Formatting, looking for a good codec pack for Win 7

You don't need a codec pack for Windows 7. It'll play just about every file type without needing any external help. For the rare video that it can't play back(I haven't had this issue though), all you need is Media Player Classic - Home Cinema. It comes with it's own built in codecs that don't mess with the OS, meaning it's all contained in the program itself.
 
Unfortunately you may need to still download at least quick time lite to stream .mov from a few sites. Some also recommend using a MKV splitter but why not just convert it?

I also use programs like Win HD Video Converter and Any Video Converter to turn video into format that is both native friendly with Windows 7 thumbnail generation and PS3 streaming.
 
To quote Bahamut in an older post:

1) As mentioned above, MPC-HC is pretty much the defacto recommended media player (primarily for video content but it can play audio just fine too) on Windows 7 these days.

Also, as noted above, DO NOT INSTALL CODEC PACKS - Windows 7 does multi-format decoding all by itself now.

There are 3 "popular" formats/containers Windows 7 can't/won't play natively:

- Real Media crap (mostly used for anime videos, if you must watch that stuff get RealAlternative to get the Real codecs)
- MKV containers - if you install Haali's Media Splitter (it's not a codec), then Windows Media Player as well as Windows Media Center can read MKV files natively and play them. MPC-HC can of course read MKV files natively.
- FLAC/Ogg Vorbis audio files (and Ogg video containers as well) - you can install the Ogg Vorbis codecs from HERE and then you'll be able to use WMP/MC7 to play those containers/formats also.

The latest version of MPC-HC can be found here (the sourceforge version is very old):

http://www.xvidvideo.ru/media-player-classic-home-cinema-x86-x64
 
ffdshow is a multiformat decoder - there's no use for it since Windows 7 does the same thing natively and covers the same formats with it's own highly developed and quite capable multiformat decoder. The only thing that I've ever found that Windows 7 cannot play natively are RealMedia content files (RealAudio, RealVideo, etc). It'll play QuickTime files locally (.mov, etc) but no it won't stream them natively - as someone noted installing QuickTime Alternative will allow for that since it installs the necessary components for browsers to handle the streams.

RealMedia content can be handled by installing RealAlternative as well.

But "codec packs" are simply unnecessary, tend to cause problems more than they resolve them for most of the people that install them, they break things in Windows 7 that the OS handles better natively, etc.

The only thing I've ever seen that's 'required' is Haali's Media Splitter so you can play MKV and other containers using Windows Media Player or Media Center. I've never used Haali's since I use MPC-HC exclusively (updated daily builds available here: http://xhmikosr.1f0.de/ - get the VS2008 builds) and never had issues playing anything yet.

If you want to play Ogg Vorbis files (either audio or video) and FLAC as well using WMP/MC all you require are the DirectShow filters from the Vorbis project found here:

http://xiph.org/dshow/

That's about it. Full blown codec packs are more troublesome than they're worth for most folks... it's one of the most problematic and frequently brought up topics on many forums related to media playback on computers, and my suggestion is simply avoid "codec packs" with all possible reasoning if you're using Windows 7 as the OS.

They just aren't necessary... we're talking about Windows 7 here, not Vista, not XP, and not any other OS ever made by Microsoft. Windows 7 is simply better than all the rest in this respect.
 
Windows 7 doesn't nearly give you as much config power that FFDShow does.. that's why I use it.
 
Everything you just said I agree with 100%.

I'm not totally against codec packs, but it makes far more sense to utilize them as a last resort. Better, in my opinion, to register individual codecs on a strictly as-needed basis, one at a time, but only if necessary.
 
As far as the options for ffdshow, yes it's quite capable but, when you use something like MPC-HC with Windows 7 it too is quite capable and typically offers up more potential configuration options than most people could or would ever dream of even trying to make some coherent sense of - even more than the "basic" stuff ffdshow offers, by a wide margin. :)
 
offers up more potential configuration options than most people could or would ever dream of even trying to make some coherent sense of - even more than the "basic" stuff ffdshow offers, by a wide margin. :)

What?

The Windows decoders offer basically nothing in the way of configuration. Not even close to what ffdshow allows you to do.

ffdshow is better than the included Windows codecs in every way, especially for audio. The only place it is not the best solution is for hardware accelerated h.264, which MPC-HC handles internally.
 
If you're going to quote me, at least do it correctly and stop chopping it to make your so-called point:

As far as the options for ffdshow, yes it's quite capable but, when you use something like MPC-HC with Windows 7 it too is quite capable and typically offers up more potential configuration options than most people could or would ever dream of even trying to make some coherent sense of - even more than the "basic" stuff ffdshow offers, by a wide margin. :)

That's the part you left out, whether accidental or not I have no idea. The point being: MPC-HC offers the configuration options, not the decoder itself. The configuration options are passed to the decoder just as they are with ffdshow...

In the MPC-HC options are all the rendering configurations needed, audio configurations, internal and external filter configuration, etc etc.
 
If you're going to quote me, at least do it correctly and stop chopping it to make your so-called point:
The whole point of your post was to not use ffdshow and use the built-in Windows codecs instead. I don't think I missed it, or that my quote was out of context.

That's the part you left out, whether accidental or not I have no idea. The point being: MPC-HC offers the configuration options, not the decoder itself. The configuration options are passed to the decoder just as they are with ffdshow...
No. You're just wrong. Since you've apparently never used it, this:
ffdshow.png

is an ffdshow dialog box, not an MPC-HC one, and it allows you to do a lot of things you can't do otherwise. There is a similar box for the audio configuration as well, equally more flexible than the included codecs.
 
"It ain't Ragu but, it's in there... and a whole lot more too."



That's just one set of options off a flyout menu - MPC-HC has tons more potential configuration options, it just requires some digging to find them all. And best of all: you can use ffdshow and access it's many options through MPC-HC as well...

As for me not using ffdshow, you're right - I stopped using it when Windows 7's first beta leaked and I started using MPC-HC along with it for all my media purposes because of Windows 7's native multiformat decoding capabilities, as I continue to do to this day.

ffdshow for me in my situation is simply unnecessary. The whole point of my post was to demonstrate that for the vast if not overwhelming majority of people using Windows 7 that ffdshow is just that - simply unnecessary - as Windows 7 + MPC-HC offers pretty much the same capabilities without requiring yet another codec being tossed into the fray.
 
In MPC-HC, is there a way to turn off the play/stop/volume setting notification in the top left corner?
 
That's just one set of options off a flyout menu - MPC-HC has tons more potential configuration options, it just requires some digging to find them all. And best of all: you can use ffdshow and access it's many options through MPC-HC as well...
Yes, I am aware of the shaders. It's a different thing than the configuration ffdshow allows, and if you use MPC-HC with ffdshow, you get both.

ffdshow for me in my situation is simply unnecessary. The whole point of my post was to demonstrate that for the vast if not overwhelming majority of people using Windows 7 that ffdshow is just that - simply unnecessary - as Windows 7 + MPC-HC offers pretty much the same capabilities without requiring yet another codec being tossed into the fray.

Probably true, but it's still substantially better than the included ones. As I said, especially for audio.
 
Back
Top