Microsoft More Secure Than Apple, Adobe

Hah, I so wish there were an edit button. Infact, this should have been the OP to my recently closed thread @ http://hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=1513720

-------------------------

Have you ever pirated antivirus software? They come either with a crack or a method to keep the program supplied with a known and authorized account for updates. If it's this easy to crack and bypass the mechanisms within an antivirus program to use the full, registered version and receive updates, then the whole model of antivirus fails.

"If it's this easy," why can't it be easy for a virus? The security of antivirus software is jeopardized in itself for existing. LOL

It's one of those situations where there will always be people out there figuring out how to manipulate security mechanisms within a program so that they could use the full version without having to pay for it. There will always be cracks and so-forth for Windows. The topic of antivirus is big enough to qualify for this position.
 
No antivirus? Large and reputable websites have been found to have malware in their ads and they didn't even know it. Bad things are everywhere and you can't avoid running into it anymore, no matter how you surf or how smart you are.

QFT! It was only 2 or 3 weeks ago that Anandtech had this issue with one of their advertisers. Besides, most houses that are robbed have locks on the door and the vast majority are locked when they're robbed.
 
Here is an example: This guy at work, Rick, is a Mac. With Mac lappy, iphone, waiting for ipad, etc...

So I told him he should check into antivirus as a new mac virus came out. He said...I dont need too worry about that...I'm apple.

So his GF who sits next to me then starts talking about how he is fighting three charges that showed up on his checking account all of a sudden that he did not make. He think someone scanned his ATM card since there is a task force trying to catch a band of ATM bandits...

I just said...bummer dude.
 
I had a windows 7 starter netbook with Microsoft Security Essentials get infected within 2 hours of giving the machine back to their owner. It was a fresh install.
All they did was go to google and search for their website, esac.us.

It is an iframe attack. There is no spyware/trojans on his site but clicking his site in the google results sends you to a trojan site. So you can get infected clicking a link to a site you know is safe.
 
I had a windows 7 starter netbook with Microsoft Security Essentials get infected within 2 hours of giving the machine back to their owner. It was a fresh install.
All they did was go to google and search for their website, esac.us.

It is an iframe attack. There is no spyware/trojans on his site but clicking his site in the google results sends you to a trojan site. So you can get infected clicking a link to a site you know is safe.

How did you detect the trojan?
 
How did you detect the trojan?

I did the google search on multiple computers and malwarebytes blocked it and on my hackintosh it comes up with a google warning.

Safe Browsing
Diagnostic page for 87.248.180.0

What is the current listing status for 87.248.180.0?
This site is not currently listed as suspicious.

Part of this site was listed for suspicious activity 1 time(s) over the past 90 days.

What happened when Google visited this site?
Of the 9 pages we tested on the site over the past 90 days, 0 page(s) resulted in malicious software being downloaded and installed without user consent. The last time Google visited this site was on 2010-04-24, and the last time suspicious content was found on this site was on 2010-04-24.
This site was hosted on 1 network(s) including AS31252 (STARNET).

Has this site acted as an intermediary resulting in further distribution of malware?
Over the past 90 days, 87.248.180.0 appeared to function as an intermediary for the infection of 710 site(s) including marchex.com/, heatherchouphotography.com/, permianbasinautoclub.org/.

Has this site hosted malware?
Yes, this site has hosted malicious software over the past 90 days. It infected 922 domain(s), including marchex.com/, mtfcares.com/, tribal-sun.com/.

Next steps:
Return to the previous page.
If you are the owner of this web site, you can request a review of your site using Google Webmaster Tools. More information about the review process is available in Google's Webmaster Help Center.
 
I did the google search on multiple computers and malwarebytes blocked it and on my hackintosh it comes up with a google warning.

How as the machine setup? DEP on? UAC at maximum? Do you have an ID of the specific attack?
 
I had a windows 7 starter netbook with Microsoft Security Essentials get infected within 2 hours of giving the machine back to their owner. It was a fresh install.
All they did was go to google and search for their website, esac.us.

It is an iframe attack. There is no spyware/trojans on his site but clicking his site in the google results sends you to a trojan site. So you can get infected clicking a link to a site you know is safe.

Think I found it. All I did was a Google search on "esac.us", I didn't actually click on any of the results. A few seconds latter MSE popus up:

Malware%20Attack-001.jpg


Info about the attack: http://www.microsoft.com/security/p...e=Trojan:JS/Redirector.CI&threatid=2147631820

Now I can't be certain that this is what you're talking about but it looks like it must have been.

MSE picked it up for me and its been in the MSE defintions for almost two months.
 
XP Antivirus was where it all started as far as main spyware being on windows computers. This can infect XP machines as well as Vista/Windows 7 machines. There are many others out there now of days that do the same thing, but just have a different name. I work at a PC store and we get about 5 PC's every day that have this type of spyware on the machine. Yes these people are stupid by using limewire so it is their fault. Windows seems to be a little bit more secure, but not by too much.

I use a mac, but I know there are security holes in it and the reason we aren't attacked is because we are such a small market. I'm not a huge fan of apple the company I think they are stuck up douche bags, but I do like my macbook pro, and iPhone. I have 2 windows machines at home, my gaming windows 7 machine, and my media center PC also running windows 7. Both run just fine with no virus's, but neither of them really go online at all. All surfing and webmail is done on my mac.

Mac does need to step up, but Windows still sucks at stopping spyware, I just don't know why you are allowed to write to the OS files such as the hosts file in windows. The mac also probably does something as equal stupid I just don't know about it. I guess stupid people will always get infected. That or people who just love to look at porn.


I do really like windows 7, but I also do like OS X.

All in all don't be retarded and no matter what OS you use, you should be fine.
 
Quit using Internet Explorer.

Why? It doesn't seem to have any more security issues than FF, maybe more than Chrome. But there's some addins that I have that don't work in other browsers and IE 8 actually is touch enabled pretty nicely, works great on my tm2. FF, Chrome, even Opera don't work nearly as well with a touchscreen.

At any rate I've not seen an observeable malware attack on any of my personal machines in so long (well over a decade) it's kind of good to be reminded to stay on my toes!
 
Why? It doesn't seem to have any more security issues than FF, maybe more than Chrome. But there's some addins that I have that don't work in other browsers and IE 8 actually is touch enabled pretty nicely, works great on my tm2. FF, Chrome, even Opera don't work nearly as well with a touchscreen.
Try repeating the scenario you described, but using Firefox. I'm curious to see the result.
 
Think I found it. All I did was a Google search on "esac.us", I didn't actually click on any of the results. A few seconds latter MSE popus up:

Malware%20Attack-001.jpg


Info about the attack: http://www.microsoft.com/security/p...e=Trojan:JS/Redirector.CI&threatid=2147631820

Now I can't be certain that this is what you're talking about but it looks like it must have been.

MSE picked it up for me and its been in the MSE defintions for almost two months.

Ya, that is what I was talking about. The netbook with Win 7 Starter and MSE that was up to date didn't detect it for some reason.
 
I tested that with Chrome, FF and IE. The only problem is that it seems to be random, sometimes it just went to the site it was supposed to go to and other times it redirected. I also inspected the source and even that was random when I hit refresh for the coding. But with FF I had the same dialog box for MSE that heatlesssun got with IE. Mind you I don't run noscript or any thing on FF, just a vanilla install just like with IE and Chrome.

@Zepher, I can't believe that site owner hasn't done anything to clean up his own site even after his own PC got infected cause of it. Lazy ass site owners.
 
I tested that with Chrome, FF and IE. The only problem is that it seems to be random, sometimes it just went to the site it was supposed to go to and other times it redirected. I also inspected the source and even that was random when I hit refresh for the coding. But with FF I had the same dialog box for MSE that heatlesssun got with IE. Mind you I don't run noscript or any thing on FF, just a vanilla install just like with IE and Chrome.

@Zepher, I can't believe that site owner hasn't done anything to clean up his own site even after his own PC got infected cause of it. Lazy ass site owners.

I discovered the same thing, I've not been able to replicate getting this error, just using IE 8, however I just did a full scan in MSE and it found nothing. I do full scans with malwarebytes from time to time but so far I've been happy with MSE.

But yeah, somebody needs to clean this up.

@Cerulean, I guess FF can have the same issue.
 
I tested that with Chrome, FF and IE. The only problem is that it seems to be random, sometimes it just went to the site it was supposed to go to and other times it redirected. I also inspected the source and even that was random when I hit refresh for the coding. But with FF I had the same dialog box for MSE that heatlesssun got with IE. Mind you I don't run noscript or any thing on FF, just a vanilla install just like with IE and Chrome.

@Zepher, I can't believe that site owner hasn't done anything to clean up his own site even after his own PC got infected cause of it. Lazy ass site owners.
There are two routes I would try (not together -- for testing purposes):

1) Try OpenDNS and see if this is DNS poisoning or hijack
2) Try FF with Adblock, Flashblock, and NoScript -- see what notifications NoScript pops up (post the log here?)
 
Ah, nevermind.This is what it is: http://www.microsoft.com/security/p...=Trojan:JS/Redirector.CI&ThreatID=-2147335476

All it is is a JavaScript. You aren't getting infected. MSE is just stopping it in its tracks from you being redirected to a different website. Obfuscated JavaScript can be used for both good and malicious purposes, although I wouldn't know why someone would obfuscate it if it's for a good reason...unless they're trying to employ a low-level method for preventing people from finding out a direct link to a file download they offer.
 
Ah, nevermind.This is what it is: http://www.microsoft.com/security/p...=Trojan:JS/Redirector.CI&ThreatID=-2147335476

All it is is a JavaScript. You aren't getting infected. MSE is just stopping it in its tracks from you being redirected to a different website. Obfuscated JavaScript can be used for both good and malicious purposes, although I wouldn't know why someone would obfuscate it if it's for a good reason...unless they're trying to employ a low-level method for preventing people from finding out a direct link to a file download they offer.

Thanks! Yes, that's what MSE points you to when the warning pops up. Apparently the example we're finding is random and does seem to see it. Don't know what happened in Zepher's case.
 
the day it happened on the netbook, a bunch of pop-ups popped up saying the machine was infected and started to do a scan. This wasn't MSE doing the scan, it was one of the pop-ups that opened a window and started to scan.
It put 14 infected items into the machine which malwarebytes removed.

When I picked up the netbook, I did the same thing he did, googled esac.us and a few pop-ups and the scan window popped up.

I made a thread here, about the issue.

From what I read, it isn't the site itself (maybe the host server) that is the problem, or is it?
 
I've seen those from time to time. It's just a browsing trying to trick you into installing something in most cases saying that the machine is infected, its social engineering attack and of course any smart user shuts that shit down immediately.
 
I've seen those from time to time. It's just a browsing trying to trick you into installing something in most cases saying that the machine is infected, its social engineering attack and of course any smart user shuts that shit down immediately.

It installed 14 infections, maybe more, but Malwarebytes saw 14 total, 1st scan found them and deleted them then the 2nd scan showed no infections/infilitrations.
 
By any chance would you happen to have any screenshots of all those popups coming up and a copy of the MalwareBytes results log?
 
the Malwarebytes logs are on the netbook, so I'll have to wait for him to come back from Europe.

I don't have a spare machine at the moment to intentionally infect, wish I still had that 8GB SSD from my Mini9, could have used that to test.
 
I ignored the "Reported Attack Site "warning on my main rig and proceeded forward and Eset grabbed the trojan,
eset.jpg
 
When I got the pop ups wanting to install something it first wanted to d/l it first. When that hapened all you got to do is hit cancel and be done with it. Nothing got installed and MSE blocked it from even being able to be d/l anyways. The pop ups try to look like the little pop up window boxes to trick users into d/l there shit. Unsuspecting users would prolly hit save file and then are now infected. That is prolly happened to that dude, he hit save and it ran.
 
Now honestly I hate thieves, and I hate stealing, but I understand the process involved. TBH, hitting up mac users would probably be easy money. Businesses, alot (err, some) of home users with windows and linux, check or have people to check the security of their pcs. Or at the least have built in security (Linux/vista/7). But mac users believe everything that is told to them.

I'm sure someone could hit up a majority of the mac users and they won't even know for months. And if they find out they may not even believe it.
 
Was the subscription active? Had it been active and running since the OS was installed, with no lapses?

once you have a virus, it's generally too late. With that said, i agree that safe browsing habits are still necessary
A lot of them are up to date...having antivirus software doesn't make one immune to threats. If find it funny that a lot of times antivirus software itself causes the machine to slowdown more than infections do.
 
If find it funny that a lot of times antivirus software itself causes the machine to slowdown more than infections do.

That just isn't the case with most modern AV products. MSE for instance is extremely fast and lightweight and doesn't even slow down netbooks.
 
A lot of them are up to date...having antivirus software doesn't make one immune to threats. If find it funny that a lot of times antivirus software itself causes the machine to slowdown more than infections do.
Heh, it's easier to cause damage than it is to prevent it. :(
 
A lot of them are up to date...having antivirus software doesn't make one immune to threats. If find it funny that a lot of times antivirus software itself causes the machine to slowdown more than infections do.

But even that wasn't my question. If I have an up to date AV package that lapsed for 6 weeks, then for 6 weeks it was vulnerable....and once a system is compromised, it can be very hard to clean the system up using an automated system, since the malware frequently loads itself before the AV software.
 
I'm sure someone could hit up a majority of the mac users and they won't even know for months. And if they find out they may not even believe it.

Luckily this isn't a Mac forum :) Or they would have called for a tarring for slandering Steve Jobs' good name.
 
virus writers go after whatever gives them the largest target audience. As apples market share grows they will face more of these problems.
 
I Posted this elsewhere a few weeks back, it was in relation to this same article and one of jobs disciple's was bragging on the forum about OS X never having had a virus, seems relevant here too.

zombiebeat said:
Virus writing is organised crime, and has been for some time, hence why they target the biggest market also there are and were plenty of other ways to exploit an OS X system...

This was from 2004:
http://news.techworld.com/security/1798/mac-os-x-security-myth-exposed/

Mac OS X doesn't stand out as particularly more secure than the competition, according to Secunia. Of the 36 advisories issued in 2003-2004, 61 percent could be exploited across the Internet and 32 percent enabled attackers to take over the system. The proportion of critical bugs was also comparable with other software: 33 percent of the OS X vulnerabilities were "highly" or "extremely" critical by Secunia's reckoning, compared with 30 percent for XP Professional and 27 percent for SLES 8 and just 12 percent for Advanced Server 3. OS X had the highest proportion of "extremely critical" bugs at 19 percent.
and bringing us relatively up-to-date:
http://threatpost.com/en_us/blogs/a...Threatpost&utm_medium=Tabs&utm_campaign=Today

lack of viruses ≠ a secure system.
 
We accept your apology.we still loved you.
Just mocked you quietly. :)
 
stock install they are both secure, i am sure most people who have FF don't even know what ad block is or no script is.
I agree.

Take a skim at this -- http://www.joyunbound.com/2010/04/securing-your-network-and-browsing-experience/

Last I know, the “other browsers” I mentioned do not support suggestions 2 through 5 because of lacking the same flexibility as Mozilla Firefox. Some people will use Chrome or said-browser because it’s faster, or maybe uses less system resources. Well, in the battle of the browsers, all browsers have their pros and cons. Mozilla Firefox is no better or worse than any other browser as far as speed and resource usage. However, the security of Mozilla Firefox can be greatly improved through the use of plugins.
Second to last sentence there, let me add "security" to the list too. :p
 
stock install they are both secure, i am sure most people who have FF don't even know what ad block is or no script is.

That is, unfortunately, true. I suspect of those that use plugins, most stick to xmarks, cookie managers and ad blocking.

I put it on my mothers PC and got her to use it, but there's no way I could get my dad to use no script.
 
I put it on my mothers PC and got her to use it, but there's no way I could get my dad to use no script.
NoScript is too advanced for most people. :S (Unfortunately, but that's the way it has to be.. ?)
 
Back
Top