's amazing marketing team, who will never be questioned by the media, at least as long as their stock continues to rise. God help them once their stock bubble bursts... there'll be a ton of stories about how it was all a charade, and it was always overvalued, etc.

Don't forget the antitrust suits that Apple is involved in either... Right now, there are the staff poaching one and the e-book pricing one. There is also the embarrassing story about the blogger (Seattle Rex) that sued them and won for the Nvidia card issue (which they admitted it would cost them nothing to fix). Even Time picked up that story! For all we know, Tim Cook could only be referencing those.

Yeah, I think it partly has to do with advertising dollars. Ever notice how all of the blogs that defend Apple vigorously run Apple ads and always post launch day reviews?
 
Sounds like what Google's been doing. Buy everyone out versus fighting legal battles.
 
Which means he will drive Apple into the ground.

I liked it when Steve Jobs was around. RIP:rolleyes:
 
Apple recently lost a patent lawsuit to Motorola relating to the iCloud services in Germany. Maybe this current CEO just prefers not to take a beating once in awhile?

My interpretation of his statement: "We're gonna get our ass kicked. So we're gonna play nice now."
 
The iPhone wasn't as much of an 'evolution' as it was made out to be. They just trumped it up as one since it was an 'Apple' product.

Of course it was just an evolution. It was made possible by brand spanking new hardware. Just because they were the first to ship a product built on someone else's hardware innovation doesn't make their contribution revolutionary as well. And it's always easier to launch a new platform and OS for a radically new piece of hardware than to try and figure out how to rework an existing one. That's a big reason Apple and Google could so quickly pick up the new tech, and RIM, Palm, and Microsoft could not.

And to be clear I'm not saying that the iPhone was bad or anything, Apple made a spectacularly good feature phone. I am instead saying that I believe phones of today would be very similar even if there wasn't an iPhone. It's not like companies were looking at capacitive touch screens and thinking to themselves "nah, we'll keep this small, shitty resistive screen with a stylus". Apple has really good timing and really good polish. The UI interactions themselves are all pretty natural extensions of a touch-based interface, and most (if not all) of them already existed years before, just with one-off hardware prototypes, not something that could be mass produced.
 
Back
Top