Robots with Knives Could Attack Humans Accidentally

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Scientists at the (ominous sounding) Institute of Robotics and Mechatronics, have put on a little demonstration today showing you what would happen if your robot went crazy. Seriously.
 
Hmm so you'd have to turn off collision detection if you wanted your robot to slice turkey eh?

Also, the guy at the end had enormous balls.
 
Wow, I thought the tests with the pig were cool...
Then they showed the test on a real guy. That was unexpected.:eek:
 
I just chuckled manically when the steak knife cut 101mm through the pig.

Also, that guy had massive testicles.
 
I just chuckled manically when the steak knife cut 101mm through the pig.

Also, that guy had massive testicles.

I think I've seen this sorta technology before... but it was with a saw blade. They used a hotdog to demonstrate and it got a tiny nick maybe 1-2mm deep but the saw blade was stopped instantly after it detected it wasn't cutting through a piece of wood anymore.

I still wouldn't stick my finger in there just to test :p
 
All Robots must be made and programed subject to Asinov's three laws or robotics!
 
Sorry "Asimov" (we need an edit button)
Isaac Asimov's "Three Laws of Robotics"

1. A robot may not injure a human being or, through inaction, allow a human being to come to harm.

2. A robot must obey orders given it by human beings except where such orders would conflict with the First Law.

3. A robot must protect its own existence as long as such protection does not conflict with the First or Second Law.
 
They should have given that robot something cooler than a steak knife. Maybe a Spyderco Military or even an Endura.

I think I've seen this sorta technology before... but it was with a saw blade. They used a hotdog to demonstrate and it got a tiny nick maybe 1-2mm deep but the saw blade was stopped instantly after it detected it wasn't cutting through a piece of wood anymore.

I still wouldn't stick my finger in there just to test :p

I "saw" that video for the table saw as well. That was pretty cool but I think it cost around $20,000. A bit out of my league for my shop.
 
Yeah, I can imagine getting a robot out the door (As a business) after pushing several programmers and robotics guys for the last couple of years.

Then after it gets to the masses, a bug somewere deep in the logic makes all of the bots kill thousands of people.

Especially so if the robot learns via NN.
 
I think I've seen this sorta technology before... but it was with a saw blade. They used a hotdog to demonstrate and it got a tiny nick maybe 1-2mm deep but the saw blade was stopped instantly after it detected it wasn't cutting through a piece of wood anymore.

I still wouldn't stick my finger in there just to test :p

The table saw is called SawStop. Go to the site and watch the videos. Very cool. A friend of mine owns one of those. Luckily he hasn't had an issue, but the technology could potentially save lives and digits.
 
btw, they killed the saw stop product. no manufacturer wanted to assume the liability of a saw that *should* stop before cutting someone. no doubt someone would lose a hand and then own the company.
 
I don't think I understand the point of the video.

Most industrial robots I've seen all had some form of programmable collision detection.
 
ok. I checked other stuff from them and it seems they are mostly just testing out features to ensure they work.
 
The table saw is called SawStop. Go to the site and watch the videos. Very cool. A friend of mine owns one of those. Luckily he hasn't had an issue, but the technology could potentially save lives and digits.

As i understand it from the demonstration i saw on tv, the table basically self destructs if it's triggered. How much would it cost to put back together?

Also, how does the robot in the op's video detect an obstruction? So how does it manage to detect the flesh past the knifes weight and momentum?
 
As i understand it from the demonstration i saw on tv, the table basically self destructs if it's triggered. How much would it cost to put back together?

A whole lot less than it'll cost to sew your mangled hand back on :)
 
Sorry "Asimov" (we need an edit button)
Isaac Asimov's "Three Laws of Robotics"

1. A robot may not injure a human being or, through inaction, allow a human being to come to harm.

2. A robot must obey orders given it by human beings except where such orders would conflict with the First Law.

3. A robot must protect its own existence as long as such protection does not conflict with the First or Second Law.

Those laws are bullshit.
 
As i understand it from the demonstration i saw on tv, the table basically self destructs if it's triggered. How much would it cost to put back together?

Also, how does the robot in the op's video detect an obstruction? So how does it manage to detect the flesh past the knifes weight and momentum?

Actually, what happens is that the saw is built into a cartridge system that activates once flesh closes the circuit through the saw blade. The sampling rate is pretty high and once activation occurs then it kicks in with in a millisecond or so. Then stop system kicks in and halts the blade, but it kills the mechanism which would have to be replaced to the tune of about a few hundred, but at least you keep your finger.

A device like this if adopted by all machine operators across all forms of industry would lower liability costs, insurance costs, save people from horrific injuries, and other numerable benefits. Alas, industry has decided to ignore it much to their detriment.
 
Those laws are bullshit.

One of the greatest (if not THE greatest) science fiction (and in some cases science fact) writers ever, thought they were pretty good, and in fact so do many scientists etc..

So you can't just make a declaration like that without some sort of explanation. What in particular do you find to be bullshit about those laws?
 
One of the greatest (if not THE greatest) science fiction (and in some cases science fact) writers ever, thought they were pretty good, and in fact so do many scientists etc..

So you can't just make a declaration like that without some sort of explanation. What in particular do you find to be bullshit about those laws?

Cruise Missiles (Shown to be very effective), UAV's (Armed and Autonomouse models are ready to come out of experimental stage), Autonomous Tanks (still under development, but good enough find their way around rough terrain, and i'm not talking about the little ones).

Not exactly self aware, but smart enough to make their own decisions. And they show that the laws of robotics are just a fantasy, there's actually nothing stopping people from making a robot that kills.
 
And they show that the laws of robotics are just a fantasy, there's actually nothing stopping people from making a robot that kills.
uh, duuuuh!

although technically it is science fiction. and in the science fiction a robot is defined as something with a positronic brain that is self-aware. hell, you can make a can-opener that kills, that does not make it a robot. none of the things you describe are self-aware or have positronic brains.
 
Actually, what happens is that the saw is built into a cartridge system that activates once flesh closes the circuit through the saw blade. The sampling rate is pretty high and once activation occurs then it kicks in with in a millisecond or so. Then stop system kicks in and halts the blade, but it kills the mechanism which would have to be replaced to the tune of about a few hundred, but at least you keep your finger.

A device like this if adopted by all machine operators across all forms of industry would lower liability costs, insurance costs, save people from horrific injuries, and other numerable benefits. Alas, industry has decided to ignore it much to their detriment.

uh, duuuuh!

although technically it is science fiction. and in the science fiction a robot is defined as something with a positronic brain that is self-aware. hell, you can make a can-opener that kills, that does not make it a robot. none of the things you describe are self-aware or have positronic brains.

They do not anatomically match a human, but they are robotic artificial intelligence.
 
Cruise Missiles (Shown to be very effective), UAV's (Armed and Autonomouse models are ready to come out of experimental stage), Autonomous Tanks (still under development, but good enough find their way around rough terrain, and i'm not talking about the little ones).

Not exactly self aware, but smart enough to make their own decisions. And they show that the laws of robotics are just a fantasy, there's actually nothing stopping people from making a robot that kills.

Did you say "decisions?"

Nothing about any of that technology decides what its going to do when. And its a far fucking cry from any sort of AI
 
Sorry "Asimov" (we need an edit button)
Isaac Asimov's "Three Laws of Robotics"

1. A robot may not injure a human being or, through inaction, allow a human being to come to harm.

2. A robot must obey orders given it by human beings except where such orders would conflict with the First Law.

3. A robot must protect its own existence as long as such protection does not conflict with the First or Second Law.



Didnt Asimov's books then go on to describe real world logic faults in the three laws and how they could be used to harm?
 
I'm confused... clearly it's demonstrating collision detection vs. the lack of collision detection. But when you actually want it to cut something you'd turn collision detection off... and that's when all the accidents would occur right?
 
Saw stop video:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=esnQwVZOrUU

Time Warp (slowed down and original was in HD)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E3mzhvMgrLE
I "saw" that video for the table saw as well. That was pretty cool but I think it cost around $20,000. A bit out of my league for my shop.
Naw
http://www.google.com/products?q=sawstop&hl=en&aq=f
Only about $3k from what I see there.


I think I've seen this sorta technology before... but it was with a saw blade. They used a hotdog to demonstrate and it got a tiny nick maybe 1-2mm deep but the saw blade was stopped instantly after it detected it wasn't cutting through a piece of wood anymore.

I still wouldn't stick my finger in there just to test :p
Yep, called sawstop. I linked a video with a guy using his finger to test.

btw, they killed the saw stop product. no manufacturer wanted to assume the liability of a saw that *should* stop before cutting someone. no doubt someone would lose a hand and then own the company.
Nope, still there from what I can tell:
http://www.sawstop.com/
I doubt that was the reason its not been put on other saws. Probably a licensing or cost issue.

As i understand it from the demonstration i saw on tv, the table basically self destructs if it's triggered. How much would it cost to put back together?
It destructs the stop cartridge, not the table. The stop cartridge is UNDER $100 bucks according to a quick google. It contains sensors and precision equipment (like the high speed stuff to stop the blade instantly). The blade is probably also ruined when this happens (see the videos above for why).

Unfortunately, you have to have a table saw designed for this with it built in. I don't think you can retrofit existing table saws. But if I was buying one, I'd probably get one with this in it. My fingers are worth a $3k table saw, and a $100 stop cartridge..
 
Back
Top