Tesla Suing Top Gear

So Tesla should have known that Jeremy Clarkson would as usual blatantly lie and slander the vehicle, and therefor the guilty party here is... Tesla?

Thats like blaming rape victims that they should have known better than to leave the kitchen. Its her fault. Slut.

Reviewing a Tesla is a lot like being raped. Poor JC.
 
So Tesla should have known that Jeremy Clarkson would as usual blatantly lie and slander the vehicle, and therefor the guilty party here is... Tesla?

Thats like blaming rape victims that they should have known better than to leave the kitchen. Its her fault. Slut.


Yes, EXACTLY like that. Actually they should have known he'd pick out some flaw and make entire review about it. All their complaints are nit picky shit. OMG you showed that batteries can go dead!!! SLANDER! OMG you drove the piss out of a car and found its less efficent! SLANDER!!!!!!!!!! OMG something broke and you stated what broke incorrectly! SLANDER!!!!!!!!!!!!!
 
Okay, the exact quote from the transcript of the show is:


TG did not say the brakes "failed". You're an engineer, there's a whole lot of difference between "failure" and something's that just "broken". Although I agree "broken" does imply that they didn't work at all, more than just "loss of power assist." But in laymen's terms, "brakes had broken" is accurate enough since it prevented TG from taking the car out on track. (I'd definitely NOT take a car out on track if it had lost power assist to the brakes, and I'd doubt the Tesla would like it if Clarkson did as well.)

So how would you describe the "loss of vacuum to the brake booster" to your grandma?

I'd personally tell her that her brakes were broken if she had lost power assist to the brakes and definitely would NOT recommend my grandma drive her car without power assist to the brakes if it came with power assisted brakes.

My grandma doesn't watch Top Gear. Since I would be describing it to your average Top Gear viewer, I would say, "The car lost power brakes, so the brakes worked just like the car it's based on, the Elise, which has manual brakes."

Depending on the master cylinder and brake piston sizes, the car would likely fare just fine on the track without the booster. Again, the Elise has manual brakes.

In this case, saying "the brakes broke," is definitely an oversimplification for the typical Top Gear viewer. It's up to the courts to decide if it was done to promote ratings at Tesla's expense.
 
Tesla is a pretty suspect company all around IMHO. Car and Driver slammed the crap out of the car - I am surprised they didn't sue them too. Electric cars don't work as well in practice as they do in theory. Range is a huge issue - because if you run out of juice you can't quickly recharge - throw in the fact that batteries store hardly any energy and you have an issue.

Uh. What? How don't they work as well in reality? They are freaking amazing. Have you ridden in a Tesla? Probably not. I have, and I have several friends that work at the company. If you get in one and come out not smiling, you should probably have your happy fun place checked.

Range is an issue because Americans think bigger is better. Who needs a range of 200 miles? 2-5% of the US, that's who. The rest can live day in and day out on less than a 200 mile range. Don't believe me? How exactly do you think people withOUT cars get around? Range isn't exactly hurting them, is it?

Batteries will get better. It's the nature of material science. It's not a steady improvement like the computing sector. It's hit or miss for years until a major breakthrough. We're due for one soon. Mark my words, a doubling of battery capacity (not terribly difficult with the newer lab technologies now) will make gasoline obsolete.

bbf: I'm with you buddy. Tesla is a good company trying to to innovative things. All these people sucking TG's teet haven't read the facts.
 
The only real issue I've had with Top Gear was when they tested the Shelby GT500, and gave it shit for not having 500HP on the dyno...at the wheels. Should have measured it at the flywheel like it's rated for. Not to mention that was the only car I've ever seen them put on a dyno and compare manufacturer HP numbers with the car they actually received.

As for the Tesla thing. Meh, Tesla should know going in. Call Porsche or Ferrari before hand, they have to know what to expect with the amount cars they hand over.
 
Thing is if Top Gear slags of American cars (and no one else does) then maybe the US car manufacturers might start to improve them.

What Clarkson says (comedy value aside) does have a lot of sway in the Car Industry. Ask GM how they felt over his Vauxhall Vectra review and one or two others. In fact about 15 years ago they had to scrap a car because Top Gear gave it such a bad review. Customers complained because overnight their cars that were nearly new lost £5000 in value.

A review from Clarkson can make or break a car. But if it means manufacturers sit up and improve then thats better for us. And if Tesla cant make a 'perfomance' electric thats truly usable from a performance perspective then thats their fault.
 
Thing is if Top Gear slags of American cars (and no one else does) then maybe the US car manufacturers might start to improve them.
The American car manufacturers have improved their cars by leaps and bounds and overtaken a hell of a lot of overseas car manufacturers in the process. Their biggest problem right now is overcoming people's ignorance.
 
There seem to be a lot of people commenting about TG who haven't even watched the show. The show isn't a serious car reviewing programming. One of their reviews they drove a car in an amphibious assault and had Royal Marines firing assault rifles from the vehicle. Some might say that wasn't a "real world test" well it was quite amusing.

TG seem to consider that the vehicle with the brake problem wasn't safe to drive on the track. Tesla Motors believe it was safe to drive (so long as you drive like you grandma).

This lawsuit will just result in the Tesla constantly being slagged off on the program, which will result in damage to their image.

All I have to say is:
"We no longer have a pan fire, its now a van fire!"
 
Range is an issue because Americans think bigger is better. Who needs a range of 200 miles? 2-5% of the US, that's who. The rest can live day in and day out on less than a 200 mile range. Don't believe me? How exactly do you think people withOUT cars get around? Range isn't exactly hurting them, is it?

I think I explained why range is a big issue. Those range numbers are dependent on how you drive - VERY dependent. How far do you get in cold weather? How far do you get driving aggressively? That's one factor - the other if you DO run out of juice you can't walk down the gas station and get a gallon of gas. You are STUCK SCREWED etc. Hence the TG demo. It's a big issue..

Batteries will get better. It's the nature of material science. It's not a steady improvement like the computing sector. It's hit or miss for years until a major breakthrough. We're due for one soon. Mark my words, a doubling of battery capacity (not terribly difficult with the newer lab technologies now) will make gasoline obsolete.

A good battery might make the thing work - but until then don't count on it. They have been working hard on batteries with little success for many many years. Gasoline and diesel store huge amounts of energy per weight making them a very hard to beat fuel choice in both range and performance. Fuel cells OTOH work - but are too expensive.

Uh. What? How don't they work as well in reality? They are freaking amazing. Have you ridden in a Tesla? Probably not. I have, and I have several friends that work at the company. If you get in one and come out not smiling, you should probably have your happy fun place checked.

Yeah but most 100k cars are pretty darn sweet - GTR's, Porsche 911 and such. A 2012 GTR will do so to 60 in almost a second less - and costs you 10k less.

Anyway besides Clarkson the Car and Driver guy thought the car sucked too - really crappy seats I guess if you are going on a long drive and seriously pain in the ass recharging features. The guy had the car for a whole week. Not everyone loves it. It's cool that you know the guys there - but don't expect everyone to buy it.
 
I just watched the review again.

http://www.spike.com/video-clips/c3neux/top-gear-reviews-the-tesla-roadster

I really cant see what Tesla have to argue over. TG just showed some of the potential shortfalls of the tech.

The long and the short of the TG review is -

The car is fast, very fast.
The car is heavy and not that great in corners.
They dont deny the 200 mile range of the Tesla.
The car is cheap to power though takes time to charge.
The car may well fall short of 200 miles if driven under race conditions.
The motor and brakes may fail/shut down under race conditions.
The car is expensive.

Kind of what I would expect really. Thats just common sense factors.

They are probably more annoyed by the hydrogen fuel cell car shown later in that show.

Tesla are setting themselves up for a fall.
 
More technical details:

http://www.crunchgear.com/2011/03/30/tesla-vs-top-gear/


Over the last several months, we have written to the BBC, asking them to stop repeating the serious and damaging lies on the show. Specifically:

The Roadster’s true range is only 55 miles per charge. Clarkson says: “Although Tesla say it will do 200 miles we worked out that on our track it would run out after just 55 miles.”
They always show their bias against American cars why would the Tesla be any different they just took it too far this time.
 
Time for Tesla to put a car on a poper (as in not an oval) racetrack with a impartial race driver and show the world what it can do.

Put up or shut up. I bet it does far less than 100 miles and some parts cook.

On a normal road commuting to leisure driving I bet it could well do 200 miles. Just not racing.
 
My laptop will do 6 hours on battery just browsing the web and Word etc.

If I play BF2/Eve/COD on it I get around an hour from it if I'm lucky.

Why should the Tesla be any different?
 
I swear it's like Tesla never watched the show before. Other manufacturers have sent crews with the cars to fix things when something goes wrong, Tesla should have just done the same.

Would not have mattered. It's an electric, and it's American.
The show is about entertainment and tooting UK car makers horns. It's Top Gear, not Road & Track.
 
UK car makers...I find that really funny.

To the US folks...we dont have ANY mainstream UK car firms anymore, havent for years.

All we have are a few small barn sized independant sports car firms.

There is NO UK car industry of note.

Aston Martin/Lotus/Rolls Royce/Bentley/Rover/TVR/Jaguar/Land Rover etc. Either foreign owned or gone.

Thats why we can take the piss out of all the cars.
 
I have run 18 gallons through a 600Hp car in around 20 minutes or so on a dyno. How long do you people really think a sports car's fuel tank goes when you are thrashing the throttle?
 
UK car makers...I find that really funny.

To the US folks...we dont have ANY mainstream UK car firms anymore, havent for years.

All we have are a few small barn sized independant sports car firms.

There is NO UK car industry of note.

Aston Martin/Lotus/Rolls Royce/Bentley/Rover/TVR/Jaguar/Land Rover etc. Either foreign owned or gone.

Thats why we can take the piss out of all the cars.

I laughed too. But Top Gear still seems to favor those makers that have identities born in the UK. If you don't see it, I doubt anyone could convince you.
 
Hmm... Waiting for the Bentley law suit now.

It's an "Albanian" Bentley. ;) LOLOLOL

Although yeah, Bentley actually has MORE reason to sue Top Gear than Tesla. LOL

A Bentley with a window that can't be closed properly, a Bentley that struggles in mountain roads, a Bentley that isn't exactly spacious, a Bentley that breaks down easily, a Bentley that makes it hard for you to switch gears...

It was but then he had massive problems with it, he loved the idea of it but actually owning it was a nightmare for him as the alarm system kept the car from moving or working.

Regardless though he still actually loves it over his Mercedes-Benz. lol

"I don't care if it barely does 11MPG, it's still a Ford GT!" He said that during their Southern France road trip.

Its pretty hard to take "car experts" seriously when they can not spell Camaro correctly

Could you even spell Koenigsegg properly? LOL

I laughed too. But Top Gear still seems to favor those makers that have identities born in the UK. If you don't see it, I doubt anyone could convince you.

Actually they don't. Not anymore. They constantly slag Aston Martin recently for example, and although they sometimes wax lyrical about Land Rover, they don't really like them (they prefer Toyotas for example). The only "born in the UK" cars they like are Jaguars, and to a certain extent Lotus.

And then there's their eternal feud with the Morris Marina...LOL
 
Well I guess you have to agree that Aston Martin/Bentley/Rolls Royce/Jaguar/Lotus tend to make far more exciting cars than 90% of other manufacturers.

It's just the way it is.
 
My laptop will do 6 hours on battery just browsing the web and Word etc.

If I play BF2/Eve/COD on it I get around an hour from it if I'm lucky.

Why should the Tesla be any different?

If I drive my gas car like I stole it I get shitty gas mileage.

Why should your gas car be any different? :rolleyes:
 
There's a huge difference between an unfavorable review, and an outright false one. For example, they review crap cars all the time. However they don't make sh*t up about them because they don't have to. On the other hand, it appears they falsified info outright here. I'll reserve judgement but I'll say it's possible, given how much the boys hate battery electrics and hybrids.

they have falsified outright for comedic effect before, watch the Ford Fiesta review when he compares it to VW and Lotus'

They also hate American cars.

really? when they did their muscle car episode they bitched about some of the quirks of the cars but in the end they really liked them... same thing with the ford fiesta, I don't think Ford could have made a better commercial for the Fiesta than the TG episode... I am willing to bet that the Fiesta episode of TG is one of the reasons Ford brought the Fiesta to the US markets
 
Calling Telsa a shady company and not pointing a finger at GM and Ford is pretty nuts.

No. You don't bring in every company when you talk about one. The "he did it too" argument only works in preschool. Let's not paint these Telsa guys as a paragon of virtue. They are likely using tax payer money to sue some British entertainment show. SNL should do a skit about Telsa so we can watch them try to sue SNL too.

http://www.inc.com/news/articles/2009/06/tesla.html

465 million in loans. Who wants to bet they stick around and pay those loans back?..

What people don't get about electric cars is that they are mostly hype. It does you little good to use electric cars if the US has decided to generate its power through coal and natural gas plants. Coal/Natural gas is only about 33% efficent. So sure with ICE engines being about 20% efficency its a small boost (assuming its warm out) but its not going to do jack squat about global warming even if EVERYONE switched to purely electric cars.

Now if we had a strong nuclear industry I'd be all for Tesla. But right now they seem to be intent on making a buck by capitalizing off the feel good do nothing regulations the democrats are coming up for the car industry. The worst area for this is of course California - so its fitting that they are from there.

California has the highest energy costs - and the least reliable power..
 
Pointless counter post and getting the wrong end of the stick award of the week! :D

That was the point of the post. My bad for not realizing that you wouldn't get it - should have been obvious given your post(s).

Since you didn't get it, let me explain it to you. Your original post is pointless. No one in this thread said or expected that an electric car would not get lesser range when driven hard. Everyone knows that when you use a laptop for gaming less battery life results.
Everyone also knows that gas powered cars get lesser range when driven hard.

Yet you posted an analogy of the electric car to your laptop, somehow alluding that this is a negative of electric cars, when in fact the exact same thing occurs with gas cars. In fact, in the case of gas cars, it's even worse, as they use much more energy per mile and gasoline is much more expensive per unit available motive energy then electricity. Gasoline becomes a significant expense in car racing, 2nd to tires and engines. Not so with tracking an electric car.

It sucks to run out of gas in a regular car, too. Just not quite as much as much as it would in an electric. Thing is, I haven't ended up in the side of the road due to being out of gas in years. If you have some damage to your brain's frontal lobes, I can imagine having difficulty with the basic planning necessary to avoid being stranded by running out of charge. Then again, you probably shouldn't be driving if that's the case, anyways, considering Tesla put a lot of effort into the available range prediction, warnings and safety mechanisms involving SOC. Note that Top Gear's cars never even went below 25% charge despite the fact they were being tracked.
 
No. You don't bring in every company when you talk about one. The "he did it too" argument only works in preschool. Let's not paint these Telsa guys as a paragon of virtue. They are likely using tax payer money to sue some British entertainment show. SNL should do a skit about Telsa so we can watch them try to sue SNL too.

http://www.inc.com/news/articles/2009/06/tesla.html

465 million in loans. Who wants to bet they stick around and pay those loans back?..

What people don't get about electric cars is that they are mostly hype. It does you little good to use electric cars if the US has decided to generate its power through coal and natural gas plants. Coal/Natural gas is only about 33% efficent. So sure with ICE engines being about 20% efficency its a small boost (assuming its warm out) but its not going to do jack squat about global warming even if EVERYONE switched to purely electric cars.

Now if we had a strong nuclear industry I'd be all for Tesla. But right now they seem to be intent on making a buck by capitalizing off the feel good do nothing regulations the democrats are coming up for the car industry. The worst area for this is of course California - so its fitting that they are from there.

California has the highest energy costs - and the least reliable power..

Natural Gas generation efficiency is around or above 50% in Houston, where Gas is the primary source of electricity. Combined cycle gas plants can reach 60% or higher. Coal given current technology can reach almost 50% with new design plants. Also note you didn't even mention Nuclear, which makes up a significant % of US capacity.

The 20% estimate does not take into account the wasted energy of engine idling and the energy wasted every time the car brakes - in reality a comparison is much worse.

If you want to talk about emissions - don't. Even a basic coal plant is so much cleaner then the best ICE on a unit of energy basis it's not even funny.

By the way, I have worked in the electrical power industry as an engineer. I currently work in oil & gas.
 
Gas generation efficiency is around or above 50% in Houston, where Gas is the primary source of electricity. Combined cycle gas plants can reach 60% or higher. Coal given current technology can reach almost 50% with new design plants. Also note you didn't even mention Nuclear, which makes up a significant % of US capacity.

Newer plants are better but US coal efficency is 33%. And that's not counting the transmissive loss. If we want to play the alternative power plant game I'd point out that diesel engines are very efficent. Even the less advanced engines in cars can hit 30%

I don't see us building a gazallion new coal plants to reach 50% do you? Let's keep it real. No one with any sense wants a coal plant anywhere near them..
 
I'm going to have to side with Tesla on this one. Top Gear is entertainment first, review second. But this time they went a little far...

Yeah, of course if the Tesla runs out of juice, it would need to be towed/pushed to a charger. But that's why the car has a charge gauge and warnings that appear before the car goes dead. If you intentionality drive the car past this point and get yourself in a situation where you need a tow it's really your fault. Add on the fact that they totally staged the "incident" doesn't sit well.

Top gear did state the brakes failed in their review. If in fact it was the vacuum pump that failed (rather the fuse to the pump blew) they did NOT fail. Loss of vacuum to the brake booster is NOT brake failure, period. Take this from a mechanic and a mechanical engineer.

Sure Top Gear is a a show for entertainment, rather then serious reviews. However, the problem is they are perceived by much of the public as a legitimate review source, thus Top Gear has some responsibility here.


To me, it looks like Top Gear took advantage of the novel situation (review of first electric sports car) to put together a sensationalized review for ratings on TV at the expense of Tesla's reputation.


I am sure some people are upset by the fact that their car review source is really in fact drama/entertainment/production.
I'll ask you the same question I asked someone else. If TG's intention was to embarrass Tesla, wouldn't Clarkson have thrown that drag race by purposely losing against that yellow Lotus? :confused:

Tesla should spend more $ on reliability engineering than lawyers. :rolleyes:
 
You are so smart. How about some common sense? We cannot replace all ICE cars with electrics overnight, neither can we replace all coal plants with nuclear or renewables overnight. Doing these two tasks serially (eg replacing all coal plants with nuclear before starting development on electric cars) is fucking stupid. Obviously it makes sense to do these efforts in parallel. with the goal being, to one day have all electric cars powered by nuclear (or renewable) energy.

Using our current method of producing energy as reason why electric cars are mostly hype is just being stupid on purpose.
 
I remember them racing this lil box car thingy against a table where the table won lol strange they haven't be sued over that rather lol
 
Everyone knows that when you use a laptop for gaming less battery life results.
Everyone also knows that gas powered cars get lesser range when driven hard.


However, Tesla's pointless case makes it appear that it doesnt.

Thats the point and thats why they'll get crucified.
 
I'll ask you the same question I asked someone else. If TG's intention was to embarrass Tesla, wouldn't Clarkson have thrown that drag race by purposely losing against that yellow Lotus? :confused:

Tesla should spend more $ on reliability engineering than lawyers. :rolleyes:

Bending it here and there while remaining plausible he could do. Throwing the drag when numbers from every where else show the gas Lotus as being slower, would have severely damaged his credibility.

Like any other journalist, there are limits to how much of your personal bias you can show b4 nobody but the choir takes you seriously. He would end up looking like the Geraldo Rivera or Rush Limbaugh of the auto journalism world had he been that blatant.
 
I don't see us building a gazallion new coal plants to reach 50% do you? Let's keep it real. No one with any sense wants a coal plant anywhere near them..

I'm not following you... why build new coal? :confused: Keep what real?All I was saying is... sure, there is alot of coal power in the US. But there is also alot of Nat Gas and Nuclear as well. Don't forget about the portion in Solar and Wind (and wind keeps growing...)

Again, even if you just look at coal, which is stupid and short sighted, they're still an order of magnitude cleaner then your best ICE.
 
Again, even if you just look at coal, which is stupid and short sighted, they're still an order of magnitude cleaner then your best ICE.

Really? Is it cleaner then a hydrogen ICE? <g> MB has built a hydrogen ICE with 42% efficency.


Anyway Coal power plants kill 30,000 people a year based on pollution. It's incredibly dirty and not very efficent. Coal spews particulates of dust into the air which are toxic and mildly radioactive. It produces huge lakes of toxic dust - that when dry blows over the surrounding area.

As our power needs grow we are burning more and more coal. Alternative fuels are all hype and no substance as they produce almost none of our energy and will continue to do that for the forseeable future.
 
You are so smart. How about some common sense? We cannot replace all ICE cars with electrics overnight, neither can we replace all coal plants with nuclear or renewables overnight. Doing these two tasks serially (eg replacing all coal plants with nuclear before starting development on electric cars) is fucking stupid. Obviously it makes sense to do these efforts in parallel. with the goal being, to one day have all electric cars powered by nuclear (or renewable) energy.

Yeah cept we aren't replacing coal with nuclear/renewables - we are building more coal. The point about electric cars is this - they are false sense of progress. Your just moving the problem to a different from city streets to the people that live around coal plants.

It's estimated by 2030 85% of the world's power will be generated via fossil fuels. (International Energy Agency). I am not saying electric cars have a net negative impact - but really its a drop in the bucket because of the way we generate electricity.

The thermodynamic laws don't change burning fossil fuels to turn a turbine isn't a huge improvement over burning fossil fuels to turn a crankshaft. We should be building nuclear power plants not villify car owners.. Build enough and we could use hydrogen powered cars (which gets around the battery problem).
 
Back
Top