Getting new switches for an office

V4705

n00b
Joined
Jan 12, 2011
Messages
60
Hi.
We have 2 offices next to each other, for the same company.
One side is with the internet router, servers and around 30 users.
The other side is with around 50 users.

Right now I have 2 switches,
HP J9088A on the first office, and Netgear JFS524 connected to it, on the 2nd office.

I'm pretty sure both of them are 10/100, and I'm planning to use an Active directory server with roaming profiles, and Quickbooks enterprise database for all users. So I think I need gigabit lan in this office.

a. Am I right? do I really need gigabit lan?
b. Which switches do you think I need? I don't want to spend more money than I have to. I don't know if I need "managed" switch or something else, I just need to get the most lower cost that will work good for us.


Thanks!
 
Well here's the way I see it.

Your backbone across your network is running 100 Mbit

Your users are all connecting at 100 Mbit

Your servers are connected at 100 Mbit

Option 1..... Change it all out

Change everything to gigabit. All the NIC cards on all the machines that are 10/100 an both switches.


Option 2.... Upgrade one switch

Which will allow you to: Upgrade the backbone, upgrade any important connection to gigabit.




My suggestion is buying this: HP V1810-48G Switch (J9660A) or something like this: PowerConnect 2848

Place the new switch at the side with the internet router, servers and the 30 users. Connect the old HP J9088A via its 1000baseT connection to the V1810-48G switch. This will provide a gigabit pipe to the second switch with the possibility of improving performance for the users of the old switch by a max of x 10.

Instead of 30 users connected via 100 Mbit....trying to all talk through a 100 Mbit pipe, they would be 30 users connected via 100 Mbit ....all talking through a 1 Gigabit pipe.

Make sure that your servers are using decent Intel branded 1000baseT cards, preferably PCIe if possible. Also make sure your gigabit cabling is all cat5e minimum.



To do option 1, just buy (2) of the switches listed above.

With as many ports and users you have, I would recommend having a simple managed switch. To drop the cost more is going to require sacrifices that arn't worth the small savings.
 
Last edited:
Without more information, no one can answer your question. Active Directory is not a bandwidth intensive application, roaming profiles could be, depending on usage.

With roaming profiles, your users will be downloading their profile every time they logon. Some applications will store a LOT of data in that profile. My desktop PC has a local profile, it's over 10GB. If that's your situation, you'll find that GigE isn't your problem. When those 80 users walk in on Monday morning and login, your real problem will be the server not being fast enough to serve up all those profiles from a disk perspective.

Quickbooks enterprise, again, possibly, depends on usage, this is something you'd want to talk to quickbooks about.

What you really should do is gather some current stats. Use perfmon on your server and log a days worth of network activity. What is the peak? Setup a pilot with roaming profiles for 1/2 a dozen users and see what happens when they logon/off. Remember the longer you use a system, the more junk fills your profile, so your pilot day 1 stats will almost certainly be far different than pilot day 30.

From a business perspective however, $1200 to get gig to every PC isn't a bad investment. If it means all your users login just 1 minute faster, you pay for your new switches in 3 weeks. From a CYA perspective, if your performance suffers, you point out that you bought the fastest connection commonly available for desktops.

P.S. as long as you're buying 2 gig switches, connect them together with 2 gig links in a trunk
 
Thanks for the answers,
a. The problem with roaming profiles from the server side should be fine, we're getting a new server just for SBS (AD/Exchange).
b. I do want gigabit lan for every PC, this company grows fast and I would like to fix problems before they happen.
c. What is "2 gig links in a trunk"? every switch support that? what technically should I do?


Thanks!
 
Thanks for the answers,

c. What is "2 gig links in a trunk"? every switch support that? what technically should I do?


Thanks!

Not every switch supports (link aggregation) aka "2+ gig links in the trunk"

Buy (2) of the switches I recommended above. Both models supports link aggregation, but I do recommend staying with one brand or another.
 
c. What is "2 gig links in a trunk"? every switch support that? what technically should I do?
Thanks!

A 2GB trunk means you are bonding 2 1GB interfaces together on the switch to increase bandwidth throughput. Usually for linking 2 switches together at the backbone, or to a server to increase bandwidth for users.

You should be looking to use LACP for your trunks, but remember that not all switches support link aggregation.

HP V1810-x series switches are nice, but if you are looking for a true fully managed layer 2 switch I would look at Procurve E2510G-x switches or Dell Powerconnect 54xx switches. They stack (meaning that one switch commands all the others, allowing for things like spanning vlans) and will provide a more robust backbone to your network. However you go from looking at switches that are $300 a pop to switches that are $800 a pop.
 
Depending on how fast you expect this company to grow, and cash at hand I'm going to have to agree with C7J0yc3.

There's nothing wrong with 2x V1810s. Its just going to mean a going into (2) interfaces to program them instead of one; which depending on what you are doing could be a bit annoying.

But in your original post you said:

"I don't want to spend more money than I have to"


So now were down to: What defines "have to"?
 
Last edited:
Thanks, I contacted dell reseller next to me, I think 2x 2848 will be good enough for us.
 
I really like the Procurve's. They're not the cheapest but they aren't overly expensive and they come with a lifetime warranty.

An added bonus is that if you need to find guides on doing stuff from the CLI you'll usually find it for Cisco and Procurve but less so IME for Dell.
 
I really like the Procurve's. They're not the cheapest but they aren't overly expensive and they come with a lifetime warranty.

Just so you all know. THIS IS NOT TRUE ANYMORE!

HP is only giving its limited lifetime warranty to E series and up fixed and modular port switches from now on. The V series (14xx 17xx 18xx 19xx) now have a 3 year limited warranty. This started Q4 2010.

The 2848 is an excellent switch, and is just a trimmed down 5448 (they now have full serial and CLI management). I have a 2816 at home, and was quite surprised to see the improvement over the 27xx series.
 
Active directory server with roaming profile


make sure you use server 2008, it allows only files changed to be moved over for profiles, unlike 2003 and before it would literally copy your entire profile back and forth, 2008 it only copies what has changed.

Using roaming profiles with folder redirections is a better way to go.
 
1. About wiring, on our cables it says: berk-tek 24 awg cmp/mpp *ul) esa fcc ft6/ft4 lan-tek tm lan grade ieee 802.3 10base-t etl verified lvl 3 16 mbs 132854.
And there are 8 cables inside.
Do I need to replace all the wiring before upgrading the switches?
I actually not sure what all the "codes" means but "10base-t" and "16 mbs" sounds like it won't support gigabit lan :/



2. About folder redirection, I'm going to use SBS 2011 and if I remember correctly it's based on 2008 r2, but I would love to hear more about the difference between "regular" roaming folders and roaming with folder redirection.


Thanks again!
 
Yuck, that cable is ancient. Throw it away ASAP. I agree with jeffmoss - ETL Verified Lvl3 sounds a lot like Category 3, and anything that's old enough to list the Token Ring speed rating is _ooold_.
 
level 3 16mbs ??!?

Could that be 16mb token ring? I doubt very much that will support gig speed.
 
I'd just use CAT6. The 1910 is due for replacement in the next 3 years with the 1920 series.

The warranty will change then.
 
Back
Top