PS3 Motion Controller Delayed

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
According to a statement made by Sony’s Kazuo Hirai, the PlayStation 3 Motion Controller is being pushed back to the fall. The company pushed the launch of the controller back until they had a “comprehensive portfolio of attractive and innovative games.”

"We have decided to release the Motion Controller in fall 2010 when we will be able to offer an exciting and varied line-up of software titles that will deliver the new entertainment experience to PS3 users," Kazuo Hirai, president of Sony Computer Entertainment, said in a statement.
 
I assume this plan developed as soon as they heard Natal wasn't releasing until Christmas. No need to rush it to market now.
 
Natal has little to do with a motion controller. This has more to do with a Wii controller like device. Your kinda confusing the two. I thought the Siaxis controller already had gryo's in it for motion? How is this different?
 
Natal has little to do with a motion controller. This has more to do with a Wii controller like device. Your kinda confusing the two. I thought the Siaxis controller already had gryo's in it for motion? How is this different?

This is a wand with a sensor and a camera that maps your motion... sure it's like a Wii controller but it's PS3's version of motion control, just like Natal is Microsoft's. sure they're not identical but they are still targeting the same segment.

Sixaxis is just an accelerometer built into the controller, not very versatile, and is barely used for anything.
 
Honestly they should scrap the entire idea. If anything the wii proved that motion control is a worthless novelty and that hasn't changed in the entire time the wii has been out. Why Sony seems to think they can change that is beyond me. I was excited about the wii motion controller when I first heard of it, however it quickly became nothing more then a nuisance. I firmly believe that not only is this accessory not going to help move more ps3's, but it will just become another playstation eye that just gets laughed at and sits on shelves.
 
Honestly they should scrap the entire idea. If anything the wii proved that motion control is a worthless novelty and that hasn't changed in the entire time the wii has been out. Why Sony seems to think they can change that is beyond me. I was excited about the wii motion controller when I first heard of it, however it quickly became nothing more then a nuisance. I firmly believe that not only is this accessory not going to help move more ps3's, but it will just become another playstation eye that just gets laughed at and sits on shelves.

I really disagree about the Wii being a worthless novelty. I know a lot of people thoroughly enjoying their Wii, especially the Wii Fit. But even if one gets tired of using the Wiimote, you can also use a regular Nintendo controller in some games.

It would be shortsighted to scrap the project altogether when there might be a hit game or three that would benefit the motion control. Think of it like this: the Wii Fit platform is wildly popular. Can you imagine how much more a PS3 could do in this genre considering it's sheer power over the Wii? If they do it right, it just might take off.
 
I really disagree about the Wii being a worthless novelty. I know a lot of people thoroughly enjoying their Wii, especially the Wii Fit. But even if one gets tired of using the Wiimote, you can also use a regular Nintendo controller in some games.

It would be shortsighted to scrap the project altogether when there might be a hit game or three that would benefit the motion control. Think of it like this: the Wii Fit platform is wildly popular. Can you imagine how much more a PS3 could do in this genre considering it's sheer power over the Wii? If they do it right, it just might take off.

I thought the sword and shield demo looked pretty cool. The problem with these types of controls to me, is that when using motion control for a character's limbs etc. you have no really intuitive was to deal with walking/running and looking around.
 
I thought the sword and shield demo looked pretty cool. The problem with these types of controls to me, is that when using motion control for a character's limbs etc. you have no really intuitive was to deal with walking/running and looking around.

I know what you mean. I have the Clone Wars Lightsaber Battle for my Wii and I did not like it at all. The Wiimote movement had nothing to do with how your character moved! I mean, sure they don't expect you to do backflip or anything like that, but still, basic sword movement needs to mimic real life movements at the very least. Not "Twist your wrist to perform a thrust. Wiggle your nose to do a parry" :-P
 
I really disagree about the Wii being a worthless novelty. I know a lot of people thoroughly enjoying their Wii, especially the Wii Fit. But even if one gets tired of using the Wiimote, you can also use a regular Nintendo controller in some games.

It would be shortsighted to scrap the project altogether when there might be a hit game or three that would benefit the motion control. Think of it like this: the Wii Fit platform is wildly popular. Can you imagine how much more a PS3 could do in this genre considering it's sheer power over the Wii? If they do it right, it just might take off.

I said the motion control was a worthless novelty, not the wii itself.

1) The wii fit has nothing to do with motion control, it is no different then any other accessory for any other system.

2) The wiimote ends up a worthless accessory because once people learn that they can use a gamecube controller or the wii mote as a normal controller they quit using the waggle feature. Also in almost all games (please note I said almost all, not all) non motion control is more accurate and gives a clear advantage over the motion control.

Honestly developers for the wii have had years to turn it into something other then a novelty and failed. I think it is absurd to think that developers are going to do any different for an optional accessory for the PS3. Of the three, project Natal is the only one that really stands apart a having a real chance to do anything different and even that I doubt will be more then a gimmick.
 
Honestly they should scrap the entire idea. If anything the wii proved that motion control is a worthless novelty and that hasn't changed in the entire time the wii has been out. Why Sony seems to think they can change that is beyond me. I was excited about the wii motion controller when I first heard of it, however it quickly became nothing more then a nuisance. I firmly believe that not only is this accessory not going to help move more ps3's, but it will just become another playstation eye that just gets laughed at and sits on shelves.

You mean the worthless novelty that is worth a *fortune* and was the reason for almost a year of the console that used it being constantly sold out? The same worthless novelty that caused the Wii to capture 48% of the console market share, both globally and in the US?

You have a very odd definition of "worthless". I do not think it means what you think it does. Is it worthless for hardcore gamers? Yup. Is it worthless for casual gamers and people who enjoy things like Mario Party with their friends? Nope, quite the opposite.
 
According to a statement made by Sony’s Kazuo Hirai, the PlayStation 3 Motion Controller is being pushed back to the fall. The company pushed the launch of the controller back until they had a “comprehensive portfolio of attractive and innovative games.”

Ugh, I can see this being as popular as the I toy for PS2, one game and bugger all interest in it.
 
You mean the worthless novelty that is worth a *fortune* and was the reason for almost a year of the console that used it being constantly sold out? The same worthless novelty that caused the Wii to capture 48% of the console market share, both globally and in the US?

You have a very odd definition of "worthless". I do not think it means what you think it does. Is it worthless for hardcore gamers? Yup. Is it worthless for casual gamers and people who enjoy things like Mario Party with their friends? Nope, quite the opposite.

Motion control didn't sell the wii, price point did. Again for those who seem to have trouble with basic English, I said nothing about the console. I refer only to the motion control mechanic that remains largely worthless to this day and most people quickly abandon using as soon as they figure out they can. :rolleyes:
 
I said the motion control was a worthless novelty, not the wii itself.

1) The wii fit has nothing to do with motion control, it is no different then any other accessory for any other system.

2) The wiimote ends up a worthless accessory because once people learn that they can use a gamecube controller or the wii mote as a normal controller they quit using the waggle feature. Also in almost all games (please note I said almost all, not all) non motion control is more accurate and gives a clear advantage over the motion control.

Honestly developers for the wii have had years to turn it into something other then a novelty and failed. I think it is absurd to think that developers are going to do any different for an optional accessory for the PS3. Of the three, project Natal is the only one that really stands apart a having a real chance to do anything different and even that I doubt will be more then a gimmick.

Totally agree with you on this. Natal will be the least responsive of all input systems since it lacks *any* buttons, so yeah I think its already headed down the path of being a gimmick and MS knows this, but will try to encourage developers to make a ton of Wii like shovelware for the system. Think of pretty much any game, and at some point you need to press once button a lot. This could be shooting, jumping, or holding down the gas pedal in a driving game. 99% of the time, using your thumb to press a button is going to be more responsive than moving an entire body part and having that translated on screen before the action takes place.
 
I don't get this. The PS3 controller already has motion control capabilities, it's just exhibited on very very few games. From the games that do, it does everything the Wii controller does, and just as well.
 
I don't get this. The PS3 controller already has motion control capabilities, it's just exhibited on very very few games. From the games that do, it does everything the Wii controller does, and just as well.

Sony wants close to 1:1 tracking in real time with a higher degree of accuracy and responsiveness than that Wii has. The combination of motion sensors in the PS3 motion controllers and a camera sensing the glowing orb positions help get to this level of accuracy.
 
Motion control didn't sell the wii, price point did. Again for those who seem to have trouble with basic English, I said nothing about the console. I refer only to the motion control mechanic that remains largely worthless to this day and most people quickly abandon using as soon as they figure out they can. :rolleyes:


OK BUDDY.
 
Motion control didn't sell the wii, price point did. Again for those who seem to have trouble with basic English, I said nothing about the console. I refer only to the motion control mechanic that remains largely worthless to this day and most people quickly abandon using as soon as they figure out they can. :rolleyes:

No, motion control is *exactly* what sold the Wii. The 360 Arcade is $50 *cheaper* than the Wii. The Wii's claim to fame and its massive popularity is due entirely to its unique take on console controls. Feel free to keep ignoring the obvious, though.
 
No, motion control is *exactly* what sold the Wii. The 360 Arcade is $50 *cheaper* than the Wii. The Wii's claim to fame and its massive popularity is due entirely to its unique take on console controls. Feel free to keep ignoring the obvious, though.

That is only a recent change, for the bulk of time when the Wii was at it's highest point in popularity it was significantly cheaper then the 360 and PS3.

Original Price Points
Wii - $250
360 - $399
Ps3 - $499/$599

Couple that with a heavy marketing campaign aimed at family oriented games and that was the recipe for success for the wii. The motion controller had very little impact whatsoever. The wii was all about coming in at a low price point and appealing to non gamers. Perhaps next time before you decide you know it all, you should actually know what you are talking about.
 
What some of you mean to say, I think, is that the Wii's version of motion control is a useless novelty. Watch the demo Sony put out for their version, it looks pretty sick and is actually accurate.
 
That is only a recent change, for the bulk of time when the Wii was at it's highest point in popularity it was significantly cheaper then the 360 and PS3.

Original Price Points
Wii - $250
360 - $399
Ps3 - $499/$599

Couple that with a heavy marketing campaign aimed at family oriented games and that was the recipe for success for the wii. The motion controller had very little impact whatsoever. The wii was all about coming in at a low price point and appealing to non gamers. Perhaps next time before you decide you know it all, you should actually know what you are talking about.

I'm starting to have trouble telling if you are serious anymore, the lack of research on your part is pathetic.

November 2005 the 360 was launched with 2 models, Core and Pro. Core was a $299 part. Also bear in mind that the Wii launched a *year* later and was continually out of stock for basically the entire year of 2007.

If you think price was the reason for the Wii's success, well, everyone's entitled to their opinion, but please leave the personally attacks out of this. You don't have any idea what the hell you are talking about either, as this is entirely speculation :rolleyes:

As for the marketing campaign towards casual gamers - yes, they were marketing the *MOTION CONTROLLER* as being easier to use. Yay internet arguments! :rolleyes:
 
According to a statement made by Sony’s Kazuo Hirai, the PlayStation 3 Motion Controller is being pushed back to the fall. The company pushed the launch of the controller back until they had a “comprehensive portfolio of attractive and innovative games.”

well....if the standards they used to launch the PS3 to begin with are any indicator, im going to say the "comprehensive portfolio of attractive and innovative games" list is going to be a short one, they just finally have a few decent games for it now.....nevermind entirely new programmed games for motion control....we shall see
 
Wait... PS3 has games?

GilmorD, folks! Straight out of 2008 and brandishing rapier-like wit.



Serpico said:
That would be a shame. The demo they had at E3 last year blew away the Natal demo.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qiX-26VL4bM

Shame those engineers were so nervous and awkward, because the technology itself is really impressive.


I have to admit I wasn't utterly impressed with either Microsoft's or Sony's showing of 'motion-gen' controller devices last year at E3, but you're right; Sony's presentation was far more intriguing than Natal.

Both implementations have great potential but it's going to come down to which gaming studios can produce intuitive software. I think the final say will be determined more by third parties than either Sony or Microsoft themselves.
 
I have to admit I wasn't utterly impressed with either Microsoft's or Sony's showing of 'motion-gen' controller devices last year at E3, but you're right; Sony's presentation was far more intriguing than Natal.

Both implementations have great potential but it's going to come down to which gaming studios can produce intuitive software. I think the final say will be determined more by third parties than either Sony or Microsoft themselves.

Games as always will decide which one is better. Hardware means squat when there's no software to back it up. Third parties aside, I think Sony has a better shot than Microsoft at supporting it if they choose to. They have much better first party studios than Microsoft does at this point. Nintendo is the only company that puts more emphasis on first party development, but arguably at the expense of third parties.
 
Back
Top