Amazon Fights Demand for Customer Records

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Amazon is fighting back against the state of North Carolina’s demand for detailed customer information that includes names, addresses and exactly what you bought. :eek:

The lawsuit says the demand violates the privacy and First Amendment rights of Amazon's customers. North Carolina's Department of Revenue had ordered the online retailer to provide full details on nearly 50 million purchases made by state residents between 2003 and 2010.
 
good for amazon for sticking to their guns. I applaud them for not giving in
 
YES !!! FIGHT FIGHT FIGHT!!!!

Beverly Purdue can go suck eggs.

(I live in North Carolina)
 
go amazon.. if they actually fight them and dont bend over and take it in the ass i may buy from them again..
 
Bravo for Amazon... but how is this any different some big wall street bank or something just saying "Nah we're not going to tell you who earned what money".

bottom line is many (most? all?) states require that you declare purchases made out of state on your taxes, I'm guessing NC is one of those states and simply are going after dead beats who are not paying taxes.
 
bottom line is many (most? all?) states require that you declare purchases made out of state on your taxes, I'm guessing NC is one of those states and simply are going after dead beats who are not paying taxes.
What's unfathomable to me is why state governments think people would actually opt to pay sales tax on out-of-state purchases, law or no law. I've never done it; I'll never do it.
 
Bravo for Amazon... but how is this any different some big wall street bank or something just saying "Nah we're not going to tell you who earned what money".

bottom line is many (most? all?) states require that you declare purchases made out of state on your taxes, I'm guessing NC is one of those states and simply are going after dead beats who are not paying taxes.

As per North Carolina's 'use tax', if I go on a vacation in California (or anywhere out of state), and find a necklace for my wife at a local craft fair in California. By North Carolina's 'use tax' I am required to report it.

My response? civil disobedience
 
What's unfathomable to me is why state governments think people would actually opt to pay sales tax on out-of-state purchases, law or no law. I've never done it; I'll never do it.

I guess some people are too honest and report their internet purchases to the IRS when filing their tax returns. Opting to pay taxes when purchasing items would exempt that purchase from needing to be reported when filing, wouldn't it?

H&R Block always ask me if I make any purchases over the internet. I always say no because my purchases are 90% of the time made with my company credit card, not my own. The other 10%, bleh. :-P Who keeps track?
 
I would guess that NC is hurting for money, but they had the funds to actually send these people all the way to Washington just to demand information, so maybe they're just jerks.
 
I guess some people are too honest and report their internet purchases to the IRS when filing their tax returns. Opting to pay taxes when purchasing items would exempt that purchase from needing to be reported when filing, wouldn't it?
I misspoke slightly. They would be opting to not pay use taxes that are generally equivalent to the state's sales tax, i.e. reporting out-of-state purchases for the purpose of the state government levying the use tax.

I honestly don't even know how it all works, to be frank. I do my own taxes, and I genuinely have no idea how I would even go about reporting out-of-state purchases if I, for some insane, nonsensical reason, wanted to.
 
Wow, f*** North Carolina. Looks like I'll be buying more from Amazon as well.
 
Hmmm...sales taxes. Don't the businesses pay sales taxes? Sure, they add them to the receipt but they are the ones having to pay it. Why would it be called a sales tax if it in fact were a purchase tax?

I think the corporations that profit from the sales are the ones responsible for paying.
 
Amazon has threatened states that it would stop doing business with that state if they were forced to collect taxes or report sales.
 
Damn, IRS/State must be desperate for new funds! I can imagine the backlash on that shit.
 
Amazon has threatened states that it would stop doing business with that state if they were forced to collect taxes or report sales.

Really? I know that Amazon dropped any North Carolina based affiliate because of North Carolina's more recent actions.
 
If Amazon loses this, then over time every state (maybe a few exceptions) will be taxing all out of state state purchases. The precedent in court would be set unless the Supreme Court overrides it. North Carolina won't stop with Amazon, and about every other state will be going after Amazon too.
 
I read this on CNET this morning. If NC wins against Amazon, this would have a very chilling effect on not just future online purchases, but perhaps past ones, too! Right now, I'm a little concerned, but that could turn into complete worry if this plays out unfavorably. :eek:

Fight the good fight, Amazon!
 
I don't really know the law all that well, but I thought the Constitution only allows Congress or the Federal government to regulate or tax interstate commerce. Is there something I am missing?
 
funny, werent americans just making fun of the whole Canada/Facebook privacy laws a few months ago protecting people from this


up here no one can give out any sort of private info, at all. without fist getting permission from that person.
 
One more reason I'm glad I got out of NC. They come out short on their state budget and they find a way to steal the money from everyone else. :mad:
 
Bravo for Amazon... but how is this any different some big wall street bank or something just saying "Nah we're not going to tell you who earned what money".

bottom line is many (most? all?) states require that you declare purchases made out of state on your taxes, I'm guessing NC is one of those states and simply are going after dead beats who are not paying taxes.

Then the state needs to go after the people responsible for paying the taxes. Not the people running a business.
It's called a fishing trip. NC can't prove shit without getting Amazon to spill the beans. The state knows absolutely nothing about how much they are missing out from Amazon.
 
I don't really know the law all that well, but I thought the Constitution only allows Congress or the Federal government to regulate or tax interstate commerce. Is there something I am missing?

Prett much. States can only enact and enforce laws within their own territory. Anything that crosses state lines is Federal. There is no Federal sales tax therefor purchasing online from an out of state e-tailer means no taxes.

N.C. can push, Amazon will push back, Supreme Court will tell N.C. to get bent.
 
Prett much. States can only enact and enforce laws within their own territory. Anything that crosses state lines is Federal. There is no Federal sales tax therefor purchasing online from an out of state e-tailer means no taxes.

N.C. can push, Amazon will push back, Supreme Court will tell N.C. to get bent.

Indeed, that's what should happen. But it will be a mess till then. And really, any federal court can tell NC to go screw itself.
 
Then the state needs to go after the people responsible for paying the taxes. Not the people running a business.
It's called a fishing trip. NC can't prove shit without getting Amazon to spill the beans. The state knows absolutely nothing about how much they are missing out from Amazon.

Actually, I think Amazon has given data on purchases in NC down to the zip code. So NC knows what they are missing, they just don't know who. Amazon isn't about to give names out.

I think if NC somehow wins, we will be paying back taxes (with interest?) and maybe fines all the way to 2003. And also if NC wins, other states will do the same.
 
Go Amazon! They've been my favorite etailer the past few months. I usually check them first now before newegg.
 
I dont understand why USA just dont use federal sales tax which would have to be added to final price and companies would after that send it to IRS. This is the way EU have VAT and it work pretty well for government (yes, I also hate our taxes, VAT etc. but current system in USA is mess and lots of people might pay huge fines and interest on old taxes if Amazon losses).

 
Actually, I think Amazon has given data on purchases in NC down to the zip code. So NC knows what they are missing, they just don't know who. Amazon isn't about to give names out.

I think if NC somehow wins, we will be paying back taxes (with interest?) and maybe fines all the way to 2003. And also if NC wins, other states will do the same.

correct me if I'm wrong, but I believe they can only go back 3 years.


either way, I don't see NC winning this. This is the same thing NY tries time and time again and it always seems to get canned for one reason or another
 
correct me if I'm wrong, but I believe they can only go back 3 years.


either way, I don't see NC winning this. This is the same thing NY tries time and time again and it always seems to get canned for one reason or another

Oh, not sure. But the article said they wanted data back to 2003.
 
What law is on the books that would allow this? None, otherwise NC would have handled this differently.

The growth/power increase of the government at every level in the last decade has been absolutely terrifying. I wish more people would wake up and see what is happening!
 
Back
Top