IPhone 4 Breaks When Dropped

If you drop something, and it breaks, that is your fault. Man up, take responsability for your actions and don't start complaining about how the product should have been able to withstand the drop. The company didn't drop your phone ... you did.

Companies making devices capable of withstanding what is to be expected during everyday use? Imagine that.

Oh wait, I've had 4 BlackBerries.. I've dropped each of them quite a bit, all are working 100%. My Curve has seen more falls than I can even remember, probably 50-60 in the 2 years I've had it.

You have a foolish attitude.
 
sad how they brag about how precise it is, how tough, how elegant blah blah, then you need to go wrap it up with a case and make it bigger at the same time as ugly

my iphone has dropped many of times when iget out of the car etc, but i have the slim otter box on it.. i hate it, the phone looks and feels much better without but i dont see it taking drops to pavement on its own
 
Apple should put out a wrist strap like Nintendo did for the Wii. Surely more iPhones are going to see air time increase now that it's a full fledged "gaming" system/sixaxis/phone/controller/thing.

The iStrap?

You heard it here first folks.

BRILLIANT!!!1!1 GENIUS!111!!! I WANT 7!!!11!
 
Companies making devices capable of withstanding what is to be expected during everyday use? Imagine that.

Oh wait, I've had 4 BlackBerries.. I've dropped each of them quite a bit, all are working 100%. My Curve has seen more falls than I can even remember, probably 50-60 in the 2 years I've had it.

You have a foolish attitude.

Seriously. I have literally drop kicked (dropped it and at same time while walking, my foot "kicked" it) my curve down a parking garage ramp some by accident, and it still works like a champ.

Apple apologist at their finest (or worst)?!?!
 
Might as well just get a lanyard and hang the god damned things around your neck if you're gonna go that far. Why bother carrying it, just "loop it" and be done with it where it's always within reach.
 
My daughter dropped my wife's iPhone 3G while sitting on those shopping cart, from that distance fell flat directly onto the concrete floor. I saw the glass side fall first right into the floor and survived!... I was expecting a cracked glass when I picked it up since it made a slapping/cracking noise as it landed.. but no, it survived unblemished...

two minutes later, she dropped it again while sitting on a regular chair... still survived :)
 
icrap this and icrap that... GESH give it a rest with the icrap.

seriously... use your brain... you think a 3 and half foot drop would cause that kind of damage. All you apple haters really have to open your eyes... so eager to find something negative, blinded by your own prejudices.

+1 and +1 again...

seems like ever since Steve became the main news poster all we've had are apple nerd rage threads in the news section....

horrible, horrible news posts as of late......
 
My daughter dropped my wife's iPhone 3G while sitting on those shopping cart, from that distance fell flat directly onto the concrete floor. I saw the glass side fall first right into the floor and survived!... I was expecting a cracked glass when I picked it up since it made a slapping/cracking noise as it landed.. but no, it survived unblemished...

two minutes later, she dropped it again while sitting on a regular chair... still survived :)

I've dropped mine several times with and without a case or screen protector and it suffered no damage. Inserting the dock connector in the dark, or without looking, has however completely raped the shiny plastic bezel around the screen. Looks like it's been sandpapered.
 
+1 and +1 again...

seems like ever since Steve became the main news poster all we've had are apple nerd rage threads in the news section....

horrible, horrible news posts as of late......

how about -1 for all 3 of you

How is this horrible news? A company is claiming that their device is more rugid that is really is.

Find a story about how a toughbook breaks after a 2 feet fall and send that in to Steve to post.
 
They do. The Moto Droid, for instance, has the same Gorilla Glass that the iPhone 4 will be using. The cheap Android phones might not, but the nicer ones do.

ya well, no way I'm going to verizon :)

I am waiting for the dell streak so I can finally upgrade from my G1

ive dropped my G1 and iPhone 2G several times, and they are both still fine... they look like they have had better days, but work lol
 
how about -1 for all 3 of you

How is this horrible news? A company is claiming that their device is more rugid that is really is.

Find a story about how a toughbook breaks after a 2 feet fall and send that in to Steve to post.

Ehh, not a fair comparison, Toughbooks lol

Drop a Moto Droid, maybe, or whatever Android phone that also use glass screens.
 
Ehh, not a fair comparison, Toughbooks lol

Drop a Moto Droid, maybe, or whatever Android phone that also use glass screens.

I think you misunderstood my comment. I wasn't saying as a comparison between the two devices. He is bitching that there is an article about an iPhone which apple claimed to be stronger than other phones breaks just as easily as the rest. I was simplily stating that if he could find an article about a "ruggid" device not being ruggid then to submit it to Steve so that he can post it. A toughbook was the first device that came to mind. If a toughbook did not live up to its name and was easily broken then posting that would be the same as this article. Nobody cares about the devices that work like they say they do. Your not going to see Steve and them posting articles about a normal laptop breaking in ways that a normal laptop should break, or a normal phone breaking in ways that a normal phone would break. You are however going to see them post about ruggid or devices created by GOD himself and beamed down to earth not lasting when they are able to be broken as easily or easierly than a normal device.

A good example is the article about that phone awhile back that was said to be unbreakable. They offered the reporter a free phone if he could break it. It hit it against the side of an aquiarum and shattered the screen. That was clearily a device that did not last as well as was claimed.

That is all i was trying to tell him, was to find stuff like that. Not trying to compare a toughbook and an iPhone
 
Companies making devices capable of withstanding what is to be expected during everyday use? Imagine that.

Oh wait, I've had 4 BlackBerries.. I've dropped each of them quite a bit, all are working 100%. My Curve has seen more falls than I can even remember, probably 50-60 in the 2 years I've had it.

You have a foolish attitude.

Taking responsability for ones actions is a foolish attitude?

Yup .. that's about what I have come to expect these days.
 
In that case the company shouldn't claim that their device can't be broken by being dropped.

Allegedly taking the shell of an iphone, with no parts inside, and drop testing the device is an accurate test of durability?
Not disclosing the surface it was dropped onto, or taking into account the lack of internal components, should raise some questions.
 
I dropped mine from a height of about three feet once. Not a scratch. I have several barely-distinguishable hairline cracks in the plastic near the volume rocker and a very scuffed-up chrome bezel, but that's about it..

My daughter dropped my wife's iPhone 3G while sitting on those shopping cart, from that distance fell flat directly onto the concrete floor. two minutes later, she dropped it again while sitting on a regular chair... still survived :)
WARNING: Do not give iPhone to children, the elderly or women.

How is this horrible news? A company is claiming that their device is more rugid that is really is.
No, they claim the glass is more durable. No such claims about the durability of the device.
 
I think you misunderstood my comment. I wasn't saying as a comparison between the two devices. He is bitching that there is an article about an iPhone which apple claimed to be stronger than other phones breaks just as easily as the rest. I was simplily stating that if he could find an article about a "ruggid" device not being ruggid then to submit it to Steve so that he can post it. A toughbook was the first device that came to mind. If a toughbook did not live up to its name and was easily broken then posting that would be the same as this article. Nobody cares about the devices that work like they say they do. Your not going to see Steve and them posting articles about a normal laptop breaking in ways that a normal laptop should break, or a normal phone breaking in ways that a normal phone would break. You are however going to see them post about ruggid or devices created by GOD himself and beamed down to earth not lasting when they are able to be broken as easily or easierly than a normal device.

A good example is the article about that phone awhile back that was said to be unbreakable. They offered the reporter a free phone if he could break it. It hit it against the side of an aquiarum and shattered the screen. That was clearily a device that did not last as well as was claimed.

That is all i was trying to tell him, was to find stuff like that. Not trying to compare a toughbook and an iPhone

ok, i know what you mean. But the funny thing is we all know Apple embellishes and exagerrate their products in advertisements, but we constantly act like it's a huge surprise when we perform tests like this drop test. The article should mention that Apple is known for not being completely honest in their ads, in addition to proving the fact, not act all "omg, Apple lied!! IPhone is teh suck!!" when in fact it's no different from any other glass smartphones.

We here know it's no Toughbook and we also know we should not take Apple's ads at face value.
 
The harder they make the glass (to be scratch resistant) the more liable it is to crack shatter on an impact. Make it soft so it won't shatter on a drop, but then it becomes scratchable ...
 
No, they claim the glass is more durable. No such claims about the durability of the device.

Yeah, but the glass is what broke. The rest of the device was fine ;)

Allegedly taking the shell of an iphone, with no parts inside, and drop testing the device is an accurate test of durability?
Not disclosing the surface it was dropped onto, or taking into account the lack of internal components, should raise some questions.

They said what they dropped it onto. They dropped it onto cement. That was stated about a half dozen times. And why would the lack of internal components raise some questions? They are a repair shop. A bunch of high profile repair shops have gotten iPhone 4 parts so that they can be ready when the devices ship. Not unusual or weird at all. And again, the lack of internal components really made this a best case scenario. Its lighter, and thus less likely to be damaged in the fall.
 
Taking responsability for ones actions is a foolish attitude?

Yup .. that's about what I have come to expect these days.

Are you really THAT thick? It's a phone. People drop phones. That's a fact of life. If Apple can't make a device that survives one of the most basic negative things that can happen to it (and statistically, it is, because people drop things; again, fact of life), that's a 100% FAIL.

And I love your "taking responsability for ones actions" bullshit. If I pay Apple $600 fucking dollars (which I'm not, ever, by the way), I expect something that isn't going to shatter into a million pieces the first time it's dropped. Period. I'd expect that of a glass figurine; not a phone, and certainly not one advertised as "durable" and "stronger than plastic".

P.S. I dropped my HTC Magic from a moving bike, at 15 km/h, onto a paved bike path, from about 5' up. Not only did it survive, there was nothing but one scratch on it. THAT's how a phone SHOULD be build.
 
iPhone protection sleeves have been around since the first iPhone. Get one, use it. If you don't have one, you deserve your broken iPhone. That goes for just about any large touchscreen smartphones.

The thing about those is that they pretty much negate the phones aesthetics, which is a huge part of Apples marketing.

If you drop something, and it breaks, that is your fault. Man up, take responsability for your actions and don't start complaining about how the product should have been able to withstand the drop. The company didn't drop your phone ... you did.

Not when the said company makes the phones durability as its selling point.
 
I don't know what the weekend warrior physicists are talking about, but I bet money on the "heavy," not hollow phone, fairing a bit better. I don't like Apple and can see the it ain't bullet proof glass as advertised angle, but it's amazing what people will try and pass off as obvious logic.

I might lose my bet, as the guts of the phone cause it descend at mach speeds, but at least I never implied I really know wtf I'm talking about.
 
My iPhone has sustained many drops from that same height. However, the new design is obviously more fragile with the glass back.
 
Not the least bit surprising, glass is glass it breaks when it falls.

More accurately it breaks when it comes into contact with something that just won't budge. ;)

"It's not the fall that kills you, it's the impact with the stationary object(s) that does you in...
 
If Apple can't make a device that survives one of the most basic negative things that can happen to it (and statistically, it is, because people drop things; again, fact of life), that's a 100% FAIL.
It survived twice. It failed the third time. 33% fail?

And I love your "taking responsability for ones actions" bullshit. If I pay Apple $600 fucking dollars (which I'm not, ever, by the way), I expect something that isn't going to shatter into a million pieces the first time it's dropped.
It didn't shatter the first time it was dropped. It shattered the third time. From what we know, if you want a phone that doesn't shatter the first time it's dropped, then an iPhone seems like a pretty good choice.
 
The thing about those is that they pretty much negate the phones aesthetics, which is a huge part of Apples marketing.



Not when the said company makes the phones durability as its selling point.

It depends on which you pick. Mine's the very thin hard rubber snap-on back plate. It's only about 1/16th of an inch thick. Worked well for me since a little over a year ago when I got this 3GS from my boss. I tosz the phone on my desk often and dropped it a few times too. I have a scratch guard over the screen as well
 
yeah I had one of those hard cases on too, with the screen protector that was thicker, i literally by accident threw my phone 4 feet in the air, it bounced and not one single scratch.


I have an employee who has never used a protector on his 3g, and his screen has been smashed by keys in his pocket twice. theres a piece of clear tape holding it together as I type this.


my 40$ protector saved me 100$ for a new screen.
 
Maybe you shouldn't drop it... just putting that out there, I usually don't drop my valuables.
 
Nice sample size of 1. They might take another one off the shelf and drop it 1000 times and not have a problem. Could have been a problem with a small batch of glass. Who knows.....

Guessing they are suddenly going to have a difficult time sourcing iPhone parts after this... lol
 
Look like a blog post they are just trying to get hits on so they can get more customers :shrug:
 
Nice sample size of 1. They might take another one off the shelf and drop it 1000 times and not have a problem. Could have been a problem with a small batch of glass. Who knows.....

Guessing they are suddenly going to have a difficult time sourcing iPhone parts after this... lol

They did test a second phone, dropping it onto a variety of surfaces instead of just concrete. It didn't break on carpet, but it still broke on concrete. There is a link to it on the posted article.

I don't know what the weekend warrior physicists are talking about, but I bet money on the "heavy," not hollow phone, fairing a bit better. I don't like Apple and can see the it ain't bullet proof glass as advertised angle, but it's amazing what people will try and pass off as obvious logic.

I might lose my bet, as the guts of the phone cause it descend at mach speeds, but at least I never implied I really know wtf I'm talking about.

"weekend warrior physicists"? High school physics is all you need to work it out. Being heavier won't cause it to fall any faster All objects in a vacuum fall at the same speed regardless of weight. Given that hollow and full they have the same aerodynamic profile, weight won't cause it to fall much faster, if at all. Extra weight will cause it to hit with more force, however. Likewise, when its hollow it will more easily be able to deform, which extends the impact time and thus lowers the impact force. Think of it like falling 20 feet onto cement vs. falling 20 feet onto foam. You hit with the same velocity and experience the same net force. Both will decelerate you to a 0 mph. However, landing on the cement will seriously injure you. Landing on foam you can hop up and walk away without a scratch. Why? Because the impact duration is much longer when you hit the phone, thus the total impact force is spread out over a "long" duration, meaning you only experience fractions of the impact force. Its like sustaining 5Gs over 10 seconds vs. sustaining 50Gs over 1 second. The net Gs experienced is the same in both cases, but one you can survive without much trouble and the other will kill you.

But by all means feel free to explain why you think putting more weight into the phone and making it more rigid will help it survive a fall. I'd love to hear how you think physics works.

That said, I'll totally take your bet. Free money is free money :p
 
All of the major ones do. My Droid Incredible definitely does.

seems like verizon got all the nice android phones :(

I'm still rockin my G1, which I think might also be glass, or something... not sure...

I really really hope dell releases a T-Mobile version of the streak *crosses fingers*
 
Back
Top