Bit-Tech: Why GFWL sucks

Status
Not open for further replies.
GFWL is a load of bollocks, it should be outlawed. GFWL in Fallout 3 causes crashes and GFWL in GTA IV is useless and gets in the way
 
Do you know that they were FORCED? They being Bioware. Are you sure Bioware made no decision to actually charge for the DLC?

I see no evidence of it being forced, and wikipedia mentions nothing about this, that I can see.

The one company that I know is being forced to charge for DLC is Valve. The TF2 patch for 360 is taking so long because Valve wants to do one huge release so people only have to pay once or twice at the lowest price possible.
 
Thus far, Steam is simply a copy (in most aspects, but not all) of XBox live. You've got achievements, downloadable content and such...stuff XBox did much earlier.

And again, I don't care if you think that they won't be an evil monopoly. Having competition means they will always be competiting to get better prices, better service, better features, etc. Saying you want GFWL to die is like saying you want AMD to die, and Intel to have a monopoly.

and LIVE copied xfire cross game joining with mates etc
 
No, it's not. Smaller teams get more done per-person, especially when they're part of a company that isn't riddled with pointless management and layer-upon-layer of useless process. This is especially true now that Steam is a mature product, so you only need maintenance staff plus a small group to code new features. Trust me, I'm a software developer, and have worked on teams of all sizes.

Microsoft is stifled by this very problem - they have layers of management that serves no purpose now that the whirlwind growth of the 90s is over. Said management has overreacted to the public image that Microsoft software is "buggy," and has stifled their creative developers with too much process. Said management also is lacking in collective foresight and patience, so Microsoft wastes developer effort on worthless re-inventions of the wheel, and managers make it priority-one to lock people into their platform, and usability a distant second.

QFT. im working on a similar sized project like steam and only 5 of us are working on the j2me version of such
 
It offers some competition to steam, kinda.

It basically just allows you to invite friends to your game. This is only useful for games that don't support steam invites.

Example: For CoD:WaW, steam doesn't support sending game invites to friends, but if GFWL was included, then you would be covered in that respect. OK, yes this is a poor example, but it still illustrates my point.

Three reasons it's a poor example:

1. CoD: WaW is a game that is hardly worth playing online to begin with. It's another ADD infested game, but what really makes it suck is the pop-gun sounds for every weapon. The sounds completely ruin the game.

2. If they would just incorporate the ability for invites through steam, GFWL would be truly useless.

3. Steam would still be better because you can use it to see what everyone's up to even when you're not in a game. Not to mention automatic game updates, the ability to view servers without launching the game etc.


GFWL is totally doomed, steam flat-out owns it. I was thinking they might be able to get something going if every game for windows was required to have it, then on top of that they integrated GFWL into windows itself and basically ran it just like steam as far as automatically updating your games etc. GFWL would take on all of steam's functions and steam would be reduced to just another place where you could pay to download a game.

Basically they just need to stop this madness because if they couldn't get messenger to work, then wtf are they even trying with GFWL?
 
What I'm annoyed about is the fact, because I'm not 18, they think I'm completely incompetent and can't do anything by myself without my parents around to verify everything for me.

The fact that you also cannot access your save games without it online an updated is just ridiculous. Thankfully, because of it's flaws, there are ways to defeat it and get it off your system, several mods, .dll's and the like.

This is why Steam rules the roost, it dominates everything. So much so that high-street gaming stores have actually tried to force Game Devs to release Steam-Free versions of their games, so Steam doesn't steal the market. They may as well just say, "Oh, Sh*t! Steam doesn't suck like GFWL does, they must be stopped!" The reason Steam controls 70% of the internet market is because of the crazy sales they have on, for example, the 2k pack was £300, during the Christmas Sale, it was £40. No wonder Valve are one of the richest companies in the world.
 
Fuck GFWL. It was one of the primary reasons I stopped playing GTA IV on PC. I will not buy any GWFL games going forward.
 
Here's the thing, I don't mind GFWL as an OPTION, something that you can chose to install if you feel it benefits you.

To me it's just bloatware so I have no interest in installing it, it just adds another layer of software onto my computer which I simply do not want. The problem is they've moved things like saved games to live accounts, that sort of shit cannot be stood for.

Leave all the traditional game elements in game, things like server browsers and save abilities, and if they want to add EXTRA things in GFWL like say cloud based saved games then fine, but make it an option.

I don't buy GFWL titles anymore, or anything else that comes with bloatware for that matter, not without knowing first, I have been known to hack out GFWL to not need installs as well, if there's a title I really want.
 
Its not going to.
Buy GTA 4 and see for yourself. Its ridiclous, convoluted and pointless, especially if you bought it on steam.

Oh god my brother and I both went through hell to get it to work for GTA4 and we went through it again with Resident Evil 5. We have both sworn off buying any game that has that piece of shit attached to it. I hate to say it but this is possibly one of the worst things any company has done to a game.
 
The GWFL matchmaking was pissing me off royally last night in DoW II. I keep getting matched with team mates that have a TS score of less than 10 and also against opponents that have TS scores in the mid 30-s. Of course, even if you haven't play the game, you can figure out that a match up like that is going to be completely one sided. Even in 1v1 matches I keep getting stuck against people wayyyy above my skill level and there isn't a damn thing I can do about it. :mad:
 
GWFL is pretty awful, I will say its gotten better in recent months, but never the less the system is terrible. It just feels like tacked on DRM. If it doesnt make my life easier as a gamer then I dont want it.
 
You cannot compare Steam being bad at the beginning to how GFWL is now. With steam it was originally optional to use. GFWL on the other hand is prebundle on a ton of games and you cannot play/use the game without going through GFWL.

Steam was literally the first concept for digital downloading clients. It's like comparing a Southwest flight to the Wright brothers.


What pisses me off more is microsoft announcing its renewed commit to PC gaming = More games will require shitty GFWL DRM.
 
Fortunately the next DoW2 expansion pack is ditching GFWL in favor of Steamworks.
Personally I wish games companies would just go back to basics. This includes Steam, sorry but I myself have no use for their crappy in-game chat systems. It's really an un-needed shit system like GFWL service IMHO. Yes I use Steam for buying alot of my games now but I still hate their stupid overlay shit.
If I want to chat with my friends while I game I'll use XFire or Vent.
 
Personally I wish games companies would just go back to basics. This includes Steam, sorry but I myself have no use for their crappy in-game chat systems. It's really an un-needed shit system like GFWL service IMHO. Yes I use Steam for buying alot of my games now but I still hate their stupid overlay shit.
If I want to chat with my friends while I game I'll use XFire or Vent.

The only complaint I have about steam is I'd like the old client back. The new annoys the shit out of me doesn't change anything for the better and trying to go back and forth from small mode continually fucked up my settings.

however if you hate it all together you can set steam to completely disable notifications and steam community if that's your only complaint.
 
The only complaint I have about steam is I'd like the old client back. The new annoys the shit out of me doesn't change anything for the better and trying to go back and forth from small mode continually fucked up my settings.

however if you hate it all together you can set steam to completely disable notifications and steam community if that's your only complaint.
The point was is that it installs it all in the beginning just like GFWL does and yet people seem to praise Steam all the time ;). When all they have going for them is cheap games, the rest just sucks.
 
'A sign in change has occured'! I get booted in the middle of my game to main menu by the shitty GFWL client. FUCK YOU GFWL, I was having a good match tooo.....
 
i hate Games for Windows Live, it made my Bioshock 2 experience a totally shitty one, that was on top of playing the mediocre game itself

double whammy
 
I'm confused how seemingly knowledgeable folks fumble with GFWL. I dont think I've ever had any real serious issue with the platform. Well no issue that any PC gamer hasn't dealt with on any other platform. When Steam was new it was a bugged to fuck Steam(ing) pile of shit.. let us not forget those days.

GFWL has a long way to go, but it is hardly this broken service that people try to convince others it is. I have 12 GFWL games, none of them have major issues. The one real issue I had was Shadowrun not auto patching, a problem I solved by downloading and installing manually... crazy talk I know.

To each his own and I"m not going to knock people for having genuine reasons for disliking the service but overall I have no problem with it. And honestly I'm growing tired of blind hatred for the system. People are too much in bed with Steam that they will tear down just about anything that has potential (even if years out) of becoming half of what Steam is.

Competition is good, it makes our hobby better and more affordable. I welcome competition and am willing to deal with learning curves, albeit Steam, Steamworks, Impulse, GOG, D2D or GFWL.
 
I've never had any issues with GFWL either. While I'm not crazy about the service in general, it hasn't been a problem for me.
 
I've always been able to get my GFWL games to work but there was considerable annoyances associated with it. I would go so far as to say that I hate GFWL.
 
Oh, and just for the record, it turns out that not only is Operation Anchorage already on Torrent sites, but it’s easier to download when pirated too. Good job, Microsoft.

Another, great example of overreaching regulation.
 
I bought Dead Rising 2 from Steam, come to find out that Steam doesn't even need to be loaded to play DR2, it just uses GFWL. If I would have known that then I would have just bought it through GFWL.
 
I bought Dead Rising 2 from Steam, come to find out that Steam doesn't even need to be loaded to play DR2, it just uses GFWL. If I would have known that then I would have just bought it through GFWL.
Steam needs to be running to play any game you purchase through the service.
 
Wow, old thread is old... but little has changed, so whatever I guess.

I'm confused how seemingly knowledgeable folks fumble with GFWL. I dont think I've ever had any real serious issue with the platform. Well no issue that any PC gamer hasn't dealt with on any other platform. When Steam was new it was a bugged to fuck Steam(ing) pile of shit.. let us not forget those days.

It's great that you haven't had any major problems with GFWL... but you have to realize that many people, even folks as tech savy as yourself, HAVE had major problems with it (well beyond manually downloading updates). Some of them utterly game breaking. And that's on top of the general annoyingness and redundancy of GFWL. And yes. Steam kinda sucked when it first launched, but it got much better. GFWL has been out for what, coming up on 4 years now? And it hasn't seen the same kind of improvement over that time.

Keep in mind, not everyone had accelerator problems with their Toyotas either. That doesn't mean that the problem didn't exist or that the people who had the issues were less intelligent than those who didn't. It just means that some folks haven't been affected yet. The same goes for GFWL issues.

I bought Dead Rising 2 from Steam, come to find out that Steam doesn't even need to be loaded to play DR2, it just uses GFWL. If I would have known that then I would have just bought it through GFWL.

Steam needs to be running to play any game you purchase through the service.


Most games you purchase through Steam don't need it running in order to play. It's pretty much just Valve games that require it, plus a couple 3rd party games that went a little overboard with the Steamworks drm. Most of the time, the steam app is pretty much optional once the game is installed.
 
Last edited:
Let's not forget the GFWL live update that caused unmuted (turned down all the way in game and/or muted in the volume panel in Windows) microphones to crash DOW II every 3-5 minutes! I couldn't even use Ventrilo while playing DOW II because of a stupid GFWL update that obviously wasn't properly tested.
 
Let's not forget the GFWL live update that caused unmuted (turned down all the way in game and/or muted in the volume panel in Windows) microphones to crash DOW II every 3-5 minutes! I couldn't even use Ventrilo while playing DOW II because of a stupid GFWL update that obviously wasn't properly tested.

Also, the most recent updates broke Batman: AA and GTA IV for me (and broke a lot of other games for other people). A simple GFWL client re-install fixed Batman (though, GFWL will no longer save my password and auto log me in, so that's an annoyance that I need to look into), but GTA IV still freezes at GFWL sign in. I'm sure the fix is something asinine, but my drive to play the game hasn't out weighed my laziness yet, so it will remain broken for the time being lol.
 
Took me about half an hour to play batman: AA when I purchased it from steam. We now have to go through 2 DRM systems?

Not being able to save without logging in is quite annoying.
 
Took me about half an hour to play batman: AA when I purchased it from steam. We now have to go through 2 DRM systems?

Not being able to save without logging in is quite annoying.

Make sure you beat the game. You can't use that save if you reinstall the game.
 
I recently had a very dumb issue with GFWL and Lost Planet 2 where the game wouldn't start because GFWL wouldn't start, and the reason GFWL wouldn't start turned out to be because they had updated the TOS. Unfortunately there was no pop-up "accept" window or anything, just an error code, and I had to go to the Live website, log in to that, accept the TOS there, then restart LP2. The unforgivable part was that the support web page that the GFWL error pointed to didn't exist, which is fucking amateur hour. It was only by Googling that I discovered what the problem was.

It's a service I don't use and don't want and which offers nothing of value as far as I'm concerned. I'm happy to use Steam because it makes managing games more convenient, and at least it does all its housekeeping before the game launches.
 
Nearly 2 years, and the fact that nothing has changed says a lot about GFWL.

+ infinity.

which is sad after all the times MS has said they are serious about gaming. But lets face it, they are serious only because they want to charge a monthly fee for it or milk it for money as much as they can while giving users bugs to deal with.

I do remember the steaming pile of shit that Steam used to be, but for some reason, i think it allowed you to do more and fixes and forums where more helpful, your saves where not affected, your voice chat was not affected, and match making actually worked faster then in 5 minutes. (DOW II still takes a long time to find a game, for me at least)
 
Lol I had no idea it was an old thread until someone started talking about buying the Pitt when it comes out "next month". GFWL was shit, still is shit, and will most likely remain a big steaming pile of shit.
 
GFWL would be fine if it worked.

Batman AA is the only GFWL game I haven't had troubles with. Lost Planet, Resident Evil, Dawn of War II & Chaos Rising, Fallout 3, Gears of War and DiRT2 have all given me grief solely on the GFWL issue, requiring several uninstalls and reinstalls of the game, GFWL and "title updates" for any joy.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top