RAID array, 5-bay or bigger, no pci card needed...

shackrock

Limp Gawd
Joined
Oct 15, 2008
Messages
150
Alright so... I'm looking for a RAID array, 5 bay or bigger, that DOESNT have a PCI card that I need to use with it. I want it to work on its own. Am I basically looking only at full servers or NAS systems now? Anyone have suggestions from past experience on something good for the value?
 
You're talking about an external box? If you don't want a PCI card or an eSATA port to be used, a NAS is your best bet.
 
Yeah, external box with built in RAID card + PSU...

I don't mind SATA port being used. The problem is I have a micro-atx MB so I have zero leftover PCI-e slots...
 
If that RAID card is not allowed to use PCI (and PCI-express i assume) then how do you want to connect it?
 
I think the op is either looking for a NAS or one of those one chip external hardware raid / sata port expander solutions that go for $100 to $200.
 
Basically a NAS, it might come down to that. The thing is I don't require network connectivity.

Something like the Thecus 7700 would be great, but ideally I can find something cheaper, and like I said - I don't NEED the network connectivity, although I'll take it.
 
I should I add, I have about 6 WD EARS Green drives... and I know these are notorious for somethings not working well with raid arrays....
 
Do you have any 5 year computers laying around with 6 sata ports?

I ask because there is free software that will turn a machine into a nas. And that software raid under bsd / linux ... is quite fast and does not require TLER so no problems with your WDC greens.
 
I could probably round one up.... Do you have a RAID card suggestion/op system?
 
In that case you do not use a raid card but use the motherboard ports directly or use a HBA.
 
Basically a NAS, it might come down to that. The thing is I don't require network connectivity.
That is a contradiction in terms. A NAS is a NAS because it is network-attached. A NAS without network is - by definition - not a NAS.

NAS = network attached storage
DAS = direct attached storage

I should I add, I have about 6 WD EARS Green drives... and I know these are notorious for somethings not working well with raid arrays....
All non-TLER/CCTL drives have this problem, and it applies to Windows RAID and Hardware RAID environments only. Non-Windows software RAID can use your and other non-TLER disks just fine.
 
One thing I forgot to mention if you go the nas route. Are you set up for running a gigabit network? If not the speed will be capped at around 10MB/s.
 
Yep, Gb.

Yeah so what I meant sub.mesa was that a NAS would suffice, but I don't require network connectivity, so I should have said a DAS is fine. correct.

So...you think if I build a linux RAID box myself, I can be off good huh? I'm basically pretty new to linux...
 
It would not hurt to try. There are dozens of threads here on that subject and quite a few experts that can help if you need help.
 
Alright... I'll probably end up buying new though, I suspect - and maybe just throwing FreeNAS on there.

I have an HTPC that works great, but the issue is again: PCI slot for a raid card, room for hard drives...
 
If you use RAID5/6 it will have issues. There are other methods to combine your disks without using raid 5/6.

Also my question to you is do you need raid. I actually removed all raid from my HTPC so that I could use individual drives and spin down each drive when not in use to save power. For me loosing a single drive (even a 2TB disk) worth of recorded tv programs will not be the end of the world.
 
It would just be the biggest pain to lost a drive of my DVDs, and have to re-rip every single one of those.... I suppose I could just copy a drive once it's full, for backup...
? haha.
 
Back
Top