Isolating the bad drive in a RAID5 setup

Llathos

Limp Gawd
Joined
Mar 16, 2005
Messages
151
I've worked with enterprise data storage systems that have LED indicators for bad/failing drives...but this Rosewill unit does not(or if it does it's not working):

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produ...5&cm_re=Rosewill_5_bay-_-16-132-015-_-Product

The SATARAID5 software that comes with it only works with UAC off (annoying as hell), and is indicating that the RAID5 configuration of 3 WD EARS 2GB Green drives is "reduced". The documentation suggests that I have a single drive failure in the RAID. That's pretty terrible news, but what's worse is that I don't know which one failed and which one to RMA!

The software utility has no indicator, and any OS level tools I use will only recognize the 1 RAID5 volume and not individual drives. What do you guys suggest I do to isolate the bad drive?

The only good news in this is that I have the data backed up already, so if the RAID group completely fails it won't be catastrophic.

Suggestions?
 
Install the hot spare, let the array rebuild, borrow a stethescope and find the one that's most silent.
 
The hot spare?

I've got 3 drives engaged making up the RAID5. There is no hot spare.

The software shows the 3 drives as ID 2, 3, and 4 on Channel 1. All three are marked yellow and the RAID group is classified as "reduced".

So yeah, I guess it indicates by "port number" but since all three are marked the same, it doesn't seem useful ...
 
The only other option I can think of it to rely on the backup.

Wipe the RAID and rebuild is as JBOD and run disk utilities on each drive...

Does that sound sane?
 
The hot spare?

I've got 3 drives engaged making up the RAID5. There is no hot spare.

The point of that is after adding the fourth disk which you will need anyways the failed disk will be not in the array.
 
The only other option I can think of it to rely on the backup.

Wipe the RAID and rebuild is as JBOD and run disk utilities on each drive...

Does that sound sane?

I would not do that. You could stop the machine and pull the disks 1 by 1 and look at smart on them. If you have to plug them into a non raid controller so the drives do not show up as part of any array.
 
I cannot tell from the pictures if it has activity lights. Are there any LEDs on each tray that blink when data is read or written? If so, just duplicate a big folder on the RAID, and look for the tray without a blinking LED.
 
Back
Top