Please Recommend Tablet for Win7 User

Detox11

n00b
Joined
Mar 10, 2011
Messages
27
I am looking for a tablet that uses Win7. The reason I need this is because I have to run some company software that will only work with Win7 OS.

I have no idea where to start, what brands are good etc. My price range is around $750. Capacitive touch would be great.

Input greatly appreciated.

Thanks,

Detox
 
HP have the Slate 500 out, but its not supposed to be great.
Problem is at the moment I think people are holding off on Win 7 tablets because Windows 8 is more optimised for tablet use.
You could maybe try and get a Dell XT2. laptop/Tablet.
runs Windows 7 pretty well. But unless you get a good deal secondhand, its well out of the 750 dollar range.
Maybe look at the Dell Inspiron Duo?
review here

http://www.reghardware.com/2011/03/17/review_tablet_netbook_dell_duo/
 
When heatlesssun wakes up, he's the guy to "ask" or he'll be posting in this thread soon enough - he's the resident "Tablet PC dude" one could say. He's got the newest Asus Eee Slate (iirc), the HP Slate, and many others so I'm sure he'll be offering suggestions and recommendations in short order.
 
When heatlesssun wakes up, he's the guy to "ask" or he'll be posting in this thread soon enough - he's the resident "Tablet PC dude" one could say. He's got the newest Asus Eee Slate (iirc), the HP Slate, and many others so I'm sure he'll be offering suggestions and recommendations in short order.

I was going to suggest to wait till he wakes up too. xD

He's made quite a name for himself
 
I am going to guess that Heat will say that the Asus EEE Slate (EP121) is the best windows tablet out. Unfortunately it's $999 - $1099, so that puts it out of your price range. The HP Slate is smaller, cheaper, and weaker - but it might be a good fit. The weaker internals bring longer battery life and a smaller device.

Other alternatives would be to look at a convertible notebook (like an HP tm2 or an older tx2).
 
While heatless and others may or may not agree, my first impression (after thinking about it since the last post I made) is not going to be for a brand new machine right now; tablets are too expensive for full Windows 7 capability, which could be the Achilles' heel for the OP in that respect.

I would seriously recommend that he or she look into previous generation Tablet PCs, most notably - and I say this from my own personal experience with many models - ThinkPad convertibles like the X61 series or even better would be the X201 series products since those are basically "last gen" products. The pricing on those, especially if you buy one used or a refurb from Lenovo, will offer tremendous value and obviously they'll run Windows 7 just damned fine.

What I mean basically is the normal reaction for such threads or questions is to recommend the newest latest toys when in far more circumstances the previous generation products or even slightly older ones (say, up to 3 years passed) can still work just as well as something that's brand new for the given tasks the OP or whoever that's looking for such items would be concerned.

Personally, I wouldn't buy a brand spankin' new tablet from anybody right now, not one company out there. Instead, I'd spend significantly less money on the X201 as a used item or refurb and max it out with as much RAM and potentially a nice fast SSD as well instead of "blowing a wad" on the latest hardware which isn't all that much faster in the long run.

The battery life on the newest products might be improved but, again, in the long run I'll still suggest looking into older products: the Dell Latitude XT series models from last year and 2008-2009, the ThinkPad tablets from the past 3 years or so, even some Fujitsu stuff, but again those are personal observations and experience - I simply don't prefer to use or recommend HP Tablet PCs, like the TM or TX series but I've got my reasons for that (*cough*AMD*cough*ATI*cough*) :D

And yes I know you can get some HP tablets with Intel based hardware but, bleh... I just don't like HP tablet computers, not one of 'em, but that's me and my opinion being expressed, don't take it as anything but.

Also, consider the most important aspect of all: Windows 7 performs AMAZINGLY WELL on hardware that's old, even 5+ years or more. It most definitely outperforms Vista on the same hardware from years past and can even give XP a run for its money. I've got Windows 7 installed on a Toshiba M205 Tablet PC with a Pentium M at 1.5 GHz and 1.5GB of DDR in it and it works so well it's not even funny. Was a bit of a chore to get the video working properly since the laptop is nearly 7 years old but, I did manage to get everything functional for the tablet aspects and it works great.

So, don't always assume a brand new device is required in all situations. I'm a huge fan of re-using old(er) hardware simply because it can get the job done just as well, albeit a tad slower than today's high end stuff.

It's definitely worth looking into...
 
Thank you for the information, I guess I should clarify the use a little more and this may help in the choice. I should also note that I wasn't clear on the terminology difference between "Convertable" and straight "Tablet"

The tablet will basically be used for one function only which is run my company software. I will more than likley end up purchasing a standalone tablet such as an iPad for fun multimedia type stuff.

Portability wise, it's most intended for me to be able to read PDF documents on the couch, scroll through them etc. The iPad would have been perfect, accept for the rest of the proprietary software which I do need to run the application. Which doesn't require much processing power. An older convertable sounds like a good option, just not sure what models are good.

Also, it would be great if the screen had an accelerometer so when I move the device from portrait to landscape etc, (like the ipad).

You are probably wondering why I just don't get a laptop then, will its because the amount of reading I will be doing, it would be a lot easier ergonomically to have something like a tablet.

Thanks,

Detox
 
The basic gist:

Convertible = a "laptop" in traditional clamshell form where the lid/display section can be rotated around back on top of the keyboard/palmrest area. While not technically a "tablet" in the strictest sense (since it's a full blown laptop, keyboard, etc) it is generally considered to be a Tablet PC in a convertible form.

Tablet = a true tablet, with no physical keyboard/number pad, etc. Almost always much thinner than a full convertible, but not as thin as what's becoming "the standard" nowadays, which is the...

Slate = the truest table, in the thinnest form, basically a sliver of what the convertible's thickness typically is. Still no physical keyboard, and primarily designed to be lighter and more manageable than a Tablet PC in most respects. They've been around for over a decade, and traditionally what people think of when presented with the term "Tablet" computer.

As for recommendations on older hardware, again I'll revert to Dell Latitude XT's, ThinkPads in the X61 series (the X201 I mentioned is from 2010 so it's newer and fairly expensive whereas you can find very nice X61 models for under $400 on eBay, sometimes a lot lower), and maybe a Fujitsu or even a Toshiba model of various kinds.

It sounds like you want something that is primarily touch-controlled, which is something you need to have clarified as well in terms of "tablet" computers. Again, traditionally, Tablet PCs up till maybe 2 years ago were pen/stylus-controlled as far as the screen aspects go. It wasn't until capacitive touch screens came along (which are actually activated by the touch of the skin and not pressure, etc) that the "touch" revolution really cranked into high gear.

Nowadays, the Slate tablets that are coming out, every single one of them except some models by Archos and those really really cheap-shit Android tablets from no-name Chinese or companies of some Asian origin are cranking out in mass quantities at low prices - avoid them at all costs. Obviously since you're requiring a Windows 7-capable device those are out of the question, but you mentioned some media uses and they still won't cut the mustard.

Now that I think of it and that I mentioned it, the Archos 9 Tablet might be an option for you. Come to think of it, it really could be a decent option for you as it's a Windows 7-powered device from the gitgo, capacitive touch screen, the bells, the whistles, etc. The only thing it doesn't have going for it are a big popular brand name behind it - Archos has always been considered as the "Apple wannabees" in terms of making their smaller tablet devices with 5" screens and nowadays their line of 4.3" and smaller screen Android powered devices. Regardless, the Archos 9 is something to keep in mind as a potential solution to the device you're looking for.

Having said that, capacitive touch screen tablets don't really work with pens/styluses like the old Wacom pressure based models and other similar types of digitizer hardware. N-Trig is a company that's been making touch screens and digitizers for a while now; they supply hardware to Dell for the Latitude XT line and some other companies as well.

Bleh, I'm babbling... heatless will be along at some point to either back up what I've said or correct me if and when I've been a bit fudgy on the actual stats of stuff I'll bet. :)

Considering that you want to read PDFs and you mentioned it specifically, you're probably going to want something with at minimum a 10.1" diagonal screen, that's the bare minimum to get adequate resolution and pixel density so you can read a full page typical PDF without issues, I'd say.

Aside from that, you'll get more recommendations and suggestions as people get involved...
 
Having said that, capacitive touch screen tablets don't really work with pens/styluses like the old Wacom pressure based models and other similar types of digitizer hardware.

Exactly - That's why most current tablets/slates in the windows world have both a capacitive touchscreen and a digitizer (wacom or n-trig). It's only on the android/ipad side that you see ridiculously ineffective attempts to use a stylus with a capacitive screen only. Although, I do think there is an android slate in development that also has an n-trig screen. Apple has a staunch opposition to the stylus, so I doubt that we will see anything from them in the near future.

I think most of us agree with Joe about looking at older hardware to stay within your budget. If you do, pay attention to viewing angles - a lot of convertibles look ok in horizontal mode, but if you turn it to portrait mode the usable viewing angle is horrible (picture becomes very washed out or the colors look inverted). That's why newer devices use IPS or similar tech. Also consider the fact that many older tablets use resistive touch screens instead of capacitive screens (most of them also include active digitizers for pen input like current convertibles).

Consider the old tm2 or the older tx2 if you want to broaden your used-device list to include HP.
 
Yes, my favorite subject! Sorry for being late to the party, I just noticed this thread. JA's recommendations are solid. I think the biggest factor you'll want to consider is if you need a digital pen or not. Then after than would be if a convertible Tablet PC as Joe mentioned will work for you. I'll give you a high level overview of three popular Table PCs that I own.

At $800 dollars which is a little outside your price point you can get a base model tm2 convertible, pretty fast with an i3 and about 5 hours of battery and it's also a laptop. The screen isn't that good especially for a device that's meant to work in different orientations and angles and it's heavy for a tablet at 4.5 lbs but I will give you the best bang for the buck. You get capacitive two point multi-touch and a very nice and accurate Wacom digitizer, great for inking text and digital art.

The HP Slate 500 is also $800 but is a true slate, no physical keyboard. It's very light for an x86 machine at 1.5 lbs and gets solid battery life at 5 hours but it's an Atom device so its a little on the slow side. It comes with a dock with HDMI out and case, one USB port and a full SD slot. It has a four point multi-touch capacitive touch digitizer and a digital pen based from N-trig. The touch interface is pretty responsive but the pen isn't nearly as good was Wacoms technology, this is probably the biggest issue that people have with the device is the mediocre inking experience overall. Still very usable for note taking and text input but it just isn't in Wacom's league. But if you want a very portable device, and don't want or need a highly accurate ink experience this is still a solid machine and it has actually been well received by owners.

The hands down best consumer pure slate currently is the EP121 as Virtus mentioned. It is outside your price range but it's proving to be highly regarded. Of the currently 48 reviews on Amazon it has 37 5 start reviews. It's only flaw is that it gets only about 3.5 hours of battery life with standard desktop use. But it is a 2.5 lbs. Core i5 so considering the power for its weight it's not horrible, just not in the same league as mobile OS devices. But this EP121 has it all, great capacitive two point-multi touch, a very good Wacom pen digitizer and a beautiful 12.1 AFFS+ display, a technology similar to IPS in that it has great viewing angles but works better outdoors and in bright light.

Another popular Windows tablet that I don't have is the ExoPC and it's variants. It doesn't have a pen digitizer and is Atom based like the HP Slate but it has been well received by Windows tablet folks.
 
Not fully understanding the full function of the digital pen, I can say I don't need a pen to take notes, doodle or sign documents etc.

Because the majority of time will be spent reading PDF files, I would like this part to be smooth. Scolling through the pages with my finger and activating links with the PDF as you wouldwith any good ebook, ereader etc.

I looked at the X61 on ebay and the price is right. Can it do capacitive touch? What about the HP TM2 if I can pick it up for around $600?

The Archos looked neat, but I think 9" screen is too small., 12.1 is ideal.
 
I've got the previous-gen TX2. I just dropped an Intel X25-M 120GB in it this weekend and it runs a lot cooler and snappier. Battery life has gone up, I'm pretty sure, also.

The TX2 is pretty nice. I don't have any real complaints, besides the touch detection could be better. The Wacom in that is supposed to be way better than the N-trig in my TX2.

The TM2 would be my go to if I was going to spend decent money on a tablet convertible upgrade. Instead, I use a rooted Nook color as my real tablet gadget and the TX2 mostly as a laptop.

I'm not a huge fan of the win7 touch experience, but it's better than the ipad folks like to say it is. I wouldn't get the EP121 myself, although it is the best pure win7 slate.
 
Last edited:
$600 would be about the cheapest that you'd get a used tm2. The X61 is a solid machine, a better screen than the tm2 though the tm2 does have a higher-resolution 1280x800 screen though the 1024x768 4:3 screen might appeal to you better.

If you're using it for PDFs a digital pen might be of use to you. One of the most popular uses of a digital pen on Tablet PCs is marking up documents. There are a number of good applications out there like PDF Annotator and Blubeam PDF Review that are excellent viewers and PDF document editors that have very good support for ink annotation that's searchable right on top of existing documents.
 
Not fully understanding the full function of the digital pen, I can say I don't need a pen to take notes, doodle or sign documents etc.

Because the majority of time will be spent reading PDF files, I would like this part to be smooth. Scolling through the pages with my finger and activating links with the PDF as you wouldwith any good ebook, ereader etc.

I looked at the X61 on ebay and the price is right. Can it do capacitive touch? What about the HP TM2 if I can pick it up for around $600?

The Archos looked neat, but I think 9" screen is too small., 12.1 is ideal.

BTW

As far as scrolling through PDFs, I found that PDF Xchange performed a lot better on my TX2 for scrolling and viewing than Adobe Reader or Foxit. Used it for tabletop RPG gaming. Might be worth testing when you get whatever you decide on.
 
While the Q1 is a neat gadget, nobody would argue otherwise except some old farts probably, it's not a good recommendation for the OP since a) he wants something that can run Windows 7 without issues and the Q1 just ain't it, even if it can run that OS - it's just too limited for real-world use, and b) the OP has stated at least twice now that he (or she) will use the device for reading PDFs so that becomes the primary focus, at least from my perspective, and trying to read PDF files on a 7" screen like that ain't gonna cut it, it's just not gonna happen. :p

As for a 12.1" screen, that's pretty much the Asus Eee Slate territory at the moment and not much else out there, it's the only game in town that I'd end up recommending - downside is it's outside the OP's price range. I'm still going to recommend/suggest a purchase of older hardware at a serious discount from eBay or some other reseller or outfit.

The X61 or some other convertible would be in that range. 12.1" is probably the most popular diagonal screen size for actual Tablet PCs - the Toshiba M205 that I've used in the past has a 12.1" 1400x1050 screen, kind of an oddball for a Tablet PC at that resolution but it's sharp as hell and PDFs look fantastic.

Also, because I've used them in the past and I do love the true slate styling, don't forget about the Fujitsu Stylistic lineup 'cause they're pretty awesome machines too.

The biggest issue in the decision comes to the screen: absolutely must-have the capacitive touch capability, or the use of a pen/stylus as the form of screen input, it's one of the other for the most part, and also the one factor that will affect the eventual pricing more than any other.

I owned a Fujitsu Stylistic ST4021P a few years ago, and while it did come with a stylus for the Wacom digitizer, the one cool aspect of that slate was that I could use a fingernail - not the pad or tip of my finger, the skin/fleshy part - but a fingernail to do the input. I discovered that by accident at one point and was quite happy to start using the tip of a fingernail to do the input, which made me look like somebody right outta Star Trek: The Next Generation tapping away at the screen - and that was nearly 4 years ago, before anybody even had capacitive touch screens on the market that worked worth a damn, and most certainly not in a laptop or "tablet PC." :D

Just some more ideas and opinions to consider... eBay has tons of Fujitsu Stylistic tablets from a lot of reputable resellers, so definitely keep them in mind as the are true slates, sometimes in packages with the docking stations/keyboards and other goodies as well. People are dumping the old hardware - which is still completely functional and can run Windows 7 just fine, albeit somewhat slower because of their age/hardware - in favor of the newest stuff and paying the price for it.

Can't hurt to keep the older stuff as an option for many reasons, the first being they'll be a lot cheaper and get the job done with Windows 7 just the same, if not better in the long run.
 
Back
Top