WD releases first SSD - SiliconEdge Blue 64/128/256GB

InvisiBill

2[H]4U
Joined
Jan 2, 2003
Messages
2,608
http://www.pcper.com/article.php?aid=878
There's no way to know for sure, but based on the PCB similarities, there's a chance this might actually be the JMF612 with a custom firmware. We say this because this Western Digital unit performed significantly better than the JMF618 based drive - different enough for me to hesitate to call it the same controller.
PROS:
  • Competitive sequential read and write performance
  • Reliability carries forward from a long-time player in the embedded market

CONS:
  • relatively low IOPS performance
  • Price (see below)

MSRP
  • 64GB: $279 ($4.36/GB)
  • 128GB: $529 ($4.13/GB)
  • 256GB: $999 ($3.90/GB)

Anand reviewed it too.
http://www.anandtech.com/storage/showdoc.aspx?i=3757
Final Words

I've repeated it enough times that you should get the point by now - Western Digital's SiliconEdge Blue is just a bit behind the performance of an Indilinx based SSD. The drive performed relatively well in our tests. TRIM worked as expected under Windows 7. Compared to a standard hard drive it's great, but so are just about all other SSDs. Given that the Blue isn't the fastest SSD in the world, what this really boils down to is price.

At $529 for 128GB, the SiliconEdge Blue just isn't worth it. To be honest, the Blue needs to be priced similarly to Kingston's SSDNow V Series to even make sense. It has to be cheaper than both Intel and Indilinx drives, which means cutting the MSRP in half. Not to mention that I received and tested a 256GB version of the drive priced at $999. It remains to be seen how the 128GB drive performs as that one will most likely be the sweet spot of price/capacity/performance.

Looks like it's nothing great, especially for the price, but it should mean more competition and options, which is always better for the consumer. Hopefully WD can improve their SSD game to become a leader like they are in HDDs (and to encourage other manufacturers to improve their SSDs too). Maybe we'll see a "Black" line of SSDs with better performance, though they'd need to work on the price.
 
Looks like it's nothing great, especially for the price, but it should mean more competition and options, which is always better for the consumer. Hopefully WD can improve their SSD game to become a leader like they are in HDDs (and to encourage other manufacturers to improve their SSDs too). Maybe we'll see a "Black" line of SSDs with better performance, though they'd need to work on the price.

This is what i was hoping too. We have so many in the market that hopefully they can battle it out driving down prices and speeding up innovation. WD has the budget for it. I understand the benefits of an ssd but still can't justify the price right now.
 
So to sum it up:

It looks like an overpriced Kingston V+ series, based on the latest JMicron JMF612 controller with a slightly tweaked firmware for "compatibility" backed up by a large HDD vendor/name.

(uses Samsung memory instead of Toshiba memory)
 
Last edited:
No current HDD manufacturer will play a significant role in SSDs, as its a completely different market. Key in SSDs is the controller; the HDD companies have been neglecting their firmware-based controllers for years, and still some ancient over 15-year old code lives in current modern drives. No HDD manufacturer opted to write a new HDD controller from scratch.

So if HDD companies can't do this with their own products; how on earth will they ever play a role in developing a fast SSD controller? Probably none, as WD uses a JMicron controller to power their SSD. Apparently they didn't like the chip to say JMicron, so they hide its true identity just like the OCZ Apex and other products did.

Don't buy shitty products, go for good products like Intel, Sandforce and the new Micron controller. Those three offer some degree of quality at this moment.
 
The random IOps of this drive is very low and that's what you need for your system drive. So an Intel drive would be much better than this 'pimped' JMicron-SSD.
 
Here, compare this:

WD SSD
wd_hdtune4.jpg


Intel SSD:
intel_34nm_hdtune4.jpg


And the Random read IOps is much lower than the Intel too, 2200 versus 16.000+.

So this is just a crappy SSD. Good SSDs use intelligent controllers: Sandforce, Micron, Intel.
 
These SSDs are already cheaper than their MSRP:



Currently:
64GB version @$250
128GB version @$450
256GB version @$800




These are all from the Egg. Granted that they're a little bit cheaper, but based on the reviews these are still not worth the money. Why blow $450 on the 128GB version when the 160GB intel g2 can be had for $430?
 
No current HDD manufacturer will play a significant role in SSDs, as its a completely different market. Key in SSDs is the controller; the HDD companies have been neglecting their firmware-based controllers for years, and still some ancient over 15-year old code lives in current modern drives. No HDD manufacturer opted to write a new HDD controller from scratch.

So if HDD companies can't do this with their own products; how on earth will they ever play a role in developing a fast SSD controller? Probably none, as WD uses a JMicron controller to power their SSD. Apparently they didn't like the chip to say JMicron, so they hide its true identity just like the OCZ Apex and other products did.

Don't buy shitty products, go for good products like Intel, Sandforce and the new Micron controller. Those three offer some degree of quality at this moment.

Hell, forget the controllers for a minute (even tho it's really the most integral part to a SSD)... Let's say HDD companies do sink a pile of money into R&D and develop their own controllers, they're still at the mercy of NAND flash pricing (which is on Intel/Micron's & Samsung's hands)... So even if they had a reputable controller to implement they'd be no better off than Intel or others (who obviously saw this and moved in with time). Isn't Micron's controller made by Marvell tho?

Intel and Samsung are the big players here, even if Samsung's controllers are behind the pack performance-wise... With some competition from smaller players like Sandforce/Indillix.

Anand speculated that the WD SiliconEdge Blue was probably gonna sell for under MSRP but their current pricing is still ridiculous, as noted above...I wonder if WD is benefiting from any key OEM contracts as Samsung was/is or what. You would think Intel, of all people, could muscle in fairly easily past that kinda scenario... Yet they don't seem to be doing so. Then again they do have a hand on the NAND pricing itself so maybe they're content w/that for now.
 
Back
Top