iPhone to Get Long-Awaited Multitasking Ability

CommanderFrank

Cat Can't Scratch It
Joined
May 9, 2000
Messages
75,399
Tired of running only one program at a time with your iPhone? The solution may be as close as this summer for some of the iPhones, but unfortunately not all. We ran a story on this about a month ago, outlining some of the features. Updated information has been added by Apple recently.


The iPhone already permits some multitasking, but that's largely limited to Apple's own programs. Apple had not given users ways to seamlessly switch among all the software "apps" available from outside software companies, the way phones from rivals Palm and Google already do.
 
Based on what I've seen how other people use computers/phones, I think this semi-multi-task is actually a pretty good idea. I think full multi-task would actually cause more problems for the general non-techy crowd.

Have you ever noticed people who leave like 50 windows open on a regular computer, even though they're only using like 3 of them? Then on multi-task phones like some Nokia phones, there are like 10 apps with the spinning circle icon next to them, meaning they're all running in the background.

I haven't really used macs, but the problem is probably compounded on there because as far as I know, closing an application doesn't really close it, it just minimizes it to the dock at the bottom.

I think majority of users don't know what RAM is, or what a processor is, so they'll abuse it and drain the battery.
 
This is not true multitasking, just a really good faking of multitasking. Apple is really good at bending the truth to whatever they want users to believe. With iAd and Apple not wanting developers using non-Apple compilers Apple might lose a lot of ground to better platforms.
 
This is not true multitasking, just a really good faking of multitasking. Apple is really good at bending the truth to whatever they want users to believe. With iAd and Apple not wanting developers using non-Apple compilers Apple might lose a lot of ground to better platforms.

How is it fake mutlitasking? How is iAd going to be any more annoying than current ads in free apps? What better platform do you speak of?
 
How is it fake mutlitasking? How is iAd going to be any more annoying than current ads in free apps? What better platform do you speak of?

Because you can only have real multitasking with a few certain apps or processes. Meaning they run in the background. The other stuff is "frozen" in it's last state or something. I only read up on it briefly though.

Droid > iphone
 
Because you can only have real multitasking with a few certain apps or processes. Meaning they run in the background. The other stuff is "frozen" in it's last state or something. I only read up on it briefly though.

Droid > iphone

You can listen to music from pandora, load websites, upload pictures on facebook, etc. What do you need running that won't be running? Droid is not better, The marketplace is crap, OS is slow even with fast hardware, inefficient layout, etc.
 
How is it fake mutlitasking? How is iAd going to be any more annoying than current ads in free apps? What better platform do you speak of?

As stated above, most apps are just frozen and do not run simultaneously. All adds are bad but a motion ad like the two iAd demos shown is worse then static ads IMO. Better platform is one that is more robust like Android and maybe WinMo 7. Being locked into a single hardware platform is never a good idea really, and the more open the OS the more hardware improvements will come about. Apple does not push hardware limits they stagnate them IMO, but they do make a nice UI for their hardware. Personally phone makers need to get the basics down solid like making a phone that is a phone first then other stuff second. Sorry for my little rant.
 
Aside from games, the Android Marketplace is matching the iPhone store in most areas and obviously surpassing in some (since, you know, you can't really customize an iPhone.) It grew by over 9000! apps in March and a week into April it already had 2k new apps. With the release of the N1 and Incredible on VZW in a couple of months, I think it's going to become pretty impressive. Mainstream games like

I'd actually say the Android layout is far more efficient, not just because you can do whatever you want with it but because of the capability of glancable information. I don't need to open very much to find out most of my information.

Whether it's better or not is really an apples and oranges thing; they're clearly marketed towards different crowds. I'll tell you that if you think the Droid is slow, especially on 2.1, you're wrong. It's a tad slower than the 3GS and N1, but it's close. And of course when you overclock it to 1.2ghz, there's nothing slow to speak of, including the battery usage. :| 1ghz seems to be about the point where battery doesn't really take a hit.

As for your point about multi-tasking, the one glaring thing is instant messengers. I use Meebo IM and Skype (Nimbuzz, actually) a lot, for the chat features. On iPhone OS4, they still won't stay open. Overall, however, Apple handled it pretty well. Not webOS well, but at least it'll work for most things.
 
Its the single best Multi-tasking implementation on a phone. It lets apps do the things that matter in the background while having a surprisingly low hit on battery life.
 
As stated above, most apps are just frozen and do not run simultaneously. All adds are bad but a motion ad like the two iAd demos shown is worse then static ads IMO. Better platform is one that is more robust like Android and maybe WinMo 7. Being locked into a single hardware platform is never a good idea really, and the more open the OS the more hardware improvements will come about. Apple does not push hardware limits they stagnate them IMO, but they do make a nice UI for their hardware. Personally phone makers need to get the basics down solid like making a phone that is a phone first then other stuff second. Sorry for my little rant.

I don't see why all apps need to be "running" if they're not doing anything. The iAd demo was after you select the ad, otherwise it's still small. Being locked into a platform not good? Is that why MS is now finally setting requirements for 7 so people don't have bad experiences? Palm does the same. Android phones can run from craptastic to pretty good. When the 3GS came out it was the most powerful phone hardware wise, I wouldn't call that stagnate. The iPhone works perfectly fine as a phone as well.
 
Wonder how much this round of features the damn thing should have shipped with will cost the apple faithful?
 
Wonder how much this round of features the damn thing should have shipped with will cost the apple faithful?

Nothing. Like the other OS updates was.

Aside from games, the Android Marketplace is matching the iPhone store in most areas and obviously surpassing in some (since, you know, you can't really customize an iPhone.) It grew by over 9000! apps in March and a week into April it already had 2k new apps. With the release of the N1 and Incredible on VZW in a couple of months, I think it's going to become pretty impressive. Mainstream games like

Since it was brought up, why are skins and wallpapers counted as apps? It really isn't something that the average person does and in my opinion is the equivalent of the fart apps that people complain are what most iphone apps are.
 
I think you're right. No one really knows where we'd be at if they dropped the crap from both stores. The nice thing is that if you do really want to fart on your Android phone (or do most other stuff, really), there's a free way to do it.
 
I don't see why all apps need to be "running" if they're not doing anything. The iAd demo was after you select the ad, otherwise it's still small. Being locked into a platform not good? Is that why MS is now finally setting requirements for 7 so people don't have bad experiences? Palm does the same. Android phones can run from craptastic to pretty good. When the 3GS came out it was the most powerful phone hardware wise, I wouldn't call that stagnate. The iPhone works perfectly fine as a phone as well.

It is not that all apps need to be "running", but principle that Apple needs to tell whole truths and not half truths that their phone multitasks. Requirements for 7, Palm, Android, and others is different in the same way Windows, Linux, Unix, etc. have requirements while Apple is closed. With competition comes great hardware, Apple does nothing new but they market well. My biggest grip is how consumers have become so ignorant to learning what is best for them and now just follow trends. 3GS might have had powerful hardware but it most likely was not the "most powerful", outside the US phones like in Asia and Europe phones have a lot better features. The US is often slow in phone technology.
 
If you actually looked at the conference or actually read something about it other than going with a youtube bitchfest over it then you would know that they spent a decent length in explaining why they did what they did and what they targeted api wise. It's nowhere near as portrayed as they said they had multitasking and then all the developers found out how it worked when they got home. I could care less on if it's a full program sitting in memory or a daemon as long as the device is still speedy, responsive and not forced to be tethered to power while it's doing it.
 
It is not that all apps need to be "running", but principle that Apple needs to tell whole truths and not half truths that their phone multitasks. Requirements for 7, Palm, Android, and others is different in the same way Windows, Linux, Unix, etc. have requirements while Apple is closed. With competition comes great hardware, Apple does nothing new but they market well. My biggest grip is how consumers have become so ignorant to learning what is best for them and now just follow trends. 3GS might have had powerful hardware but it most likely was not the "most powerful", outside the US phones like in Asia and Europe phones have a lot better features. The US is often slow in phone technology.

I think it's in the way you guys do your purchases. I'm no sure how it is in the rest of Asia, but in where i live, TV advertisements on gadgets are nonexistent. You won't see an ad from any of the manufacturers. We're one of the most prolific mobile consumers in the world, so i guess there's not much point in advertising ;)

Specialty stores that cater to a single brand are rare. There are actually iPhones in pretty much every store. The thing is, there's usually other brands on display next to them as well. Since there's no advertisement, and shipping costs are prohibitive (100% customs tax!!!), we've got no choice but to go to the store in person and compare them ourselves. Do a side by side iPhone vs Nokia vs LG, and the average person will always walk away with either of the last two. Despite apples claims about huge sales in asia, i have yet to meet a person that actually has an iphone. There's almost always someone tapping away on a touchphone every time i board a bus, none of them from apple.

In contrast, the US where you guys seem to do a lot of point-and-click shopping. You're more susceptible to hype. See enough banners and you'll likely go to the online store, do a keyword search and click the most familiar item on the list. You never get to actually see other alternatives.
 
If you actually looked at the conference or actually read something about it other than going with a youtube bitchfest over it then you would know that they spent a decent length in explaining why they did what they did and what they targeted api wise. It's nowhere near as portrayed as they said they had multitasking and then all the developers found out how it worked when they got home. I could care less on if it's a full program sitting in memory or a daemon as long as the device is still speedy, responsive and not forced to be tethered to power while it's doing it.

I think the point is that while multitasking, do the platforms with true multitasking suffer from significant speed loss, responsiveness or battery life? All they showed off was simple stuff like playing Pandora while checking your email. If you've got all 7 APIs running, what effect will it have? And how much better/worse is it than the way the other OSes would handle those same 7 services?

Apple's claim is that they've done it this way so that they don't suffer slowdowns and battery issues. The immediate inference from that, for Apple crazies, is that the other platforms DO suffer slowdowns and battery issues while multitasking, therefore Apple's solution is better. I submit, at least on my Droid, that that's not the case.
 
Fuck you Apple. I've been using multitasking on my iPhone 3G since I jailbroke it a year ago. (ridiculously easy, void the warranty my ass) . The phone works fine using it and it is completely capable of multitasking but you won't do it until now? Fuck you Apple.

I'm actually not that mad or surprised but it does irritate me when technology is held back...you can say its all about money but I would argue that the iPhone would have done even better if it had all these features available from the beginning.
 
Because you can only have real multitasking with a few certain apps or processes. Meaning they run in the background. The other stuff is "frozen" in it's last state or something.
You should watch the presentation. You can background quite a bit, actually -- practically whatever a developer wants to do in the background he can, apart from obvious things like rendering.

Fuck you Apple. Fuck you Apple. I'm actually not that mad...
Yeah, I sensed that...
 
hahaha I've been multitasking on my Blackberry since the day I got it. Feels good man.
 
People mad at Apple for implenting well thought out implementations of services for all users.

They really can't win with some of you,

Maybe it should have been there, but it wasnt, and you bought anyway. Now it is, and your mad.
 
People mad at Apple for implenting well thought out implementations of services for all users.

They really can't win with some of you,

Maybe it should have been there, but it wasnt, and you bought anyway. Now it is, and your mad.

Not going to applaud Apple for being YEARS late with this kind of stuff.
 
People mad at Apple for implenting well thought out implementations of services for all users.

They really can't win with some of you,

Maybe it should have been there, but it wasnt, and you bought anyway. Now it is, and your mad.

Does it make it any less crippled?
 
After watching that vid it does not look very impressive. "It almost works??"
 
Just got back from the mall

iPhone 3GS = $1,067.00
 
It is not that all apps need to be "running", but principle that Apple needs to tell whole truths and not half truths that their phone multitasks. Requirements for 7, Palm, Android, and others is different in the same way Windows, Linux, Unix, etc. have requirements while Apple is closed. With competition comes great hardware, Apple does nothing new but they market well. My biggest grip is how consumers have become so ignorant to learning what is best for them and now just follow trends. 3GS might have had powerful hardware but it most likely was not the "most powerful", outside the US phones like in Asia and Europe phones have a lot better features. The US is often slow in phone technology.

Phones in ASIA have terrible UIs and suck. I don't give a shit if I can use my phone to open my house door and use it as a credit card if the phone sucks.
 
The immediate inference from that, for Apple crazies, is that the other platforms DO suffer slowdowns and battery issues while multitasking, therefore Apple's solution is better. I submit, at least on my Droid, that that's not the case.

I don't have any issues on my Nokia N900 either. Same CPU speed and almost same battery as the iPhone 3GS. Lasts the same length of time as an iPhone for the same type of user. And according to Apple, it's "not done right" so...what's that say for their system?

Those of you defending Apple, it comes down to this: If you background an application that renders in iPhone OS 4.0, is it going to have changed state as if you had left the application open in the foreground?

Yes - the device multi-tasks.
No - the device does not multi-task.

It really is that black and white. If you ask "Why would you want to do that" you are missing the point or carrying on just like the stereotypical "Apple hater" that I'm sure you dislike hearing about.

That said, Apple's implementation of quasi-multi-tasking is going to work well for them and their device in the restricted environment. If a company that is making real smart phones doesn't already do things like that, it will give them something additional to think about for future designs.
 
But have you actually seen it multitask other than some youtube video using apps that don't have it enabled? So what if the apps in the end does have a changed state? What you are going to say then? The same old It should have had it before jazz? It's been said. We get it, and get over it.
 
Back
Top