I need PCIe lanes!

Speed-Freak

Limp Gawd
Joined
May 23, 2000
Messages
246
I am looking at upgrading my main desktop. The problem I am running in to is there seem to be very few boards that have enough PCIe lanes for how I want to setup my system.

Primary Vid card x16
Secondary vid card x16
OCZ RevoDrive x4
Asus Xonar x1

Anyone else feeling my pain when looking for a new board?
 
[H] reviews say you will be fine with 8x on your secondary videocard.
 
[H] reviews state that you'll be fine at x8 on both cards if you're not doing extremely high resolution NVSurround or Eyefinity (3 1920x1200 or above monitors). I don't think any motherboard can supply x16 to the second graphics card while still providing x4 to your SSD. Maybe you'll have better luck with the Asus M4A89TD, as that board has two x16 slots and an x4, but I'm not sure how the lanes are configured.
 
The new Intel DX58SO2 has x16, x16, x8 (physically x16) and then another x1 slot, should work for you. 40 PCIe 2.0 lanes, gives them ability to do it on X58, it's just difficult finding a board where they divide it the way you want it.
 
I thought I had the X58 version. Apparently its not for sale a newegg anymore.
 
Is that a joke? The P55 chipset only has 16 PCIe 2.0 lanes to begin with, if you want to use the nf200 chip to multiplex the lanes, that's any option, but you're still limited on total bandwidth by those 16 lanes.
The P55 chipset has 8 PCIe lanes, and can only be configured as x1 - x4, including connecting PCIe devices on the motherboard itself. The 16 PCIe lanes used by video card(s) are built into the CPU.

A P55 based system would handle the OP's requirements if he didn't mind running the video cards in x8/x8 mode.

A better option than LGA 1156 of course is LGA 1155 plus a 2500K. At MC, a P67 board + CPU would be around $300 and be dead simple to overclock.
 
The P55 chipset has 8 PCIe lanes, and can only be configured as x1 - x4, including connecting PCIe devices on the motherboard itself. The 16 PCIe lanes used by video card(s) are built into the CPU.

A P55 based system would handle the OP's requirements if he didn't mind running the video cards in x8/x8 mode.

A better option than LGA 1156 of course is LGA 1155 plus a 2500K. At MC, a P67 board + CPU would be around $300 and be dead simple to overclock.

Sorry, I should have said the CPU only had 16 2.0 lanes. The chipset also has 8 1.1 lanes, but they're hindered by the DMI link (2 GB/s) back to the CPU, meaning they're absolutely useless when it comes to using them for an SSD card.

The same goes for LGA 1155, the DMI link now has more bandwidth (20 Gb/s, yes a lowercase b, Intel didn't want to make it look too bad when shown in the block diagram), but it's still the weak point and you'd want to avoid it if you're using an PCIe SSD card. Nothing like the bandwidth QPI (25.6 GB/s) provides.
 
It seems the answer is...
YES!

Looking more and more like I may have to wait for the LGA 2011 X-series chipset from Intel. Rumor mill has it coming with 40 PCIe lanes native over 2 QPI interfaces. Really got fired up seeing the Sandy Bridge reviews but for my application they are crippled by the P67 chipset.

The two video cards are NOT run in SLI/Crossfire. I have a 30" screen running off the primary vid card and two 24" screens running off the secondary card. So I can indeed take advantage of true x16/x16 PCIe slots.
I appreciate the discussion. Lets see what we can find in the mean time.

SF
 
The two video cards are NOT run in SLI/Crossfire. I have a 30" screen running off the primary vid card and two 24" screens running off the secondary card. So I can indeed take advantage of true x16/x16 PCIe slots.
I appreciate the discussion. Lets see what we can find in the mean time.
...and no, you can't. It still won't make a difference if both slots are running 8 lanes each instead of 16.
 
thanks yeah I got fooled by that new diagram, thinking was a 10 fold increase in bandwidth.

Is QPI really expensive to add or something? or is intel just been lame by deliberatly making QPI top end only.
 
I am looking at upgrading my main desktop. The problem I am running in to is there seem to be very few boards that have enough PCIe lanes for how I want to setup my system.

Primary Vid card x16
Secondary vid card x16
OCZ RevoDrive x4
Asus Xonar x1

Anyone else feeling my pain when looking for a new board?

Are you planning on upgrading? Dont see a signature attached, so thought id ask :)
Here is a LINK of comparison of the # of lanes between P67/H67/H61 and P55/P57/H55 chipsets... (Scroll down to the middle of the page where you see a Chipset comparison table)

The P67/H67 both have 8 PCIe Lanes (5GT/s) both ways... If you need more than that then i suggest waiting wait for LGA 2011...
 
Is QPI really expensive to add or something? or is intel just been lame by deliberatly making QPI top end only.
Not expensive to add. DMI is lower risk (server platforms typically lag corresponding desktop platforms by months... not due to sitting on hands) and is good enough for the target market. And of course Intel would like to sell higher end hardware in higher end configurations. The DIY crowd tends to think of themselves as average consumers, but the enthusiast "(I think) I need this and that," even if they don't, amounts to a tiny percentage overall.

And for the fear I read a couple of weeks ago about SATA 6Gbps throughput on "slow" DMI, check out the performance on techreport.com where the awesomely fast HT connected SATA 6Gbps controller on the AMD system is totally crushed by the "slow" DMI connected SATA 6Gbps controller on the Sandy Bridge system.
 
And for the fear I read a couple of weeks ago about SATA 6Gbps throughput on "slow" DMI, check out the performance on techreport.com where the awesomely fast HT connected SATA 6Gbps controller on the AMD system is totally crushed by the "slow" DMI connected SATA 6Gbps controller on the Sandy Bridge system.

I don't think we're worried about a single sata 6g devices having issues, more like hanging a OCZ Z-Drive off of the pcie slots for your boot drive while having multiple hard drives hanging off the sata ports. You only have 20 Gb/s of bandwidth over that DMI link, where you have 40 Gb/s of bandwidth going to your 8 PCIe 2.0 lanes, plus all the other things you have hanging off of chipset.
 
The two video cards are NOT run in SLI/Crossfire. I have a 30" screen running off the primary vid card and two 24" screens running off the secondary card. So I can indeed take advantage of true x16/x16 PCIe slots.
I appreciate the discussion. Lets see what we can find in the mean time.
Then why do you want both to be x16?

Is QPI really expensive to add or something? or is intel just been lame by deliberatly making QPI top end only.
It's just that 1 QPI per CPU limits it to single-socket boards. Dual-socket boards need CPUs with 2 QPIs or they don't work. And Intel likes to charge people who need this kind of thing through the nose.
 
I don't think we're worried about a single sata 6g devices having issues, more like hanging a OCZ Z-Drive off of the pcie slots for your boot drive while having multiple hard drives hanging off the sata ports. You only have 20 Gb/s of bandwidth over that DMI link, where you have 40 Gb/s of bandwidth going to your 8 PCIe 2.0 lanes, plus all the other things you have hanging off of chipset.
And why would someone with a high end configuration go for a mainstream to low end platform? I know some would just because LGA 1155 is available first, but that scarenario seems a bit contrived.
 
And why would someone with a high end configuration go for a mainstream to low end platform? I know some would just because LGA 1155 is available first, but that scarenario seems a bit contrived.

Did you read the OP and then read the responses? I think we're in agreement here, that the current choice is x58 for a single processor system until the higher end Intel products are released for Sandy Bridge.
 
Back
Top