Apple Store Security Will Shoot You

maybe its because i live in canada where you really can't carry guns around, especially security at a store like that....but killing a thief over this? just seems so wrong. not saying he should have gotten away with theft but killing him? weather intentional or not that seems excessive.

I kind of willing to bet that he killed him for shooting at him first. Most likely scenario:

-Guard unexpectedly sees intruders
-Intruders start shooting at him
-He uses his own weapon to successfully defend his own life
-We debate how screwed up California is

In Canada:

-Guard unexpectedly sees intruders
-Intruders start shooting at him
-Guard dies, intruders get away
-Media blames the guns for the guards death
 
maybe its because i live in canada where you really can't carry guns around, especially security at a store like that....but killing a thief over this? just seems so wrong. not saying he should have gotten away with theft but killing him? weather intentional or not that seems excessive.

Excessive? So it's excessive to want a bad person who is trying to take your life to die instead of an average citizen?

You should sign a waiver and give it to your local law enforcement so they don't have to risk their lives trying to save you should any criminal ever decide to shoot at you with the intent of ending your life as that would be excessive to kill someone trying to kill you.
 
maybe its because i live in canada where you really can't carry guns around, especially security at a store like that....but killing a thief over this? just seems so wrong. not saying he should have gotten away with theft but killing him? weather intentional or not that seems excessive.

It is too bad that a security guard in Canada can't carry a firearm as that pretty much makes them worthless as security. If you say well he could have pepper spray etc an armed suspect would make him look like a kitten.

I think the point your missing is "multiple armed subjects" taking things by force with threats. I think that pretty well summarizes when it is viable to use deadly force and if not then when?
 
It is too bad that a security guard in Canada can't carry a firearm as that pretty much makes them worthless as security. If you say well he could have pepper spray etc an armed suspect would make him look like a kitten.

I think the point your missing is "multiple armed subjects" taking things by force with threats. I think that pretty well summarizes when it is viable to use deadly force and if not then when?

My local campus security has assault rifles and sub-machine guns (in a gun cage, they don't carry them around). Crazy how different it is 100 miles from the border.
 
a shootout over ipads?? just let the crooks go. Not worth getting shot or putting bystanders at risk.
 
"An armed robbery of an Apple Store is theft. Clean and simple. It's smash and grab. It ain't no different than smashing a window at Tiffany's."

Hm.
 
tbh if anyone shoots at me first (guard or not) I'm firing back as many controlled rounds as I can with intent to kill. I don't care they were some Ipads or not, the guard certainly didn't pull out his gun and shoot 40 rounds and these idiots. If he did that's fine, a prison he goes but as was stated earlier the most likely scenario is that he was fired upon first. The driver died in the parking lot so they certainly were not speeding away down the street.

If anyone here is questioning the response of the guard after being fired upon first (if indeed that is what happened) even when they are fleeing (in the parking lot :rolleyes:) then that is in my mind why this country is going down the shitter. It again reminds of the "And then I broke his jaw" thread.
 
This is a start at least. Im sure there were plenty more humans in the apple store, also more worried about their image and monetary objects vs understanding how technology actually works.
 
How do you get 35 out of that? Are you just counting the states that don't have a codified Castle Doctrine?
only 15 states have a castle doctrine with a no-retreat necessary requirements outside of your home, there are 50 states total, you do the math. Other have castle doctrine with no-retreat necessary but only inside the home. However castle doctrine usually doesn't allow you to shoot a retreating assailant, so that's why you say he wasn't retreating, he just wasn't facing you when you shot him.

Now with gunfire being fired back and forth I'm sure rules change, the guy is actually a security guard who's job it is to protect an area not just some random joe off the street, so I"m not sure how rules differ in cases like that. But if a police officer shot a guy in the back as he ran away he'd be in deep shit.
 
As for who shot first, all of the news articles describe a "Han Shot First" scenario - the guard shot his first round in response to the crook drawing a gun. That's a clean shoot in my book.
 
-Guard unexpectedly sees intruders
-Intruders start shooting at him
-He uses his own weapon to successfully defend his own life
-We debate how screwed up California is
Some corrections, he used his own weapon to defend his, and other people's lives most likely.

And no one debates how screwed up California is, they just instantly declare it is :)
 
Was the store even open for business at 6:15 AM?

In Texas, for concealed carry:

http://www.txdps.state.tx.us/internetforms/Forms/CHL-16.pdf
Subch. C. PROTECTION OF PERSONS
PC §9.31. SELF-DEFENSE. (a) Except as provided in Subsection
(b), a person is justified in using force against another when and to the
degree the actor reasonably believes the force is immediately necessary
to protect the actor against the other's use or attempted use of
unlawful force. The actor's belief that the force was immediately
necessary as described by this subsection is presumed to be reasonable
if the actor:
(1) knew or had reason to believe that the person against whom
the force was used:
(A) unlawfully and with force entered, or was attempting to
enter unlawfully and with force, the actor's occupied habitation, vehicle,
or place of business or employment;

Hmmm...I'll take (a) Alex.

If the store was open (really? at 6:15AM?) then go here:
PC §9.32. DEADLY FORCE IN DEFENSE OF PERSON.
or here:
PC §9.33. DEFENSE OF THIRD PERSON.

you can also go out on the lawn and protect your property:
PC §9.42. DEADLY FORCE TO PROTECT PROPERTY.

What's the fuss over? Answer this: who was breaking the law...the folks performing the smash and grab? Or the guard...?
 
I never even seen a mall cop/security guard carry a gun.
 
only 15 states have a castle doctrine with a no-retreat necessary requirements outside of your home, there are 50 states total, you do the math. Other have castle doctrine with no-retreat necessary but only inside the home. However castle doctrine usually doesn't allow you to shoot a retreating assailant, so that's why you say he wasn't retreating, he just wasn't facing you when you shot him.

Now with gunfire being fired back and forth I'm sure rules change, the guy is actually a security guard who's job it is to protect an area not just some random joe off the street, so I"m not sure how rules differ in cases like that. But if a police officer shot a guy in the back as he ran away he'd be in deep shit.

I like when they expanded Tennessee's protection laws to basically say "You can blast any person who threatens you or enters the 3 foot space around your person". They don't even have to be hostile, if a kid runs up smiling and wants to borrow a dollar.. you can pull out your Colt 45 and punch a hole in him. One stipulation to all this, if you use an unregistered firearm, even in self defense inside your own home, you are automatically treated as a felon, e.g. a guy breaks in your house with a gun and you get in a shootout and injure him. Cops show up. Arrest him for burglary and check his gun, it's registered so just burglary given the shootout. Check your gun, not registered, arrest you for assault with a deadly weapon and/or attempted murder. Carrying or using an unregistered weapon counts as a felony so using said weapon means you committed an act in the process of committing a felony .. therefore screwed.
 
I like when they expanded Tennessee's protection laws to basically say "You can blast any person who threatens you or enters the 3 foot space around your person". They don't even have to be hostile, if a kid runs up smiling and wants to borrow a dollar.. you can pull out your Colt 45 and punch a hole in him. One stipulation to all this, if you use an unregistered firearm, even in self defense inside your own home, you are automatically treated as a felon, e.g. a guy breaks in your house with a gun and you get in a shootout and injure him. Cops show up. Arrest him for burglary and check his gun, it's registered so just burglary given the shootout. Check your gun, not registered, arrest you for assault with a deadly weapon and/or attempted murder. Carrying or using an unregistered weapon counts as a felony so using said weapon means you committed an act in the process of committing a felony .. therefore screwed.

Colt 45 is a beverage not a gun.
 
bonus points for the head shot, probably played COD

He worked at an Apple store, and if he is also an Apple user then he just got the original Half Life like 3 weeks ago, forget about COD! :D


However, if you arrange things so that you are standing in the road as they escape toward you, then you can shoot them. They're threatening you with a deadly weapon - the car - after all.

Actually in NY you would still be charged since you should/count have retreated to a safe area.

Remember in NY if I break into your house and while carrying your tv out I trip over your coffee table and break my leg your liable for my injury.


Okay, the chain of events both of these reports is not especially clear. Were they shooting from the car? Was the car heading towards or away from the guard? Need more info before condemning the guard, but don't need more info to condemn the thieves.

Yeah we don't have enough information to draw solid conclusions, but it's appears that the low lifes were in the store and then left and the guard followed them, although to what extent we can't be sure from the information we have.

Don't get me wrong, I wouldn't shed a single tear if all these thugs were killed, I'm just curious how the case will be handled in California.


maybe its because i live in canada where you really can't carry guns around, especially security at a store like that....but killing a thief over this? just seems so wrong. not saying he should have gotten away with theft but killing him? weather intentional or not that seems excessive.

The problem was that the low life thugs were willing to kill to steal the items and at that point your not returning fire to protect the product but to protect your life and/or stop a violent criminal.
 
From another article posted, he shot the guy through the passenger window. He might be in deep kimche, might not, just depends on the angles and if they still presented a threat (In my mind, they did, they had obviously opened fire previously and until they are completely unassed from the area, they are a threat.)

Regardless, they initiated the firefight, they (singular, lol) should burn and he should walk. Unfortunately our justice system is retarded. I hope he comes through unscathed.
 
Back
Top