RAID 0 on two IDE drives? explain to me the difference?

2wiced

2[H]4U
Joined
Feb 14, 2005
Messages
3,366
Hey guys.

I have 3 hard drives

i have 2 120gb IDE drives and 1 320GB sata drive.

Now i would like to raid 0 the IDE drives, but would that not be as fast as raiding SATA drives?

Its either that, or I buy a new 1tb drive. I just want to try out raid for gaming speed.
 
RAID0 is based on parallel I/O; that does not work properly if only one device can be accessed at a time, such as with Parallel ATA. Thus the performance benefits are small.

Also, a 120GB HDD with 60 or 120GB platters is going to be much slower than a 500GB-per-platter drive. In other words; any modern drive will be much faster. So perhaps you should just ditch the 120GB drives; they do use 8W idle which is ~16 euro a year in electricity cost if you leave them running 24/7.
 
Last edited:
if you just want to experiment as compared to tossing the drives out, then go for it. you might get some benefit out of it, if only for the learning experience.
 
For your information and indirect reference, single run results

seeker /dev/md2 (1,4,8 threads)

1 - 67 seeks/second / 14.77 ms random access
4 - 137 seeks/second / 7.26 ms random access
8 - 147 seeks/second / 6.78 ms random access

WD40GB IDE + Maxtor 40GB IDE in Linux MD RAID-1. /dev/md2 about 25GB
 
RAID0 is based on parallel I/O; that does not work properly if only one device can be accessed at a time, such as with Parallel ATA. Thus the performance benefits are small.

Also, a 120GB HDD with 60 or 120GB platters is going to be much slower than a 500GB-per-platter drive. In other words; any modern drive will be much faster. So perhaps you should just ditch the 120GB drives; they do use 8W idle which is ~160 euro a year in electricity cost if you leave them running 24/7.

I think you made a mistake in your calculation or made a typo, because at $0.125/kWhr I get that the two drives would cost about $17.50/year. If he replaced the two with one drive that idles at 3 watts, he would save about $14/year at $0.125/kWhr.
 
Sorry i meant to say 16 euro; twice that of the idle wattage when considering 24/7/365. That's the price in my country; but i assume in the US you pay much less.

Here's a nice chart:

cbsprijsvergelijking.gif


If we take 0,22 euro per kWh, and we assume a drive with 8W idle is running for a year long, the math would be: ((8 * 24 * 365) / 1000) * 0,22 = 15,42.
Translating that to dollars would be 15,42 * 1.3129 = $20,24
 
Last edited:
Ditch all 3 and get new one.

It will be faster, consume less power and most probably will be quieter.

Also benefits of raid 0 for gaming are questionable at best:
http://www.anandtech.com/show/1371/10

wow thanks for that. If it consumes less power and performs faster, im just gonna buy a second SATA drive like a 1TB or 1.5TB transfer all the stuff I have on it, and give my old ones to my friend
 
Back
Top