[H]ot ....Auto Refinance?...

SilverSliver

[H]F Junkie
2FA
Joined
Feb 23, 2004
Messages
13,240
Well, I figure I'd put this out here to save some folks some money.

I just refinanced my car with Pentagon Federal Credit Union. It's free to government employees, or $20 bucks to join some military families association and then join PenFed.

They offer a 3.99% for 60 months online only rate on new and used cars, including refinanced vehicles. I had a 5.25% rate, and this is saving me $100 a month. A lot of you may not finance, or may have gotten 0% rates -- if so, great. But if you have anything higher, this is a good deal.

https://www.penfed.org/productsAndRates/loans/vehicleLoans/autoLoans.asp

edit -- obviously not a good deal if you are upside-down or anything like that.
 
Last edited:
I found this deal literally days after buying my new car this spring. I actually refinanced before I made my first payment. Also, their GAP was only $300 compared to $600 from Capital One through the dealership. My dad is retired Army, so I didn't even have to join anything.
 
for new cars, anything more than 0% is a bad deal. 3.99% is a good deal on used or refinancing though.
 
for new cars, anything more than 0% is a bad deal. 3.99% is a good deal on used or refinancing though.

Yeah, if you have a 850 credit score.

Realistically, if you have average credit (600-700) look at getting 5-7% on an auto loan for a new car.
 
for new cars, anything more than 0% is a bad deal. 3.99% is a good deal on used or refinancing though.

See, you're trying to appear intelligent and informed here, yet you neglect the fact that 0% interest rates are priced into the car. The dealership will sell the car for thousands cheaper if you don't use 0% promotional financing. It's impossible to say whether or not a certain rate is a "bad deal" without running all the numbers.
 
for new cars, anything more than 0% is a bad deal. 3.99% is a good deal on used or refinancing though.

This is simply untrue. And with third party financing you can actually haggle over price, unlike with dealer financing. :eek:
 
See, you're trying to appear intelligent and informed here, yet you neglect the fact that 0% interest rates are priced into the car. The dealership will sell the car for thousands cheaper if you don't use 0% promotional financing. It's impossible to say whether or not a certain rate is a "bad deal" without running all the numbers.

+1

If you elect to take the 0% financing you are probably turning down a couple thousands of dollars of customer cash. I would consider anything under 4% a good rate.
 
What credit do you need?
I have a 680 score..
Can I get this?
My current rate is 7.9% :(
 
Penfed's a great CU, I've been a member for a long time and before the economy went to crap I got a rate rate on one of my cars through them. Good if you're buying a car that doesn't have incentives on it (like my MINI a couple years ago). Sign up and 2 days later you get a check in the mail. Their Platinum card is great too for gas/foreign travel too btw.
 
What credit do you need?
I have a 680 score..
Can I get this?
My current rate is 7.9% :(

I think you can get their advertised rate, I've heard of many students with no credit getting loans through them. That's for new loans, I dunno about re-fi.
 
Penfed's a great CU, I've been a member for a long time and before the economy went to crap I got a rate rate on one of my cars through them. Good if you're buying a car that doesn't have incentives on it (like my MINI a couple years ago). Sign up and 2 days later you get a check in the mail. Their Platinum card is great too for gas/foreign travel too btw.
QFT.

I have a car financed with them on very good terms, and their Platinum rewards card as well. There aren't many rewards cards that give you 5% cash back any more, but Penfed pays 5% cash back on all gas station purchases and it's automatically credited to the balance every month. No waiting for $50 or however many points. Straight cash back, and lots of it.
 
I applied for the Loan, it's pending..
Let's hope I get it..
I'll reduce my payments from 376/month to 313/month :)
 
This is simply untrue. And with third party financing you can actually haggle over price, unlike with dealer financing. :eek:

Hardly. First off, you CAN haggle with dealer financing. Granted, its better to have good credit and much more beneficial, but it can be done.

2nd, say you get a rate @ 3.9% and buy a $30,000 car @ 72 months (what most people go for these days due to less monthly payment). You pay $3700 in interest by the end of the car.

So, 0% financing @ 30,000 is 30,000. You telling me they will drop your car price to $26,300? I highly doubt that, as the $30,000 is probably already haggled down from $32,500 if you knew what you were doing (if not more). Even in this economy, they arent giving cars away (atleast not good cars, maybe stripped down nakeds yeah).

Ill gladly take 0% interest @ Invoice pricing anyday over 3.9% financing at below invoice.
 
My bro in in the Air Force, does that mean I can get in? Only ask because the guy's dad is military, so he said he was in, so am I with my brother? I doubt it, but worth asking...
 
Hardly. First off, you CAN haggle with dealer financing. Granted, its better to have good credit and much more beneficial, but it can be done.

2nd, say you get a rate @ 3.9% and buy a $30,000 car @ 72 months (what most people go for these days due to less monthly payment). You pay $3700 in interest by the end of the car.

So, 0% financing @ 30,000 is 30,000. You telling me they will drop your car price to $26,300? I highly doubt that, as the $30,000 is probably already haggled down from $32,500 if you knew what you were doing (if not more). Even in this economy, they arent giving cars away (atleast not good cars, maybe stripped down nakeds yeah).

Ill gladly take 0% interest @ Invoice pricing anyday over 3.9% financing at below invoice.

How would you know what the companies invoice on the car is?
 
Yeah, if you have a 850 credit score.

Realistically, if you have average credit (600-700) look at getting 5-7% on an auto loan for a new car.

no. 740-750 will do it. if you can't get 0% at $500 over dealer cost, then you should really reconsider the idea of even buying a new car. even 0% @ dealer cost is a bad investment.

:confused::confused:
I've never seen 0% on New cars i do like. :eek:

GM currently has the Z06 Corvette at 0% for 72 months. and if you shop around, you can find them for about $16k under sticker.

See, you're trying to appear intelligent and informed here, yet you neglect the fact that 0% interest rates are priced into the car. The dealership will sell the car for thousands cheaper if you don't use 0% promotional financing. It's impossible to say whether or not a certain rate is a "bad deal" without running all the numbers.

i bet you've never taken the time to calculate interest on an auto loan.

last new car i bought had a sticker of $57,000. i paid $39,000 with 0% for 60 months. and the new car before that, i paid $25,500 with 0% for 60 months on a car with a sticker of $38,000. $0 down on both too. let me know when you find a better deal. i'm still right side up by $5-10k on both loans too.

i've only been buying and selling cars for 30 years though, so what do i know.

This is simply untrue. And with third party financing you can actually haggle over price, unlike with dealer financing. :eek:

no, that is simply untrue on multiple levels. for starts, most new car loans are not financed by the dealer. secondly, the lender rarely plays any active role in price negotiations.

+1

If you elect to take the 0% financing you are probably turning down a couple thousands of dollars of customer cash. I would consider anything under 4% a good rate.

only if you don't know what you're doing and allow yourself to be screwed. i know *exactly* what i'm willing to pay for a specific vehicle with specific options *before* i go to a dealership. if they won't sell it to me at my price after an hour or so of haggling, i leave.

Hardly. First off, you CAN haggle with dealer financing. Granted, its better to have good credit and much more beneficial, but it can be done.

2nd, say you get a rate @ 3.9% and buy a $30,000 car @ 72 months (what most people go for these days due to less monthly payment). You pay $3700 in interest by the end of the car.

So, 0% financing @ 30,000 is 30,000. You telling me they will drop your car price to $26,300? I highly doubt that, as the $30,000 is probably already haggled down from $32,500 if you knew what you were doing (if not more). Even in this economy, they arent giving cars away (atleast not good cars, maybe stripped down nakeds yeah).

Ill gladly take 0% interest @ Invoice pricing anyday over 3.9% financing at below invoice.

:) finally, somebody (in addition to the OP) in this thread who understands car shopping and financing.

How would you know what the companies invoice on the car is?

google, edmunds, kbb, auto trader, lowest advertised internet prices, etc.
 
Last edited:
Yeah, if you have a 850 credit score.

Realistically, if you have average credit (600-700) look at getting 5-7% on an auto loan for a new car.

btw, the average FICO score is currently 690-695. 85% of the country has a score above 600, nearly 60% have a score above 700, and less than 15% have a score above 800.
 
Do they do motorcycles? With great credit, my last bike finance was 7.5%. My new Subaru (2005) was 2.99.

I'd be interested in it for motorcycle financing...

6.49% on motorcycle loans. Not bad either...
 
You have a $173,000 car loan?!

Sounds more like he just re-fied and did so for another 60 months on top of how long he's already been paying. So, his loan was for a lower principal amount paid over 60 months from the loan date. Thus, he'll still be paying on his loan for much longer than he originally would have.
 
Sounds more like he just re-fied and did so for another 60 months on top of how long he's already been paying. So, his loan was for a lower principal amount paid over 60 months from the loan date. Thus, he'll still be paying on his loan for much longer than he originally would have.

Correct, my previous loan was 60 months and this is another 60 month note. I have had my previous car loan for 1 year, so this is tacking an additional year onto it. I will have it paid off within a couple of years, but I was wanting some lower payment flexibility along with a lower interest paid amount until that point.

I had also tied in some negative equity from my previous car into the initial loan, and my note is significantly less than the value of the car now. Figured I'd take advantage of that.
 
Last edited:
no. 740-750 will do it. if you can't get 0% at $500 over dealer cost, then you should really reconsider the idea of even buying a new car. even 0% @ dealer cost is a bad investment.

Not all dealerships even offer 0.0% financing to anyone, at least not around here. Even with a 810 credit score the lowest rates I could get were usually promo rates a few years ago. So unless someone is sitting around waiting for a 0% offer from the manufacturer, its not very realistic for more people to simply NOT buy a car unless they can get 0% on it.

Of course then someone racked up $40K on my credit cards and hid the bills from me, thus dropping a nuke on my awesome credit. I was lucky to get a 4.9% rate on the last car I bought :p
 
Last edited:
+1 for penfed. I joined to get their rewards card

5% on gas
2% on groceries
1.25% on everything else

no limit on rewards, automatically credited monthly, no anual fee.

one of the best cards i've seen out there.

if you join for the refinance and you tend to pay your CC off every month... get the card too :)
 
Not all dealerships even offer 0.0% financing to anyone, at least not around here. Even with a 810 credit score the lowest rates I could get were usually promo rates a few years ago. So unless someone is sitting around waiting for a 0% offer from the manufacturer, its not very realistic for more people to simply NOT buy a car unless they can get 0% on it.

true, but irrelevant. buy last years model when new year models hit the dealership (the time when 0% is most commonly offered), or buy in Jan-Feb. if your local dealership doesn't offer 0%, then buy from another dealership. spend 5 min searching on the interweb and you can almost always find a dealer who is offering 0%.
 
true, but irrelevant. buy last years model when new year models hit the dealership (the time when 0% is most commonly offered), or buy in Jan-Feb. if your local dealership doesn't offer 0%, then buy from another dealership. spend 5 min searching on the interweb and you can almost always find a dealer who is offering 0%.

What market do you live in, because seriously that *never* happens around here (Maine). Maybe this is a major market thing... In Maine its manufacturer's offer OR some shitty 3rd party bank financing every time (and that bottoms out around 5.9%). I've never seen a local dealer offering 0% on cars through their own deal. Heck my roommate bought and sold cars for 5 years, he never heard of this either... :p

I looked into buying my last couple cars out of state and it seemed like a pain in the ass :(
 
Last edited:
New car promotions of 0% are fairly common. A 3.9% used rate is not too shabby, though.
 
I got 3.9 Apr in 2005 on Wife Graduation Gift (New Honda S2000). Replaced our Winter Car with new Toyota Yaris. Cheap enough to pay for it out of Savings. (ie Cashier Check).

(you know what a Convertible Sports Car is on ICE? Roller Skate)

Still lots of Stupid Paperwork.
 
if you have less than very good credit dont bother even applying, you'll just be wasting a hard inquiry on your report for a guaranteed denial
 
I got 3.9 Apr in 2005 on Wife Graduation Gift (New Honda S2000). Replaced our Winter Car with new Toyota Yaris. Cheap enough to pay for it out of Savings. (ie Cashier Check).

(you know what a Convertible Sports Car is on ICE? Roller Skate)

Still lots of Stupid Paperwork.

Are you implying that we should SAVE for a car and not get into DEBT??? That is unheard of, well, in this thread anyway. Why does everybody have to have new cars and worry about all this haggling and financing unless it is on used vehicles? Guess you are all richer than me ;)
 
Ok, I read enough misinformation on the first page to make a whole dealership full of sales guys happy for the holidays... This might get long.

Preface: I know what I'm talking about because I sold cars for a "different kind of car company" and a three letter Korean brand for two years. I did regular and internet sales.

First, dealers don't "finance" cars. Dealers arrange financing for you through other banks. (NOTE: some dealers do finance cars, but only to poor credit customers. This is special financing and I am not going into it because it is a whole 'nother post.) These banks give the dealers money to arrange the financing. When you apply for a loan at a dealership, they send the application to 1-5 banks, depending on how tricky the situation might be. The banks come back and tell the dealer yes or no, and give terms of the deal.

Some lenders determine your rate on a bunch of factors including credit score, vehicle year, options, and mileage, term of the loan, and your debt to income ratio. Some lenders like certain deals and dislike others (hence sending it to multiple lenders). One of the terms the lender send the dealer is the "buy rate." The buy rate is the rate the interest rate the bank will let you have the car for. The dealer is then free (under certain state and bank enforced regulations) to mark that rate up and collect on the difference. It's called marking the rate, and it is common.

You can negotiate the rate with the dealer! But they won't go any lower than the buy rate (for obvious reasons). Now, the finance manager may have given you the buy rate or he/she might have marked it, you don't/won't ever know. So, you have to tell them, "I checked online and saw my bank/local credit union/some bank is offering X rate." Make sure you do this, or they will call your bluff. Believe me, they know what rates are out there much better than you do. Do your homework and figure this out.

Once you "threaten" with that rate, they won't dare mark yours lest they loose the financing. Even if they give you the buy rate, they make a flat fee off signing you up with the bank (called: a flat). If you finance outside the dealership, they make nothing.

Now, when you see 0% financing!!!!! That is almost always (99% of the time) from the manufacturer's financing wing. GM uses GMAC (for now anyway), Ford has Ford Credit Something, etc, etc for each manufacturer. The manufacturer almost always has a choice these days, between the financing and some amount of money off. Just tell the sales guy you want them to figure it both way so you can see which is better. The sale/finance staff gets paid the same whether you take the 0% or the money off, either way the manufacturer reimburses the dealer (remember, the people that make the cars are a completely separate company from those that sell the cars).

So, now you've threatened outside financing, and told them you know about the incentives. Here is where the real negotiating takes place. My advice is to pick three cars you like, test drive them all, then go home and do some research. Edmunds.com will tell you the invoice price of a car with certain options. Plug in the options, get the price.

Expert Tip: The invoice price does NOT reflect the total cost for the dealer of the car. The dealer gets a "holdback" and a marketing fee for each car it sells. Therefore, the dealer makes a little profit even if you pay "invoice." I was never a manager so I never saw an exact holdback or marketing fee amount, but got the impression there was about $400-600 combined.

So, you know the invoice price. Pick what car you want the most (don't dick around, it's just a car) and call your sales guy. Tell him/her in a polite but firm tone, "Ryken, Thanks for the time you spent with us, we really liked working with you. We've decided that if you can make the numbers work, we are ready to come in and buy the car XXXday. We'll pay ($250 over invoice price), but if you can't make that happen, we're going to call the other dealerships and see who can. Let us know."

It is key that you are polite, but firm. Also, you want to tell them the exact day that you can pick up the car. This is VERY important. Then the sales guy goes to the manager, "Boss, he said he'd pick it up tomorrow if we can do this. The boss gets pissed and says get more money blah blah, sales guys says they're gonna start shopping if we can't do this price." Then boss will more likely than not roll over and just get the car on the road.

Don't dick around, don't try to play games. The dealer is ALWAYS better at games, they play them 3 times a week, you play them once every 5 years. There are two types of sales people, those that hate playing games and will play nastier games back at you, and those that love games and will play nastier games back at you.

Car buying lesson over.

EDIT: to the post above me. I would never buy a new car either, but most people are not good enough at saving. Or, if you are young like me, you have to finance because you need a car to go to work and make money to save. It takes a while for young people to save enough money to buy a car outright, while paying off their first loan. I'll eventually be to the point where I buy my cars in cash, but it'll take some time.
 
Last edited:
Ok, I read enough misinformation on the first page to make a whole dealership full of sales guys happy for the holidays... This might get long.

Car buying lesson over.

Good post. Glad you showed up to this thread, it was getting stupid.
 
the post above me. I would never buy a new car either, but most people are not good enough at saving. Or, if you are young like me, you have to finance because you need a car to go to work and make money to save. It takes a while for young people to save enough money to buy a car outright, while paying off their first loan. I'll eventually be to the point where I buy my cars in cash, but it'll take some time.

That is why I left the used portion in there, because I know my first car was definately used and also financed. But the comment was directed towards even those that can "afford" the payments.

I find common qualities between electronics and vehicles which makes this especially appropriate for these forums. 1. Buy high, sell low 2. Depreciation is insane (in most cases) 3. Those who want bleeding edge who can pay for it, will pay for it. And even the people who own this website are very verse in both subject matters but buying a car and buying a pre-configured gaming rig are whole different ball games. This thread was really refreshing but thanks goes to Ryken for bringing it to a level most of us can relate to.
 
no. 740-750 will do it. if you can't get 0% at $500 over dealer cost, then you should really reconsider the idea of even buying a new car. even 0% @ dealer cost is a bad investment.



GM currently has the Z06 Corvette at 0% for 72 months. and if you shop around, you can find them for about $16k under sticker.



i bet you've never taken the time to calculate interest on an auto loan.

last new car i bought had a sticker of $57,000. i paid $39,000 with 0% for 60 months. and the new car before that, i paid $25,500 with 0% for 60 months on a car with a sticker of $38,000. $0 down on both too. let me know when you find a better deal. i'm still right side up by $5-10k on both loans too.

i've only been buying and selling cars for 30 years though, so what do i know.



no, that is simply untrue on multiple levels. for starts, most new car loans are not financed by the dealer. secondly, the lender rarely plays any active role in price negotiations.



only if you don't know what you're doing and allow yourself to be screwed. i know *exactly* what i'm willing to pay for a specific vehicle with specific options *before* i go to a dealership. if they won't sell it to me at my price after an hour or so of haggling, i leave.



:) finally, somebody (in addition to the OP) in this thread who understands car shopping and financing.



google, edmunds, kbb, auto trader, lowest advertised internet prices, etc.


I agree with you for almost entirely. Other than the Z06 sales being relevant to the scenario as it's an unlikely purchase for most.


There's no point in arguing, as soon as someone reads a post, most people just jump on the bandwagon and argue your valid points.

Although I do wish I could get this loan, 8 points is what I'm paying now.
 
If you are in Michigan, check out Credit Union One, http://www.cuone.org/ they have the same rate available. I have currently have two loans with them, and refer all my friends/family to them.
 
Back
Top