Consumer Reports Retracts iPhone 4 Recommendation

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Adding insult to injury, it looks as though Consumer Reports has retested the iPhone 4 and has come to the conclusion that they simply can not recommend the phone. Ouch.

Our findings call into question the recent claim by Apple that the iPhone 4's signal-strength issues were largely an optical illusion caused by faulty software that "mistakenly displays 2 more bars than it should for a given signal strength."
 
They're simply stating what everyone else that had half an inkling of what the issue was already knew.
 
Wow. I've never seen a company's reputation get destroyed so quickly.
 
When Consumer reports says you have a problem, you really do have a problem.

How do you think Jobs will shurg this one off?
 
Boy, I'd like to say ouch, to bad for Apple. But you know, I can't for the life of me think of one thing I have purchased where I used Consumer Reports to help decide.
 
When Consumer reports says you have a problem, you really do have a problem.

How do you think Jobs will shurg this one off?

Unkie Steve will scream, "Emergency power to the RDF Scotty!" :D
 
It doesn't matter to the ibots, they will keep praising thier iphone 4's as the best ever.

How many people will have to die before the justice department launches an investigation into the coverup?


I don't know how to turn off my car if the gas pedel sticks VS I couldn't call for help because my call kept dropping.
 
"Consumer Reports' engineers"

HAHAHAHAHA

engineers.... right.....
 
Wow. I've never seen a company's reputation get destroyed so quickly.
BP???

Boy, I'd like to say ouch, to bad for Apple. But you know, I can't for the life of me think of one thing I have purchased where I used Consumer Reports to help decide.
They know their autos, that's for sure.

But other than that, research is usually key. Most people don't do that, and I can name many people that I know that'll only buy a product if they recommend it. Yea, this hurts Apple.
 
Since when has reality ever factored into the iCult?

This changes nothing.
 
Boy, I'd like to say ouch, to bad for Apple. But you know, I can't for the life of me think of one thing I have purchased where I used Consumer Reports to help decide.

I've actually found their ratings quite useful, although you need to understand how/what they are testing.

I keep my cars for many years, and their reliability ratings have pretty much matched my own & many people I know experiences over the years. Long term reliability is my major concern when buying a car, so I don't like that they have been putting less importance on reliability in recent years.

Their appliance ratings also seem to be pretty accurate.

Their TV and computer ratings are another thing.

They test TV’s based on their “out of the box” settings. Most TV’s need a least a little adjustment to the picture settings to give you an accurate picture. Most have the color and brightness set too high by default, since the average consumer thinks it looks better in the brightly lit store.

As for computers, where do I even start? They rate them from a noobie viewpoint & how well the call in support can answer stupid questions.
 
Jobs: Consumer Reports, you know, their whole "Lab Tests and Research" philosophy? It's bullshit, that's what it is. In fact, our own internal development team have discovered an error that concludes that Left Handed persons do not exist, Apple will be releasing a patch to correct this physical error.
 
Wow. I think you are dreaming a little big there :)

Your hatred is strong...

The thing is Apple HAD to know about this problem and could have engineered a simple fix and just didn't. Not saying that companies don't do this all the time but this is Apple, that name is synonymous with quality and this is anything but quality. It shows to me a company that thinks it can just push out anything old thing with whatever flaw and they know people will buy it by the truckload. Apple's getting lazy, a victim of its own success.

They could have fixed this, they chose not to.
 
I've actually found their ratings quite useful, although you need to understand how/what they are testing.

I keep my cars for many years, and their reliability ratings have pretty much matched my own & many people I know experiences over the years. Long term reliability is my major concern when buying a car, so I don't like that they have been putting less importance on reliability in recent years.

Their appliance ratings also seem to be pretty accurate.

Their TV and computer ratings are another thing.

They test TV’s based on their “out of the box” settings. Most TV’s need a least a little adjustment to the picture settings to give you an accurate picture. Most have the color and brightness set too high by default, since the average consumer thinks it looks better in the brightly lit store.

As for computers, where do I even start? They rate them from a noobie viewpoint & how well the call in support can answer stupid questions.
I'd agree... Yep.
I question their tech ratings. Computers you have to distrust them for, as yes... They'll dock points for bloatware and stuff, which we know has no bearing if you take it off...
But that might be a good thing for NOOB users, IDK.
I just don't trust them much for anything that involves software, as we all know: tons of variables.

The antenna issue is one I trust them on, read how they tested it (Put it inside an RF-shielded room and ranked the signal to their own little tower in the room... 100% controlled test)...

iPhone 4 = Windows Vista
??? There wasn't anything wrong with Vista itself though. At least major. (UAC glitches, and Networking glitches...)
It's not like the OS would boot up and anytime you tried to open the Start menu it'd crash... Which is more akin to what the iPhone is doing, and actually closely resembles the behavior of Windows ME :D
 
It shows to me a company that thinks it can just push out anything old thing with whatever flaw and they know people will buy it by the truckload.
A company "that thinks"???? Seems like they did just that.
 
Consumer Reports to Apple: We are owning you little bars......:eek:

Honestly, I don't see this hurting the sale of the phone one little bit. CR backed off at the end and stated that the rest of the phone was better than sliced bread anyway.

Just slap some duct tape or JB Weld on it.:D
 
The thing is Apple HAD to know about this problem and could have engineered a simple fix and just didn't. Not saying that companies don't do this all the time but this is Apple, that name is synonymous with quality and this is anything but quality. It shows to me a company that thinks it can just push out anything old thing with whatever flaw and they know people will buy it by the truckload. Apple's getting lazy, a victim of its own success.

They could have fixed this, they chose not to.

Apple does not consider this to be a major defect, it is as simple at that. They know most people will use a case or not touch their phone there enough to drop a call.

One of my friends at work is waiting until "Mid August" for an iPhone to arrive at a local store. He already bought 2 bumper cases for the phone because he could not decide on a color, but knew he needed a case. So yeah, they sell a truck load of these and people do not care about the signal issue. This is not affecting their bottom line since they cannot make the devices any faster.
 
Somehow, I feel like Steve Jobs is gonna pipe up over this CR thing, just a gut feeling about it but I think we'll hear something from him pretty soon.

And I don't mean some damned unverifiable email either...
 
DAMMIT KYLE... I can't fit all that into my sig, crap. :D

/me bows down to The [M]an... hilarious as always, and spot on.
 
Consumer Reports: "We can't recommend this phone"
Steve Jobs: "You're holding it wrong"
 
Apple does not consider this to be a major defect, it is as simple at that. They know most people will use a case or not touch their phone there enough to drop a call.

One of my friends at work is waiting until "Mid August" for an iPhone to arrive at a local store. He already bought 2 bumper cases for the phone because he could not decide on a color, but knew he needed a case. So yeah, they sell a truck load of these and people do not care about the signal issue. This is not affecting their bottom line since they cannot make the devices any faster.

And this is THE problem. What else did Apple simply gloss over? As a consumer advocate, how could Consumer Reports look at this and say "no big deal" because they get it too. Apple is simply taking its customers for granted here.
 
I??? There wasn't anything wrong with Vista itself though. At least major. (UAC glitches, and Networking glitches...)
It's not like the OS would boot up and anytime you tried to open the Start menu it'd crash... Which is more akin to what the iPhone is doing, and actually closely resembles the behavior of Windows ME :D

And there's really nothing wrong with the iPhone that a piece of tape can't fix. I was talking about the bad PR, not the technology. The iPhone 4 looks like sweet device but this bad PR and even Apple won't fully recover from this until iPhone 5.
 
HAHAHAHAHA

Took me a second to realize what the Swype reference was for but I got it... damned cool technology.
 
I just found it funny that shortly after this debacle we have news stories being posted that "ATT's Fault" of course ATT will bend over further and take the heat for Jobs and crew.
 
Kindof OT but you been able to figure out a way to get speech-to-text working while keeping the Swype keyboard???

Nope. You can change the input method quickly by simply holding down on the input box though.
 
For those that are lost on Swype........

<object width="853" height="505"><param name="movie" value="http://www.youtube.com/v/-I7dbisCRuM&amp;hl=en_US&amp;fs=1?color1=0x3a3a3a&amp;color2=0x999999"></param><param name="allowFullScreen" value="true"></param><param name="allowscriptaccess" value="always"></param><embed src="http://www.youtube.com/v/-I7dbisCRuM&amp;hl=en_US&amp;fs=1?color1=0x3a3a3a&amp;color2=0x999999" type="application/x-shockwave-flash" allowscriptaccess="always" allowfullscreen="true" width="853" height="505"></embed></object>

It is also rumored that Swype is talking to Apple about the tech implementation on its phones.
 
Consumer Reports: "We can't recommend this phone"
Steve Jobs: "You're holding it wrong"

Lol, but I think it will be more like this:

Consumer Reports: "We can't recommend this phone"
Steve Jobs: "No iPhone for you!"

Apple's response will be to cut consumer reports out of any news conferences and no longer provide them any samples. Not like CR really needs either, but that seems to be their response to other reporting agencies that don't like their latest product(s).
 
Back
Top