The GNOME Desktop Project Released

CommanderFrank

Cat Can't Scratch It
Joined
May 9, 2000
Messages
75,399
After almost five years in the making, GNOME 3 has been released. The newly streamlined version will support smaller computing platforms like netbooks and tablets and offers many new improvements.

"Perhaps the most notable part of the design process is that everything has been done in the open. We've had full transparency for every decision (good and bad) and every change we've made. We strongly believe in this model."
 
"full transparency" ha!

More like "we let you watch in horror as we made really stupid UI decisions. And listen? LALALALALALALA I can't hear you. LALALALALALALA" :p

The interface does have some slick functionality, but it is horrid in the first 3 release. Ars did a nice review recently.
 
The Gnome update was enough to get me to stop bothering with keeping my distro up to date. For my server, I switched to xfce. It's a clusterfuck.
 
"The biggest change is the most visible: The new GNOME desktop."

Yeah, visuals were always Gnome's forte. Duh...


gnome_gnome3_final2.png
 
This newest desktop just screams of going completely overboard in trying to be like Apple. Removal of the minimize buttons, reduction of the settings screen to what basically amounts to "idiot mode," a taskbar and jumbo-sized icon view that look lifted straight from iOS, and on and on.

For wanting so hard to be "not Apple," it sure looks like that is where the Linux community is headed.
 
I've use (and am currently employed using it) Linux since the early nineties, and I'm disappointed with where things have gone with both Gnome 3 and KDE 4. They're both unusable in my opinion. Maybe it's because they're pretty far from the paradigm I'm used to, but I don't care honestly. I've switched to XFCE, and won't be going back if KDE and GNOME continue down the road they're both on.
 
I've use (and am currently employed using it) Linux since the early nineties, and I'm disappointed with where things have gone with both Gnome 3 and KDE 4. They're both unusable in my opinion. Maybe it's because they're pretty far from the paradigm I'm used to, but I don't care honestly. I've switched to XFCE, and won't be going back if KDE and GNOME continue down the road they're both on.

That's the general consensus I hear from Linux hardcores, that both GNOME and KDE have taken large strides to appeal the the mainstream and so lost their roots. It's odd too, because that kind of change is what gets you all the market share you so desperately desire. It's like you all have a love/hate relationship with the consumerization of Linux.

Myself, I don't care since all I use Linux for is servers and the only Linux interface I know is bash. :)
 
I like how it looks...but when are they going to get rid of the pixelated "rounded" corners of the windows in the default GNOME and KDE configs? I mean everything else is so smooth and streamlined...why the rounded corners with no alpha blending? I hate having to depend on Emerald or Compiz to get the job done.
 
I havn't used KDE or Gnome in years.... if I wanted my desktop to look like windows, i'd boot windows. e16, and now e17 for me, tho I do like how xfce looks too and might give it a try.
 
Fascinating. Now if you can do everything without having to enter a single word of command, linux may actually have a future in the mainstream outside of nerdsville.
 
Fascinating. Now if you can do everything without having to enter a single word of command, linux may actually have a future in the mainstream outside of nerdsville.

Never gonna happen ;) :p

All I can say is "Looks nice... not switching back."

Never really liked Gnome to begin with, I always used KDE, though I dont like the new KDE, I may try xfce...
 
Fascinating. Now if you can do everything without having to enter a single word of command, linux may actually have a future in the mainstream outside of nerdsville.
Nice concept, but the stack comes in many pieces. The GUI is often only a thin veneer over the guts. With package managers and well stocked default software repositories, average users don't have to get their hands dirty at all. Beyond that it can get very messy.

For example, if in say 2011 you do something dumb like have a Wireless-N network and "supported out of the box" Intel wifi NIC. The frustration over lack of basic tools like a control panel t check device settings (not connection settings) come into play when you're trying to figure out why you can see but not connect to the network. Luckily, many people will have reported the problem, many other people will respond with incorrect solutions (usually ways that wipe the system, which will do nothing to fix it, or things that can make fixing the problem harder) and finally you'll dig up a real solution. The solution in my example was that some pinhead thought it was best to disable wireless-N connections by default on the Intel Wireless N series of adapters. :rolleyes: Manual editing of the config file in some random place fixed it.

Apple has really shown how a Unix can be made friendly, as easy or easier to use as Windows.
 
Apple has really shown how a Unix can be made friendly, as easy or easier to use as Windows.

That is the result of them, as you put it, piecing together the stack better. Apple has a large stake in tons of FOSS projects because they extensively modify them to work together for Apple better. The GNU tools you find under the hood of Mac OS (things like PHP, Samba, etc.) are all many releases behind, because Apple places priority on making sure it works with the full stack instead of updating for the sake of updateing. Unlike Linux distros, Apple also isn't afraid to roll their own piece if there isn't a suitable free solution, the best example being X.org being completely inadequate in the 21st century and they rightfully dumped.

Of course Apple draws hate for doing just this. A Linux hardcore wouldn't dream of running Samba 3.4.12 when 3.5.9alpha1 is available, and what respectable Linux distro doesn't use the X window system, why that's just heresy!
 
Back
Top