Intel Insider - It's Not DRM

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
There have been stories describing Intel Insider as a ‘DRM’ technology. DRM means ‘Digital Rights Management’ and is used to control the use of digital media by controlling access, and preventing the ability to copy media such as movies. This means that if you pay only a rental fee, your service provider decides when and for how long you will be able to view your movie. Or if you buy a film it will let you keep and view it forever, but not copy it and share it with your friends, or burn it onto a DVD, mass produce it and sell it on the streets. DRM is a piece of software, not hardware. Now there are opponents and proponents of DRM, and I am not going to get into a discussion about the pros and cons of DRM in this blog; but I will say that Intel Insider is NOT a DRM technology.
 
They can try and spin it all they want, but it amounts to the same thing. The only real difference is they are doing it with hardware (not a new trick by any means). So really it should be called something like HDRM or Hardware digital rights management as you are using hardware to control digital content rights. So "technically" it is not drm, but that is naturally abusing a technicality of the wording.
 
then what is it?

So Intel created Intel insider, an extra layer of content protection.

Modern PC’s with components from chip makers such as Intel, AMD and Nvidia already support another feature called ‘HDCP’ or High-Bandwidth Digital Content Protection

if they compare it to HDCP, which IS drm, then what is it?
 
Reminds me of an Animaniacs episode way back. "Do you want pasta or noodles? Marinara or red sauce? Drink or beverage?"
 
then what is it?

It's encryption/decryption of content that is being streamed directly to be played your TV. Intel's case seems to be that DRM is only "DRM" when it's protecting a file you had to begin with, where in this case there is no file since the intent is for the media to be played in real time and not buffered/saved ala "renting" over iTunes (where they actually give you a file, which then expires after a few views).
 
It's as shocking as HDCP (an encryption layer not controlled by the media owner), which "protects" the signal from the video output device to a TV/monitor. "DRM" has just become a scare word that triggers turning off the brain. :p
 
In its basic form, it is a type of DRM, just like HDCP. I don't think it will be any more intrusive to the computing experience, though, reading its description. My take is that like HDCP protects source data to the display device, this Insider stuff seems like it works the same way only via a network acting as the source.
 
How is Intel Insider not DRM?

DRM

DRM

Sounds like a stupid politician making herself sound even more idiotic.

It's not DRM because it makes no decisions about whether content can be viewed or copied. It blindly encrypts the data passed to it to protect the content during point to point transmission.
 
What a terrible marketing job. An apparently brief announcement with few facts, and a poorly spun blog article. Intel Insider appears to be a movie service, no wait its a content protection hardware feature of the 2011 core processor, no wait its "Not DRM".

The technology in the 2011 core processors that enables this appears to indeed not be DRM, much in the same way that HDCP is not DRM. But it is content-protection technology.

The problem is, it's utter BS. So I'm expected to buy a completely new computer just to watch a movie? No Thanks.
 
What everyone needs to realise is that the new Sandy Bridge processors have this added layer of DRM. If you plan on upgrading, keep an older PC around for capturing content. I'm not touching the new chips and I don't know why this new "feature" wasn't mentioned in the reviews.
 
What a load of double-talk bullshit. Jeez, do they really think we are that damned stupid?
 
It's not DRM because it makes no decisions about whether content can be viewed or copied. It blindly encrypts the data passed to it to protect the content during point to point transmission.

It IS DRM because it controls the data being sent to the "purchaser". When the control of the data purchased is not controlled by the purchaser and falls to another to determine what the purchaser can do with it then it is DRM. Blind encryption like that contained in HDCP and this technology is without question DRM because it only takes the rights of the sender into consideration. When control is given on both sides of the "blind encryption" as you stated then they can say it isn't DRM. And if for one minute you think that this technology does NOT make decisions about where the content can or can't be viewed you are delusional. Just use a pre-HDCP compatible monitor and I GUARANTEE you that content will not be allowed to be displayed.

Funny quote from the article:
"Think of it as an armoured truck carrying the movie from the Internet to your display, it keeps the data safe from pirates, but still lets you enjoy your legally acquired movie in the best possible quality."

If that analogy were true there would be NO NEED for the armored truck once it got to your machine because you are NOT a pirate since you bought the content in the first place. What they are saying is here is the data you paid for, we delivered it, and kept if from the pirates , but even if you paid for it, it's not YOURS, it's OURS and we are letting you use it for now as long as you comply with our demands. If you don't comply you can't watch it even if you paid for it.
 
My law-abiding media and software-purchasing legit customer ass has been bummed bleeding red too many times by DRM since the early 2000's (one fine example: I got hold of an RGB monitor, beautiful image quality, games never looked better.. but DVDs appeared in green and black thanks to MacroVision. Which was easily circumvented by a bootdisc but still). This seals the deal, I'm going BullDozer unless that too implements something like this, but does it worse.
 
... and the military doesn't kill anybody, they just depopulate the area.
 
It's not DRM because it makes no decisions about whether content can be viewed or copied. It blindly encrypts the data passed to it to protect the content during point to point transmission.
Yeah, it's copy protection. Considering there is no formal definition for DRM, you can't really say whether copy protection is or isn't a form of digital rights management. Either way, though, you can't exercise Fair Use rights because of CP, so the end result is the same.
 
Jeez I thought Intel built processors! Now they're getting involved with RIAA and MPAA. Not sure this "insider" is a good idea.
 
So Intel isn't locking out overclocking on SB, you can still overclock but only the most expensive models and there will be a $25 price premium on top of them. And they're not putting a DRM in the new procs either, its just something that acts like a DRM.

Gotta say, not a big fan of Sandy Bridge so far. Hopefully AMD won't follow this trend.
 
Hopefully AMD won't follow this trend.
Well, AMD Fusion processors and every major manufacturer of modern video cards support scary DRM like HDCP and P(A)VP. Not only that, but the x86 instruction set in general is capable of supporting many different DRM schemes. It's like Halloween in January. Scary new information to chill your spine. :rolleyes:

Seriously, whenever DRM is mentioned, most people actually come out less informed than they were minutes earlier. :p
 
yeah, i'm still trying to figure out how intel has been coerced into building this tech into their hardware design. I can understand if there is a potential client base that they are trying to win or keep by this move, but it sure as heck isn't being done in light of the general consumer
 
yeah, i'm still trying to figure out how intel has been coerced into building this tech into their hardware design.
Blinders blind thinking.

Intel Insider is a proposed application of the strong encryption hardware engine. The encryption engine could actually be very handy for many different applications. The biggest drawback is that it's limited to SB, which would also be the problem for Intel Insider.
 
Blinders blind thinking.

Intel Insider is a proposed application of the strong encryption hardware engine. The encryption engine could actually be very handy for many different applications. The biggest drawback is that it's limited to SB, which would also be the problem for Intel Insider.

So the Intel Insider is really just a feature designed to improve security and could be used broadly for a variety of purposes that WOULD be beneficial to the general consumer?
 
If that analogy were true there would be NO NEED for the armored truck once it got to your machine because you are NOT a pirate since you bought the content in the first place. What they are saying is here is the data you paid for, we delivered it, and kept if from the pirates , but even if you paid for it, it's not YOURS, it's OURS and we are letting you use it for now as long as you comply with our demands. If you don't comply you can't watch it even if you paid for it.

^^ Right on the money with this one

... and the military doesn't kill anybody, they just depopulate the area.

^^ Made me chuckle

So Intel isn't locking out overclocking on SB, you can still overclock but only the most expensive models and there will be a $25 price premium on top of them. And they're not putting a DRM in the new procs either, its just something that acts like a DRM.

Gotta say, not a big fan of Sandy Bridge so far. Hopefully AMD won't follow this trend.

I got back into AMD just because of this. Keeping my fingers crossed.
 
So the Intel Insider is really just a feature designed to improve security and could be used broadly for a variety of purposes that WOULD be beneficial to the general consumer?

It's nothing more than hardware decryption that could be used for many things.

The most obvious of those things being that since they already have integrated high-def video/audio decoders on their chips, they could theoretically make a 100% hardware-level media reception, decoding, decryption, and playback pathway that is encrypted from start to finish and doesn't interact with your operating system or software at all.
 
So the Intel Insider is really just a feature designed to improve security and could be used broadly for a variety of purposes that WOULD be beneficial to the general consumer?
Back up a second. "Intel Insider" is the name a proposed application of the encryption engine. It is not a service that exists. It does not wrap around any existing applications. I have not seen the name of the encryption engine, which is why I typed out the whole long thing a couple of times already. :p

To answer your question, no, it would not be broadly beneficial to users who have no need for strong encryption. Most users would never use it. But it does have several potential uses for those who need that sort of thing. There are several other features in modern CPU that most users never use too. It's not that big of a deal. It's honestly just a lot of hysteria, as usual.
 
For real, I'm not too keen on having a GPS or Killswitch built into my processor. Its a bit intrusive if you ask me.
I like how if I don't go to THG, THG comes here. /headdesk

I miss the knowledgeable people who used to post here.
 
Resistance if futile! The scene will be all over this and it will be hax0red soon enough. Intel is wasting their time.
 
Resistance if futile! The scene will be all over this and it will be hax0red soon enough. Intel is wasting their time.

This is what we have to hope for. Relying on AMD to not follow suit would be a bit of a pipe dream. Think about it, if Intel has been muscled into doing this, AMD will be too. AMD may not want to, but what happens when/if the MPAA releases movies that only run on Intel because AMD refused to play ball. AMD doesn't have the PR department of Intel or MPAA, so it will quickly be spun as a shortcoming of AMD in the public eye.
 
I can see the back of the DVD case now: "This is an Intel Insider movie.*"

"*Only playable on PCs with Intel Inside™."

And they thought DVD sales were hurting now...
 
I like how if I don't go to THG, THG comes here. /headdesk

I miss the knowledgeable people who used to post here.

You're not kidding. I don't know how many times you've tried to drive into everyone's head's what Intel is really doing here, but they JUST DON'T LISTEN.

Instead we get a bunch of dumb "That's why I'm sticking with AMD" comments from people who don't realize WTF they are talking about.

It's like all the hoopla that's been created over the "Death Courts" and the net neutrality...everyone listens to the talking heads trying to convince everyone that this is bad and is only here to ruin your life, when in actuality, the reality is far different from what the talking heads are throwing up out of their mouths.

Read and think for yourselves and if you truly don't understand it, don't form an opinion on it because you'll end up looking like a mouth breather.
 
You're not kidding. I don't know how many times you've tried to drive into everyone's head's what Intel is really doing here, but they JUST DON'T LISTEN.

Instead we get a bunch of dumb "That's why I'm sticking with AMD" comments from people who don't realize WTF they are talking about.

It's like all the hoopla that's been created over the "Death Courts" and the net neutrality...everyone listens to the talking heads trying to convince everyone that this is bad and is only here to ruin your life, when in actuality, the reality is far different from what the talking heads are throwing up out of their mouths.

Read and think for yourselves and if you truly don't understand it, don't form an opinion on it because you'll end up looking like a mouth breather.

Explain to me how this adds any relevant beneficial functionality to how a processor processes data from a consumer's perspective? Is this some new architectural change that nets you huge FLOP gains? Adding more layers of complication with the aim of functionally limiting a piece of hardware based on the demands of intellectual property holders is not beneficial to a consumer in any way.
 
Explain to me how this adds any relevant beneficial functionality to how a processor processes data from a consumer's perspective? Is this some new architectural change that nets you huge FLOP gains? Adding more layers of complication with the aim of functionally limiting a piece of hardware based on the demands of intellectual property holders is not beneficial to a consumer in any way.

No, but the people shitting bricks about it is getting absurd.

Where does it say anything about functionally limiting a processor? How is a proposed encryption engine (ie not even in the chips yet) functionally limiting a processor? How does encrypting a streaming movie being downloaded from say Netflix limit a processor?

WTF does this have to do with pushing higher FLOPS?
 
Misspoke...strike the not even in the chips yet line, the engine is there, the uses are only proposals..
 
This is not a matter of "encryption", Intel's processors can already do hardware AES and I haven't heard a word of complaint about that, because it is a benign and functional addition. Intel makes a direct comparison to HDCP, and we all know that nobody got screwed out of fully using hardware that they paid for, for entirely legitimate purposes due to HDCP... :rolleyes:
 
The Intel marketing droid is "technically" correct.

Intel Insider IS NOT DRM.

However, it supports features that allow content providers to implement DRM for their media content. The underlying technology can be used for other things, but in the context of the Intel Insider "feature" the only thing it can be used for is implementing DRM.

Meh. Marketing speak.

But if we're ever going to get legal high quality HD streaming video, secure hardware decryption is a necessary evil.
 
Back
Top