Why Aren't There More Spam Lawsuits?

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Why aren’t there more spam lawsuits? That’s a damn good question! It turns out that one of the problems is that most crusty old judges don’t understand technology enough to hear a spam case.

There are a couple of reasons, but by far the largest one is that, unless the recipient is unusually lucky, anti-spam lawsuits are difficult to prosecute and win. The evidence in such suits is very technical--mail headers, WHOIS data, traceroutes, ASN numbers, affiliate codes and HTTP redirections that tie a sender to a particular message, or more likely, a thousand messages.
 
Our gov needs to get a firm grasp on technology, ruling on matters you don't understand, and passing laws you on technology you don't understand is not a good thing
 
um, im pretty sure everything involved in such a case from a technological standpoint would also apply to say....a nigerian businessmen......or perhaps even a RIAA/MPAA case right?

i mean, there seem to be no shortages of judges when <insert large music or movie company name here> wants umpteen million bucks from an unemployed, social security supported grandmother for downloading a song or two supposedly

but when we ask to prove the same ownership of the source in a spam case and suddenly nobody is willing to hear it???????

good question
 
I don't see what the big deal with Specially Packed American Meat is
 
IMHO, it doesn't really matter right now if the judges are tech-savvy -- the current laws simply have not caught up with the computer/internet age and that puts a burden on the judges. Their hands are tied no matter how tech smart they are. Just like the (software) patent fiasco, lots of overhauling is seriously needed, now rather than later.
 
Every piece of spam allows you to make a purchase if you so choose so the sellers are easy to find. You go after the sellers, who in the end are the spammers.

The big issue is money. How much money will anyone spend to avoid a minor annoyance? It’s cheaper to use free filtering software or change email accounts.

No profit in a spam suit and lawyers, loveem or hatem work for money.
 
It kinda defeats the purpose, if you spam the legal system with spam lawsuits ... doesn't it?
 
The big reason is that the law (CAN SPAM) is somewhat ambiguous about who has standing. It's clear that a commercial ISP could sue, and that an end user using the ISP's mail servers can't sue. It's not clear if running a personal mail server is enough to be able to sue. There's also something about having to sue over a 'real cost' for accepting the messages.

The commercial ISPs generally only sue for the large cases, and the smaller ISPs (and personal mail servers) have too nebulous a case to pursue.
 
RIAA is effective because they are able to file thousands of suits at once, and many of these people settle, giving the RIAA little actual cost but a huge profit margin. The same does not apply for spam. Much originates from overseas making civil litigation virtually impossible. Others coming from the US requires extensive investigation and end result you might find junior working in his basement. I think if they want to go after people they should pass laws making it illegal to market products via unsolicited email. Now that would have an impact.
 
Don't bother putting a lawsuit against those who send the spam. Put out a new law against using such, then sue those companies paying the spammers to send out the spam.
 
This is the problem with almost ANY tech related suit these days.

The Judges/Lawyers/Jury are to god damned stupid.

Either they toss it out going 'WTF is wrong?' because they have no idea, or they let it through (Like the RIAA) cases because there is no way this bog company can be wrong.

Its god damned sad.
 
i agree with some of you, forget challenging the act of spamming, click through the links, make a purchase, then fine the pants off the company that sold you the product for illegal solicitation
 
I call bullshit. There is nothing more technical involved than in a RIAA lawsuit, and the judges tend to believe them. Even when the plaintiff admits to Illegal activity to acquire the information, they still win.

The only difference is money and lobby. If Lincoln had a time machine he would have changed the words to "For the corporations, By the corporations".:(
 
eh, RIAA lawsuit, look at how ignorant they were about the jamie thomas lawsuit, and how they admitted their mistakes....
 
The only difference is money and lobby. If Lincoln had a time machine he would have changed the words to "For the corporations, By the corporations".:(

I seriously doubt lobbies have a significant affect on judges and court rulings. The Judicial branch of government seems to care more about principal than the practical affects of their rulings, as evidenced by the judge who barred Microsoft from selling Word.

I think the problem lies more with the laws than the courts enforcing them.
 
Back
Top