New PSU, amperage too low

Atheist

Limp Gawd
Joined
Nov 27, 2005
Messages
272
I just got my GTX 470 and while reading over the manual, I saw that it needs 38A on the 12V lines. Mine only does 17A on each of 3 12V lines, so I'm SOL.

Anyways, I'm looking for a new PSU now.

I've gotten strong recommendations for the Antec TruePower New 750 - $120

I've also read reviews (including [H]) about the EarthWatts 750 - $90 shipped, $20MIR brings it to $70 eventually

Any reason not to go with the EarthWatts over the TruePower for $30-$50 less?


Edit:
Any opinions on the Thermaltake TR2 RX 750W?

I'm short a PSU at the moment and can drive to a Microcenter, so this one for $100 doesn't seem too bad.
 
Last edited:
The 38A recommendation for the GTX 470 is total combined +12V amperage, not on each +12V rail.

The EA750 has 6A less in combined +12V capacity than the TP750 -- 56A versus 62A. In this particular case, between those two you get what you pay for (I don't include rebates in the final price because a fair number of people have had their rebate requests declined or have never received their rebate checks or prepaid Visa debit cards for some other reason).

As for that Thermaltake TR2 RX 750W, I'd recommend avoiding it completely. All of the currently-manufactured TR2 and TR2 RX series PSUs are manufactured by HEC/Compucase -- a known mediocre PSU manufacturer (quality-wise). At $100 at Micro Center it is way overpriced for its quality and performance to begin with; in fact, I would not pay more than half of that price including tax and shipping for that particular PSU. What's more, the TR2 RX 750W cannot realistically provide anywhere near its rated 750W in realistic internal PSU operating temperatures: The "750W" rating is achieved at an unrealistically low internal PSU operating temperature of only 25°C (77°F) - but in real life, most PSUs operate at or near 50°C (122°F) even at idle. (Under realistic internal temperatures, that TR2 RX 750W actually provides only 550W to 600W.) By comparison, the EA750 and the TP750 are made by Delta and SeaSonic, respectively and are rated at their actual advertised ratings at 50°C (122°F).
 
Last edited:
Your current NeoHE 500W should be able to handle a GTX 470. Furthermore, it's actually a single-rail PSU rated at 38A, so it meets nVidia's recommended specs (which themselves are pretty generous). I think you should stick with what you've got unless you end up with problems.
 
Thanks for the info, guys.

Zero, the label shows 12V1, 12V2, 12V3 @17A each - even if I plug in 12V leads from two separate "rails," wouldn't I only get 17A per line?
NeoHE 500W specs

I won't be able to test it until I go back to school in a handful of days - I forgot to bring my box of modular cables home with me :rolleyes:
 
Thanks for the info, guys.

Zero, the label shows 12V1, 12V2, 12V3 @17A each - even if I plug in 12V leads from two separate "rails," wouldn't I only get 17A per line?
NeoHE 500W specs

I won't be able to test it until I go back to school in a handful of days - I forgot to bring my box of modular cables home with me :rolleyes:

The rating isn't for the card itself, it's for the card plus the rest of the system, and is generally a worst case. Meaning Nvidia is assuming you're putting their card into a system with a high power draw CPU (e.g. 145w), plus a couple hard drives, lot's of memory, and a few cooling fans. So you're okay.
 
Sweet, thanks for the info again guys. You saved me $100 :D

I was hoping (and figuring) that it would be ok, but then when I saw the "3" 17A rails, I wasn't so sure. Thanks for the heads up.
 
Sweet, thanks for the info again guys. You saved me $100 :D

I was hoping (and figuring) that it would be ok, but then when I saw the "3" 17A rails, I wasn't so sure. Thanks for the heads up.

The "17A" technically is where the manufacturer set the OCP (Over-Current Protection) at on each of the three wires (which in the case of the NeoHE 500W, are all actually connected to a single 38A output). Thus, the "3" rails are actually three wires coming from the same output. Furthermore, since they are all connected to a common output, when one wire hits 17A, the PSU would automatically put more load on the other two ("underutilized") wires.
 
Back
Top