Tesla Suing Top Gear

Yeah cept we aren't replacing coal with nuclear/renewables - we are building more coal. The point about electric cars is this - they are false sense of progress. Your just moving the problem to a different from city streets to the people that live around coal plants.
The efficiency of a coal plant and high voltage distribution system is FAR higher than the efficiency of a tiny ICE and trucks transporting liquid fuel.

Coal money is not contributing to foreign wars, middle-eastern and south-american anti-US cartels.

And no, I own a Corvette and an old Impala SS, no hybrid, but I know damn well that electric cars are better for America. :)
 
BTW, I forgot to add that coal plants in Texas are all "clean coal" stations that emit very little pollution other than lots of CO2 and the environmental impact of mining the coal itself.

The CO2 is also being dealt with, as several plants here now utilize carbon sequestration, which captures, compresses, and traps the CO2 deep underground beneath layers of clay.
 
Electric cars are a new market, there is much to improve. The cars themselves are progress, but the expanding the marking and improving the technology is progress. Its not a solution but it is one part of a solution. Whether or not we build a nuclear power plant today doesn't mean we can't build one tomorrow. True though, that is another part of the problem-- getting more nuclear plants built. Just saying, you can't dismiss any progress because it is not an instant solution.

Shit my car gets ~18mpg at best. I'm not saying to vilify car owners, but I would say we should dump money into research for alternatives rather than giving subsidies to oil companies. Long term research will pay off more.

Also BTW the 30,000/year coal plants kill, best part was number of deaths due to Solar power. If we put up solar panels on every building we'd have a huge number of deaths due to people falling off the roofs, lol. Puts into perspective how safe nuclear power is, despite situation in Japan.
 
Really? Is it cleaner then a hydrogen ICE? <g> MB has built a hydrogen ICE with 42% efficency.


Anyway Coal power plants kill 30,000 people a year based on pollution. It's incredibly dirty and not very efficent. Coal spews particulates of dust into the air which are toxic and mildly radioactive. It produces huge lakes of toxic dust - that when dry blows over the surrounding area.

As our power needs grow we are burning more and more coal. Alternative fuels are all hype and no substance as they produce almost none of our energy and will continue to do that for the forseeable future.

Much cleaner then a hydrogen ICE. You do realize that hydrogen is not truly a fuel, right? It's just a carrier, like electricity. Hydrogen is extracted from natural gas, releasing carbon just like burning it. Just more so because burning it and converting it electricity is much more efficient. You can also get it from electrolysis of water, but that's terribly inefficient. It's MUCH better to put that electricity to use charging a battery.

There are few other ways of getting hydrogen, all of them require more energy then what's produced in hydrogen.

Hydrogen isn't harvested.

Again, where do you pull this crap from? Most of the particulates in coal production are removed from the flue gas via scrubbers and other methods. Not only that, but coal ash is put to many uses such as an ingredient for concrete. They probably produce less particulates then a diesel. Burning coal does not produce radioactivity. Only what was there in the coal to begin with.

Do you want to dig a bigger hole and spread more misinformation? It's a real pet peeve of mine when someone rambles about something they know nothing about.
 
Again, where do you pull this crap from? Most of the particulates in coal production are removed from the flue gas via scrubbers and other methods. Not only that, but coal ash is put to many uses such as an ingredient for concrete. They probably produce less particulates then a diesel. Burning coal does not produce radioactivity. Only what was there in the coal to begin with.

It's widely known and not crap. <sigh> If you are going to question a poster you better bring a source of your own buddy.

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/5174391/
http://www.catf.us/resources/publications/view/24

Fine particle pollution from U.S. power plants cuts short the lives of nearly 24,000 people each year, including 2800 from lung cancer.

Hundreds of thousands of Americans suffer each year from asthma attacks, cardiac problems, and respiratory problems associated with fine particles from power plants. These illnesses result in tens of thousands of emergency room visits, hospitalizations, and lost work days each year.

Power plant pollution is responsible for 38,200 non-fatal heart attacks per year.

Those numbers have only risen since 2004. Coal kills. Go move near a coal plant if you don't believe me.
 
It's widely known and not crap. <sigh> If you are going to question a poster you better bring a source of your own buddy.

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/5174391/
http://www.catf.us/resources/publications/view/24

Fine particle pollution from U.S. power plants cuts short the lives of nearly 24,000 people each year, including 2800 from lung cancer.

Hundreds of thousands of Americans suffer each year from asthma attacks, cardiac problems, and respiratory problems associated with fine particles from power plants. These illnesses result in tens of thousands of emergency room visits, hospitalizations, and lost work days each year.

Power plant pollution is responsible for 38,200 non-fatal heart attacks per year.

Those numbers have only risen since 2004. Coal kills. Go move near a coal plant if you don't believe me.

Stupidity kills too.

So there's some grandfathered coal plants which aren't as clean as others. How does this make electric cars dirtier? Electric cars aren't somehow going to make these old grandfathered plants produce more. They're already baseload.

You said yourself that more coal plants may be built in response to demand created by electric cars. These new plants will not be grandfathered thus they will be quite clean.

These old plants will slowly be shut down or revamped as they age.

Electric cars can and will have no effect on how much electricity comes from these plants (they are already at baseload) thus this point is COMPLETELY IRRELEVANT. Then again you're quite good at ignoring key details like pointing out MB's hydrogen ICE without analyzing the hydrogen supply chain efficiency, unlike what you did so elegantly (lol) for the dirty electricity powering electric cars.

I'd post references, but you wouldn't read them and wouldn't understand them. Hint: they wouldn't come from consumer lobbiest and news websites.
 
Oh, I am not questioning you. I am telling you that you're wrong. References aren't even necessary because the logic is just flawed to begin with.

I'll keep replying - to protect the ignorant!
 
You said yourself that more coal plants may be built in response to demand created by electric cars. These new plants will not be grandfathered thus they will be quite clean.

You have provided zero evidence that new coal plants are clean. <g> You talk big but your arguments stink.
Coal is dirty and kills people. Go back to your job and the coal factory. Hell the recently halted production of a coal power plant in Kentucky because the people their know better. It was a brand new plant. Clean coal is a myth.

http://www.eia.doe.gov/oiaf/archive/aeo05/figure_115.html

Mercury emissions from coal plants continue to CLIMB.

http://www.guardian.co.uk/environment/blog/2011/jan/07/dirty-business-clean-coal

Check out this documentary on coal...
 
Electric cars can and will have no effect on how much electricity comes from these plants (they are already at baseload) thus this point is COMPLETELY IRRELEVANT. Then again you're quite good at ignoring key details like pointing out MB's hydrogen ICE without analyzing the hydrogen supply chain efficiency, unlike what you did so elegantly (lol) for the dirty electricity powering electric cars.

LMAO. I already admitted that electric cars would have a small postive effect - but its very small because most of our energy is generated from dirty coal. And coal is not much cleaner or more efficent then ICE.

BTW you can generate hydrogen from water.. Stop crying because I disproved your ridiculous theory that coal plants are so much cleaner then any ICE. Yes its not currently cost effective to do it that way - and I am not suggesting we switch to hydrogen cars. I am saying hydrogen burning ICE are cleaner then your precious coal. <g>
 
The efficiency of a coal plant and high voltage distribution system is FAR higher than the efficiency of a tiny ICE and trucks transporting liquid fuel.

Coal money is not contributing to foreign wars, middle-eastern and south-american anti-US cartels.

Absolutely coal is not contributing to wars - but its killing us with pollution. You can't win burning any fossil fuels for energy. Electric cars are only as good as the source of their energy. Yes you gain a small boost in efficency but if the problem calls for elimination of CO2 - you have to stop burning fossil fuels altogether.
 
LMAO. I already admitted that electric cars would have a small postive effect - but its very small because most of our energy is generated from dirty coal. And coal is not much cleaner or more efficent then ICE.

BTW you can generate hydrogen from water.. Stop crying because I disproved your ridiculous theory that coal plants are so much cleaner then any ICE. Yes its not currently cost effective to do it that way - and I am not suggesting we switch to hydrogen cars. I am saying hydrogen burning ICE are cleaner then your precious coal. <g>

I couldn't care less about coal. I am just trying to protect the ignorant from your misinformation. I work in oil and gas and live in Houston. We love gas and diesel cars. Our electricity comes from CC plants which are 50%-60% efficient.

Gas engines are 20 something percent efficient when they're actually accelerating the car. They just waste more energy when decelerating, braking and idleing.

How could you possibly say that my arguments are weak? You haven't even made any arguments. You just make baseless and consistently incorrect statements.

You proved that a coal plant is cleaner then an ICE? HAHAHAHA. Please, could someone point out where this guy made this proof?

>> BTW you can generate hydrogen from water.

BTW, you're a doofus. BTW, I already mentioned this. BTW, where do you think the energy comes from to "generate" that hydrogen? :p Please also know that it's about 50% efficient, if you put in 100 BTU's of electricity to generate 50 BTU's of hydrogen, burn those 50 BTU's of hydrogen in an ICE and you get 17 BTU's of motive energy, when the car isnt idleing or wasting more braking.

You could just use those 100 BTU's of electricity to charge the battery of an electric car and you'd get 80 BTU's of motive energy out of it. And nothing wasted idleing and even a little reclaimed braking. But you wouldn't do that because the electricty going into that electric car comes from DIRTY COAL, right? hahahaha :p

Here are some numbers for you to chew on from an operating and profitable coal plant in Texas. Let's see what you can do with this for now and I'll put it in direct comparison to an ICE car later for you. I am going to bed soon, not going to play with it now.

NOx: 0.08 lb/MMBtu
SO2: 0.192 lb/MMBtu
CO: 0.34 lb/MMBtu
PM10: 0.015 lb/MMBtu

On Hg, Luminant, for example who has about 8 GW of generation capacity in coal (that's about 350,000 running vehicles worth - about 3,500,000 total vehicles - and enough to power a good 10,000,000 electric vehicles), spent $1 BILLION (raises pinky) dollars between 2005 and 2009 to reduce NOx, SO2 and Hg emissions in existing plants. In 2010, they were 20% below 2005 levels, making that six year old chart you posted on Hg emissions look a little... wrong.

Instead of watching and posting those sensationalist "documentaries," why not read something that's actually factual, with real analysis and unbiased. Here's a good reference to start.

http://web.mit.edu/coal/The_Future_of_Coal.pdf
 
So what do we do with the millions of tons of dead batteries all those electric cars will create? How much energy will be spent to recycle them?
 
How could you possibly say that my arguments are weak? You haven't even made any arguments. You just make baseless and consistently incorrect statements.

LMAO. Just because you got your butt hurt about your theory that there are no cleaner ICE's then coal. Stop crying dude..

Anyway I made my arguments plenty clear - let me spell it out for you since you are clearly challenged in the reading comprehension department. I provided references - so they aren't baseless.

1) Because of our power grid the net gain from switching to Electric cars is marginal. Since your blathering on about this I looked up some numbers to clarify my point.

For the US - an electric car hooked up to our grid puts out 115 grams of CO2 per kilometer driven. For a european car (which are smaller and often diesel) its about 149 grams of CO2 per kilometer. So sure Electric cars are more efficent but because of our power grid its not THAT efficent.

For FRANCE OTOH who use mostly nuclear power that number is way lower - it's under 20 grams of CO2 per kilometer driven. So until we switch over to renewable/nuclear fuel sources in the States electric cars on their own won't really solve our problems.

2) Coal is dirty. its really ****** dirty. It's also inefficent in the US under current plants. That's a sidenote though - it's the reason WHY electric cars aren't so efficent or clean as they seem on paper.

3) None of this is Telsa's fault. But they are bit of douchey company for suing an entertainment car show for screwing around. But I guess they take direction from posters like you. <g>
 
TG is a huge show and has a lot of influence, Tesla has a right to take action against the BBC if these claims can be proven, which I don't doubt.
 
TG is a huge show and has a lot of influence, Tesla has a right to take action against the BBC if these claims can be proven, which I don't doubt.

Oh sure under British law they have a right - I have little doubt of that. But its pretty low class to sue anyone you can. Plenty of other car makers could have sued top gear - it's not like Telsa is the only car maker to get comically slammed by that show. They do it to all of em - its entertainment.
 
Here are some numbers for you to chew on from an operating and profitable coal plant in Texas. Let's see what you can do with this for now and I'll put it in direct comparison to an ICE car later for you. I am going to bed soon, not going to play with it now.

Unfortunately the pollution coming out of the smokestack is the least of coals problems. It's the entire process - from the mining to the coal ash waste. It's really some dirty shit.

Among the surprising conclusions: the waste produced by coal plants is actually more radioactive than that generated by their nuclear counterparts. In fact, the fly ash emitted by a power plant&#8212;a by-product from burning coal for electricity&#8212;carries into the surrounding environment 100 times more radiation than a nuclear power plant producing the same amount of energy

That's just a tidbit - not a whole argument. There are all kinds of other crap in that ash too.. Anyway dude I think we can agree to disagree. You believe in clean coal but all the evidence I have seen points to the fact that it's some dirty shit. I'd much rather living within a few miles of a nuclear power plant then within 30 of a coal plant.

And that's sidestepping the whole CO2 emissions thing..which is what many folks are most worried about..
 
Oh sure under British law they have a right - I have little doubt of that. But its pretty low class to sue anyone you can. Plenty of other car makers could have sued top gear - it's not like Telsa is the only car maker to get comically slammed by that show. They do it to all of em - its entertainment.

Indeed, as I have said already Bentley has actually more of a case of suing them compared to Tesla.

1) They explicitly stated that Bentley "changed their minds right before we're about to leave for Albania"
2) That because of that abrupt change, they had to buy a "local" Bentley.
3) That car is called a Bentley every time throughout the show.
4) Considering #3, here's what they have said: "I can't close this Bentley's window properly"; "This Bentley is struggling to keep up in the mountain roads"; "Looks like the engines in Bentley's aren't that reliable when they break down as often as this"; "Why didn't your Bentley stop?" "I had the handbrake up, but it wasn't working"; "There's not much space in this Bentley. And it's not comfortable too"; "So we just saw a Bentley go down a cliff and blow up after being chased by the police."
 
The efficiency of a coal plant and high voltage distribution system is FAR higher than the efficiency of a tiny ICE and trucks transporting liquid fuel.

Coal money is not contributing to foreign wars, middle-eastern and south-american anti-US cartels.

And no, I own a Corvette and an old Impala SS, no hybrid, but I know damn well that electric cars are better for America. :)

I don't think there is any money to be made in the coal black market, if there is such a thing?

And when the $5k worth of batteries are replaced, they wind up in some poor old guys backyard in China, yep that's being environmentally friendly...to the U.S anyway.

So in order to power the car, your willing to burn up a crap load of coal, to power the giant laptop battery, I'm betting your Corvette can do at least 200 miles on one tank, typical road cruising speeds, and doesn't take eight hours to refuel?
 
of course it get 55 miles on the track its working a hell of alot harder than it would on the street, f the fuse went causing brake issues the its still broken, whos going to drive around a track at speed with brakes that sort of work, yes on the street they will bring you to a safe stop with some work to pass codes but its not practical, if they broke they broke... every car has its flaws and design error that need fixed


they are probably mad if investors loose faith in them over this
 
Bending it here and there while remaining plausible he could do. Throwing the drag when numbers from every where else show the gas Lotus as being slower, would have severely damaged his credibility.

Like any other journalist, there are limits to how much of your personal bias you can show b4 nobody but the choir takes you seriously. He would end up looking like the Geraldo Rivera or Rush Limbaugh of the auto journalism world had he been that blatant.
That's true that throwing the drag race would've made Clarkson look incompetent, but if he really wanted to diss Tesla, he could've said, "the car feels slower than its numbers indicate" that he and the rest occasionally say about other cars.
 
Tesla has filed a lawsuit against the BBC show Top Gear. How do I know this? Because the car company has made a website dedicated to the lawsuit called Tesla vs. Top Gear. This all seems a bit drama queen-ish, don't you think?

swriously man. how much money did they lose? hey if the record companies win that 75 trillion from wikiwire then maybe tesla can borrow sum?!?! :)
 
I like TG's rebuttal in that link swatbat posted. :cool:

To me most of the lawsuit was complete bullshit from what I had read because you can watch the clip and see tesla was putting words into top gears mouth that it didn't say. The only issue I saw was where they made it look like it ran out of charge even though they didn't claim it did. Sounds like telsa was onsite when the issues came up. If what top gear said is true then this is really a pathetic lawsuit.
 
To me most of the lawsuit was complete bullshit from what I had read because you can watch the clip and see tesla was putting words into top gears mouth that it didn't say. The only issue I saw was where they made it look like it ran out of charge even though they didn't claim it did. Sounds like telsa was onsite when the issues came up. If what top gear said is true then this is really a pathetic lawsuit.
Yeah, it really doe seem like a silly lawsuit, and esp. for it to be filed 2+ years later. If it does go to court, I hope the judge reprimands Tesla for wasting everyone's time and $.
 
LMAO. Just because you got your butt hurt about your theory that there are no cleaner ICE's then coal. Stop crying dude..

I'm just annoyed by people who troll misinformation, get all their "information" from less then credible sources and act like a zealot when presented with real information. This has nothing to do coal or any particular technology. This is not a matter of politics or opinion - the fact of the matter all of the parameters can be precisely measured and compared objectively, something it seems you are incapable of doing. Instead choosing to post your "references" (again, I am sorry - but a sensationalist documentary or a lobbiest website does not count as a source of valid information) If you think that's "butt hurt," or "crying," then I don't know what's wrong with you.

In fact, one of the very reasons you are quite wrong is in fact what I'm talking about - every coal plant has an array of sensors and dataloggers the document every bit of particulate, Hg, CO, SO2 and NOX released to the atmosphere. This is not even close to the case for ICE powered automobiles. Don't even try to compare vehicle emissions testing. ;)

Anyway I made my arguments plenty clear - let me spell it out for you since you are clearly challenged in the reading comprehension department. I provided references - so they aren't baseless.

You haven't made any arguments. You only post statements (often incorrect)
Again, lobbiest websites and documentaries don't count as "sources." How about one from a non-biased source - a university, hell, even the government. I already posted one that covers it all, actually. MIT's study is quite comprehensive and recent, although I am sure you won't touch it because you won't like what's inside.

1) Because of our power grid the net gain from switching to Electric cars is marginal. Since your blathering on about this I looked up some numbers to clarify my point.

For the US - an electric car hooked up to our grid puts out 115 grams of CO2 per kilometer driven. For a european car (which are smaller and often diesel) its about 149 grams of CO2 per kilometer. So sure Electric cars are more efficent but because of our power grid its not THAT efficent.

For FRANCE OTOH who use mostly nuclear power that number is way lower - it's under 20 grams of CO2 per kilometer driven. So until we switch over to renewable/nuclear fuel sources in the States electric cars on their own won't really solve our problems.

Wow, you actually posted some numbers. I am impressed. I'd say you are underestimated the difference between the 115 and 149 g/km in this case. Take into account that coal produces a lot more CO2 per kwh generated then natural gas or even gasoline/diesel and you'd realize that the electric car is surprisingly efficient. This doesn't even take into account how much cleaner centralized electric power generation is when it comes to actual pollution - like NOx, SO2. (note: CO2 doesn't count as pollution - it's a natural byproduct of combustion involving carbon - and can't be reduced without sequestration and capture, changing fuels or improving efficiency.)

2) Coal is dirty. its really ****** dirty. It's also inefficent in the US under current plants. That's a sidenote though - it's the reason WHY electric cars aren't so efficent or clean as they seem on paper.

More 'wah wah' baseless statements. You were doing well there for a minute. Yes, coal is (by far) the dirtiest of all electric generation - but it's still cleaner then your ICE powered car.

3) None of this is Telsa's fault. But they are bit of douchey company for suing an entertainment car show for screwing around. But I guess they take direction from posters like you. <g>

What the heck does <g> mean? It keep showing up in your replys. Is there something with your browser?

Unfortunately the pollution coming out of the smokestack is the least of coals problems. It's the entire process - from the mining to the coal ash waste. It's really some dirty shit.

More pointless, incorrect and baseless statements. Coal ash can be and is used for concrete and brick manufacture. Sulfur from emissions cleanup can be used for wallboard manufacture.


That's just a tidbit - not a whole argument. There are all kinds of other crap in that ash too.. Anyway dude I think we can agree to disagree. You believe in clean coal but all the evidence I have seen points to the fact that it's some dirty shit. I'd much rather living within a few miles of a nuclear power plant then within 30 of a coal plant.
You don't even know what an argument is. That is not argument. It's a statement. In this case, a horribly deceptive statement, which is a real shame. Here - I'll use basic logic to explain why:

NUCLEAR PLANTS DON'T HAVE EMISSIONS! They actively emit almost ZERO radiation. It's all contained and sealed into the reactor. It's no wonder that coal plants emit more. The only reason the number they came up with is 100 times and not infinity times is that they are probably taking into account the minuscule amount of leakage and releases that will occur during operation of a nuclear plant. Also irradiation of boiler water that may be released to the environment.

That's the first directly (and probably intentionality - if it was reviewed by an engineer who knows his ass from his elbow) deceptive statement I've seen - it casts even more doubt on your sources.

Here are some better industry numbers for coal emissions. Straight from the MIT study. Since you found some #'s before, why don't you find some vehicle emissions numbers (per mile or similar) and I'll do the math so we can have a direct comparison. Warning: you problably won't like the result.

SO2 2666.666667 ton / billion kwh
NOx 1111.111111 ton / billion kwh
Particulates 0.005 lb / million BTU


Oh, I'll be happy to agree to disagree... as soon as you stop posting crap.

And that's sidestepping the whole CO2 emissions thing..which is what many folks are most worried about..
And ICE based vehicles are the worse in this category. Even taking into account that coal based generation produces much much more CO2 then natural gas or petroleum per unit of energy. And CO2 sequestration and nuclear power - our only real means in the future of reducing CO2 emissions both aren't even options for ICE vehicles.

of course it get 55 miles on the track its working a hell of alot harder than it would on the street, f the fuse went causing brake issues the its still broken, whos going to drive around a track at speed with brakes that sort of work, yes on the street they will bring you to a safe stop with some work to pass codes but its not practical, if they broke they broke... every car has its flaws and design error that need fixed

It's a blown fuse man. A bit much to call it a design error without additional information. Maybe they could have just popped in a bigger fuse.

they are probably mad if investors loose faith in them over this

Well, yeah, that would be the point of the lawsuit. Glad you figured that out :D
 
Yeah, it really doe seem like a silly lawsuit, and esp. for it to be filed 2+ years later. If it does go to court, I hope the judge reprimands Tesla for wasting everyone's time and $.

After reading TG's reply, it seems to me Tesla's only case is TG's depiction of the car running out of juice and being pushed. It's for the courts to decide I suppose...
 
After reading TG's reply, it seems to me Tesla's only case is TG's depiction of the car running out of juice and being pushed. It's for the courts to decide I suppose...
If the car runs out of juice (electricity), it'd have to be pushed, just like a gas car that runs out of gas. I really don't see how Tesla can win this unless their lawyers are far superior to TG's. Very often, it's the side with the better lawyers that wins. :(
 
Back
Top