Verizon Throttles Data Hogs

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
I guess the big question here is this...are you in the top five percent? I have a sneaky feeling that, if anyone was in the top 5%, it would be you guys. :D Thanks to cbags101 for the link.

On Thursday we now know there's a catch. If you're in the top 5 percent of Verizon's data users, you'll be throttled. Verizon announced the change in a note on its Website (PDF link). Once you've crossed the 5 percent threshold, Verizon will reduce your data speeds "periodically ... at locations and times of peak demand" through the next billing cycle.
 
I really hate all this fair usage crap, if you pay for an "unlimited" contract then surly the limit should be the max speed possible times the amount of time.

Say 1mb/s was the max speed then the limit should be about 590GB a week, yes i know that's a crazy amount of data and insane for a mobile connection but unlimited to me should mean the only limitation is the speed of the connection across the time of the contract.
 
Seems pretty fair to me imo. If you use a lot of bandwidth they might throttle you during peak times. Sounds like it only benefits everyone as a whole. They did not say we are going to shut you down whenever you hit x limit. I mean to me it seems like you could still call it an unlimited contract. Assuming they do as they say its only going to throttle when its in a peak area/time and that makes sense to me.
 
I'm not sure why this is suddenly in the media. Currently if you breach 5GB they throttle you back anyways. I could care less. The throttling doesn't stop me from doing anything and I breach 5GB without tethering pretty consistently. HQ Youtube videos, streaming Flash media, and NFL Mobile Live eats up a lot of bandwidth.
 
Interesting, so users before Feburary 3rd were grandfathered:

If you subscribe to a Data Plan or Feature on February 3, 2011 or after, the following applies:

I'm paying Verizon $80 a month for a 4G modem with a 10 GB cap. They really don't need to screw me further.
 
I think it would have been nice to point out that this is mobile data, as opposed to Verizon's FIOS or DSL products.
 
I really hate all this fair usage crap, if you pay for an "unlimited" contract then surly the limit should be the max speed possible times the amount of time.

Say 1mb/s was the max speed then the limit should be about 590GB a week, yes i know that's a crazy amount of data and insane for a mobile connection but unlimited to me should mean the only limitation is the speed of the connection across the time of the contract.

Couldn't agree more with you. It should be against the law to call this bullshit "unlimited" Its not even remotely so.

Its so crazy that you can get away with calling something unlimited when it is in fact VERY limited.

ISPs around the world are just going insane , poor Canada can't even use Netflix now without first putting a down payment down there intended bandwidth first.
 
Thankfully this type of behavior is perfectly fine under Net Neutrality rules here in the USA.
 
Seems pretty fair to me imo. If you use a lot of bandwidth they might throttle you during peak times. Sounds like it only benefits everyone as a whole. They did not say we are going to shut you down whenever you hit x limit. I mean to me it seems like you could still call it an unlimited contract. Assuming they do as they say its only going to throttle when its in a peak area/time and that makes sense to me.

They don't just throttle you at peak times though. It says you can be throttled for the entirely of not just your current billing cycle but also the NEXT month's billing cycle too. So if you use too much data in January (a number that is hidden and you won't know) you could have significantly slower speeds all the way through to the start of March. Seeing as how Verizon's EVDO isn't exactly a speed demon at full speed (1Mbps is about the average maximum you're going to see) you could be looking at 2 months of very slow data.
 
Good thing the data package isn't mandatory pr that would suck! I'll just use the internet when there's wifi available and save money.


Oh...wait
 
I really hate all this fair usage crap, if you pay for an "unlimited" contract then surly the limit should be the max speed possible times the amount of time.

Say 1mb/s was the max speed then the limit should be about 590GB a week, yes i know that's a crazy amount of data and insane for a mobile connection but unlimited to me should mean the only limitation is the speed of the connection across the time of the contract.


That makes entirely too much sense.
The marketing people and lawyers will never allow that.
 
I think it would have been nice to point out that this is mobile data, as opposed to Verizon's FIOS or DSL products.

yep...was like wtf.

seriously i expect this from mobile, i have a hard time seeing massive amounts of data being transmitted to a handset at this point in time. Naturally that will grow...however for now i don't see much of this as unreasonable.

a home internet connection on the other hand...totally different world
 
whew, title startled me for a second. luckily i only subscribe to their home internet service (not mobile)
 
At least if I want to cancel my contract I can bring this issue up and use it as leverage to avoid paying an early cancellation fee. I love it when companies increase demand and don't bother to properly manage the capacity side of things. I guess streaming football games while traveling for work will be a bit more of a problem.
 
Punishment for using what you paid to use in the first place.

Sounds an awful lot like Insurance.
 
Glad I have ATT. They don't throttle the unlimited 3G. I've consistently used around 10GB a month on my iPhone without any slowdowns.
 
yep...was like wtf.

seriously i expect this from mobile, i have a hard time seeing massive amounts of data being transmitted to a handset at this point in time. Naturally that will grow...however for now i don't see much of this as unreasonable.

a home internet connection on the other hand...totally different world

Honestly, on just my phone, before tethering 5GB is not hard at all. It's called Hulu and YouTube.
 
At least if I want to cancel my contract I can bring this issue up and use it as leverage to avoid paying an early cancellation fee. I love it when companies increase demand and don't bother to properly manage the capacity side of things. I guess streaming football games while traveling for work will be a bit more of a problem.

You still get "unlimited" data even when your speed is throttled.

Anyways, this is good. When 5% of your user base is using the majority of the bandwidth and you have network congestion, there's a problem.
 
Honestly, on just my phone, before tethering 5GB is not hard at all. It's called Hulu and YouTube.

Unless you're watching Hulu at work all day on your phone, yea it is hard for most people. This is assuming you have Wifi at home.
 
I used around 14GB tethering to my Droid X last month but I will admit I am not a normal user.

I'm actually ********** the movie Faster right now as I type this tethered to my phone.

Am I the problem here?

Yeah, well...

|
|
|
|
|
|
|
v


Tough shit!!
 
If they keep throttling the top 5% of each month every month, wouldn't they finally hit a point where everyone's basically been throttled?

Even though it says:

Once you've crossed the 5 percent threshold, Verizon will reduce your data speeds "periodically ... at locations and times of peak demand" through the next billing cycle.

So, even if you're just throttled the next month, and go back to your regular ways the month after that and go back into that 5% bracket the month after your throttle, this still means you are throttled every-other month.

What this really means is not that the top 5% are throttled, but that (at the minimum) the top 10% are throttled every other month, assuming they stick to their ways after their throttle.

So, you either adjust your ways permanently, or the top 10% are throttled every-other month. If you adjust your ways permanently, more than the current top 10% are effectively throttled.

Looks a little different now, doesn't it?
 
If they keep throttling the top 5% of each month every month, wouldn't they finally hit a point where everyone's basically been throttled?

Even though it says:



So, even if you're just throttled the next month, and go back to your regular ways the month after that and go back into that 5% bracket the month after your throttle, this still means you are throttled every-other month.

What this really means is not that the top 5% are throttled, but that (at the minimum) the top 10% are throttled every other month, assuming they stick to their ways after their throttle.

So, you either adjust your ways permanently, or the top 10% are throttled every-other month. If you adjust your ways permanently, more than the current top 10% are effectively throttled.

Looks a little different now, doesn't it?

Does not look that much difference imo. To be throttled you have surpass some cap and be in the top 5%. Who knows what that "extraordinary" amount is but it is there. I am very much against the arbitrary caps put into place my ISPs but when it comes to mobile companies I can somewhat understand the issue. I just look at how often ATT network is crippled in high traffic areas.
 
I am sure they must refund those customers that use very little data each month as well...
:rolleyes:
 
Does not look that much difference imo. To be throttled you have surpass some cap and be in the top 5%. Who knows what that "extraordinary" amount is but it is there.

The "amount" is determined by the top 5% of users each month.

But don't confuse this with thinking it will only affect 5% of users. It won't. Each month 5% of different users will be throttled, so at minimum in each two-month timespan 10% of users should have been affected by this throttle.

The only way this doesn't happen if it they throttle you, but you can still end up in the top 5%. If you can, then the throttle is ineffective.

Assuming the throttle is effective, 10% of users will have been throttled for a month every two months.
 
The "amount" is determined by the top 5% of users each month.

But don't confuse this with thinking it will only affect 5% of users. It won't. Each month 5% of different users will be throttled, so at minimum in each two-month timespan 10% of users should have been affected by this throttle.

The only way this doesn't happen if it they throttle you, but you can still end up in the top 5%. If you can, then the throttle is ineffective.

Assuming the throttle is effective, 10% of users will have been throttled for a month every two months.

Wow, big math fail here.
 
Back
Top