Iceland Unveils Crowd Sourced Constitution

CommanderFrank

Cat Can't Scratch It
Joined
May 9, 2000
Messages
75,399
In what is a first among nations, Iceland will have a constitution that is written entirely by its own citizens on the internet. The proposed draft of the constitution was put up on its own website and suggestions for additions and deletions were made via Facebook, Twitter and other websites until it was decided upon and presented to Iceland’s Parliament.

Iceland’s original constitution was created in 1944 when the country gained independence from Denmark. The country’s economic collapse in 2008 prompted calls for a rewrite with checks and balances to prevent a repeat of the financial crisis.
 
Hope it works out for them...God knows it'd be a disaster in the states.

Imagine if our Constitution was a semi-protected article on Wikipedia.

I can't decide if it would be total chaos or actually good for the country.
 
This will be an interesting experiment to watch, though. In response to an economic crisis, will people embrace rational free-market principles? Or will they just draft themselves a totalitarian government that bans everything anyone possibly thinks could have contributed to the crisis.
 
I love the idea of direct democracy. Until I actually think about the people I know on facebook and twitter...then I'm absolutely sure it would be a catastrophe.
 
Sorry, it wouldn't work here -- too many idiots with internet access in the states. However, I'm interested in seeing how this works out for them.
 
Well, if I understand it right, they're asking for ideas/things written up, then they decide what to put into it. So presumably the idiots/trolls/etc would be ignored.
 
I love the idea of direct democracy. Until I actually think about the people I know on facebook and twitter...then I'm absolutely sure it would be a catastrophe.

Agreed, though I have to say that the politicians in office, are just like those people, main difference being that they have the remarkable gift of raising funds for their campaign.
 
"For the People, By the People".

Wasn't there another country that held up that phrase?
 
Our Constitution is just a rag the CFR puppets in Washington wipe there ass with.
 
This will be an interesting experiment to watch, though. In response to an economic crisis, will people embrace rational free-market principles? Or will they just draft themselves a totalitarian government that bans everything anyone possibly thinks could have contributed to the crisis.

Well.. given that the main thing that contributed to their particular crisis was an utterly free market for the banking system, I'm picturing something a bit heavy handed. That and the countryside being strip mined by Alcoa due to loose mining regulation...
 
Well.. given that the main thing that contributed to their particular crisis was an utterly free market for the banking system, I'm picturing something a bit heavy handed. That and the countryside being strip mined by Alcoa due to loose mining regulation...

This is the socialist view, the main thing that contributed to the crisis was too much regulation and the countryside could use a lot more strip mining.

However this constitution is a sham and will never be accepted, note that the leftist group, that wrote it was elected by a 30% turnout in an election that was later ruled illegal by the supreme court, the leftist government later ignored this ruling and so the draft looks more like a manifesto of a left wing party than a constitution.

The constitution was open for debate on the internet, it was not written on it and the ideas that have been expressed so far about it there have been more or less ignored. This was just a PR stunt.

Thankfully these changes will most likely never be accepted, since a new parliament has to ratify it and polls show that the new leftist government will not be in power again any time soon.
 
This is the socialist view, the main thing that contributed to the crisis was too much regulation and the countryside could use a lot more strip mining.
.

not+sure+if+serious.jpg


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2008–2011_Icelandic_financial_crisis
 
Iceland rocks... I met some Icelanders once and they were awesome... I hope this help makes their country an even better place
 
In response to an economic crisis, will people embrace rational free-market principles?
The free market is only rational in principle, in reality the free market is anything but rational which is why A) you can make money in the stock/futures/forex markets and B) we are in the mess we are currently in.

Iceland rocks... I met some Icelanders once and they were awesome... I hope this help makes their country an even better place
So based on you meeting some Icelanders you are making a judgement about their country and whether it was a good place to begin with? My guess is that your statement doesn't even make sense to you now that you get to read over it again. Sucks to not be able to edit, eh?
 
Direct democracies by definition are mob rule.
I know that, but he said "open", not "direct". I'm curious where he gets the idea that having public input in lawmaking results in mob rule.

And the news story is about openness, not voting. They are taking suggestions from the public, not tallying votes.
 
I know that, but he said "open", not "direct". I'm curious where he gets the idea that having public input in lawmaking results in mob rule.

And the news story is about openness, not voting. They are taking suggestions from the public, not tallying votes.

Probably just another case of "did not read the article, formed own hysterical opinion, posted". Public input on laws can be good. As long as it doesn't result in heavy handed collectivism.
 
Back
Top