double spacing on PCI-e slots?

dandapice

Weaksauce
Joined
Nov 14, 2005
Messages
122
Is there a reason why most motherboards don't do double spacing on their PCI-e slots? Is it that the extra space doesn't provide any beneficial cooling? Is it a bandwidth / length of traces issue? I look at the Asus p6t deluxe rev. 2 and the Asrock X58 Extreme and those have double spacing. What gives?:confused:
 
The extra spacing DEFINITELY helps with cooling! I have two 5770 HAWKs in Crossfire, and on my MSI X58 Pro-E there was only one slot between the two cards. They were so darn close together they were literally touching at the far end. The top card ran about 15C warmer than the bottom card under load.

Because of this I ordered a new mobo (eVGA X58 SLI) so I can space the cards out more. I'll report the results tonight or tomorrow, hopefully. I can almost guarantee you there will be a very significant difference.

As to why manufacturers don't design boards with more space between the 16x/8x slots I have no idea. Seems quite logical to me.

TL/DR: If you are considering Crossfire/SLI, I strongly recommend using a mobo with more than one slot between the 16x/8x slots, especially if you are going to OC like me.
 
Hey Cruiza,
I have the eVGA X58 SLI. I did 2x 280 gtx in sli and in slot 1+2 they were so close together my top 280 overheated to the point of black+green stripes on the screen / no post!. Putting the 2nd card in the 3rd slot gives you 16+8X which to my eyes I couldn't tell a difference in frame rates. I didn't use fraps or any other monitoring software so maybe there is....
 
Most motherboards don't have the space for both tri-SLI or tri-Crossfire slot spacing and having two spaces between the first two slots, so they have to go with one or the other. I suspect that most go with three slots simply for marketing reasons.
 
Now I'm worried about my own upcoming setup, heh

Using a Gigabyte X58A board, the final slot PCIE 16x is too close to the PSU for dual slot card. Intended to use my old 9800GTX card for physx.

If I understood the post here correctly, I guess could fry my GTX 295 card if the 9800 is put next to it :eek:


I think i'm beginning to regret my choice of board:(. I've always thought they had enough space for air intake
 
That's why you go with water cooling, no need to worry about water cooling issues.

Not to mention water cooling has come down in prices quite a bit. You can find a bunch of good deals right here in the trading forums (got a couple of them myself) :D
 
Hey Cruiza,
I have the eVGA X58 SLI. I did 2x 280 gtx in sli and in slot 1+2 they were so close together my top 280 overheated to the point of black+green stripes on the screen / no post!. Putting the 2nd card in the 3rd slot gives you 16+8X which to my eyes I couldn't tell a difference in frame rates. I didn't use fraps or any other monitoring software so maybe there is....

Yeah, that's what I'll be doing, too. I have the board up and running now, but I also got a new case with a bottom-mounted PSU. Now the 8-pin EPS cable or whatever it's called is too short to route properly so it blocks all my PCI and PCI-E slots except the top slot for my primary video card. I ordered an extension, and once I get it installed I'll be able to get my second 5770 installed and see how the temps look.
 
This is a big reason I didn't go X58 a few months ago, but I hope we see some more boards with better spacing. Gigabyte's X58 layouts are all the same. :(
 
Last edited:
Tsumi,
That might have to be the case here. How do any of you feel about the Silverstone Fortress 2 or the whole 90 degree Mb mounting in general? I like the concept, but looks like there have been some complaints about the 5.25" bay area sata cables coming in contact with a second VGA card. Any thoughts?
 
I love the 90 degree rotation concept, and reviews seem to show that it does indeed improve temps throughout the system. I really wish/hope more cases will have this feature in the near future. The only reason I did not buy the Raven or Fortress is the external aesthetics. Neither case really looks that great to me. The price of the Fortress didn't help either, haha.
 
I made a mistake and bought the RIIE, great board, but the layout for SLI was retarded like most of the other X58 boards. I sold it and "upgraded" to a P6T Deluxe v2 which served me well to this day.

Can't they make the x16 slots as far from each other as possible?
 
Asrock is the clear winner with this imo. All of their X58 boards have great layouts, especially the Deluxe.
 
I made a mistake and bought the RIIE, great board, but the layout for SLI was retarded like most of the other X58 boards. I sold it and "upgraded" to a P6T Deluxe v2 which served me well to this day.

Can't they make the x16 slots as far from each other as possible?

Yeah I never could understand why ASUS went with the slot layout on that thing.

Asrock is the clear winner with this imo. All of their X58 boards have great layouts, especially the Deluxe.

So far the best one I've worked with personally is the EVGA X58 3X SLI Classified.
 
Tsumi,
That might have to be the case here. How do any of you feel about the Silverstone Fortress 2 or the whole 90 degree Mb mounting in general? I like the concept, but looks like there have been some complaints about the 5.25" bay area sata cables coming in contact with a second VGA card. Any thoughts?

I currently have a pair of gtx 275 in sli on my evga x58 sli mb in a ft02. Was initially going to run the second gfx card on the third pci-e slot, but I didn't like that it would cover the debug led. So I decided to just use the first two slots instead. I was worried that the first card would overheat in that config, but in the ft02 it was not an issue.

The 2 cards pretty much stay within 5 degrees C of each other at idle and at load the differential raises to about 8 degrees, all at 55% fan speed.
 
Asrock is the clear winner with this imo. All of their X58 boards have great layouts, especially the Deluxe.

That is why I bought the Deluxe as well. The only downside to it is the sad bclk limitation. If they redid the BIOS so it was like the Extreme in that it had the needed voltage options to get higher it would be an excellent board.
 
Well, there's only so many options motherboard makers have when doing a layout for 3x SLI or Crossfire. They only have 7 expansion slots to work with, and pretty much all modern graphics cards take up two slots, leaving only 1 slot to put either in between two of the cards.

The Silverstone design is definitely interesting, and it seems like it would work. However, those cases tend to be on the expensive side, and I don't want to spend more than $100 on a case. Also, some people complain about cable routing issues. They also don't have as many features (the Raven cases only come with 3x180 mm fans and 1x120). A lot of cases have much more cooling capability than that for a lower price.
 
Double spacing is very nice cooling wise, but it does require more space inside the case.
 
Back
Top