Apple Copycats Another Company's Case?

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
About a dozen people have sent me links to this article that basically shows that Apple totally copied the design for its new smart cover from someone else. I'm no expert but I can definitely see where the InCase people might have a case (pun intended) against Apple. Lawsuit in 3...2...1.

Thing is, we've seen the design before. Oh sure, Apple improved upon it significantly, but there's no mistaking its InCase Convertible Magazine Jacket heritage. See the two slug it out on video after the break in some kind of weird reverse KIRF cage match.
 
A new iPad! Time to recycle the period jokes.

I hear if you and your roomates all have an iPad after a while they sync up.
 
Just like most things in the tech realm (and elsewhere) it's easier to ask for forgiveness rather than permission. You can pretty much steal whatever you want as long as the company is small enough - then after they put up a fuss, throw them some cash and all of the sudden an 'agreement has been reached' and the larger company goes on to rack in the cash and claim innovation.
 
A new iPad! Time to recycle the period jokes.

I hear if you and your roomates all have an iPad after a while they sync up.

Eh, as much as I disdain the terrible name I can't really continue bashing it until android or windows manage to produce something better.

That said, it is a neat device but complete lack of USB and being forced to buy a "special" cable to use the hdmi renders it useless to me. I am laughing at the audacity of Apple to flat out rip off a case design though, do they have no shame anymore?
 
Kind of like how they copied the names iPad from Fujitsu and iOS from Cisco?
They licensed the iOS mark from Cisco. 'Bought and paid for', so to speak. Same with Fujitsu.

As for the 'Smart Cover' — there's a definite similarity. The article doesn't say whether the design is patented though.
 
I'm not sure a foldable case really qualifies as unique enough to mean somebody else had to see your design and 'copy it' for the end result to seem similar. I mean, any cover that can be rolled up yet still be strong enough to be a stand is going to have the same rectangular design due to physics.

There are quite a few differences, the InCase one covers the back and has a hand strap, while the Apple one supposedly almost puts itself on with it's magnets that align it and it turns the iPad on and off when opened or closed. The InCase one seems like it's trying to hide the fact that it has rectangular squares on the inside with a fabric covering, while the Apple one seems to outright wants you to notice that it's made of 4 rectangular squares. Both have something the other doesn't.
 
Well, the interesting part of the whole iOS name is that Apple was in talks with Cisco about it, but never reached an agreement. So they went ahead and used it just like the iPhone name. Cisco had to sue them in order for Apple to play ball.
 
I am shocked that someone would suggest that one of our fine upstanding American corporations, much less a company as outstanding as Apple in its, always perfectly pure ethics, has appropriated the intellectual property of another.

Why if such things were going on our otherwise perfect court system would be bogged down and filled up with patent lawsuits and other pointless activities that overall would bleed our country dry by using up resources that could go into feeding the homeless and world peace.

I am sure everyone agrees with me that a maker of such fine gadgets and technology could never once steal anything - why everything from the Apple 2 to the latest Iphone has been completely original and flawless.

That said, there are times I miss my old apple 2c. While its capabilities are insignificant by current standards, it had a feel to it - being able to write basic and with one disk pascal, so easily, as well as so many new and inventive ideas and games. Lode Runner anyone? Original Wolfenstine? The Ulitmas.
 
Eh, as much as I disdain the terrible name I can't really continue bashing it until android or windows manage to produce something better.

That said, it is a neat device but complete lack of USB and being forced to buy a "special" cable to use the hdmi renders it useless to me. I am laughing at the audacity of Apple to flat out rip off a case design though, do they have no shame anymore?

Wait wait. You can't continue to bash the name or the product until something better comes out? If your talking about a name, well a tablet makes sense. By definitoin, the shape/design is identical to a tablet in shape.In terms of performance? Ughhh, tablets again I'm afraid. They were out years before the iPad and they ARE better in many ways. USB, HDMI, Runs anything that Windows XP can, full internet browser, upgradeable, etc are just a few starting ways.

Apple just made the Apple Tablet and changed the name Tablet to iPad really, removed a lot of features and usability in favour of a really small form factor, put their own limited ecosystem on it and turned around selling it for double to triple the price based of the 'cool' // 'sleek' factor.
 
I like the apple OS and some of the devices. The ipod is a great music play - the ipad is a great lightweight portable device. For my mobile computer needs it would cover just about everything. Light word processing, light spread sheet, and general browsing interconnectivity.

My issues are with the Apple corporate culture and the gestapo like control it wants over how I, the person who has paid for the merchandise, can and will use the hardware.

I think it is funny that a corporation, well know for getting its start ripping off ideas from xerox (etc) and which continues to take what it wants, is so overbearingly litigious about protecting its self from the same practices.

I just cant respect a business model and culture that tells me what I can and cant do with a piece of hardware after I buy it.
 
Just did a search, it appears it was both.



The claim I made was copied, not stolen. ;)

I believe that they stole it first, and then later they paid for it...;) Kind of like how they first promised the Beatles that Apple Computer would never have anything to do with music, and so received Apple Records' permission to use "Apple" as a trademark for computer sales. After they stole the Apple trademark to use to sell music, Apple then paid the Beatles $50M to legitimize the whole thing.

The good thing about the things Steve Jobs steals is that he steals them in order to "pay homage" to the original owners. What a guy...:D
 
Back
Top