Could Apple Get in Bed with AMD?

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Could Apple be considering a switch to AMD? We hear rumors like this at least a couple times a year, could this time be the charm?

Thanks to some insider knowledge, Apple got in on Intel just as the breakthrough Core line of chips came out (the CPUs that knocked AMD out of the running for the performance crown instantly), and now speculation is running wild that Apple knows something we don't about what AMD is up to.
 
Since they mentioned Apple booting AMD out because they came up short in performance, it could very well just be that Apple wants AMD for their graphics card because they're pretty much ahead in that field.

I'm not sure Yahoo knows what they're talking about because of this little snippet:

That would not only mean renegotiating supply contracts with a notoriously erratic company but redesigning the company's entire computer lineup, too — and probably a ground-up rewrite of the MacOS, to boot.

I doubt of OSX would require a "ground-up" rewrite. Perhaps optimizations, but not a rewrite.
 
An interesting article written by someone that doesn't know what the hell he is talking about.
 
its actually not that hard to make osx work on an AMD system.. theres already cracks/fixes to allow osx to run on an AMD system.. the work arounds have been out since the original OSX hit the market.. all apple has to do is combine them into the next update of OSX and boom it works..
 
Its going to the the AMD iCPU I'll cost 10 times as much and do the same thing as their other processors. But it'll be an apple exclusive ;)
 
Its going to the the AMD iCPU I'll cost 10 times as much and do the same thing as their other processors. But it'll be an apple exclusive ;)

You beat me to the punch. I am not sure why it has taken Apple this long to come up with the idea, but they can get AMD processors cheaper and sell computers for the same amount. More money for Apple.
 
This was reported on Gizmodo last week.

It may be nothing more than a bargaining tool between Apple and MS.
 
I don't think much would come out of this. The most likely as said above would be ATI's gpus, and then maybe a low cost server would be next.
 
What would keep them from using amd chipsets, cpu's , and video cards. It's not like it's radically different. Maybe drivers and a little tweaking of OSX.
 
LOL AMD runs way cooler than core chips. You know how apple likes to go fanless. Only makes sense. I'm just amazed that I didn't see it coming. It only makes perfect business sense for AMD and Apple.
 
I was speaking from personal experience. Plus I think its common knowledge as well that i7 runs hot. Google it.

No doubt that a hyperthreaded quad core (or hexacore) will run hot in a small enclosure. "Personal experience" isn't quantifiable; do you have anything else to back up what you said or are you going to tell me to refer to Google again?
 
No doubt that a hyperthreaded quad core (or hexacore) will run hot in a small enclosure. "Personal experience" isn't quantifiable; do you have anything else to back up what you said or are you going to tell me to refer to Google again?

Google.com.
 
I was speaking from personal experience. Plus I think its common knowledge as well that i7 runs hot. Google it.
"Run hot" is relative. The thermal sensors on i7 processors are not the same as those on AMD processors and are thus temperatures not directly comparable.
 
This rumor is whipped out by Apple every time they are looking at hardware for their next gen latest greatest whatever...its a negotiating tactic.
 
Since they mentioned Apple booting AMD out because they came up short in performance, it could very well just be that Apple wants AMD for their graphics card because they're pretty much ahead in that field.

I'm not sure Yahoo knows what they're talking about because of this little snippet:



I doubt of OSX would require a "ground-up" rewrite. Perhaps optimizations, but not a rewrite.

In the notebook field they aren't ahead of nvidia, they are really behind. I can't see them making a better solution than optimus in the next six months. It really is amazing for battery life.
 
LOL AMD runs way cooler than core chips. You know how apple likes to go fanless. Only makes sense. I'm just amazed that I didn't see it coming. It only makes perfect business sense for AMD and Apple.

From my experience, on a performance per watt basis, Intel is leap and bounds ahead of AMD, especially in laptops, which is probably most of what Macs are nowadays.
 
i think we will see a 13in mbp with amd chips

Why? GPU-wise I could see it, but CPU-wise, Intel would kick AMD's ass all over the place in terms of power savings and performance.
Their are several problems with the recently released 13" macbook pros that could make and AMD powered notebook possible.
1. Extremely small motherboard. Apple desperately wants half-decent graphics chips capable of Open-CL while still cramming all the other features they got on there now. Only Nvidia and AMD can do that right now. Its also why Apple compromised and only put Core 2's with an Nvidia IGP on them for now.
2. Nvidia doesn't have the rights to produce a chipset for Intel's latest chips. Using an integrated GPU from Nvidia or AMD would limit the chips on board and allow the motherboard to be smaller. Intel will eventually phase out the Core 2's that the 13' Apple notebooks are using now. We also know that AMD chipsets won't work with Intel chips.

Combine these 2 issues, and you start to see why AMD might be viable to their low-end notebooks. As it stands, the only solution is to rip out the optical drive (likely) or put a smaller battery (less likely) into it allowing them to use the larger motherboard from the 15" and larger MB to allow a discrete Nvidia or AMD gpu with additional cooling to be bolted on in addition to a Core i5 and chipset (3 chips). With AMD fusion, they could do the same thing with one AMD cpu and a small cheap southbridge while still keeping the motherboard tiny, keep all the same features including large battery and optical drive, and not have to upgrade cooling.

This same argument may be able to be applied to the mac-mini also, but the argument there would lean more heavily toward keeping thermals in check while keeping the same form factor.
 
This same argument may be able to be applied to the mac-mini also, but the argument there would lean more heavily toward keeping thermals in check while keeping the same form factor.

If I can piggyback on your post, Apple also has their $999 MacBook price point to keep in mind--so getting a big bulk deal with AMD that meets their power and performance needs could help them meet that. That thing needs a real update.
 
I'm out in left field, but who's ahead in the (Fusion) cpu+gpu combo. Could that be the reason.
 
The only reason, in my opinion that Apple would go with AMD is cost reduction. Period.
 
Okay, go troll elsewhere. :)

LOL you attack my post then call me a troll. Get outta here with that crap. Either stay on topic or GTFO.

And yes, I'm thinking AMD/ATI solution is on track for a nice solution that will fit apple's needs.
 
Also I'd like to state the obvious that we have no idea on costs other than the chip itself. Theres all the behind the scenes stuff that isn't public information. So I think we should talk about what we know best and leave the rest to the suit's forums.

Hardware wise, why is this a good or bad choice.
 
From a content creation standpoint, I think that is why most people would own a mac to begin with.

For video encoding (final cut pro users) would probably miss intel and nvidia.
Pro Tools people prolly wouldn't notice. etc etc
 
I was speaking from personal experience. Plus I think its common knowledge as well that i7 runs hot. Google it.

Mine runs just fine at 42 when it's doing something intensive 36 just sitting about, my old AMD ran at 40 something just idling, the newer ones weren't much different (64 series and X2's) that I had built for family, friends and customers.
 
LOL you attack my post then call me a troll. Get outta here with that crap. Either stay on topic or GTFO.
Either provide something more than "in my experience" and referring people to Google when you can't do anything else. That is trolling.
 
I'm not sure Yahoo knows what they're talking about because of this little snippet:

I doubt of OSX would require a "ground-up" rewrite. Perhaps optimizations, but not a rewrite.

Ditto, hackintosh works on AMDs, I'm sure Apple could come up with a similar solution to the problem that doesn't involve a "ground-up rewrite" in any sense of the former word.
 
Since they mentioned Apple booting AMD out because they came up short in performance, it could very well just be that Apple wants AMD for their graphics card because they're pretty much ahead in that field.

I'm not sure Yahoo knows what they're talking about because of this little snippet:



I doubt of OSX would require a "ground-up" rewrite. Perhaps optimizations, but not a rewrite.


I'd say partial rewrite. Just make it so OSX doesn't Intel's framework for EFI.
 
Back
Top