Consumer Reports Retracts iPhone 4 Recommendation

I think they knew about it. I was simply playing devil's advocate for how to define the term defective :D


I have no doubt that Apple knew about it.

Apple Engineer: "Um, if I hold this phone like this the signal drops out."
Apple Manager: "Sure enough, I'll escalate to Jobs".
Jobs: $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ "You're just holding it wrong. Release the phone!"

I'm sorry, but that reminded me of : "Release the Kraken"!
 
I wanna give Consumer Reports the benefit of the doubt. They seem to know there shit for the most part. Apple is doing its usual PR damage control but seriously how could this have not been found in testings? Do they only test the prototypes with right armed amputees?

Apple should have had this fixed before it ever launched , simple as that.
 
I wanna give Consumer Reports the benefit of the doubt. They seem to know there shit for the most part. Apple is doing its usual PR damage control but seriously how could this have not been found in testings? Do they only test the prototypes with right armed amputees?

Apple should have had this fixed before it ever launched , simple as that.

Microsoft should have found all the flaws of the 360 before it launched. Sometimes companies are too far along into development, that they'd rather take the PR hit, then delay the product and fix the flaws.

Apple is probably very worried about the other phones out there pulling even more marketshare than they are already doing. Not to mention, it'd mess with their regular release times.

I bet, even if a recall occurs, most of your mac fans will just keep the phone. They'll just hold their phone differently or spend $30 on that rubberband case.
 
Microsoft should have found all the flaws of the 360 before it launched. Sometimes companies are too far along into development, that they'd rather take the PR hit, then delay the product and fix the flaws.

Apple is probably very worried about the other phones out there pulling even more marketshare than they are already doing. Not to mention, it'd mess with their regular release times.

The difference is that Microsoft was actually willing to fix the issues.
 
The difference is that Microsoft was actually willing to fix the issues.

To be fair, MS did pump out prone-to-fail units for what seemed to be ages. Some signal degradation is infinitely better than all out hardware failure. Could Apple have handled the issue better? Without a doubt.
 
Actually they don't accept samples, they go out and buy product like a regular consumer. That way they don;t have to worry about companies sending them "golden" samples.

Thank you for stating the obviously, which I already stated in my comment. I am not sure why you felt the need to re-say what I had already said.
 
Apple is pretty arrogant. Somehow I think there's a chance they won't recall the phone just becuase they think they are never wrong.
 
This reminds me of the big lawsuit by Sharper Image against Consumer Reports :cool: (Consumer's Union)
Something to do with Consumer Reports saying that their Ionic Breeze was practically worthless and did nothing and was not recommended. Sharper Image sued and lost, having to pay all of the Consumer Unions court costs :D

Sharper Image filed for bankruptcy soon after, right?
I'm sure this will not hurt Apple much, but it will be interesting to see what happens.

I can totally understand why Apple is removing threads/posts **laughing**

PS-- For those of you bashing Consumer Reports........ Remember, they are Independent and purchase all their own products. With the help of donations of course. Oh, and no ads in their magazines either! Non biased reviews!


Found the lawsuit info-
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Sharper_Image

In 2002, Consumer Reports tested many fan-driven air purifiers alongside The Sharper Image's Ionic Breeze Quadra. The Sharper Image was not happy with the results, and sued Consumer Reports in order to get what they thought would be a more fair testing of the product.[22] However, the suit was dismissed, primarily due to the court finding that the company "has not shown that the test protocol used by Consumers Union was scientifically, or otherwise, invalid," and had not "demonstrated a reasonable probability that any of the challenged statements were false." Furthermore, Sharper Image could not "come forward with any evidence from which a finding of malice could be made."[23]

Two years later, Consumer Reports stated that the Quadra could be dangerous to consumers' health, because of the trace levels of ozone produced by the unit.[24] As a result, sales plummeted, and the stores took back units that were even years old for a cash refund. The Sharper Image's response was to work with the Engelhard Corporation and create an ozone catalyst that would reduce the purified air of excess ozone before it circulated throughout the room.[25]
 
I don't think Consumer Reports has ever lost a lawsuit, actually.

So when Consumer Reports calls you out on something, you know it's bad.
 
Apple is pretty arrogant. Somehow I think there's a chance they won't recall the phone just becuase they think they are never wrong.

I bet Apple won't even give that $29 rubber band for free to make the iPhone 4 lefty friendly.
 
The difference is that Microsoft was actually willing to fix the issues.

The difference is that Apple hasn't had time to do much else. What did Microsoft do the first few months of the 360s release?

That's right, they lied and tried to cover it up. It took them over 1 1/2 years to claim their was a problem and did nothing more than increase the warranty to 3 years. Did they fix the issue? No. They were still selling 360s that were prone to failure. They did so for another year after that.

Is that what you call, "actually willing to fix the issues?"
 
The difference is that Apple hasn't had time to do much else. What did Microsoft do the first few months of the 360s release?

That's right, they lied and tried to cover it up. It took them over 1 1/2 years to claim their was a problem and did nothing more than increase the warranty to 3 years. Did they fix the issue? No. They were still selling 360s that were prone to failure. They did so for another year after that.

Is that what you call, "actually willing to fix the issues?"

The difference is that Microsoft worked at trying to correct the issue in future releases and they did make improvements. They also ended up replacing a vast number of machines for free, and continued to replace systems. And as far as fixing the issue, I know plenty of people that have bought Xboxes in the last 2-3 years that haven't had a single problem with them. In any case, Microsoft hasn't had the same arrogance as Apple. That is the biggest difference.
 
The difference is that Microsoft worked at trying to correct the issue in future releases and they did make improvements. They also ended up replacing a vast number of machines for free, and continued to replace systems. And as far as fixing the issue, I know plenty of people that have bought Xboxes in the last 2-3 years that haven't had a single problem with them. In any case, Microsoft hasn't had the same arrogance as Apple. That is the biggest difference.

I am sure you could bet the bank that a future iphone 5 will not have this issue. then you could be like 'well apple did correct the issue in future releases'.
Posted via [H] Mobile Device
 
I am sure you could bet the bank that a future iphone 5 will not have this issue. then you could be like 'well apple did correct the issue in future releases'.
Posted via [H] Mobile Device

Perhaps, but the previous iPhones had poor antenna's and they all had the misrepresented bar readings, plus they had multiple problems with OS updates bricking phones, they have all been locked, and none of them have Java. So I am going with....perhaps not. Since Apple rarely actually listens to what people want, they just tell people what they should have.
 
The difference is that Microsoft worked at trying to correct the issue in future releases and they did make improvements. They also ended up replacing a vast number of machines for free, and continued to replace systems. And as far as fixing the issue, I know plenty of people that have bought Xboxes in the last 2-3 years that haven't had a single problem with them. In any case, Microsoft hasn't had the same arrogance as Apple. That is the biggest difference.

Yes, future releases like over a year after they admitted there was a problem. The iPhone 4 hasn't even been out a year, half a year, or even a quarter of a year. Took MS over a quarter of a year to admit there was even a problem.

Also replacing a vast number of machines for free. You mean, replacing broken machines with broken machines. They replaced them with refurb units and half the time, they didn't even repair them properly, so you'd end up with a DOA.

Nowadays, yes, you can get a new Xbox that will pretty much have no problems. It was when Jasper released. 4 years after the original 360 released. Took them 4 years to fix the issues and you're giving grief to Apple?

Perhaps, but the previous iPhones had poor antenna's and they all had the misrepresented bar readings, plus they had multiple problems with OS updates bricking phones, they have all been locked, and none of them have Java. So I am going with....perhaps not. Since Apple rarely actually listens to what people want, they just tell people what they should have.

The iPhone 4 has a better antenna. Granted, it's got that "hold it the wrong way" flaw. The bar readings are still misrepresented. Haven't heard of any OS update phone bricking for the iPhone 4, but I'm sure it'll probably happen.

Java, doesn't concern Apple. Just like Flash. While I think it's dumb to not support either, it's their decision. My 360 doesn't have a web browser, doesn't play mkv files, and there's a slew of other things it doesn't do, but I don't knock MS about it. I knew from the beginning that it wouldn't do those things.

If I wanted Flash, Java, whatever, I would have gotten an Android phone. Me, I don't need a smartphone. I have a cheap Samsung flip phone that makes calls and can SMS. Think it can surf the web and do other things, which I don't know. I have a Win7 tablet for other crap.

I think both MS and Apple handled their flaws poorly. For me, MS did a worse job. Only time will tell if Apple will top them at it. Considering the product will be replaced in a year anyways, I don't think they will.
 
The difference is that Microsoft worked at trying to correct the issue in future releases and they did make improvements. They also ended up replacing a vast number of machines for free, and continued to replace systems. And as far as fixing the issue, I know plenty of people that have bought Xboxes in the last 2-3 years that haven't had a single problem with them. In any case, Microsoft hasn't had the same arrogance as Apple. That is the biggest difference.

Are you forgetting all the microsoft lies about how "the failure rate is in line with the norm for consumer electronics"? Over half those fucking launch systems failed. Hell, my first one went down in just a few months, and they traded my pristine console for a scratched up POS with a cracked faceplate. The second only lasted about a year. Probably the worst quality control in the history of electronics and they actually had the audacity to lie about it.
 
...none of them have Java.
That's actually pro in my book; not a con.

The iPhone 4 has a better antenna. Granted, it's got that "hold it the wrong way" flaw. The bar readings are still misrepresented.
As far as I can tell in my experience with using the phone so far, I would say this is accurate. The WiFi range in particular has improved greatly (startlingly so). Whether the cell reception is competitive with other phones I can't say, however.
 
The difference is that Microsoft worked at trying to correct the issue in future releases and they did make improvements. They also ended up replacing a vast number of machines for free, and continued to replace systems. And as far as fixing the issue, I know plenty of people that have bought Xboxes in the last 2-3 years that haven't had a single problem with them. In any case, Microsoft hasn't had the same arrogance as Apple. That is the biggest difference.
I have one of the first HDMI models and mine's still chugging away...

The difference is that Apple hasn't had time to do much else.
B.
S.

They could have moved their release date back. They could have told Foxconn to stop production. Apple's logo is on the device, they controlled every aspect of how that phone ended up in consumer's hands... Their fault and none other.

Microsoft was at fault, too. Saying "Well, we only stole 5 monies, but they stole 10 monies!!" just distracts from the fact you still freaking stole 5 monies.
 
B.
S.

They could have moved their release date back. They could have told Foxconn to stop production. Apple's logo is on the device, they controlled every aspect of how that phone ended up in consumer's hands... Their fault and none other.

Microsoft was at fault, too. Saying "Well, we only stole 5 monies, but they stole 10 monies!!" just distracts from the fact you still freaking stole 5 monies.

I was talking about after the release, not before.
 
What a F-up. Really makes you second guess the "genius" of Steve Jobs. A guy who sells a phone that can't be used as a phone doesn't seem all that smart to me.
 
You realize they've been producing more, right? That they haven't stopped future production?

Again, BS. Apple hasn't done squat.

Uh, duh. I said the same thing. Did you even read any of the shit or just decide to jump in last second and be a douche?
 
Back
Top