Dead hard drives after plane flight

Andrew_Carr

2[H]4U
2FA
Joined
Feb 26, 2005
Messages
2,792
Is it common for hard drives to fail after being jostled about in luggage on a plane flight? I packed mine in padding and then put them in the middle of a giant pile of clothes. One was still in it's plastic case from Amazon as well. So far, my brand new spinpoint and an older 320gb drive have failed(clicking noises, aren't recognized).

I didn't think this would happen, especially with them packaged safely. The TSA inspected my luggage, and my other bag was torn up pretty badly(HTPC was banged up, drive bay on the inside was bent somehow), but the bag with the hard drives seemed to come through unscathed. Even my speakers in it survived fine.

Anyway, I was planning on RMAing the spinpoint, since it's brand new and should still be under warranty. Do you guys think that's reasonable, or was it just dumb to pack them in checked baggage?
 
umm, they beat your stuff fairly rigorously while loading it on the plane.

Last time I flew, my brand new suitcase ended up looking like they had it on a rope trailing the plane.
 
If you're going to put the hard drive thru checked baggage, I would recommend a pelican case :) What sort of padding did you pack the hard drive with?
 
I put them in socks, then surrounded them in clothes(lots of clothes). Oddly enough, the hard drive in my computer case(that was beaten all to hell and wasn't padded as much) survived fine. They also mistakenly shipped my bags to China, so I'm not really sure if maybe they messed things up when they went through my bags.
 
But he didnt put them in ESD bags, he put them in socks.
 
frau-im-koffer.jpg
 
But he didnt put them in ESD bags, he put them in socks.

I'm hopefully assuming that he put them into ESD bags and then into socks. Perhaps I'm just hoping that a user on this forum wouldn't just take any ESD sensitive computer equipment without at the very least putting it in one. Am I being too optimistic? :p

What about the drive in the plastic case?

Functionally, the plastic case is an ESD protection but it doesn't have any actual impact protection to speak of. Unless you're absolutely sure that you properly packaged the drive so that any impact wouldn't have resulted in it being damaged (ie. drive maker packaging requirements or so), I would guess that that impacts are what caused your drives to fail. Also, if you really didn't put the other drive in an ESD bag before the socks that's probably a very good contributor to the failure of that drive.
 
Hmm that sux, I had 2 drives in a antistatic bag, packed like you, just in clothes in a ruck sack on the way to the desert. Worked fine for 15 months, shipped home the same way, and still runs to this day. Werent super precious drives though you know.
Guess you just got some bad luck man.
 
Back
Top