No Firefox Browser for the iPhone

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Firefox users hoping to get a little action on the iPhone are pretty much SOL. The dev team had this to say about the chances:

We are working to bring as much of your Firefox experience as possible to Firefox Home. People have asked about adding more browser-like features to Firefox Home, but there are technical and logistical restrictions that make it difficult, if not impossible, to build the full Firefox browser for the iPhone.
 
Gee, a phone OS isn't as powerful and capable overall compared to a desktop OS. Who'd a thunk?
 
Gee, a phone OS isn't as powerful and capable overall compared to a desktop OS. Who'd a thunk?

Or gee, maybe Firefox just don't have the time or resource to divide their team up to do yet another OS. Safari's fine and there's always Opera. So what? I would hate to see a (1) on Apple's App Store every fucking day because Firefox won't stop pushing updates.
 
So instead of taking Operas route of making a browser specifically for the mobile market they just give up? NO ONE has put a "full desktop browser" on a phone thats fully working. We have Safari Mobile, Internet Explorer Mobile, Opera Mobile, Opera Mini, and Chrome Mobile as the main guys, than smaller guys like Mercury and Bolt for alternate choices. Did they ever really think Firefox Desktop would run acceptably on the iPhone?
 
In other words, they know Apple won't approve it because it may compete with their browser.
 
Or gee, maybe Firefox just don't have the time or resource to divide their team up to do yet another OS. Safari's fine and there's always Opera. So what? I would hate to see a (1) on Apple's App Store every fucking day because Firefox won't stop pushing updates.

Have you ever seen a mobile web broswer that's as capable as a desktop browser?
 
In other words, they know Apple won't approve it because it may compete with their browser.

There's already several browser alternatives for the iPhone. Skyfire and Opera to name a couple.
 
You seem to have missed the definition of the word "mobile".

No, I thought the point that FF was trying to make is that they didn't believe that they could me a mobile browser that was desktop like, not that they couldn't make a browser for the iPhone.
 
You seem to have missed the definition of the word "mobile".

You know what? I need to apologize for my rebuke. I thought you were dissing iOS because it wasn't fully capable as a desktop OS. That observation does seem rather silly you have to admit.

I read what you said again and realized you were being sarcastic at the Firefox dev for trying to accomplish something the wrong way because they're not looking at iOS as a mobile OS, but trying to view it as a desktop OS.

Sorry about that, heatless.
 
i dont see the point anyway trying to put a full browser on a mobile phone
 
Obviously a mobile browser will need to use less memory and run on slower CPUs than the full desktop equivalent. The user interface also has to be adapted for use on 3.x" - 4.x" screens.

This doesn't mean it's impossible to build a rich, full featured browser for mobile devices. In fact, many already exist (my HTC Desire scores 93% on Acid3 and correctly displays all websites I've tried so far). Don't really see the need for yet another browser really, and it would take a lot of time and resources to develop. A straight port is out of the question, they would have to completely rewrite most of it.
 
Mozilla has been trying to make a mobile browser for entirely too long now (Fennec, anyone?) and every single one of them sucks, plain and simple. Opera does it right, better than anyone else, in terms of a mobile browser and it's wicked evil fast on anything I've used it on (Android, Windows Mobile, etc).

Why Mozilla doesn't just flat out say "FUCK IT, WE'RE DONE WITH THIS... MOVING ON..." is beyond me. They can't do it right, so move on, geez.
 
i dont see the point anyway trying to put a full browser on a mobile phone

Oh is see the point. The coolest thing about the Libretto W100 is that its a full desktop browsing experience and when connected to 4G in a good area its just awesome. It's fast and the full web works on it like a desktop, no limitations in the weight on an iPad so not as mobile as a phone but much more mobile and easy to carry around than any other computing device I know of that has the full web at its disposal.

Now of course there's other trade offs like battery life but like I said, the full web anywhere you want.
 
I'm a die-hard Firefox user, but if it was made available as an iPhone app, I wouldn't use it.

Even if I had add-on functionality, Apple would probably have to approve every single add-on, and waiting months to get the extensions I use wouldn't be worth it.

I use Atomic Browser, and its easy Private Mode and ad blocking is terrific. If only there was a way to set it as the default browser for all apps.
 
Have you ever seen a mobile web broswer that's as capable as a desktop browser?

But today's phones can handle it.

My netbook underclocked @ 1.0Ghz can run Windows 7 and Chrome easy as pie.

So under iOS, I don't see why Firefox can't be run. Same exact speed of hardware.
 
The latest alpha of Fennec for Android is a lot faster than the previous one (but still not quick, it's simply acceptable) so it doesn't seem like it's impossible at all.
 
But today's phones can handle it.

My netbook underclocked @ 1.0Ghz can run Windows 7 and Chrome easy as pie.

So under iOS, I don't see why Firefox can't be run. Same exact speed of hardware.

Common misconception. There's a BIG difference in the amount of processing power between even that Atom and an ARM running at the same clock speed, x86 processors do a lot more work per clock than an ARM, thus x86 are CISC processors and ARMS are RISC, that's why ARMs use less power. Also consider that phones have a lot less RAM and thus a typical desktop browser is not really feasible on a mobile device. Then and on top things like plug-ins and by that time you're back to a power hungrier desktop browser anyway, not really what most would probably want out of a long battery life device like a phone.
 
They are late to the show. They missed the boat and they have nothing to show for it and even if they tried it wouldn't be that great anyway, so it is more prudent for them to leave well enough alone.
 
Common misconception. There's a BIG difference in the amount of processing power between even that Atom and an ARM running at the same clock speed, x86 processors do a lot more work per clock than an ARM, thus x86 are CISC processors and ARMS are RISC, that's why ARMs use less power. Also consider that phones have a lot less RAM and thus a typical desktop browser is not really feasible on a mobile device. Then and on top things like plug-ins and by that time you're back to a power hungrier desktop browser anyway, not really what most would probably want out of a long battery life device like a phone.

You're half right. ARM processors have always been less powerful than their x86 counterparts.
But the Atom series, while still an x86, is by far the least powerful.
For instance, the Atom N270 @ 1.6Ghz is less powerful than a 2.0Ghz Pentium 4.
And, the A4 chip is different than any other ARM processor. It is the newest and most powerful with a radically different design than 'Snapdragon', which you can tell by just how much faster the iPhone 4 is than an Evo 4G for instance.
So when it comes down to it, the A4 is definitely comparable.
You were also wrong about the RAM. Most netbooks with N270 chips came with 512MB of RAM, the same as on the iPhone 4.
So I stand by my statement that the A4 could easily run the desktop version of Firefox.
 
And it COULD run Crysis but why? It would slow and kill battery life just like a full desktop browser.

Because it has more features..? I mean that's the whole point.

And no, the Crysis statement is inccorect.. not just because it actually Can't run Crysis.

Because I doubt it would be slow. The A4 runs Command & Conquer games with 2003-2004 graphics.. I think it can handle a web browser.
 
The mobile version of Safari isn't as full-featured as the desktop version, but that's a shitty excuse for the Firefox team not to give an effort.
 
Back
Top