RIAA Rejects Reduced Penalty

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Somehow you just knew that the RIAA wasn’t going to let that reduced penalty stand, didn’t you? Oh well, hopefully this time around the jury settles on an amount smaller than $54,000. That would be pretty damn funny.

A trade group representing the major music labels said Wednesday it will reject a reduced penalty for a central Minnesota woman found guilty of sharing 24 songs over the Internet, and will instead begin preparing for another trial to determine damages.
 
I mentioned before, if they accepted the penalty, it would set precedence and the RIAA couldn't afford that when it goes after business who infringe.

I wonder if the judge knew this and also saw something that could be beneficial to the individual who now has to go back to court for a retrial.
 
I mentioned before, if they accepted the penalty, it would set precedence and the RIAA couldn't afford that when it goes after business who infringe.

I wonder if the judge knew this and also saw something that could be beneficial to the individual who now has to go back to court for a retrial.

At least he's got his head on right. What the hell type of jury would come up with such a fine in the first place?
 
Looks like the MAFIAA is getting very very desprate now.


Hopefully soon we will see, RIAA goes belly up, lack of innovation and adaption killed the beast :D
 
They reject must means they are going to appeal....
I don't see how this could be negative for the individual, the longer this plays the worse the RIAA is looking. Spawn of satan status can't be much more of slide for these organizations.
 
(almost) unbelievable.
They arent content with a just severe punishment for the small overall impact on the filesharing world that she has made.
Being a test case, they are preying on people who had no idea this would be held as such a high crime, even more severe than some pretty despicable crimes.
For Gods sake, its copyright infringement and she wasnt profiting from it.
Instead, they want to completely ruin her life.
The RIAA need to be barred from this practice.
 
Obama has 5 RIAA lawyers he's appointed to posts, that's a major fail over there. These evil people slither to and fro on the earth . . . . .
 
How does one reject a judge's ruling? What was the point of ruling in the first place?

Don't forget RIAA has Congress in their pocket. We'll see if Congress lets that judge get away with his ruling.

In last night's State of the Union address, Obama got a standing ovation when he declared that he will not let lobbyists and special interest groups dictate policy. I nearly choked on my drink.
 
out of curiousity, and I don't think I've read it on any of the articles regarding this case, who gets the money in the end? RIAA? Do they pass it on to the artists for whom the songs were made?

or do RIAA keep it in their pocket? and the artist gets nothing? :confused:

I do hope the fine gets lowered even more! the MAFIAA is the spawn of Satan. They should just go back home and burn.
 
out of curiousity, and I don't think I've read it on any of the articles regarding this case, who gets the money in the end? RIAA? Do they pass it on to the artists for whom the songs were made?

or do RIAA keep it in their pocket? and the artist gets nothing? :confused:

I do hope the fine gets lowered even more! the MAFIAA is the spawn of Satan. They should just go back home and burn.

The artists get a tiny percentage of it. I can't remember how much but I vaguely recall seeing something like 2% of the settlement.
 
We can only hope now that the sentance gets more reduced because of their actions, and judges and congress realize these bastards are greedy bastards and they need to be put in place....

let it hit the supreme court and have the RIAA ABOLISHED!!! COME ON!!!!
 
At least he's got his head on right. What the hell type of jury would come up with such a fine in the first place?

As I said before their are only so many people left from the likes of the Dueling Banjo group from the movie Deliverance. Actually they probably work for the RIAA, I keep thinking I hear the RIAA lawyers saying "Squeal, I want to hear you Squeal.":while their doing it to you.:D
 
We can only hope now that the sentance gets more reduced because of their actions, and judges and congress realize these bastards are greedy bastards and they need to be put in place....

let it hit the supreme court and have the RIAA ABOLISHED!!! COME ON!!!!

Not goona happen unfortunately. RIAA has this administration in its pay pockets. As someone mentioned above, Obama has no less than 5 RIAA lawyers in his administration. 5! He obviously approves of the methods the RIAA is using here to appoint so many of them to posts!
 
i understand the go after people.. but does anyone really pay? it seems like a total sham.
 
of course they are going to appeal, the result of this rulling is not going to instill the fear into other people to prevent stealing of music!
 
As mentioned in the article I posted in the previous thread on this subject:
Joe Sibley, an attorney for Thomas-Rasset, said his client will not settle. It is all the same, as she just doesn't have the money to pay any of the penalty amounts, and it would be financially ruinous.

http://www.theinquirer.net/inquirer/news/1589141/riaa-rejects-reduced-fine-piracy

The RIAA offered to settle for 'just' $25,000. At this point it's clear, though, that they're just pond scum seeking to make an example of the defendant, regardless of what it'll mean for her future, or that of her children. Pure mafia-style.

The members of the jury who previously okayed the 1+ million dollar punishment clearly wouldn't think it to be 'justice' if they were the ones at the receiving end. It's easy to be one in the crowd at a public lynching, yelling and making fun of the victim. Try being the one who gets the noose some time. It really changes one's perspective.
 
RIAA must of spent more than the settlement on the suit its self by now.
 
As mentioned in the article I posted in the previous thread on this subject:


http://www.theinquirer.net/inquirer/news/1589141/riaa-rejects-reduced-fine-piracy

The RIAA offered to settle for 'just' $25,000. At this point it's clear, though, that they're just pond scum seeking to make an example of the defendant, regardless of what it'll mean for her future, or that of her children. Pure mafia-style.

The members of the jury who previously okayed the 1+ million dollar punishment clearly wouldn't think it to be 'justice' if they were the ones at the receiving end. It's easy to be one in the crowd at a public lynching, yelling and making fun of the victim. Try being the one who gets the noose some time. It really changes one's perspective.

I was thinking the same thing. Assuming she doesn't have a lot of cash lying around (which she apparently doesn't), the only way she would be able to pay is with a loan. If she's lucky she owns a house and would be able to get a 2nd mortgage. Either way, she's stuck with a significant monthly payment for, what, 20 years? Again, assuming she has that kind of room in her budget.

And this is for 25 songs! Some people have thousands, but should they pay upwards of $5 million if they aren't sharing it?

This ruling was only fair in a completely relative sense to the pure and utter insanity of what the RIAA was asking for. From a proper perspective, not skewed by the RIAA, the 52,000 is still far far far too much. Here's hoping for a new ruling with a better perspective. the value of the songs times, say, 5 for damages. $125 sounds about right.
 
after reading this, i went to google and looked up RIAA's top selling albums. then i went to torrentz.com and pirated the shit out of them. come and get me RIAA, i dare you. fines dont scare me, RIAA should be scared of civilians.
 
RIAA must of spent more than the settlement on the suit its self by now.

easily. ive been reading about this case forever it seems. it MUST be over 50k in court fees alone, and maybe thats why they had to decline the settlement. however, i think it has a lot more to do with every member of RIAA having medically challenged penises and they need to compensate somehow. oh look my song just finished downloading, thanks riaa!
 
Yes, but the RIAA has "principals":rolleyes:

so does everyone else, and clearly we are winning. i actually hope this and other cases get so rediculous that a judge like 'judge judy' gets forced to deal with this shit and finally just says "GO THE FUCK AWAY RIAA, YOU HAVE NO PURPOSE IN LIFE".
 
The problem the RIAA has with piracy is that the responsibility is diluted amongst everyone that participates. Each individual downloading songs hasn't by himself caused damages that amount to more than a few hundred dollars. But by participating in that system they enable the system to continue to work.

The RIAA can't prosecute each person for a few hundred. The work required to prove each person has downloaded files would be ridiculous, compared to the possible reward. Their only alternative is to sue one or two people for ridiculous sums, and hope it scares everyone else into thinking they might be next.

Of course, no justice system should allow for a person to be held accountable for the crimes everyone else commits, which is what they're trying to do.
 
so does everyone else, and clearly we are winning. i actually hope this and other cases get so rediculous that a judge like 'judge judy' gets forced to deal with this shit and finally just says "GO THE FUCK AWAY RIAA, YOU HAVE NO PURPOSE IN LIFE".

I can so imagine her look of exasperation, rolling her eyes, as the RIAA lawyers explain about the $25 in songs that were stolen, and the damages they want.

Judge Judy for Supreme Court Justice!!! :D
 
I was thinking the same thing. Assuming she doesn't have a lot of cash lying around (which she apparently doesn't), the only way she would be able to pay is with a loan. If she's lucky she owns a house and would be able to get a 2nd mortgage. Either way, she's stuck with a significant monthly payment for, what, 20 years? Again, assuming she has that kind of room in her budget.

And this is for 25 songs! Some people have thousands, but should they pay upwards of $5 million if they aren't sharing it?

This ruling was only fair in a completely relative sense to the pure and utter insanity of what the RIAA was asking for. From a proper perspective, not skewed by the RIAA, the 52,000 is still far far far too much. Here's hoping for a new ruling with a better perspective. the value of the songs times, say, 5 for damages. $125 sounds about right.

It's clear that she should have been pressing CDs and selling them on street corners for $5 a pop. That at least would have made her the money to pay for this punishment :)
 
The problem the RIAA has with piracy is that the responsibility is diluted amongst everyone that participates. Each individual downloading songs hasn't by himself caused damages that amount to more than a few hundred dollars. But by participating in that system they enable the system to continue to work.

The RIAA can't prosecute each person for a few hundred. The work required to prove each person has downloaded files would be ridiculous, compared to the possible reward. Their only alternative is to sue one or two people for ridiculous sums, and hope it scares everyone else into thinking they might be next.

Of course, no justice system should allow for a person to be held accountable for the crimes everyone else commits, which is what they're trying to do.

None of the lawsuits have been about downloads. They're all about uploads.

One of the exclusive rights granted under copyright law is the right to distribute works that you own. Two different juries have decided that Thomas-Rasset distributed 24 songs that she did not have the right to distribute. The juries came up with the awards, not the RIAA.

And let's get the "songs are only worth 99 cents" thing out of the way right now. From the ruling:

The actual judge's ruling said:
Thomas‐Rasset argues that the ratio of the statutory damages award to actual damages in this case, when measured in songs, is 1:62,015. She bases this calculations on a cost of $1.29 per song online. She further argues that, based on a cost of $15 per album, the ratio is still 1:5,333. (Alasdair McMullan, the executive vice president of legal affairs for EMI Music North America, testified that Richard Marx’s “Now and Forever” probably retailed for $1.29 on iTunes Case 0:06-cv-01497-MJD-RLE Document 366 Filed 01/22/10 Page 10 of 38 11and the album probably cost less than $20.00 in a retail store.) Thomas‐Rasset concludes that these ratios are monstrous and shocking.

Plaintiffs accurately point out that, because they chose to seek statutory damages rather than actual damages, they were not required to present proof of the actual damages caused by Thomas‐Rasset’s infringement. See, e.g., Cass County Music Co., 88 F.3d at 643 (“tatutory damages are by definition a substitute for unproven or unprovable actual damages.”); Lowry’s Reports, Inc. v. Legg Mason, Inc., 302 F. Supp. 2d 455, 459 (D. Md. 2004) (“Because statutory damages are an alternative to actual damages, there has never been a requirement that statutory damages must be strictly related to actual injury.”) (citations omitted). However, because statutory damages have, in part, a compensatory purpose, “assessed statutory damages should bear some relation to the actual damages suffered.” Bly v. Banbury Books, Inc., 638 F. Supp. 983, 987 (E.D. Pa. 1986). c. Factual


That last sentence is why he reduced the fine -- which he decided should be 3 times the minimum fine of $750 in order to both compensate the RIAA and serve as a deterrent to future copyright infringement.
 
I was selected to be a juror on one civil case, lemme just tell you that our jury system is so messed up. I had to serve for a week and I couldn't believe all the BS that happens in a courtroom, that and how gullible people are to give such high amounts of money for stupid things like this. I saw it all happening before my eyes with "pain and suffering" and damaging being awarded that were not actual damages, future damages, etc...... There is nothing to help you seek an amount other than stupid lawyers telling you what the amounts should be. It goes a little something like this:

"Well the damages are 3 million dollars......; blah blah blah. "

Then jury then goes back and thinks that the amount rewarded should be near where the lawyers placed it, people just can't think for themselves these days. I was listening to people talk in the jury room from about 500,000 to 1,000,000+ dollars like it was water.
 
Jack Thompson down.
RIAA to go.

What if a riot/mob of people who qualify to be sued by the RIAA just suddenly showed up at one of the court trials in RIAA's face in support of their victim?
 
EDIT: It would be one of those "what are you going to do now? Sue the country?"
 
I was listening to people talk in the jury room from about 500,000 to 1,000,000+ dollars like it was water.

Its the only time in their life that a minimum wage earner can play the rich mans game. I think that they go along with the lawyers because they feel intimidated, if they went on their on tangent and put the penalty from their perspective, they would feel like country bumpkins. Secondly aren't the jury instructed what range the penalty should fall between?
 
Its the only time in their life that a minimum wage earner can play the rich mans game. I think that they go along with the lawyers because they feel intimidated, if they went on their on tangent and put the penalty from their perspective, they would feel like country bumpkins. Secondly aren't the jury instructed what range the penalty should fall between?

Nope, you are not instructed with a range. I even mentined it to the judge on what a crapshoot it was to come up with costs on damages that are not "actual" damages, she answered by saying "The correct damages are at whatever the jury finds in the jury room". So in other words, every jury will come up with a different number and it could be anywhere from $10 to $10,000,000+ million dollars apart. :rolleyes:
 
I wonder if one of these RIAA scumbags was to get a speeding ticket and they were fined $20,000,000 if they'd fight it?

They'd probably say 80,000 times the original fine is beyond excessive, and yet, that's precisely what is happening to this lady. She isn't a saint - she stole - but she isn't insider trading either... $1,920,000 for downloading 24 songs.. what next, a life sentence for stealing a candybar?
 
Back
Top