LEDs Filled with Toxic Substances

these morons need to start with the things we eat and report on that, try to improve that, then move to this stuff. the stuff we eat that we call "food" is so loaded with chemicals our water supplies are becoming tainted from it
 
then ground up the contents of each bulb in order to analyze the different substances, specifically a wide range of heavy metals.

Don't know about CA, but I typically don't grind LEDs, eat CFLs, and use lead for aromatherapy.
 
Dear tubular,

You're not going to find any trees to hug on the internet, you may want to check outside.

Love,
The Internet

Did you know that you drink water?
Did you know that they are mostly worried about ground water poisoning?
Did you know that drinking poisoned water is actually fairly bad for your health?

Sincerely,
Common Sense
 
Everything is known to the State of California to cause cancer and be hazardous to your health. I am starting to think it is California that causes cancer and is hazardous to your health.
 
Everything is known to the State of California to cause cancer and be hazardous to your health. I am starting to think it is California that causes cancer and is hazardous to your health.

LOL! California IS a big giant cancer!
 
Soon only organic all natural beeswax candles will be allowed in California.

That would never happen out here in California since that would be considered Bee exploitation.

Maybe if we made the candles from all the liposuction they do in Hollywood.
 
Don't know about CA, but I typically don't grind LEDs, eat CFLs, and use lead for aromatherapy.

The article is talking about disposal of LED products. Which in some dumps/recycling facilities they do ground up their bulk. As far as enough to be really hazardous who really knows.

I doubt theres enough LED trash out there right now to worry about as far as hazardous waste goes, everyone knew LED was hazardous but I think there should be proper disposal, remember CRTs got the exact same treatment.
 
i know it doesnt make it any better, but dont most consumer electronics get shipped overseas where they get dumped in some third world country to get stripped by the local people hard up for work? i saw a tv spot on this once
 
and the amount of LEDS you could use in a lifetime would probably be about equal to 1 of those tubes.

Wait wait wait...WTF's your deal??? Don't bring truth and logic to our severely over-regulatory Commie-fornian cultured elitists! Are you trying to destroy their minds? :eek: :p

At least some of them see through another "rallying war cry du jour". *chuckles*
 
these morons need to start with the things we eat and report on that, try to improve that, then move <on to something equally important>. the stuff we eat that we call "food" is so <intentionally> loaded with chemicals...

FTFY. ;)

PS: Great call, but that would have a REAL impact, and as such, will remain dismissed in the topic of "concerns". :(
 
FTFY. ;)

PS: Great call, but that would have a REAL impact, and as such, will remain dismissed in the topic of "concerns". :(

yeah....i dont know....it's just something about the fact the food goes through our bodies BEFORE getting into the water and soil that concerns me....and then it comes back because none of our water "treatment" plants are equipped to strip it like it needs to be
 
yeah....i dont know....it's just something about the fact the food goes through our bodies BEFORE getting into the water and soil that concerns me....and then it comes back because none of our water "treatment" plants are equipped to strip it like it needs to be

*nods*

I think the greater affront to the senses in this case is, that everyone wants to whine about relatively minor inconsequential things like this, rather than address things like our food sources/processing which has a FAR greater impact, our homeless, our healthcare, our jobs, social security, etc.

It's a collective "what can we cry out on to distract them this time" to keep from dealing with the truly important issues at hand. *sigh*

Once we (the USA) gets some of the *priority issues* solved (NOT lip serviced again for the umpteenth million time) or at least substantially improved (read as: 60-80% improvement), THEN things like this would be welcomed with open arms. But even then, I'd put feeding other nations above this level of concern, but again, only after we've got our own house in order on the previous issues mentioned.
 
Nuclear waste has the potential to be harmful, we're not publishing sensational articles about it. It's no big deal to use nuclear power or LEDs provided that we find environmentally friendly methods of disposing nuclear waste and old LEDs.
 
Nuclear waste has the potential to be harmful, we're not publishing sensational articles about it. It's no big deal to use nuclear power or LEDs provided that we find environmentally friendly methods of disposing nuclear waste and old LEDs.

1) Everybody knows nuclear waste is harmful, this is not the case with LEDs. I have them in several places around my house and love the hell out of them, buy LED replacements for things whenever I can. I had no idea they had stuff like this inside of them.

2) This article was not really sensational, just informative. You are absolutely correct about just needing to find environmentally friendly methods of disposing of these things. Currently there ARE regulations about how you are allowed to dispose of nuclear waste and there are NOT regulations of how to dispose of LEDs.

What they are trying for is regulations on how to dispose of LEDs. That is what the article is about if you had read it!
 
1) Everybody knows nuclear waste is harmful, this is not the case with LEDs. I have them in several places around my house and love the hell out of them, buy LED replacements for things whenever I can. I had no idea they had stuff like this inside of them.

2) This article was not really sensational, just informative. You are absolutely correct about just needing to find environmentally friendly methods of disposing of these things. Currently there ARE regulations about how you are allowed to dispose of nuclear waste and there are NOT regulations of how to dispose of LEDs.

What they are trying for is regulations on how to dispose of LEDs. That is what the article is about if you had read it!

Haha mind-reader, I hadn't read the article when I made the post ;). Good call.
 
Wait wait wait...WTF's your deal??? Don't bring truth and logic to our severely over-regulatory Commie-fornian cultured elitists! Are you trying to destroy their minds? :eek: :p

At least some of them see through another "rallying war cry du jour". *chuckles*


You are mocking the need to properly dispose of LEDs as tubes are way worse.
Many states and counties across the country are banning Tubes from landfills and incinerators.

How does your point make any logical sense? I mean it points out pretty obviously that you didn't do any real research into disposal practices and methods, but how does it in any way further your obvious conclusion that LEDs do not need proper disposal methods?

Is this really news?

What about tube televisions with a good hunk of lead and mercury in them? Pretty much ever modern device has something harmful in it. Hell even mattresses and couches are doused in heavy amounts of fire retardants which for a number of years leached into all of our bodies.

Same as above. And obviously you can't regulate everything at once all of the sudden.

I find it odd that they list copper as one of the harmful chemicals. Anyone that has running water is drinking water out of copper pipes. Even if you have a new home that uses PEX, the fittings are still made out of copper.

I agree, but what they said about copper was this
"copper would have the greatest impact on human and ecological health due to their ability to bioaccumulate"

I had no idea copper had a negative affect on the human body but it stands to reason that if it gathers in your body faster than your body can remove it that it might be harmful. Maybe it already being IN the water previously has some sort of great affect on you? I would be curious to find out.

On a quick google search I found this about the bio accumulation of copper.
"Copper significantly damages the surface of living cells, which results in partial loss of cell-binding abilities and release of accumulated copper back into solution. The binding capacity of living cells is significantly lower than that of dead cells. There is also a possibility of desorption and reuse of biomass in case of biosorption."
But I have no idea how reliable this source was and I would like to learn more about this subject.

It's just a study in California. They are kinda wackjob crazy out there so I'm just going to dismiss this.
Kind of like lead. Unless you are eating it, no real harm.

Can't we give California to Mexico or China?

Its harmful to humans if it is somehow ingested into the human body. And that is exactly what they are worried about. Oh ya, lead is in LEDs.

Please read the article.

Everything causes cancer in California. Hasn't affected my life yet.

Cigarettes cause cancer. My Grandma is 85 and has smoked a pack a week for the past 65 years.

Obesity greatly increases the risk of heart attack. There are many people who have been obese for decades and have not had heart attacks.

I hope you can see the flaw in your logic.

"In the LEDs, the researchers found toxic chemicals..."

Why didn't these morons just ask the LED makers what they're using?

Agreed! Exactly what I first though. Maybe they figured the manufacturers wouldn't be honest about it? They are already being manufactured with 8x the allowed lead amounts, so obviously the manufacturers are already ignoring some laws and regulations.

and the amount of LEDS you could use in a lifetime would probably be about equal to 1 of those tubes.

And in many states and counties you would have to properly dispose of just one tube as well so I fail to see your point. Also these LEDs have a wider variety of harmful chemicals and metals.

More insane eco mentalist crap, so they would prefer the lead bulbs they are pushing now where if one breaks in your house it's 10k and a week to get it cleaned! LED's are the future they last forever and use next to no power.

Where in that article do they ever say that should no longer be used? If you had actually read the article you would have read this near the end.
"Researchers stated that further research should be conducted by individual developers and manufacturers of LED products in order to produce the safest products possible for both consumers and the environment after their use"

How is that in any way condemning LED technology? If anything it is promoting it...

CFL's are thrown out by the hundreds of thousands in land fills and isn't Mercury the 2nd most toxic substance more so than the others? Why aren't they mentioning that? Where is the research on the recycling percentage of CFL's? It's probably low.

Besides, CFL's are more likely to release mercury than an LED. My dead grandmother can break a CFL. I'd have to hit the LED with a hammer to release the toxins. Big difference.

Why would they talk about CFLs when the article and research are both about LEDs? There are other articles specifically on CFLs, if you want to read about CFLs then go read one of those other articles. Pretty simple concept I'm thinking.

Or are you instead implying that if an article is about one thing, they should always talk about the other things that are worse than that?

'Breaking local news, last night there was a drive by shooting that left 3 dead and 2 hospitalized in the lower east end. Dont worry though, thousands more were killed in other countries!'

'This just in, eating too much red meat can cause heart attacks! And now for the next 5 hours we will talk about every other food that we can think of that is also bad for you.'

Deal with lead on a daily basis here. I have for 20 years. Never once score high on the tests they give me. No gloves, respirators, or eye wear.
My dad doesn't either, he's worked at the same place for 35 years.

Gun range FTW. non-updated filtration system. Grandfathered into every EPA law.

This is clearly evidence that lead is not harmful for you at all. Remember all those people in history and medical journals that died of lead poisoning? All one big conspiracy theory reaching back hundreds of years.


-----------------------------------------
This is the last sentence of the article for those that refuse to read it because it is left wing liberal hype or whatever other crazy thing you think.

"Finally, the study emphasized the fact that while LEDs are incredibly efficient, they are not completely environmentally friendly and simply carry different environmental and health risks than their counterparts."
 
"I agree, but what they said about copper was this
"copper would have the greatest impact on human and ecological health due to their ability to bioaccumulate""

Sorry, it wasnt just copper, I pasted too little, it was arsenic, lead, nickel, and copper. My apologies.
 
This is very... interesting. Ok either I missed it or not, but I'm suprised that no one has mentioned the smog in L.A. lol. Honestly I could care less right now about what gets thrown away because in some shape or form its going into our bodies and if not from that particular source than from another. Don't quote me on that, but with how much littering and crap one see's just on the side of the road it wouldn't suprise me. Hell I was up in the hills couple years ago kicking around what I thought was white ash next to an oil heater when my dad told me that was asbestos. I'm all up for living longer, but I don't want to live 20 more years under way higher taxes, more regulations and less freedom.
 
We need water people, everyone should be after a double-check on this and make sure everyone is safe.

Don't be an asshole and say "oh shit is nothing" as you could be right... but you could also be wrong and if you are then well, what happens when its too late before you actually believe the supposed "myth" ???

LEDs are green because they save power, not because they are made of bio-friendly materials.... without a doubt, stupid consumers who don't know any better about "LEDs are Green!" will assume LEDs are an all around safe and eco friendly material... totally not the case and untrue. Someone needs to inform the public (aka most stupid consumers who dont read informative news stories)
 
Next year, LED's will cost $100 each because of this.
 
Last time I checked, LED were not "bulbs" in the sense that flouro and incandescent are bulbs. They cannot be broken like the former.

I would also like to point out that LEDs emit more visible light per watt of energy used than any other light source we have available and they last a lot longer. Like 10-15 years longer.
 
Water is wet too and we all know the dangers of drowning yet still we vacation at the seashore.

Someone should do a study on coal mine tailings and pollution that results from mining operations. It's always a trade off between one bad and another bad. This ain't no Disney picture.
 
Maybe Steve is lonely, and he just loves to talk to us here at the [H]. :D He knows that as soon as he posts anything on the front page news, there will be like 100 people posting in the next 5mins. Who knows...
 
1) Everybody knows nuclear waste is harmful, this is not the case with LEDs. I have them in several places around my house and love the hell out of them, buy LED replacements for things whenever I can. I had no idea they had stuff like this inside of them.

Well, considering they're a semiconductor doped with Gallium arsenide, Aluminium gallium phosphide, and any number of arsenides and phosphides depending on the n-p junction and how they're doped and the desired color... how could you not know?
 
Yep, they ground up LED's... since the "bad" part of the LED's are encased in plastic that would probably take thousands of years to degrade, the immediate hazards of leaching would be minimal. But as with all electronic components, they should be disposed of as e-waste. It's not like the CFL replacement bulbs don't have a circuit board on them with lots of "dangerous" chemicals/elements on them if one GROUND THEM UP into a powder.

How does grinding something up change the chemical composition at all? Why are you so willing to bet the future on the mere chance plastic will hold it together (and never break, leak, crack)?

Is it really such an attack on your liberties to want to prevent hazardous materials from leaking into the ground? Or are you of the typical mindset of dealing with problems when there is no other option?
 
Well, considering they're a semiconductor doped with Gallium arsenide, Aluminium gallium phosphide, and any number of arsenides and phosphides depending on the n-p junction and how they're doped and the desired color... how could you not know?

Because I didnt realize they had Gallium arsenide, Aluminium gallium phosphide, or anything else in them? I don't know what an n-p junction is either!

hahahah, I'm going to take this sarcasm, and as such, very funny :)
 
Including the Sun. I'm surprised Californicateyou hasn't outlawed the Sun.

Give them time... :(

Wanna know how to prevent groundwater pollution? Keep humans away from it, simple really. Most groundwater toxification incidents are caused by human activities. So, to keep groundwater clean, keep people away from it. Brilliant! :D
 
Groundwater contamination = farce

Follow the Money

It's about control

What? You actually believe this?
That is terrible. Groundwater pollution very well might be the number one cause of death worldwide. Thinking it doesnt exist is ignoring more deaths than worldwar 1 and 2 combined many many times over again.

Just because you live in a north america and have nice mostly pollutant free water doesnt mean water is clean everywhere else you go........
Please try exiting your bubble someday and actually realizing there is a whole WORLD out there omgwtfbbq
 
and compact florescent bulbs are packed full of mercury. As far as disposal is concerned the good old inefficient incandescent bulb is much safer. Personally I think couple more PPM of CO2 is much better than flinging heavy metals all over the place.
 
Really they just want safe disposal methods and LEDs made with less harmful materials, like arsenic.
LEDs are good. Making them less toxic than they already are is also good.

And honestly you would think that LEDs made with less heavy metals would be cheaper, right?
 
Yeah, fuck it - I like higher electric bills. Back to incandescents I go!

Oh wait

:rolleyes:
 
Still less hazardous than the crap you would find inside a laptop, and your talking about tiny amounts of those chemicals.
 
Ya know, this would be an interesting study to me if they didn't do 3 important things:

1. Grind up the LED into powder to remove any casing and make permeation easier.
2. Expose it to unknown landfill conditions wherein other chemicals reside in the soil.
3. Expose it to ACID RAIN which I assume means sulfur dioxide or nitrogen dioxide so things break down even easier.

I could take a piece of paper and make it dangerous with the unknown additives and reactions there. Aside from that, who made the 'landfill condition' soil or air? Where did it come from? How strong was the acid rain when they say "nightmare conditions"?

To be completely honest, you could take about the equivalent weight of an LED in Centrum Performance pills and use these conditions to make a really scary combo in the ground. They've got Iron, Zinc, Copper, Chromium, Magnesium, Molybdenum, Celenium, Iodine, Boron, Nickel, Silicon, Vanadium and Tin for starters. Does this mean Centrum should have a biohazard warning and that you should call Hazmat to open the bottle for fear of dust exposure?
 
Ugh I am so tired these articles trying to blow things out of proportion. Just being alive puts you at risk for getting cancer. Get over it
 
Back
Top