Violent Video Games Alter Brain Function in Young Men

Long term effects - 1 week study.
Long term means different things in the contexts of different fields. Unless there's a neurologist here to question it, it's not fair for any of us to.

While the test wasn't very thorough and there's plenty of other variables to consider, it's not like the report says playing violent video games makes you more violent. It just says that it decreases activity in certain areas of the brain (whether it's due to the violence of the games, difficulty of the games or game playing in general, we don't know) which is what they found.

It's a little sad that people on this forum are immediately defensive and attack the researchers, when they really didn't make any controversial statements. It was a small, limited study and they just posted what they found. If you immediately crucify everyone who runs early experiments, you'll never get anywhere. The goal of scientific research is not always practical application, as discoveries are rarely the result of deliberate attempts to find them.
 
While the most obvious application of the study is to send people into war (rather than, or supplemented with the drugs they're already given), it could also be used to take people out of war and ween them back into normal brain function.

And playing video games really is distinct from watching movies or reading books. It's an interactive media, which is why playing video games is often better for you than watching TV.
 
I am confused...

Based on the abstract the results seem to indicate increased brain capability in the gamers. They used less of their brain to complete the same task. How is that a negative result?

Either the abstract is poorly written and incomplete, or this is a positive thing for violent gaming.

Also, this is totally wrong:

"This investigation provides the first longitudinal, experimental investigation of video game play on brain activity."

There have been other such investigations before, so this isn't the first. And also it isn't a study of video game play on brain activity. By their own admission it is a study of violent video game play on brain activity. Sorry, but if you can't write a half-decent abstract then why would anyone care about the results of your work?
 
It's a little sad that people on this forum are immediately defensive and attack the researchers, when they really didn't make any controversial statements. It was a small, limited study and they just posted what they found. If you immediately crucify everyone who runs early experiments, you'll never get anywhere. The goal of scientific research is not always practical application, as discoveries are rarely the result of deliberate attempts to find them.

If it's still early, they should not post results to make any claim. Yet they still seem to have done so. If you do so, you should be prepared to be met with speculation on your research.

Two weeks, in a study that mention behavioral changes is pretty ridiculous. While I don't doubt there are events that might impose such changes quickly, video is definitely not one of them, or else we'd either know that it doesn't affects someone at all, or if we'd need to build more insane asylums and prisons. Way too many people have played violent games, including myself and many others here I'm sure, that hasn't been in prison yet.

Not saying this forum is majority of the world... but I would like to think there are a fair amount here to use as a statistic.
 
While the most obvious application of the study is to send people into war (rather than, or supplemented with the drugs they're already given), it could also be used to take people out of war and ween them back into normal brain function.

...different issues. Much more complex issues coming from military service.

IF anything, it'd be more applicable to study inmates coming back into "normal" society. (...and yes, I have personal experience with both to make the connection.)
 
I have no douts that game change us mentally. Does anyone here see a chest and not want to open it? Or an even more specific example, how many of you mmo players out there have a healthy dose of skepticism? Coming from EVE online, I can say that the first thing i think of whenever there is a business deal being discussed is ' who is screwing who'. I get that totally from the EVE playerbase(and it drives my accounting teacher nuts).

One thing game do not do is make the players violent, the evidence in almost all the studies point to a difference in means which is below the standard error(in almost all cases).
 
These studies reek of slection bias, and even if there is no bias, 22 subjects? Really? You need about 220,000 randomly-selected subjects that are representative of the general public to even come close to being statistically valid.

"Fail study is fail."
 
What crap research. So why didn't they also test a group playing non violent games?
Also its known video games are addictive, what affect would going cold turkey from other addictive activities have on these brain functions.....makes me wonder how these supposed experts get their qualifications...are just awarded like perks in modern warfare?
 
What crap research. So why didn't they also test a group playing non violent games?
Also its known video games are addictive, what affect would going cold turkey from other addictive activities have on these brain functions.....makes me wonder how these supposed experts get their qualifications...are just awarded like perks in modern warfare?

The research seems to have been paid for by this group: http://www.sosparents.org/

Draw your own conclusion :).
 
"These findings indicate that violent video game play has a long-term effect on brain functioning," Dr. Wang said.

That's it. That's all they found. That's their results. It's not negative, it's not positive, it's "we observed a change". That's it.

And honestly, who the fuck cares?
 
I want a large government grant to research how large of a research grant can be frivolously wasted on an unmeritable research project, and then another grant to disprove the conclusion of my research, ad infinitum. :D
 
Who is to say this is a bad thing? I would actually argue that certain fps's with friendly fire on would make one more judicious of who is friend and who is foe.

Everyone hates a team killer so they get eradicated quickly in a real war scenario.

More power to the FPS players if it makes them more efficient at understanding right and wrong of combat.

DO KILL YOUR ENEMY

DON'T KILL YOUR TEAMMATES

DO UNDERSTAND YOUR ENEMY

DON'T SHOW ANY SIGNS OF WEAKNESS.

hmmm I'd say these are all positive values. The negative values are when these break down and dumb#^#$^ who break the rules of killing teammates show up IRL. Post traumatic stress disorder shows up too but not for a video game mostly.

When it does, its dumbshits usually blaming a game because they would of done it anyway. It's rare to see it actually precipitate from too much game time.

Usually fate is kind enough to kill those ones with blood clots in their legs.

How do I know all of this? My dad was a Vietnam vet. He saw it first hand, I learned it from him. Besides, it's built into basic training for marines. The toughest badasses out there.

Keep fragging guys until you become tired of it!
 
For large populations, certainly, but your professor would be wrong if he tried to apply that to every statistic; not every population is going to be in the thousands, or even hundreds.

Your sample size is a function of population you wish to infer upon and confidence level (i.e. how repeatable the results are). If your population is the number of middle-aged men who drive Daewoo's, the number of kids at a day care, or the number of blonde women at your workplace, then you can easily come up with a satisfactory sample size that needn't be in the thousands to be accurate.

Agreed, But still, the lower the population the increased chance of coincidence.
 
It's a little sad that people on this forum are immediately defensive and attack the researchers, when they really didn't make any controversial statements. It was a small, limited study and they just posted what they found. If you immediately crucify everyone who runs early experiments, you'll never get anywhere. The goal of scientific research is not always practical application, as discoveries are rarely the result of deliberate attempts to find them.

This study wasn't done by a bunch of well-meaning scientists that got together and said "Hey lets research this and see what we find... you know, for science." It was funded by a group that has an axe to grind when it comes to video games and they are looking to get the results they paid for.
 
This study wasn't done by a bunch of well-meaning scientists that got together and said "Hey lets research this and see what we find... you know, for science." It was funded by a group that has an axe to grind when it comes to video games and they are looking to get the results they paid for.

F--k them I say. The strong will survive, the weak shall die. That is the natural order of things. When people start screwing with it, bad things happen.
 
Faux science until all these people doing these gaming studies also include TV and books in to the mix.

I guarantee that books will by far stimulate the brain and desensitize a 22 year old the most.
 
But I'm skewed horribly. Combat is in my blood for many generations. Not just Vietnam-Oh no. I had a southern general that disagreed with stonewall Jackson. We all know how that turned out. Thankfully my father and myself are far better at strategy.
 
Video games fill the violence and killing void we have. Shit, our ancestors got to participate in it all the time.
 
But I'm skewed horribly. Combat is in my blood for many generations. Not just Vietnam-Oh no. I had a southern general that disagreed with stonewall Jackson. We all know how that turned out. Thankfully my father and myself are far better at strategy.

Burn them yanks, then fire up a vat o grits!
 
Back
Top