A (gaming) monitor with good blacks

Leopardi

Limp Gawd
Joined
Feb 15, 2010
Messages
217
I've had 2 samsung 2233RZ now, but the black levels are ridiculous. 70% of the viewable area is ruined by lightbleed. I can't watch movies or play games like Doom 3 without getting annoyed, and I'm looking forward to the game Metro 2033 and that's something this monitor can't play.

I was looking at the Dell 2209WA but as I looked some youtube videos, there seemed to be a huge backlight bleed from all corners, but reviews say there is no backlight bleed. Is Dell 2209WA the best choice if I dont want backlight bleeding? I don't have a fortune to spend also, so it must be sub 300€.
 
I had a 2209WA and the backlight bleed was very minimal. I regret selling it to be honest.
 
HI Leopardi.

Some people are confusing two terms: backlight bleed and white glow. I do not remember reading any reports of backlight bleed from 2209WA users.

What they are complaining of, I believe, is diagonal white glow. White glow is not a monitor fault. I have the 2209WA and I would say, in order to mitigate potential white glow you should have your head centered in the middle of the screen field, at a distance of about 50cm.

At this point you will be subject to the monitor's native black level and contrast ratio. The 2209WA has performance here that is typical of its generation. How you perceive the black level will be dependent on your room's lighting. In a typical room partially lit by daylight, black should be a definite black. Conversely, in a completely dark room, black will be perceived as having attained a counterintuitive luminance.
 
Actually if you get one of the new led ones like the Samsung XL2370 and put it in dynamic contrast mode the blacks are about as deep as you can get. If you don't believe me go try one yourself at best buy.
 
I've had 2 samsung 2233RZ now, but the black levels are ridiculous. 70% of the viewable area is ruined by lightbleed. I can't watch movies or play games like Doom 3 without getting annoyed, and I'm looking forward to the game Metro 2033 and that's something this monitor can't play.

I was looking at the Dell 2209WA but as I looked some youtube videos, there seemed to be a huge backlight bleed from all corners, but reviews say there is no backlight bleed. Is Dell 2209WA the best choice if I dont want backlight bleeding? I don't have a fortune to spend also, so it must be sub 300€.

Damn dude I've got 1 2233RZ and the black level is just fine and almost no bleed at all. Sounds like you got some bad panels there. I would go with the Dell 2209WA , those LED panels suck for color reproduction and LED can have some not so great side effects on pure white output. Plus that dell panel is plenty fast enough for gaming.
 
Damn dude I've got 1 2233RZ and the black level is just fine and almost no bleed at all. Sounds like you got some bad panels there. I would go with the Dell 2209WA , those LED panels suck for color reproduction and LED can have some not so great side effects on pure white output. Plus that dell panel is plenty fast enough for gaming.

Whew that is a relief, I am looking at buying one of these in a couple of days to replace my CRT. The most recent LCD I purchased about a year ago has horrible light bleed and has been relegated to just being a spare screen next to my CRT. I really hope this one is much better.
 
I am in the same boat you are with monitors I am still looking for a 24" monitor myself that has lack of similar issues.
 
There is no such thing as "good blacks" in the world of LCD, just varying degrees of awful.
Buy a 1080p plasma.

Nothing can beat Pioneer Kuro's black but LCD LED (with local dimming) can also provide very impressive contrast ratio.
However, the OP is looking for a computer monitor in the 22"-24" size range...
Nevertheless, the Dell 2709W (S-PVA) is known for the quality of its black. It features the best black have seen from a LCD monitor.
 
Damn dude I've got 1 2233RZ and the black level is just fine and almost no bleed at all. Sounds like you got some bad panels there. I would go with the Dell 2209WA , those LED panels suck for color reproduction and LED can have some not so great side effects on pure white output. Plus that dell panel is plenty fast enough for gaming.

This is pretty much how my 2233RZ looks in a dark room at 0% brightness, just the bottom leak is somewhat smaller. At 100% a black screen is almost totally blue.

http://img8.imageshack.us/img8/8445/img0246new.jpg
 
Last edited:
This is pretty much how my 2233RZ looks in a dark room at 0% brightness, just the bottom leak is somewhat smaller. At 100% a black screen is almost totally blue.

http://img8.imageshack.us/img8/8445/img0246new.jpg

Good lord man , mine look NOTHING like that at all , some slight bleed from the bottom portion of the panel but damn .. that is aweful. I don't suppose you could return them for staight up replacements? I'm willing to bet you would get a much better set with another try.

If I can tomorrow I'll attempt to take some shots with my camera to give you an idea of whats going on with mine.
 
2209WA vs. a TN model. This picture is from it168 I think.

mx2cuf.jpg
 
2209WA vs. a TN model. This picture is from it168 I think.

mx2cuf.jpg

2209wa is a major pain in the ass to calibrate but it will do good blacks at around 110cdm2. You really need a calibration unit better than spyder2 to use the thing because the factory settings for gamma ramp are terrible.
 
Yeah my 2209wa does decent blacks at 0 brightness, but it's not calibrated or anything. Minimal white glow at that setting too. What I like about black levels most about the display is that they still retain their detail - there is no black crush anywhere to be seen, which really impresses me the most. It has excellent shadow detail no matter what. High static contrast and inky blacks don't mean anything to me if you have to lose all of that shadow detail to get those kinds of levels in the first place.

I would imagine the XL2370 would have much deeper blacks being a PVA panel, but I've also heard that it's notorious for crushing blacks, so whether or not that's true, or if that's acceptable to you, is something you have to decide for yourself.
 
I do not think that bleeding is caused by the panel type (TN, IPS, PVA).
In fact, cheaper manufacturing process should be blamed.
Obviously, cheaper monitors generally use TN panels.
 
i have a Samsung 2333SW it does have blacklight bleed but its VERY minimal. if my monitor looked like those it would go back immediatly. its ridiculas that companies would ship monitors that looked like that
 
Last edited:
I love how black is displayed on my Dell U2410. After switching from a Samsung 940B, it's an unreal difference. I know it's not sub 300 eur, but it might not be possible to find something in that range.
 
Nothing can beat Pioneer Kuro's black but LCD LED (with local dimming) can also provide very impressive contrast ratio.
However, the OP is looking for a computer monitor in the 22"-24" size range...
Nevertheless, the Dell 2709W (S-PVA) is known for the quality of its black. It features the best black have seen from a LCD monitor.

Not quite true, the EIZO EV2333W measured 7000:1 static in the PRAD test, with factory sRGB gradation.
 
Would a LED TN monitor help with back-light bleed?
No.

Backlight bleed doesn't seem to be a property of the backlight. Looking at the low end Acer and BenQs' they leak just as much as their CCFL-counterparts. Albeit they do seem to sometimes get a blue tint to their leakage that old screens didn't have.
 
Wow, that sucks to hear since it's such a fantastic LCD for gaming. My 2233RZ barely has any bleed, only a small amount on the bottom but it's really not noticeable. Sorry to hear you got 2 bad panels. :(
 
No.

Backlight bleed doesn't seem to be a property of the backlight. Looking at the low end Acer and BenQs' they leak just as much as their CCFL-counterparts. Albeit they do seem to sometimes get a blue tint to their leakage that old screens didn't have.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HH_QbCv7wu8&fmt=18

I was looking at this youtube video on Dell's G2410 LED monitor in a pitch black room. I never seen any LCD handle Backlight bleed as good as this.
 
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HH_QbCv7wu8&fmt=18

I was looking at this youtube video on Dell's G2410 LED monitor in a pitch black room. I never seen any LCD handle Backlight bleed as good as this.

That doesn't make it a property of the backlight though. Dell's are usually well built and they have a good panel in that display that actually gets close to it's stated 1000:1 static contrast. That's why it looks good in the dark. Not because it's LED and not CCFL (or bonfire-lit for that matter)

Properly made displays won't leak, badly made ones will.
 
Last edited:
Since JSP is unaware and even if he was probably wouldn't even care, backlight bleed and poor/cheap/compromised panel production has a bright future.
 
This is pretty much how my 2233RZ looks in a dark room at 0% brightness, just the bottom leak is somewhat smaller. At 100% a black screen is almost totally blue.

http://img8.imageshack.us/img8/8445/img0246new.jpg

heh, I have the same display (and the same backlight bleed problem). If you raise the gamma in the nvidia CP/ati CCC it will fix most of the issues (especially dark scenes in games and movies)... the blacks will appear a dark gray though. Not a big deal for gaming, but I wouldn't use it for photoshop and/or art workstation.

Give it a try... dark scenes are painful with that display
 
I already sold my 2233RZ and swapped to my old LG L1952TQ so I can't try that... funny how a cheap 2006 monitor is much better overall. Better colors, doesn't fatigue eyes immediately and 0% backlight bleed.
 
Back
Top