X25-V Upgrade worth it?

ep3w

Gawd
Joined
Apr 4, 2008
Messages
694
I have the upgrade bug and have been thinking about an SSD. I can either look at numbers all day and never be sure or ask the people who have actually used them. I am not sure I am ready to spend the $200+ on an SSD yet so I am wondering if the 40GB X25-V is worth the upgrade? I am currently using a 640GB WD black. Am I better holding off and buying something like the X25-M? Would be an OS/a couple apps drive.
 
The 40GB should be alot cheaper than $200; but yeah i think it is worth it. In fact i think this SSD gives you the most value per money; as for <100 euro you get one of the best SSD controllers; the only difference with X25-M is that is runs with half flash channels. Even with half channels, it is still very fast. The only thing that is really lower is the write speeds (seq/random). Not that important on your system disk, and still many times faster than Indilinx SSDs.
 
I have two 40GB X25-V's coming today for fun. Good news is that they are cheap!
 
I'm getting 5 this week - will post some RAID0 benches for those interested. :)
 
I'd say wait till you can afford the $200 and get the X25-M 80Gb.

Your WD 640 is already fast. Now if you had an old crappy HD, I'd say get the 40Gb. But since you have a modern HD, the X25-V won't be as noticeable of an upgrade.
 
Any HDD is slow for the function of the system disk; especially after use. A brand clean install feels fast on HDD due to a lot of access being sequential. But as you install/remove/use the system it will become more fragmented and HDDs seek more often.

So even a cheap crappy SSD would be a great upgrade; as it adds quick boot and appliation launch speeds. The Intel X25-V 40GB adds to that great random read and write performance, much above Indilinx and JMicron/Samsung based SSDs. The only real drawback versus the 80GB X25-M is the halved random write and sequential write scores; not that important on your system disk anyway. Random write of the X25-V is still higher than Indilinx.

I think it makes an excellent system disk; the best in terms of money-benefit ratio. The real question of course is how much space you'll need on your system disk. Gamers won't be too happy about a 40GB SSD; still means their games have to be on HDDs and load slower.
 
I think I might go for the 40GB. It seems like what it lacks compared to the 80GB, besides space, is not stuff that is too important for a system drive. I think 40GB would be good to install a couple basic things like firefox and maybe 1 or 2 games. I feel even with the 80GB I would have hard time choosing what games to have on it anyways (steam folder is 153GB currently). 40GB seems enough for basic programs and one or two games no? SSDs don't have the same issue of performance degradation once they start to get too full correct? I don't feel so bad spending 115$ vs 220$. I could always pick up another for raid in the future which seems to be a popular option.
 
im in same boat. I would like a x25-v but also wouldnt mind the -m but i have hard time investing 200 bux compared to 100 when i KNOW the technology jump is going to be very soon, i wouldnt mind putting the 40gb into a diff pc when upgrading but dont think id need a 80gb ssd in kids computer hmm, also raiding few of these up is tempting as well. Are the write speeds really HALF the -m?
 
I'm getting 5 this week - will post some RAID0 benches for those interested. :)

I am interested. For RAID 0, after 4 HDDs are used, the performance increase per disk used is less than than 5%. But for SSDs, it may be difference since there are no mechanical parts and very little seek time involved. Thanks! ;)
 
I am interested. For RAID 0, after 4 HDDs are used, the performance increase per disk used is less than than 5%. But for SSDs, it may be difference since there are no mechanical parts and very little seek time involved. Thanks! ;)

By the 4th raid 0 modern SSD installed you can saturate an ICH10R's bandwidth to the X58 chipset (somewhere in the realm of 550-650MB/s) on sequential reads.
 
im in same boat. I would like a x25-v but also wouldnt mind the -m but i have hard time investing 200 bux compared to 100 when i KNOW the technology jump is going to be very soon, i wouldnt mind putting the 40gb into a diff pc when upgrading but dont think id need a 80gb ssd in kids computer hmm, also raiding few of these up is tempting as well. Are the write speeds really HALF the -m?

I had the same thinking. If I decide its not enough space I could always bump it to my laptop or HTPC. I think while write speeds may behalf, the effect that has is not that great on an OS disk, however I could be wrong. I was hoping to keep 1 or 2 games on it but when games like MW2 are almost 12GBs that could be hard...
 
Go with it. They are cheap so you are not sinking much money and you still get biggest benefits of SSD for system drive.

Also remember that around end of year there will be new cheaper drives using 25nm flash so if you are unsure you can wait.
 
Remember, if you pack it too full. it will get slower on you. ie: > 80% full

Don't expect a huge wow factor, or you will be disappointed. Boot times will be faster, and a few other things will be a little faster, but you've already got a fast HD, so it won't be leaps and bounds faster!
 
By the 4th raid 0 modern SSD installed you can saturate an ICH10R's bandwidth to the X58 chipset (somewhere in the realm of 550-650MB/s) on sequential reads.
Well i will be using them on SuperMicro controller; 2GB/s per card. I think i should be able to reach 1GB/s sequential read with 5 of them (200MB/s each). Great for the upcoming 10GBaseT; which i hope to migrate to in a year or so.

I did some RAID0 benchmarks earlier with 8 disks; and it scaled just as nicely as 4 disks did. Also, FreeBSD is one of the first OS to support TRIM with SSDs in RAID-arrays; though not for use with ZFS yet. Due to performance reasons, i might reserve some 20-50% of capacity just for the SSDs themselves; i really buy these things for performance i don't need that much space really. System disk images are 8GB large; one is 20GB. So that's 32GB+20=52GB. The rest will be used as cache device for my huge RAID-Z arrays.

I also considered using it as log device, but that would mean it sees a lot of sequential writes. I would really prefer if i could use the SSDs for at least 10 years; so i'll be postponing that idea for the moment.
 
Yea that's a much better option. I installed my 11th Intel NIC in the main storage server this week... it also has an areca management NIC and the supermicro IPMI NIC. 13 CAT6 cables hanging off is a bit excessive.

I'm going to set up a dedicated ZFS box either on EON, FreeBSD, or FreeNAS this weekend. Still trying to decide if I virtualize it and if it will be OK with only 8gb of ram. The X25-V's I was planing to use as OS + swap drives for the ZFS box.
 
I decided to go for it. I figure for $110 its a good way to get into it. If I decided its not enough space I can move it to another machine and upgrade when the new ones come out.
 
I'm pretty much in the same boat, with the small provision that i only run linux these days on my main rig, so once i get a X25-V, it will house all of my linux system, expect for data storage (have an old 500gb samsung for that, and off course the 3,5 TB fileserver)

Hopefully i'll get one for my birthday, if not, i'll buy one from my bonus
 
I don't know about pricing in US but in here you can get Kingston 30 GB boot drives with Kingston controler for around 3/4 of Intel prices.
Altrough Toshiba doesn't show such amazing 4k random reads it still stutter free fast SSD with enough space for Windows 7 for example.
 
Toshiba controller is actually a laser-etched JMicron controller, but due to their bad reputation they laser-etched the chip surface to say Toshiba instead; and did some firmware tweaks also. Still, much lower random I/O performance than Intel. It may be a bit cheaper; but its a slow SSD compared to other offerings. I don't think it's worth its money.
 
I don't know about pricing in US but in here you can get Kingston 30 GB boot drives with Kingston controler for around 3/4 of Intel prices.
Altrough Toshiba doesn't show such amazing 4k random reads it still stutter free fast SSD with enough space for Windows 7 for example.

B/c its 3/4 the size! duh!

30Gb/40Gb = 3/4 :)

Here's another for you... you can get an 80Gb for about twice the price!? WOW!? Go figure! :) LOL
 
Perhaps he meant 3/4th of the price-per-GB of Intel SSDs. Intel is slightly more expensive per GB than the Indilinx and JMicron/Samsung based SSDs; which i consider to be low-performance SSDs; Sandforce/Micron/Intel currently make up the high-performance SSDs.
 
Any HDD is slow for the function of the system disk; especially after use. A brand clean install feels fast on HDD due to a lot of access being sequential. But as you install/remove/use the system it will become more fragmented and HDDs seek more often.

So even a cheap crappy SSD would be a great upgrade; as it adds quick boot and appliation launch speeds. The Intel X25-V 40GB adds to that great random read and write performance, much above Indilinx and JMicron/Samsung based SSDs. The only real drawback versus the 80GB X25-M is the halved random write and sequential write scores; not that important on your system disk anyway. Random write of the X25-V is still higher than Indilinx.

I think it makes an excellent system disk; the best in terms of money-benefit ratio. The real question of course is how much space you'll need on your system disk. Gamers won't be too happy about a 40GB SSD; still means their games have to be on HDDs and load slower.

Once the system is booted up, and assuming Win 7, everything is loaded into RAM, how much disk access is the OS actually doing for itself? If all you have on the SSD is the OS, how much benefit are you gaining after boot-up? Apps would be faster, but then you'd have to have them installed on the SSD, so app launch speed is only benefited if you have room for them on the SSD. I guess my point it, is a 40GB really worth the money? I'd say save for the 80GB, which gives you a lot more room (like 3 times as much once you lop off ~15GB for the OS) for apps and games that will actually benefit from the SSD.
 
Back
Top