Mac Users = No USB 3.0 For You!

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Apparently Steve Jobs said Apple won’t be getting USB 3.0 any time soon. Calm down, calm down, there is no need to worry. You and I both know that when USB 3.0 eventually does come to the Mac…it will still be “an industry first,” “magical” and “amazing!” :D

We don’t see USB 3 taking off at this time. No support from Intel, for example.
 
What would you use such fast speeds for? It's not like there are a bunch of apple products that could benefit from speed large file transfers :D
 
But I though Apple was a technical leader...?!?!

I already have USB 3.0 on the Windows 7 system I built early this year.
Currently looking at some of the new USB 3.0 SATA docking stations for backup. A couple bare 2TB SATA drives are cheaper and smaller than external drives, and the speed with USB 3.0 seems much closer to SATA speed, with less problems.
 
It's not stylish enough. They need to design a proprietary connector so they can sue companies that make aftermarket connectors for their "magical" and "revolutionary" products.
 
Oh, they'll add USB 3 support, probably late 2011/early 2012. Basically, Apple is waiting for it to reach critical mass before bothering with it. All they are saying is that it is not a priority to them, so they will add it when it costs pretty much nothing extra.
 
They'll claim that the time isn't right.

Up until the moment they do it. Then they'll claim that they've finally done it properly, and *NOW* it's ready to become mainstream, so they're taking the lead, blah blah blah...

They (usually) openly admit that they aren't the originator of various things, they just claim to be the one to "do it right". See mp3 player, WiFi, tablets, etc.
 
All they are saying is that it is not a priority to them, so they will add it when it costs pretty much nothing extra.

...yet can charge a 300% premium because now it is encased in aluminum...
 
isnt this pretty typical apple?


wait for smething to be mainstream, then pawn it off as something no and fancy because its an apple?


i mean the cpus/gpus etc are always behind the curve..but they tout them as being better..magical... or anything else jobs comes up with on a keynote
 
I would skip usb 3.0 and spearhead Intel's' lightpeak
 
I'm pretty disappointed my current generation 17" Macbook Pro doesn't even have a memory card reader. I don't like Apple, but a lot of the jobs in the area want you to be familiar with Macs so I got the Macbook Pro.
 
and always coming to H for a little punishment, I have to say I'm not surprised. Have you looked at the fucking crazy prices Apple wants for its Mac Pro's, shit! No Blu-ray; no USB 3 and no reasonable prices. Starting to look at Ubuntu and Windows 7 (but w7 only in vm). :p
 
Lightpeak is their future..right?

Supposedly, but who knows when Lightpeak will see real usage.

<wild_theory>
The lack of USB3 is another step towards Apple being left in the dust by PC technology. If they can't even manage to use USB3 they are in bad shape. Apple will be relegated towards making phones and tablets, there will be no more computers coming from Apple. Why do you think they dropped the "Computer" part of their name back in 2007?
</wild_theory>
 
eh, why does apple charge so much? The simple answer which you might not like, is because they can. they have done an excellent job with their products and marketing and for that reason joe consumer is likely to buy from them.

on the other hand you have a lot of companies trying to bring out their me too products which IMO are several years too late.
 
Hey, if it's not Firewire, it's not good enough for Apple :rolleyes:

No, seriously, even when Apple implemented USB 2.0 due to market pressure, they half-assed the implementation and drivers:

* Late-generation G5 machines barely topped 15MB/s on USB 2.0. Apple blamed it on the chipsets.

* Early Intel-based Macs (2006) barely topped 20MB/s, when the same chipsets on PCs did over 30MB/s. Apple could no-longer blame this on the chipset.

* It wasn't until 2008 that the first Mac with 30MB/s USB 2.0 speeds was released (and by this time, most PCs could do 35-40MB/s).

Meanwhile, the Firewire implementations on all Macs get breathtaking speeds. Could it be that Apple is still beating a dead horse after all these years, and refusing to admit that Firewire lost?

One thing is for sure: Apple hates USB, but they're forced to use it. If Apple ever implements USB 3.0, you can bet it will be incredibly slow.
 
isnt this pretty typical apple?


wait for smething to be mainstream, then pawn it off as something no and fancy because its an apple?


i mean the cpus/gpus etc are always behind the curve..but they tout them as being better..magical... or anything else jobs comes up with on a keynote
i lol'd...even as a mac user.
 
anybody else wanna smack Steve Jobs upside the head and shout at him: well if Intel won't do it, go with AMD, it's that hard ya idiot!
 
Hey, if it's not Firewire, it's not good enough for Apple :rolleyes:

No, seriously, even when Apple implemented USB 2.0 due to market pressure, they half-assed the implementation and drivers:

* Late-generation G5 machines barely topped 15MB/s on USB 2.0. Apple blamed it on the chipsets.

* Early Intel-based Macs (2006) barely topped 20MB/s, when the same chipsets on PCs did over 30MB/s. Apple could no-longer blame this on the chipset.

* It wasn't until 2008 that the first Mac with 30MB/s USB 2.0 speeds was released (and by this time, most PCs could do 35-40MB/s).

Meanwhile, the Firewire implementations on all Macs get breathtaking speeds. Could it be that Apple is still beating a dead horse after all these years, and refusing to admit that Firewire lost?

One thing is for sure: Apple hates USB, but they're forced to use it. If Apple ever implements USB 3.0, you can bet it will be incredibly slow.

^THIS
 
I think its more along the lines of:
"well intel doesn't have a mobo with intel chipset support of USB 3 yet, and we don't want to bother with having to integrate a 3rd party chipset into our mobos until intel comes out with a chipset that supports it internally"
 
I would skip usb 3.0 and spearhead Intel's' lightpeak
I think they're both good. On one hand I can understand not wanting to jump into USB 3.0, but on the other, it's looking pretty damn good for USB 3.0. Then again, Lightpeak might be something worth holding one's breath for.

I imagine things will be ironed out by the time I'm ready to upgrade, so whatever.

Hey, if it's not Firewire, it's not good enough for Apple :rolleyes:
That explains why some current Macs omit Firewire ports entirely.
 
That explains why some current Macs omit Firewire ports entirely.

Yes, but those are the toy computers (MacBook and Air), where fashion is more important than a bulky Firewire connector.

All of their more serious computers have Firewire.
 
I just did a real world test using a 6.99 gig movie .iso file from my WD Black 1 gig sata 3 drive to the WD 150 gig Raptor drive and using a stop watch transfered the file over to the USB 2.0 Blacx dock and it took a 5 minutes and 20 second to complete the transfer! I then took the Raptor drive and put it in the BlacX USB 3.0 dock and the same file coming from the same drive the only difference is usb 3.0 and it took only 1 minute and 42 seconds! Now I know Apple users couldn't use that type of performance! LOL
 
They're just waiting for it to be integrated in the chipset. Spending money on a chip cuts into their profits.
 
why does apple care - they are making the big bucks off of iPods, iPhones, IPads, iTumes, etc. The sheep will still buy the Macs. Plus if they keep the hardware behind the curve and overpriced it will keep the market share down and there will be no need for anti-virus software - since they do not get viruses. But I am guessing the main reason is that the Mac does not bring in the $$$$ the other divisions do
 
Apple wants to be different like they've always been. I wouldn't really like lightpeak since its from Intel. We all know Intel has really high prices for everything they sell. Price/performance is where its at.
 
one other thought - they's have to hire new people to help write the OS - other OS's are able to be implemented on a myriad of hardware - Windows & Linux for example. But Apple's hiring got screwed up this year because they needed to hire antenna engineers.
 
Not to join in on all the apple bashing....

A couple of things with Firewire not using the host processor it is faster and has lower latency than USB, there are some applications this has a huge effect on. Is this one of the reasons apple is still pushing firewire?

Next point with Macs all using intel processors now and therefore Intel chipsets. It may be a wild guess on my part but the reason for the delay is because intel currently has no usb 3.0 (Native) chipsets available. Jobs is to full of himself to pay NEC money to use their external controller chips hence the reason no USB 3.0

Might be taking a stab in the dark there please correct me if i'm wrong.
 
Yes, but those are the toy computers (MacBook and Air), where fashion is more important than a bulky Firewire connector.

All of their more serious computers have Firewire.

I thought all macs were toy computers. No?
 
hrm, firewire, 25 cents per computer, $1-$2 per peripheral, dedicated chip, usb 2.0, $FREE, can be integrated into a chip, easy to see why firewire was a dud.
 
USB 3.0 devices will flourish mid 2011. Maybe that's the time Apple will consider it on their imac 2011 fall refresh.
 
If you actually pay attention to how Apple products develop (instead of just making narrow-minded elitist remarks about Apple's narrow-minded elitist users), you'll notice a trend and realize the reasons why USB 3.0 won't be integrated anytime soon:

• It requires an external controller and isn't part of a chipset, which requires more board space and more power. That practically guarantees their laptops won't have it unless Intel or Nvidia integrates it with a chipset and it doesn't drop the battery life across their lineup. (The first iPhone neglected 3G for EDGE for battery life, and I doubt next year's iPhone will use any 4G wireless connectivity unless power consumption goes down dramatically within the next few months - an unlikely event, at best).

• Apple has a vested interest in FireWire, and it's still the de facto connector on prosumer HD video cameras (most of which are heavily vested in Apple continuing to support FW for a while) because FW800 handles the data related to HD footage a lot better than any previous iteration of USB (can't really test a USB 3.0 HD camera because, well, they don't exist). I'll also bet good money there's far more FW devices on the market than USB 3.0.

• Apple doesn't jump on the bandwagon in hopes of cashing in. Otherwise, we would have Mac's with overpriced BluRay drives that nobody would buy because they're too busy streaming their movies and Atom-based Apple netbooks that would become relics the instant the tablet craze started. Despite what you might believe, Apple actually thinks everything through before they drop a product.

I'm no rabid Apple fan, but I'm level-headed enough to realize Apple has a plan. Those of us who bash Apple's products should just live with the fact that it's more than likely they weren't meant for you to begin with.
 
Back
Top