Android Tablets are a Failure

? As a huge Apple fan, even I dont really understand this answer..... are there other community maintained builds of iOS in addition to the office Apple created one?
It was kind of a quip, the point being that there's no need for an alternative community-developed build of iOS.
 
It's Ziff-Davis... The last time they had any sort of clue about which they were writing was sometime back in the early '90s.
 
It's Ziff-Davis... The last time they had any sort of clue about which they were writing was sometime back in the early '90s.

Nah, it wasn't that long ago. Early 2000s. They went to total shit when CNET bought them out.
 
people at work liked glaxy tab over ipad...
I haven't tested the tab very much, but it seems allright.
 
. No carrier is going to have a polished product right off the bat.

You're right, the ipad took a view generations to... oh wait.

:D

I'm not a huge fan of apple, but when my other choice at work is a blackberry... i chose the iphone heh.
 
You know, the article may be a bit scattered and confused, but the guy is not completely wrong at all. Comm Carrier's are the most short-sited, quick-profit, anti-consumer group of people I can think of in today's world.
I agree.

While I disagree with the author that Android OS itself is crapware, the carriers are quickly turning Android-OS phones into crapware. It bugs the tar out of me that I can't uninstall the Blockbuster app, CityID, NFS:Shift demo, etc. from my Droid 2, and even moreso that I can't uninstall Motoblur; I'd like to see Android in its cleanest form, and then make my own decisions on what belongs and what doesn't (yes, I know I could root my Droid 2, but the average user cannot). Verizon, I'm especially talking to you --who in their right mind would pay to use your lousy VZ Navigator software when Google Navigation works well and is free?

It also means that instructing someone in my organization to use an HTC phone on how to use it isn't the same as my Droid 2; the basics are, but HTC's "Sense" interface makes some changes.

I really think Google needs to implement standards and guidelines for OS adoption that at minimum, require a compromise: that carriers and phone providers can install custom apps, but that users must be allowed to uninstall them and go with the standard Android interface. This would at least be a fair compromise with the carriers, rather than going all the way to forcing standardization of the base OS on every phone.

If Android fragments too much as carriers go forward with it, I think it will become a problem. But as you and I both agree, carriers are only interested in the short-term, so they don't care, and they only care about Google as long as it sells them subscriptions.
 
You're right, the ipad took a view generations to... oh wait.

:D

I'm not a huge fan of apple, but when my other choice at work is a blackberry... i chose the iphone heh.

Considering that most of the people I knew and many websites were dedicated to the bricked iPhones when trying to do the mandatory updates, no, they did not get it right the first time. Nor did they get it right when they said people could upgrade their old iPhones to the new OS when the iPhone 4 came out and that ended up making performance on the old iPhones to nose dive causing many people's iPhones to be completely unusable. And then there is the whole iPhone 4 antenna debacle...

So even the mighty Apple is affected by setbacks when doing new things.
 
The problem is that the OS isn't accomodating to tablet style usage yet, and so basically people are getting the experience of a very large phone when they buy an Android tablet.

Android's Honeycomb version will come out and it is designed for tablets from the ground up, and will change all that.

http://www.techradar.com/news/phone...-android-honeycomb-next-up-from-google-711132

It's far too early if they'll succeed, but I think Honeycomb will be the magic ingredient.

Tablets that have come along so far are simply proving the hardware was ready before the accompanying software.
 
It's wayyy too early to declare them a failure. Android is, in general, totally bogged down with carrier AND mftr crapware, although HTC has some great stuff I think--but it's almost as easy to get a custom rom on there as it is to jailbreak an iPhone. Ideally such steps wouldn't be necessary in either case but they are possible and not difficult or opaque. I think this is going to be just like the N1: as the OEMs slowly build a foundation out of failed or outdated products, Google will unveil a first party device that sets the standards.

Google is a giant and can afford to move slowly.
 
Back
Top