Why Warhammer Failed. And StarWars:ToR will too

Zorachus

[H]F Junkie
Joined
Dec 17, 2006
Messages
12,560
This has been generating massive buzz. A very good article to read for all gamers.

http://www.massively.com/2010/10/13/blogger-claims-to-be-mythic-employee-tells-why-warhammer-faile/

"If you want to know what really went down with Warhammer, I’ll tell you right now."
http://ealouse.wordpress.com/2010/10/12/hello-world/

"And Bioware? Don’t make me laugh. They’ve spent more money making the Old Republic than James Cameron spent on Avatar. Shit you not. More than $ 300 million! Can you believe that?

And you know what they’re most proud of? This is the kicker. They are most proud of the sound. No seriously. Something like a 20Gig installation, and most of it is voiceover work. That’s the best they have. The rest of the game is a joke. EA knows it and so does George Lucas,they’re panicking , and so most of Mythic has already been cannibalized to work in Austin on it because they can’t keep pushing back launch.

Old Republic will be one of the greatest failures in the history of MMOs from EA. Probably at the level of the Sims Online. We all know it too ……
 
I gotta disagree. Replicating the sound of Starwars is probably the most important part for me.

Radio Broadcast Star Wars anyone?
 
This brings up another good article, this time about StarWars: The Old Republic, and how it has a very good chance of being a major flop, because it is not following true MMO roots, and that it might be too much like a single player game, and the story part too much for an MMO. Most MMO gamers want grouped instances, and end game Raiding, not so much single player story driven quests. Otherwise you would just play Knight of the Old Republic yourself.

The Soapbox: Episode II - A New Hype
http://www.massively.com/2010/10/19/the-soapbox-episode-ii-a-new-hype/
 
Zorachus, your quoting two opinionated blog posts as fact. The first is a dubious one that claims to be an EA employee with no proof.

The second is a soapbox article where the author claims that star wars lore is dead without even mentioning the two KOTOR games, which TOR is based around.

What's your point?
 
Zorachus, your quoting two opinionated blog posts as fact. The first is a dubious one that claims to be an EA employee with no proof.

The second is a soapbox article where the author claims that star wars lore is dead without even mentioning the two KOTOR games, which TOR is based around.

What's your point?

I guess my point is, that EA/Mythic seems to be a bad combo for MMO's. I really wanted WarHammer to be great, I played in beta, and bought it on launch day, and was sad to see it come out so early and poorly done. And now I am afraid the same thing might happen with SW:ToR, the hype will never match the gameplay.

And that soapbox article, I have to agree with a lot of what he says. MMO's are deisgned around groups of friends playing together, and Guilds playing in Instances and Raids. I am afraid that SW:ToR is focusing too much on single player storyline, that's great for a game like KOTOR, bit this is an MMO. And the space combat, a game on rails, is massive fail, seems like a quick add on not thought out properly.

I will still be a first week purchaser of SW:ToR, I just hope it's not another fail like WarHammer.
 
lol, that first link with the supposed EA employee is ridiculous. What he said about TOR is no different from any other random internet user going all Chicken Little about it. He's also obviously extremely salty that the MMO he was involved in failed horribly, and seems to be of the "if we can't have it, no one can" mentality.

Not saying TOR is or isn't going to suck, you just need to recognize bullshit from really good coherent arguments.

Now, the massively.com article, I would agree that players who thrive on the huge raiding experiences and such will probably not enjoy TOR as much as WoW. That being said... there are plenty of people out there who will enjoy the type of gameplay TOR will bring. Do those people exist in the numbers that the WoW fanatics do? Maybe, maybe not. But there are definitely enough out there to make TOR a success, if the game is otherwise good.
 
I guess my point is, that EA/Mythic seems to be a bad combo for MMO's. I really wanted WarHammer to be great, I played in beta, and bought it on launch day, and was sad to see it come out so early and poorly done. And now I am afraid the same thing might happen with SW:ToR, the hype will never match the gameplay.

And that soapbox article, I have to agree with a lot of what he says. MMO's are deisgned around groups of friends playing together, and Guilds playing in Instances and Raids. I am afraid that SW:ToR is focusing too much on single player storyline, that's great for a game like KOTOR, bit this is an MMO. And the space combat, a game on rails, is massive fail, seems like a quick add on not thought out properly.

I will still be a first week purchaser of SW:ToR, I just hope it's not another fail like WarHammer.

Agreed, I played Warhammer Online for a month then quit

it really had nothing interesting going for it and the player vs player sucked, i couldn't get into it, i even tried every class.

bleh!!

I'm with you on that the SW MMORPG will suck too.
 
I was always a naysayer of their big hype with their voiceover work in Bioware's MMO. As a former MMO player, I know for a fact that there are three things all MMO players of all genres and games hate:

1) Being stuck on default UI: thankfully, I am sure Bioware will have great customization in this area
2) Being forced to read: flavor text and quest storylines might be cool at first, but after a few hundred hours of play, no player is going to sit through and read every word of anything.
3) Being forced to listen to anything at all: likewise with sound, which is actually far more annoying since most adults can read significantly faster than even the world record for speed speaking.
 
No mention of the hideous mess of a rail shooter as "space combat"? For shame. That's one big reason that something stinks in Bioware-ville.

Point is.. this SW:ToR is NOT a Bioware game but only in brand. I sure hope that the studio in Austin has internalized some the philosophies and methods of game development and story telling of Bioware's. I sure hope that Bioware's name won't be dragged in the gutter because i do too have my doubts about this game.
 
No mention of the hideous mess of a rail shooter as "space combat"? For shame. That's one big reason that something stinks in Bioware-ville.

Why do people act like they should be putting in a full featured space combat sim in with the game?? I mean I understand the desire for that (it would be really cool), but how can you realistically expect them to do that? And I don't buy the "all or nothing" reasoning, you can have the rails experience still add a cool and different touch to the traditional RPG gameplay (and I'll bet they'll weave it into the storytelling nicely too), so I for one will enjoy it (as long as it is done as a good rail shooter)
 
All I can say is, when is Guild Wars 2 coming out ? That will be the best next gen MMO release.
 
What about us Star Wars Fanboys (me)? I'm going to try it out just because it's Star Wars...
 
I was always a naysayer of their big hype with their voiceover work in Bioware's MMO. As a former MMO player, I know for a fact that there are three things all MMO players of all genres and games hate:

1) Being stuck on default UI: thankfully, I am sure Bioware will have great customization in this area
2) Being forced to read: flavor text and quest storylines might be cool at first, but after a few hundred hours of play, no player is going to sit through and read every word of anything.
3) Being forced to listen to anything at all: likewise with sound, which is actually far more annoying since most adults can read significantly faster than even the world record for speed speaking.

Great point. In EverQuest and WoW, I read a lot of the quests first time around, then after that I wanted to click them off and never see them again.

I am afraid that SW:ToR will have people screaming "Shut Up, already" at their computer screen, with way too much talking when getting a quest, or clicking on an NPC.
 
Great point. In EverQuest and WoW, I read a lot of the quests first time around, then after that I wanted to click them off and never see them again.

I am afraid that SW:ToR will have people screaming "Shut Up, already" at their computer screen, with way too much talking when getting a quest, or clicking on an NPC.

I can probably see the WoW kiddies doing that, but you know they'd probably do the same exact thing trying to play Mass Effect or Dragon Age. The argument that "they are wasting their time with voiceover work in TOR because people always skip that crap in MMOs" isn't really sound because TOR features SP-type storylines in which listening to dialogue/cutscenes is a major part of the game.

EQ2 on the other hand is a good example of where voiceover work goes wasted That game is/was a traditional MMO style and I'm sure most people did skip right over that, especially when levelling an alt and going through the same quests over and over. TOR also has a different story for each class so at least we can avoid most of that problem (presumably... we'll see just how different each class plays at release day)
 
I guess my point is, that EA/Mythic seems to be a bad combo for MMO's. I really wanted WarHammer to be great, I played in beta, and bought it on launch day, and was sad to see it come out so early and poorly done. And now I am afraid the same thing might happen with SW:ToR, the hype will never match the gameplay.

And that soapbox article, I have to agree with a lot of what he says. MMO's are deisgned around groups of friends playing together, and Guilds playing in Instances and Raids. I am afraid that SW:ToR is focusing too much on single player storyline, that's great for a game like KOTOR, bit this is an MMO. And the space combat, a game on rails, is massive fail, seems like a quick add on not thought out properly.

I will still be a first week purchaser of SW:ToR, I just hope it's not another fail like WarHammer.

Mythic has very little to do with TOR. Its being done by Bioware's Austin studio. So whatever problems Mythic has don't really apply.
 
Why do people act like they should be putting in a full featured space combat sim in with the game?? I mean I understand the desire for that (it would be really cool), but how can you realistically expect them to do that? And I don't buy the "all or nothing" reasoning, you can have the rails experience still add a cool and different touch to the traditional RPG gameplay (and I'll bet they'll weave it into the storytelling nicely too), so I for one will enjoy it (as long as it is done as a good rail shooter)


I have this fantasy, that a true next gen MMO, would have a massive game world to explore. Something so big that even all of Cataclysm world will be the size of just one planet in a Star Wars next gen MMO, and the game world would have like a dozen or so planets to explore.

Imagine if in a Star Wars MMO, you were questing on a planet, and then you want to go to another planet, you fire up your custom space ship, which you control it, and lift off the ground, and fly it yourself through the atmosphere into space, and then you control it to go where ever you want. Lets say the game world had a dozen planets to go, but inbetween those planets, there are space stations to dock with, and enemy ships to fight, maybe Raid instances against a death star, all controlled by you the player, and deciding where to go.
 
Right... that's a cool idea, and it would definitely be an epic experience, but completely unrealistic to expect something like that. I'm sure it will happen some day though, just seems dumb to act all indignant because Bioware isn't making it happen in TOR.
 
I have this fantasy, that a true next gen MMO, would have a massive game world to explore. Something so big that even all of Cataclysm world will be the size of just one planet in a Star Wars next gen MMO, and the game world would have like a dozen or so planets to explore.

This is more or less how MMO's used to be.. massive amount of land, lots of traveling, etc.

Nowadays it's all theme park with invisible walls to keep you in.
 
I have this fantasy, that a true next gen MMO, would have a massive game world to explore. Something so big that even all of Cataclysm world will be the size of just one planet in a Star Wars next gen MMO, and the game world would have like a dozen or so planets to explore.

Imagine if in a Star Wars MMO, you were questing on a planet, and then you want to go to another planet, you fire up your custom space ship, which you control it, and lift off the ground, and fly it yourself through the atmosphere into space, and then you control it to go where ever you want. Lets say the game world had a dozen planets to go, but inbetween those planets, there are space stations to dock with, and enemy ships to fight, maybe Raid instances against a death star, all controlled by you the player, and deciding where to go.

I would call that MMO : Nerdgasm Online.

Seriously I'm with you man, when is GW2 gonna get here? Only thing I'm really looking forward to.
 
I have this fantasy, that a true next gen MMO, would have a massive game world to explore. Something so big that even all of Cataclysm world will be the size of just one planet in a Star Wars next gen MMO, and the game world would have like a dozen or so planets to explore.

Imagine if in a Star Wars MMO, you were questing on a planet, and then you want to go to another planet, you fire up your custom space ship, which you control it, and lift off the ground, and fly it yourself through the atmosphere into space, and then you control it to go where ever you want. Lets say the game world had a dozen planets to go, but inbetween those planets, there are space stations to dock with, and enemy ships to fight, maybe Raid instances against a death star, all controlled by you the player, and deciding where to go.

You were probably one of those people utterly blown away by that thread about that game capable of rendering an entire galaxy in real time, allowing the player to fly from orbit around a planet down to the surface to explore it.

I have two words for you: thinly spread.
 
You were probably one of those people utterly blown away by that thread about that game capable of rendering an entire galaxy in real time, allowing the player to fly from orbit around a planet down to the surface to explore it.

I have two words for you: thinly spread.

thats the game i want to play.

I hope I am alive to see the gigantic game worlds in virtual reality, in 20 - 30 years from now. Just imagine playing an MMO with computer graphics 20 years down the road, and 100 terabyte sized game world.
 
All I can say is, when is Guild Wars 2 coming out ? That will be the best next gen MMO release.

:cool:

I like sci-fi, but watching the video gameplay of The Old Republic is really bumming. I saw the demo game play of Guild Wars 2 when the "small" dragon lands and there is a huge fight I was like :eek:.

I can not wait for Guild Wars 2. I really think that The Old Republic will do okay but it is not going to hit high subscribers what ever those numbers that EA believes The Old Republic is supposed to hit.
 
:cool:

I like sci-fi, but watching the video gameplay of The Old Republic is really bumming. I saw the demo game play of Guild Wars 2 when the "small" dragon lands and there is a huge fight I was like :eek:.

I can not wait for Guild Wars 2. I really think that The Old Republic will do okay but it is not going to hit high subscribers what ever those numbers that EA believes The Old Republic is supposed to hit.

GW2 should be good. DCUO seems to be shaping up well too.
 
Do you guys have any idea how vast the Star Wars universe is?

it's loaded with lots of potential for a GOOD MMORPG.

All they'd have to do is have a bunch of canon (faithful to the SW lore) planets, and faithfully recreate them. Add in space travel, maybe some possible space battles. Make each planet have it's own unique quailities and characteristics, from the environments (think, each world you can gather or craft different quality stuff at them, different minerals, materials and whatnot), to the people who inhabit them, to places like Mos Eisley (Greedo shot first motherfuckers! God help me, i'm gonna receive an infraction for that) to the Cantina, to the Tatooine desert, man, the possibilities are limitless.

Allow the player to go to Dagobah, and do the trials there to become a Jedi, to Hoth, man, awesomeness.

to the Jedi Temple!!!

All kinds of possibilities here man

They really need to do Star Wars justice if they are gonna do a game about it.

It's a shame how companies have tried to milk this franchise for a quick buck (just look at Star Wars Unleashed 2 for example).

It's so easy to make a good game when you have all that material to work with.
 
Guild Wars 2 still trying to get it done without dedicated heals? When I read that I was sad. And no, that's not just my gut reaction, I've put a lot of thought into it. I remember early in WAR development, it was all about not having any heals. Then some slight heals crept in. Then there were full fledged healing classes with a quickly recovering power source which meant they were actually dumbed down and more power than traditional healers (healers are all about increasing the longevity of fights, and infinite power = stupid small grp fights). I didn't think the idea would work from the start, and I could almost see them coming to that conclusion as they started testing combat more. I'm thrilled that they have classes in GW2 with support abilities that are not heals, as good offensive/defensive support classes can make things much more interesting (more roles + more gameplay dynamics = better to an extent), but I'm still really not seeing no heals working. I could go into detail, but this post is already dangerously off topic.
 
Random angry employees or previous employees are probably not the best source of information about the company's upcoming product.
 
Random angry employees or previous employees are probably not the best source of information about the company's upcoming product.

Thank you , thats the most rational sentence in this entire thread.

Why not wait and reserve judgement for the game when its released? Its very likely a sensationalist blog meant to stir up controversy and induce negative press for a game that has mostly gotten the opposite.

And why is everyone looking for the next WoW? Don't you want the next step up? I want whatever is going to exceed WoW in its scope and play style. I don't want Star Wars and WoW mixed.

Lets just all see how the game turns out on release.
 
Do you guys have any idea how vast the Star Wars universe is?

it's loaded with lots of potential for a GOOD MMORPG.

All they'd have to do is have a bunch of canon (faithful to the SW lore) planets, and faithfully recreate them. Add in space travel, maybe some possible space battles. Make each planet have it's own unique quailities and characteristics, from the environments (think, each world you can gather or craft different quality stuff at them, different minerals, materials and whatnot), to the people who inhabit them, to places like Mos Eisley (Greedo shot first motherfuckers! God help me, i'm gonna receive an infraction for that) to the Cantina, to the Tatooine desert, man, the possibilities are limitless.

Allow the player to go to Dagobah, and do the trials there to become a Jedi, to Hoth, man, awesomeness.

to the Jedi Temple!!!

All kinds of possibilities here man

They really need to do Star Wars justice if they are gonna do a game about it.

It's a shame how companies have tried to milk this franchise for a quick buck (just look at Star Wars Unleashed 2 for example).

It's so easy to make a good game when you have all that material to work with.

I'm with you. I want a SW MMO badly, but TOR is doesn't look like it's going to be anything special. Just like you said, it's all about the cash-in.
 
Thank you , thats the most rational sentence in this entire thread.

Why not wait and reserve judgement for the game when its released? Its very likely a sensationalist blog meant to stir up controversy and induce negative press for a game that has mostly gotten the opposite.

And why is everyone looking for the next WoW? Don't you want the next step up? I want whatever is going to exceed WoW in its scope and play style. I don't want Star Wars and WoW mixed.

Lets just all see how the game turns out on release.

I disagree. Let's hype an MMO DOWN for once, so everybody expects it to be terrible - then when reviews come out, people will rave about how not completely terrible it is. In fact, it's positively mediocre!

Lower expectations (for games) are better - when I start a game expecting nothing and get nothing, it's not a letdown. But when I start a game expecting nothing and it's decent or better, I am very happy. ;)
 
I disagree. Let's hype an MMO DOWN for once, so everybody expects it to be terrible - then when reviews come out, people will rave about how not completely terrible it is. In fact, it's positively mediocre!

Lower expectations (for games) are better - when I start a game expecting nothing and get nothing, it's not a letdown. But when I start a game expecting nothing and it's decent or better, I am very happy. ;)

I try not to expect anything from a game, high or low. I like going in with a bit of a blank slate as far as opinions go.
 
I try not to expect anything from a game, high or low. I like going in with a bit of a blank slate as far as opinions go.

Same... but I think that's why a lot of sequels flop. They might not be bad, but you go in with preconceived notions if you played the first, even if you try not to.
 
Nerdgasm; in-game footage of Guild Wars2. This game looks to be the one to watch for next gen MMO's.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=youtube_gdata_player&v=GsgB9-1mysM

Check at 6:40, the ranged "Hunter" style class is pure awesomeness

The combat looks pretty good actually. Nice to finally see some big MMORPGs with good looking combat. The animations look fairly smooth as well which helps a lot.

Edit: People might want to keep an eye on DCU Online. I'm in the beta and so far I like it. We'll see if that lasts, but for now it seems like it will be a good product.
 
Last edited:
I played Warhammer Online for about 2 months before I quit. I was fine up to a point but then got, I don't know, boring. I have high hopes for SWTOR. If it is " Single player with MMO elemnts thrown in" that'll be fine with me.

I'm currently playing WoW waiting for Cataclysm to drop. I mostly soloed my Pally to 80. Now that I'm at endgame it has become a whole new game for me, some good, some bad. The endgame raids for the first time are cool and all but to have to do them over and over and over ? pfft. I'll go roll an alt or go play another game.

I'll reserve judgement on SWTOR until it is actually out and I'm playing it.To do otherwise is silly.
 
Random angry employees or previous employees are probably not the best source of information about the company's upcoming product.

True, except that if you read through the ealouse comments, you can see other former employees chiming in and even some current ones. I wouldn't dismiss his claims simply because he is disgruntled, but I would remember that he is disgruntled.
 
I'm currently playing WoW waiting for Cataclysm to drop. I mostly soloed my Pally to 80. Now that I'm at endgame it has become a whole new game for me, some good, some bad. The endgame raids for the first time are cool and all but to have to do them over and over and over ? pfft. I'll go roll an alt or go play another game.

I agree, that's my point as well. I solo'd my two 80's most of the time, except random dungeon finder in the higher 70's.

I just started to Raid my first since spring, mainly ICC, but now I am bored to death with it, the same Raid every week, after week :rolleyes: Just to get uber gear, and then rinse and repeat = carrot on a stick formula. Isn't there a better idea to do end game ? Instead of just running the same two raids over and over ?
 
Back
Top