Why We Should Play Bad Games

Well,I guess they have a point,after all,playing Wolfenstein made me appreciate how great a game RTCW was even more. But I still detest Raven for ruining a classic franchise and ripping me off!:mad:

If they hadn't completely ruined the powers the game might have been more fun. Wolfenstein had a lot of good ideas present and the world was fairly well designed. The upgrade mechanic was good. I don't like the term all that much, but the game felt very consoly. Like they never intended to port it, but did so quickly at the last minute.
 
I see it the other way around. It was only by playing alot of good games over the years did I realized within 10 minutes that Final Fantasy 14 (Online) was a incredibly horrofic game.
 
I don't like the term all that much, but the game felt very consoly. Like they never intended to port it, but did so quickly at the last minute.

Along with the whole "checkpoint" thing. I'm spoiled with quicksave I suppose. I also hate it when the console version of a game gets bashed in reviews when the PC version plays better. I remember Legendary getting absolutely demolished by IGN and a few other game review sites, but it played very well on the PC and I had absolutely none of the problems they were criticizing the game for. There was a lack of a skip option for cut scenes, but that's a minor gripe. The only "bug" I found was with the menus. I guess fighting werewolves and firedrakes just didn't fit with the "ultra-realism shooter" crowd. I'd rather see a 10-story tall golem made from cars and trucks smash through a freaking building, thanks.

That is stupid. Like saying we should put up with our car refusing to start some mornings because it really makes us appreciate the days when it does start properly.

It's more like driving someone's piece of crap Yugo that doesn't start, stalls randomly, handles like a pig in mud, has no heat and doesn't have working brakes, then going back and driving your nice [insert brand and model here] where everything is nice and functional.

I think where consoles have been causing a problem with game developers is the porting process. Game developers like Id used to be primarily PC-focused, but now everyone wants their games on the consoles to try to squeeze every last dime out of people they can owing to rising development costs. Carmack has complained about the porting process from PC to consoles several times in the past, and I think this may have a lot to do with "consolitis" in a lot of PC games. It may be easier to develop for the console and then port to PC.

I miss the old days when none of the PC developers gave a flying spork about consoles. While I don't intend on spending money on what I consider to be bad games, I can see the article author's point. Too many gamers these days are spoiled whiny little bitches that expect everything to be perfect and don't appreciate how far video games have come since Pong.
 
Along with the whole "checkpoint" thing. I'm spoiled with quicksave I suppose. I also hate it when the console version of a game gets bashed in reviews when the PC version plays better. I remember Legendary getting absolutely demolished by IGN and a few other game review sites, but it played very well on the PC and I had absolutely none of the problems they were criticizing the game for. There was a lack of a skip option for cut scenes, but that's a minor gripe. The only "bug" I found was with the menus. I guess fighting werewolves and firedrakes just didn't fit with the "ultra-realism shooter" crowd. I'd rather see a 10-story tall golem made from cars and trucks smash through a freaking building, thanks.

So you're saying Legendary is actually worth playing?

PS: I'm asking honestly, I never really gave it the time of day.
 
There's probably something to this.

I've only played about a half-dozen games this year, and although many people say the games I like suck, to me they're GOTY material.

If I potentially only play bad games, I can't rank 'em compared to great games. So, my ranking skews positively for the bad?

Your appreciation of your great games should be influenced by trying out the bad?

(Besides, good/bad is so subjective anyway... I'd like to know what I need to play that'll get me to change my opinion of Far Cry 2 from GOTY to turd...)

Farcry 1
 
Maybe in a perfect world, we're all playing the best of the best, but the problem is that most people don't really know what a great game is either. An above-average game, sure. But a really mind blowing game? Gamers will happily settle for something safe. The nature of multiplayer at times demands it. A popular game is one that even the absolute worst players enjoy. However, it's those just-passable games that are so dangerous. You think the next one is going to be a cracker, but it never is, it's always just different enough. Good enough to play until next Xmas.

A good point that the article almost touches on is that a bad game is not necessarily a bad idea riddled with more bad ideas from start to finish. It might have been a great concept with poor execution. Maybe a game that ran out of resources before it was really finished. Not a bad game so much as a failed game. Not every developer has the flexible schedule of Valve or Blizzard.

By no means should people be forced to buy inferior products, but it is a catch-22 for the industry. We all have praise for developers who take innovative risks and succeed, but it's harsh to run them out of town when their risks turn into mistakes, especially while we steadily reward those developers with big budgets and thin concepts, pushing out their regular dose of low grade crack.

In terms of 'B-grade' games, I don't think anyone is saying you should pay the maximum price for them. I don't think that's how people get into that genre of films, either. Certainly, when they're at the right price, they can become gems, perhaps a better deal than a better quality title. The traditional bargain bin rummage is enhanced by modern delivery methods such as Steam, which will gladly bait you with delicious deals. Without the constraints of time and logistics, it's not only an impulse buy situation, but a multi-directional one. You can quickly convince a group of friends to play with you. Such a situation can bring out the best in a lot of titles.

For the car analogy, Alfa Romeo comes to mind. Alfas are notoriously unreliable and depreciate rapidly, yet past and present owners will swear by the aesthetics and driving experience of the cars. Maybe you owned a similar car once. You may well own a car that 'does the job', but how much do you really enjoy it? Gaming isn't about function. Playing a game that 'does the job' is a horrid concept. But playing a game that is somehow fun despite its flaws? Sure. I'll take that every time.
 
Bad games should be punished with no sales period. I'll go so far as to say that developers that consistantly push out terrible games should shut down.
 
So you're saying Legendary is actually worth playing?

PS: I'm asking honestly, I never really gave it the time of day.

If you like run and gun shooters with a small amount of puzzle solving, certainly. It's not going to be a Doom 3 or Half-Life 2, but it's certainly a good game. It's going for about $6.00 on Amazon. I paid $25 for it and I thought it was worth it. I've played through it several times. The game uses the Unreal 3 engine, and runs about 75 Hz if you like Vsync. I guessed at this as there's no command console to show FPS. I use RefreshLock to control my screen refresh. I'm a nut for Vsync as I hate screen tearing in games. I'm running a GTX 260 with all the settings on high at 1280x1024 and I don't have any visual slowdown. I'm using XP SP3, not sure how it runs in Vista or Windows 7. A few tips without spoiling anything...

When you first start out, it's kind of a training mode so not all actions are immediately available. If you find you cannot jump right away, it's not a bug. You can jump after you're prompted the first time. Same with crouching, etc.
The melee weapon is a lot more useful than you'd think, especially on some of the more annoying creatures.
Use the gun sights. Use them a lot. They work VERY well. Spray and pray doesn't.
Use the monsters to your advantage when you can, and watch the carnage. It can be amusing.
Sprint + strafe + jump can be very useful if you need to duck to the side quickly.
There's two types of pistols in the game. I missed this the first time around. Later in the game, if you see a pistol laying around, look at it a bit more closely. The magnum is a hand cannon. You can't carry much ammo but if your aim is good it does a hell of a lot of damage.
 
Stupid article, stupid logic. Buy bad stuff so you will like good stuff more! What?
 
Also people you have to vote hard with your money if a company screws me on one game I make sure not to buy any title from that company again for 1 cycle or the next 3 years. Basically if you screw up you should be done and unable to make another game.

You wish is granted.

Now publishers will only pay to develop games that are certain to not risk any change in established "good" games. Sequels and ty-ins are virtually mandatory. Creativity and innovation are obvious sources of failure and are to be shunned. The ultimate goal is a cash cow like Madden where producing a "good game" merely requires changing the names and numbers on the jerseys and optionally mucking with the GUI.

Have a nice day.
 
I think its a load of bull. I dont need to play a bad game to recognize a good one
 
Back
Top