Raid 5 - Extremely slow speeds (ICH9R content)

rust0r

n00b
Joined
Jan 12, 2010
Messages
33
Hi all,

I've finally had enough and am unable to figure it out for myself so I'm hoping you all can help.

I am running a Raid 5 setup with 4 WD 1TB Blacks using software raid on ICH9R, when transfering anything (either within the raid or to other drives) it will burst initially at over 200mb/s and then settle at a pathetic 55-60mb/s (the problem seemed to have gotten worse after switching from vista x64 to 7 x64, but it was bad before, 70-80mb/s)

Stripe size is 64kb as most places seem to suggest, for the most part it is a media storage setup, mp3, movies, tv shows, dslr pictures(8mb+)

I've attached some HD Tune data, it seems that HD Tune is showing my average read speed at 231mb/s

raid5read.jpg


rain5slowtransfer.jpg


Can anyone give me some advice, I've done all the googling I can but don't seem to see anything as to why I would experience such terrible speeds with this setup?

(Also note, I am aware of TLER problems with WD)

Thanks guy!
 
what is your CPU or rame usage when transfering.

when i tried raid 5 on ICH9R it just sucked! speeds wre 30-40MB and my ram usage went through the roof on it, but i have seen others who have had great speeds.

Now, are you transfering large files or small ones, many small files = plenty of random seek = crappy speeds vs larger files.
 
i don't have an answer for you, but befor anyone else asks, can you confirm if tler is on or off, im sure it will help others in diagnosing your issues
 
Running a Q9550 with 8GB ddr3

During transfers: CPU usage 3-10%, ram is 35%
During idle: CPU usage 1-3%, ram is 22%

Files being transfered are usually large (bluray, truecrypt/large iso, divx movies, tv shows)

TLER is OFF (I've never attempted to turn it ON, as I believe only 2 of my drives will do it)
 
RAID 5 uses parity, and there is alot of "math" that needs to be done during writes that doesn't need to be done during reads (unless the array is degraded for some reason). It sounds like your CPU is taxing out during writes. Software based RAID 5 is a bad idea IMHO.

Dustin
 
I know there is much math for the parity calculations, but trust me, my CPU has plenty of steam left in it, see the usage %'s I just posted. People with systems of far lower CPU speeds have no problem obtaining > 100mb/s the ICH9R
 
I know there is much math for the parity calculations, but trust me, my CPU has plenty of steam left in it, see the usage %'s I just posted. People with systems of far lower CPU speeds have no problem obtaining > 100mb/s the ICH9R

Not on Raid5.

Raid5 on ICHx or AMD chipsets just suck.
Im surprised you are even getting 50MB/s writes.

If you want to do R5 get a RAID controller with an IOP chip.
 
If that isn't the case, why does my HD Tune transfer scores show 200+ ? I'm confused with the large discrepancy
 
If that isn't the case, why does my HD Tune transfer scores show 200+ ? I'm confused with the large discrepancy

What are you writing to when you are doing the transfers that feel are too slow? Your speeds are going to be dictated by the slowest part of the path. It doesn't matter how fast your raid array can read if the place you are writing to can only handle 55-60MB/s. The initial burst you are seeing happens as the target device's cache handles the inital load, after which you are limited by device speeds. Also, if you are timing transfers that both read and write to the same raid array you need to cut your expected times by half (perhaps more as you are going to be thrashing the device a bit too). If you want valid timings for your raid array you need to ensure that the target is at least as fast writing as the raid array is reading.

The reason HD Tune gives good results is that HD Tune's 'target' is the bit bucket, which writes infinitely fast. <g>
 
It can be anywhere, the 55-60mb/s were writting to a 500gb raid 1 (split for an os drive setup with some backup storage for extra security)

I am currently copying to a removable 2tb green drive using E-sata and only getting 45mb/s (which I have written to at 75mb/s using data off my 500gb raid 1 setup)

What speeds should I expect with the ICH9R 4 Disk raid setup ?
 
It can be anywhere, the 55-60mb/s were writting to a 500gb raid 1 (split for an os drive setup with some backup storage for extra security)

I am currently copying to a removable 2tb green drive using E-sata and only getting 45mb/s (which I have written to at 75mb/s using data off my 500gb raid 1 setup)

What speeds should I expect with the ICH9R 4 Disk raid setup ?

Agan, what you can expect is that any transfer will be limited by the speed of the slowest part of the path. Both of the examples you cited above are limited by the write speed of the single target disk (writing to raid 1 is even worse since you have to copy things to BOTH of the target drives, albeit usually in parallel). I don't think the speeds you are seeing have anything at all to do with the performance of the raid-5 on your ich9r.
 
What would you suggest I try then to see if I am obtaining reasonable speeds ?
 
I'll check out Iometer, the website said it was discontinued in 01, so I'm not sure how that will work on 7 64bit lol

ssdforspeed: I noticed you pointed me to the "Rapid storage technology", from googling I get that this it the new Matrix Storage manager? Will uninstalling Intel Matrix Storage Manager and installing this cause any corruption within my raid 5? (refference page http://www.station-drivers.com/page/intel raid.htm )

thanks!
 
Rapid Storage Technology is Intel's new branding for Matrix Storage Manager. You can install it with no damage to your arrays. In fact, you don't even need to uninstall your existing drivers first - go ahead and run the install script and it will install as an update. Most of the improvements in this version of the drivers were related to better support for SSDs, not making your Raid5 run faster. There is a massively better Windows UI and better integration to the taskbar for Windows 7.

I'd go to the Intel website and get the drivers directly. The ones posted to Station-drivers.com are actually the beta's. Get the current/released drivers instead.

Of course, there is nothing in these updates that will do anything to make your target drives go faster...
 
Last edited:
I'm not to sure about the Rapid Storage manager, whenever I go on intels websit and select windows 7, it brings me back to my current version of Matrix ? The only way it will navigate me to Rapid storage is if I say that I have an intel board ?

I figure that the newest update isn't going to double my output/input given everything above, but it's just part of doing everything to get the system in the best shape for 'running better' or 'properly' I guess
 
I'm not to sure about the Rapid Storage manager, whenever I go on intels websit and select windows 7, it brings me back to my current version of Matrix ? The only way it will navigate me to Rapid storage is if I say that I have an intel board ?

I figure that the newest update isn't going to double my output/input given everything above, but it's just part of doing everything to get the system in the best shape for 'running better' or 'properly' I guess
Go ahead and pull the version listed under the Intel Mobo. MSM/RSM are related to the chipset only - they are not tied to a particular board. I've been running with it since its early beta - I only bothered on the hope that they would propagate TRIM through the array, which unfortunately is a feature they dropped at the last minute (but since OCZ implemented garbage collection it hardly matters anymore). The new user interface alone is worth the upgrade. And you are right - staying on current drivers is almost always a good thing.
 
Back
Top