Apple 27” iMac First Look

Yea I know that monitor has better specs/technology than my cheap 27" Dell.

Unfortunately I don't have a 6 figure salary so I guess I have to spend my money a little wisely.

Didn't mean to get your panties all twisted up iFanboi.

I just hope for the money your spending you get a blowjob port on that thing.

My mom had an Apple ][ in the 80's, upon which I played some games and I considered buying an iPod before I bought a Rio Karma 4 or 5 years ago....did I mention my monitor is a 24" dell.

Yup, I'm an iFanboi :rolleyes:
 
A webcam?

Its a %#!@#$ 30" monitor. Your arguments are invalid.

Your argument is off as well. The iMac has everything in the space of the monitor. Comparing that to a full desktop rig is an unfair comparison, never mind that you're building it yourself. Compare it to a similar rig from Dell or HP.

Sheesh folks, Apple, IMO, is generally overpriced, but in this case, they're not. I really hate it when my fellow Windows users act like the Mac Fan boys.
 
The iMac has a built-in webcam, yes. The iMac also comes standard with a decent keyboard (albeit without a numpad, annoyingly) and what is apparently a fairly decent mouse. Not to mention an operating system. And an optical drive. And speakers.

These additions to your configured machine would raise the price by around $150-200.


I'd prefer the 27" 16:9 display to the 30" 16:10 display myself. The former offers greater pixel density, making non-native 1920x1080 gaming a little more tolerable. Nice for text rendering as well.

I'm going to give him this one. I wouldn't use the apple keyboard or mouse and frankly, I've got plenty of extras laying round that are better than what it comes with. Then again, i think the KB/Mouse that come with HP/Dell systems are also junk.

As for the OS, for most on this forum, it's safe to say they'd have to buy a 7 license for either build.
 
You are comparing a DIY rig versus a pre-built computer with a one-stop warranty, all-in-one engineering and enclosure, etc etc. It isn't a fair comparison, and it wouldn't be fair if you were making a comparison with a standard mid-tower Dell or HP.

Actually, I think that would be a fair comparison. But this isn't a tower and few of us, if any, could build an all in one with similar specs to that of the iMac.

I'm not going to buy it, but if I ever get back into photography, I'd definitely consider it.

The DIY machine you specced out would cost less than a mid-tower performance desktop from Dell or HP (and way less than from Falcon Northwest, Cyber Power PC, etc). Is it time to start ripping on them as well, or is it not as fun because they don't have the logo of a fruit on the case?

Well now that's true, but then again, I've always felt that Falcons were more overpriced than Macs (in most cases).
 
Actually, I think that would be a fair comparison. But this isn't a tower and few of us, if any, could build an all in one with similar specs to that of the iMac.

I disagree with the first sentence, I'm pretty positive that I could build a PC for less than a similarly specced Dell or HP. I know that the Dell XPS and HP Voodoo desktops that compete with the kinds of PCs I personally build would cost more, and this is before we get into dedicated "gamer/performance" type vendors like Falcon Northwest, Cyber Power PC, etc.

But yes, I think most rational people here can see that comparing prices between an all-in-one from a computer builder and a DIY tower is ludicrous, especially when iMacs were faster and had more storage than comparably priced Dell and HP AIO machines before the 27" refresh.
 
I disagree with the first sentence, I'm pretty positive that I could build a PC for less than a similarly specced Dell or HP. I know that the Dell XPS and HP Voodoo desktops that compete with the kinds of PCs I personally build would cost more, and this is before we get into dedicated "gamer/performance" type vendors like Falcon Northwest, Cyber Power PC, etc.

But yes, I think most rational people here can see that comparing prices between an all-in-one from a computer builder and a DIY tower is ludicrous, especially when iMacs were faster and had more storage than comparably priced Dell and HP AIO machines before the 27" refresh.

I wasn't saying that you couldn't build one for less (though some of the cheaper base units are often sold at a loss). What I was saying is that it's fair to compare a system I can build to a similar desktop unit that the big boys sell.

I really don't get those that spewing bile over the cost of this unit. it's not cheap, but given the monitor, it's certainly worth considering if you're in the market for a high resolution IPS monitor. I do wonder, however, why Apple uses glossy screens. Considering their target market, you'd think they'd go with a matte finish.

With that said, it probably wouldn't affect me, since I always block out the windows in my computer room.
 
Good thing Apple picks good LCDs for their iMacs huh. I can't justify NECs price anyway. I have a Dell 2209WA and lov it tho.
 
Something that a lot of you aren't taking into consideration when you're looking at the price of this unit is the fact that this isn't a normal desktop with a tower that you can build yourself with the same specs for a fraction of the price (minus the amazing 27" IPS LED-backlit 2560x1440 1000:1 display you woudln't be able to touch for less than $1300-$1400+), this is a desktop and laptop hybrid.

iMacs have all the desktop features built into the display itself which eliminates having to have a tower sitting on or near your desk somewhere. This is a big plus for office environments where you want to waste space. Also a new MacBook Pro laptop retails for the same price as this iMac with this incredible 27" screen so for Apple this is a pretty great price on this refresh. The only thing that it's missing that I really wish it had is a blu-ray drive. At this point I think Apple should be shipping them standard on the high-end models.
 
And this is the rub with all-in-one units, upgrades and options can be problematic. Nice unit however, And you can get a 30" S-IPS for $1150 now: http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16824005115

The panel used in the display matter a lot more than the size and although that LG 30" is an S-IPS the new 27" in the iMac has better specs than Apple's 30" IPS and it's suppose to be a thing of glory to see in person I guess. I'm tempted to order one from Amazon since it will only be around $1927 for the quad i5.
 
The panel used in the display matter a lot more than the size and although that LG 30" is an S-IPS the new 27" in the iMac has better specs than Apple's 30" IPS and it's suppose to be a thing of glory to see in person I guess. I'm tempted to order one from Amazon since it will only be around $1927 for the quad i5.

Isn't that panel in the 27" iMac an S-IPS panel?
 
Isn't that panel in the 27" iMac an S-IPS panel?

It is an IPS but compared to the Apple 30" IPS it's suppose to have better specs and a unique higher resolution not found on any other current shipping 27" display at 2560x1440 which means it has an excellent dot pitch.

The more I think and learn about the curious pricing of the 27” iMac, the more bizarre and incredible it seems.

It has a resolution of 2560x1440, which no other monitor in the industry seems to have (that I can find). 30” LCDs are the same width but 1600 tall. Shrinking 2560-wide into a screen that’s 3” smaller diagonally yields an impressive pixel density, especially given the panel’s still-immense size.

It has an IPS panel. IPS is the best and most expensive LCD type, giving the best viewing angle and the least color- and brightness-shifting as the angle increases in any direction. Nearly every panel on the market, including every laptop panel, is the cheap TN type. (TN panels wash out as soon as you move your head slightly, especially vertically, which is why it’s so hard to find a good viewing angle for your laptop lid while watching a dark movie.) Other 27” TN panels exist (only at the lower 1920x1080 resolution), but I can’t find any other 27” IPS panels.

It’s also LED-backlit.

So it’s a very high-specced, brand new panel that’s apparently not being mass-produced yet (since no other monitors for sale are using it). That must be expensive. How much of the base 27” iMac’s $1700 retail cost does this represent?

The closest existing panel for comparison, spec-wise, is the 30” IPS panel that Apple uses in their Cinema Display. It has the ultra-high resolution and size, but doesn’t compete with the 27” iMac’s panel for brightness, contrast, power efficiency, or color range. It’s overpriced by today’s standards at $1800, but not by much — Dell’s original 30” monitor with the same panel is $1200, and a newer version with better specs (although still not as good as the new iMac’s) is $1700.

A standalone monitor with the new iMac’s panel would be perfectly reasonably priced at about $1500. From Dell. Apple’s only charging $200 more than that for theirs, and there’s an entire high-end computer stuck to the back of it.

When they mentioned on last week’s quarterly earnings call that they expected lower profit margins for a new product, I don’t think anyone expected a change of this magnitude. How are they making anything — or even not losing money — with the base-model 27” iMac?

My guess: a massively successful negotiation with the panel’s manufacturer (most likely LG) to get not only an incredible price on these panels, but also apparent exclusivity for a while. It’s a hell of an accomplishment, and presumably a hell of an effort, for a computer that isn’t Apple’s most-selling model (or even product line). That raises a more interesting question: Why?

Until we know why the panel is so cheap, I bet we’re going to see a lot of Mac Pro owners buying 27” monitors for $1700 and trying to figure out what to do with the free computer stuck to the back. For new-computer shopping, a lot of people are going to abandon whichever laptop or Mac Pro they were considering and get this instead.

That helps answer the “why” question: Maybe Apple wants to push more buyers away from today’s default system-type choice — laptops — and show them why they should consider getting a fast, spacious desktop instead. And, for the time being, it’s a desktop with absolutely no equivalent in the PC world.

http://www.marco.org/222434049
 
burning - Thanks for that repost and quote, very interesting.

I'll take it further and say that more Mac Pro users may end up moving away from their Xeon based systems and get a high end iMac instead for the whole computer, not just the display. The i7 860 benchmarks that are coming out are extremely competitive with the baseline Mac Pro configurations with the i7 Xeons. This is what happened with me to a lesser extent a few years back.

My first Mac was a Dual CPU G4 that I got back in September of 2002 when OS 10.2 launched. I got it to run Final Cut Pro and DVD Studio Pro on. I kept it for five years, thing was a tank. When 10.5 launched I bought a new machine for Final Cut Studio, but this time it wasn't a Mac tower, it was a 24" iMac.

The Core 2 Duo CPU it used was more than enough horsepower for me to run my applications on, but more importantly it was using the same H-IPS LCD panel that is in the NEC 2490WUXi, which by itself is still $1100-$1200 on Newegg. I have one sitting right next to my iMac as its secondary display and the primary for my PC. As far as I was concerned, at that price they were nearly giving that monitor away with the computer. I didn't need to drop a boatload on a Mac Pro since the iMacs have enough performance for FCS, I was going to save space and noise in my home office, and I was getting one of the best 24" displays in the process. It was a win-win-win situation. The only change was no internal hard drives, but that's an easy fix with some FW800 and USB external hard drives.

The best part is that I'll easily be able to sell my iMac for $1000-$1200 if I decide to upgrade to the 27" model, which again is a ridiculous deal. Anyone who says Macs aren't a good value really needs to get their heads examined. They may be expensive but you're getting and retaining a lot of value in the process.
 
Do you think it's worth it to get the i7 860 2.8Ghz over the i5 750 2.66Ghz? The only difference would be HyperThreading enabled and a little over 100Mhz clock increase. I can get the i5 model from Amazon for around $1914 without paying tax whereas at the Apple Store even with the $100 education discount I'd pay over $100 in tax. I'm strongly considering picking up one of these new 27" iMacs as a Christmas gift to myself and selling my desktop PC.
 
I can appreciate that the "panel" used is of great quality. However, why not throw in a lower quality panel, and lessen the price for people like me.

I am 100% happy with a 19in wide screen from Envision that I bought 2 years ago. I don't need a fancy panel :(


Sigh: Apple just won't make a computer I will buy.
 
Do you think it's worth it to get the i7 860 2.8Ghz over the i5 750 2.66Ghz?
Not in my opinion, no. i5 is still pretty startlingly fast in most cases. You'd need to really evaluate your usage habits to make an informed decision, but odds are you're not doing anything that compute-heavy.

I just wanted to comment, though, that I spent a little time playing with the 27" on Saturday (after talking with a fairly unhelpful Genius), and I wasn't quite as blown away with the display as I thought I would be. Perhaps it wasn't really fair of me to compare the display in that environment to my current 20" ACD in my office at home, but it didn't seem quite as remarkable as I was expecting it to be.

That being said, it still looked really damn good, and it makes for a beautiful-looking machine overall. And obviously the price is outstanding.
 
Oh wow...are mac%$@s this %$@!#!#?!

You prefer a 27" over a 30" SIPS? IMHO I hope you really are just trolling because if people like you really exist I can see why creationists and 2012s exist as well.

Are you a morning drinker by any chance?

I've seen both displays, and have dual 30inch myself....

the 27" imac display is much nicer imo. Most of the 30" have an antiglare coating that produces a "sparkle" effect and muffles colors...quite displeasing if you're used to glossy IPS...

16:9 sucks tho I agree :(
 
I can appreciate that the "panel" used is of great quality. However, why not throw in a lower quality panel, and lessen the price for people like me.

I am 100% happy with a 19in wide screen from Envision that I bought 2 years ago. I don't need a fancy panel :(
Sigh: Apple just won't make a computer I will buy.

That's Apple's market niche. They have no desire to compete on the low end.

Honestly, if I could swap out video cards on this machine, I'd have to seriously consider it. Great monitor and a more than adequate CPU. The only downside, IMO, is that you can't really game with the GPU it comes with.

Nevertheless, I may take a trip to the local Apple Store to check it out.
 
Not in my opinion, no. i5 is still pretty startlingly fast in most cases. You'd need to really evaluate your usage habits to make an informed decision, but odds are you're not doing anything that compute-heavy.

I just wanted to comment, though, that I spent a little time playing with the 27" on Saturday (after talking with a fairly unhelpful Genius), and I wasn't quite as blown away with the display as I thought I would be. Perhaps it wasn't really fair of me to compare the display in that environment to my current 20" ACD in my office at home, but it didn't seem quite as remarkable as I was expecting it to be.

That being said, it still looked really damn good, and it makes for a beautiful-looking machine overall. And obviously the price is outstanding.

What about it didn't meet your expectations? What was the lighting like in the store (I rarely walk into an Apple store)? With a glossy screen, I'd think that dim/indirect lighting is vital. That's a decision that I don't understand. Matte finishes are always better. But maybe they figure that glossy helps sell it to uneducated buyers and graphics pros can either will control lighting and/or use a visor.
 
That's Apple's market niche. They have no desire to compete on the low end.

Honestly, if I could swap out video cards on this machine, I'd have to seriously consider it. Great monitor and a more than adequate CPU. The only downside, IMO, is that you can't really game with the GPU it comes with.

Nevertheless, I may take a trip to the local Apple Store to check it out.

For gaming anymore I'd personally just get a new PS3 or Xbox 360 and call it a day. There isn't really all that much any more that's coming out exclusively to PC that's really worth playing. From what I hear even Modern Warfare 2 isn't that great for multiplayer on PC compared to Xbox 360 and PS3. Final Fantasy XIII is slated to release in March so I'm definitely going to want to check that out on PS3 so I think I'm going to get one of the new slim PS3's for Christmas and just forget about gaming on PC's any more.
 
I can appreciate that the "panel" used is of great quality. However, why not throw in a lower quality panel, and lessen the price for people like me.

I am 100% happy with a 19in wide screen from Envision that I bought 2 years ago. I don't need a fancy panel :(

Sigh: Apple just won't make a computer I will buy.

What kind of price range are you looking at? You can find the new 3.06Ghz C2D 27" iMac for around $1599 but that's about as good as you're going to find for a 27" IPS LED-backlit iMac.
 
For gaming anymore I'd personally just get a new PS3 or Xbox 360 and call it a day. There isn't really all that much any more that's coming out exclusively to PC that's really worth playing. From what I hear even Modern Warfare 2 isn't that great for multiplayer on PC compared to Xbox 360 and PS3. Final Fantasy XIII is slated to release in March so I'm definitely going to want to check that out on PS3 so I think I'm going to get one of the new slim PS3's for Christmas and just forget about gaming on PC's any more.

I'll stick with the PC. Every time I bought a console, it just sat under the set unused. There are times that I like playing consoles, but not enough to justify buying one.
 
For gaming anymore I'd personally just get a new PS3 or Xbox 360 and call it a day. There isn't really all that much any more that's coming out exclusively to PC that's really worth playing. From what I hear even Modern Warfare 2 isn't that great for multiplayer on PC compared to Xbox 360 and PS3. Final Fantasy XIII is slated to release in March so I'm definitely going to want to check that out on PS3 so I think I'm going to get one of the new slim PS3's for Christmas and just forget about gaming on PC's any more.

But the graphics are SOOOOO much better for PC.
One word:
Anti-aliasing
 
First benchmarks are out on the i5 and i7 860 based 27" iMacs: http://www.macworld.com/article/143970/2009/11/core15_imac.html

tldr - In most benchmarks the i5 and i7 iMacs usually match or exceed those of the significantly more expensive quad and octo-core i7 Xeons in the Mac Pros. Granted, the Mac Pros haven't been updated since the Nehalems first dropped, but neither have i7 Xeon workstations by Dell or HP with comparable specs and prices. Their value was questionable to me before and now I really don't see the point in getting one unless you really need a PCI slot or absolute shitloads of RAM. Internal hard drives are a non-factor to me since external FW800 drives or networked storage will also do the job.

This is kind of a big thing considering that the iMac's display alone would likely cost $1500 by Dell if they offered it (their 30" display with lower specs sells for $1700), and you're getting a fast computer on top of everything. Its an insane value considering the components you're getting.

At first I thought it would at least be a good display for those with high end systems by using target display mode and using it as a pure monitor, now I think it will be the high end system itself. Apple wasn't kidding during the last earnings call when they said that they would have lower profit margins on a new product, geez.
 
Impressive resolutions, compared to my current one of 2048 x 1152, don't have that kind of money to throw around for something that would literally only get used as a screen.
 
Impressive resolutions, compared to my current one of 2048 x 1152, don't have that kind of money to throw around for something that would literally only get used as a screen.

And you'd likely have a lot of trouble even getting it to work as that:

http://www.hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=1462524

Until they have more adaptors, or ones that work better with a wider variety of graphics cards, I'm going to hold off.

I have spent considerable time playing with these at work, and the screens are every bit as impressive as they say. I did not major in photography, but I minored in it. I have used some top notch displays, and this is among the finest for color reproduction an viewing angles. But one area where it leaves most in the dust is pixel density. The images and text on this thing are so sharp and clear. I would love to do some of my editing on it, but I am not going to get one until there's an easier, more reliable way to use it as a display for my current i7 rig as well. With 12GB of RAM, a 4.0GHz CPU, a blu-ray burner, and two black edition WD hard drives in RAID-0, it still trumps the iMac substantially in HD video editing power. I would use the iMac computer for daily tasks, but when it's time to work, I would absolutely want to use my 27" S-IPS on my GTX 295 as well, and until more video cards work, or they come up with some kind of DVI to display port adaptor that's actually really universal, I can't make that kind of investment.

I would totally be willing to, though, if it wasn't causing so much trouble. $1200 of its value vaporizes if I can only use it as a display for my mac laptop...
 
SirKronan - Wish I'd seen that thread before: http://www.atlona.com/Atlona-DVI-to-Mini-DisplayPort-Converter-p-17859.html

Reviews I've read haven't had any issues with any Macs or PCs that they tested without Mini-DP ports. Some of the new ATI 5870 cards also come with Mini-DP ports.

As for work, my two year old 2.8ghz C2D iMac is fine for Final Cut Studio. The only reason I'm considering the new 27" machines are the display. Considering that the new i7 860 iMacs blow past even the Mac Pros with quad-core i7 Xeons (which are about as fast as or marginally faster than your i7 920) as well as the octo-core i7 Xeons (wow) in most benchmarks, I wouldn't worry for a moment about horsepower. This isn't a web/email machine by any stretch.

Software would be the only concern. If you're locked into the workflow of a different editing suite (no idea if you use Avid or Vegas) then there'd be less incentive to switch over to Final Cut Studio. As it stands, there are options for plugging other machines into that display, with more on the way.
 

Except for:

"Supports High Resolutions up to 1920x1200"

I would want my PC to use its native resolution as well. And honestly, I'd like to see it work with an nVidia based DVI output as well. The only reports I've been able to find where people at least sound convincing (I have yet to see pics :p) are using ATI hardware, 4000 series or newer, it seems. I would actually be happy if someone posted something new where this is working better now, especially with an nVidia card. And I'd like it to work with an adaptor cheaper than $150 ... $100 would even be reasonable, but $150 is pushing it.
 
Except for:

"Supports High Resolutions up to 1920x1200"

I would want my PC to use its native resolution as well. And honestly, I'd like to see it work with an nVidia based DVI output as well. The only reports I've been able to find where people at least sound convincing (I have yet to see pics :p) are using ATI hardware, 4000 series or newer, it seems. I would actually be happy if someone posted something new where this is working better now, especially with an nVidia card. And I'd like it to work with an adaptor cheaper than $150 ... $100 would even be reasonable, but $150 is pushing it.

The part that troubles me is that you have to have the PC turned on to use the monitor. Unless I'm misunderstanding it, that means that if I wanted to use the iMac as a monitor, I'd still have to run the iMac Computer, which is not what I expected.
 
I'm just not understanding the move to 16/9. Don't get me wrong thats a killer display but what market segment is this aimed for? I'm sorry I just don't get the point of a 16/9 monitor for a machine that does actual work.
 
I'm just not understanding the move to 16/9. Don't get me wrong thats a killer display but what market segment is this aimed for? I'm sorry I just don't get the point of a 16/9 monitor for a machine that does actual work.


But the graphics are SOOOOO much better for PC.
One word:
Anti-aliasing

You for got about high res textures, better controls, and most importantly MODS.
 
I'm just not understanding the move to 16/9. Don't get me wrong thats a killer display but what market segment is this aimed for? I'm sorry I just don't get the point of a 16/9 monitor for a machine that does actual work.

Perhaps it's because so much film work is done on these displays and much of that (especially on TV) is 16x9.

Just a guess. I don't see it has a major stumbling block. It's still a seriously high resolution display. I have other quibbles about the display, but that definitely isn't one of them.
 
Perhaps it's because so much film work is done on these displays and much of that (especially on TV) is 16x9.

Just a guess. I don't see it has a major stumbling block. It's still a seriously high resolution display. I have other quibbles about the display, but that definitely isn't one of them.

Makes sense I guess, it's not just apple I just don't understand the move away from 16x10.
 
Except for:

"Supports High Resolutions up to 1920x1200"

Good catch, looks like the device is currently only really useful for 24" displays or lower.

As for newer cards, ATI has had a massive headstart on their next generation of video cards, which is why they have mini-DP connectors available. I suspect that nvidia will get on board with mini-DP outputs by the time Fermi drops, which will hopefully make devices like Atlona's adapter irrelevant.
 
Back
Top