Google Criticizes Australia Over Internet Filter Plan

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
According to this article, Google is criticizing Australia over its plan to filter the internet. The search giant says the plan is well beyond what other countries are doing and that the scope of content is “too wide.”

Currently locked in a major dispute over censorship in China, the US web giant said its primary concern with Australia's proposal was "that the scope of content to be filtered is too wide". Google said Australia went "well beyond" filters being considered in countries such as Britain, Canada, Denmark, Finland and Sweden, which focus only on blocking material related to child sex abuse.
 
'Blocking Child Porn' is not a problem. That is not an issue. My issue is two fold.

1) there are torrents that have kiddy porn in them, does that mean blocking all torrents?
There are IPs with multiple web sites, How many are commerce sites and porn sites on one IP? So unintended consequences are severe.

2) This is a step toward filtering other items, news not sanctioned by the state, information not state approved, books the state does not want you to see, music that the state does not approve, next thing you know we live in the book 1984.
 
"When the Nazis came for the communists,
I remained silent;
I was not a communist.

When they locked up the social democrats,
I remained silent;
I was not a social democrat.

When they came for the trade unionists,
I did not speak out;
I was not a trade unionist.

When they came for the Jews,
I remained silent;
I wasn't a Jew.

When they came for me,
there was no one left to speak out."

- Martin Niemöller (1892-1984)
 
Dear countries, if you're so fucking arrogant to think you own the internet here are some steps to get what you want out of it.

1: Make your own gateway that every resident needs to go through that does all the filtering through sites like Google which for some reason you don't like.

2: Piss off and grumble about how some company on the internet allows people to search for things.
 
The child pornography issue is too widespread in terms of availability to effectively filter it. Most Usenet providers have been good about prohibiting access to the big child porn groups, but other providers haven't been (Usenet is probably still the #1 source of child porn).

The only real solution is to catch the guys who provide it or consume it and toss 'em in prison for a few life sentences, making sure to inform the GP about their behavior so they can be effectively "dealt with". Besides, no matter how much filtering you put in place, people are going to either find ways around it (you can run your own private proxy through the Google Apps engine) or simply find a new source for it. Makes more sense to have a damn good enforcement branch dedicated to cracking down on it than to waste money on blocks and filters.
 
The thread was effectively over when when the obligatory 1984 reference got busted out and when the "When they came for the ....." card got played. All before the 5th post, you guys are on the ball today. :rolleyes:

Anyway...

I can understand some folks wanting to limit/filter what is available to their kids and all that but filtering what an entire country has access to is just absurd. Legislating morality has never, ever worked. Internet filtering has never truly been effective. Combining the two is simply short sighted and foolish.

Let adults decide what they want to view (child porn excluded) and as to what children have access to, that should be up to the parents mainly. There are enough software products out there and other things that can limit what one has access to on the internet so there is no real reason for this to even be considered....except the fact that too many people are perfectly cool giving gov't more control if it means they can slough off some more personal responsibility.
 
As Jello Biafra put it best in the lyrics below.

Now it is 1984
Knock-knock at your front door
It's the suede/denim secret police
They have come for your uncool niece
 
We could just de-peer Australia. This is, after all, the country that wants to ban small-breasted actresses in porn because they look too much like kids. There's no help for them.
 
Don't block CP. Do track it, arrest any non-kid downloading it, and mandate a death penalty if they are found guilty.

Solves the problem much better than any blocking.
 
We could just de-peer Australia. This is, after all, the country that wants to ban small-breasted actresses in porn because they look too much like kids. There's no help for them.

we arent all crazy :( I dont think I've heard of anyone supporting this, its just that they paid our free to air news channels not to talk about it so most people dont even know
 
We could just de-peer Australia. This is, after all, the country that wants to ban small-breasted actresses in porn because they look too much like kids. There's no help for them.

Mandatory boob jobs for aussie porn starlets? What's next? Banning porn actors with small dicks?
 
Don't block CP. Do track it, arrest any non-kid downloading it, and mandate a death penalty if they are found guilty.

Solves the problem much better than any blocking.
I'm not a fan of death penalty, but I agree that they should do more than just blocking it.

Blocking such material isn't going to make the problem go away, certainly won't stop the people responsible for making those stuff
 
Back
Top