Exploding MacBook Batteries Are Never Fun

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
We’ve seen enough exploderized Macbook batteries in our time that one more shouldn't be a big deal. Right? Wrong! Imagine this thing sitting in your lap when it popped, that scare the crap out of you. Hit the link for the whole story and a lot more pictures.
 
MBP instructions manual:

To insure safe usage of your MacBook Pro please Do the following when turning it on.


Plug Mag-safe Adapter into wall socket.
Put on 100% UVA/UVB Shades on.
Insert Mag-safe Connector into Mag-safe Well.
Do Safety Dance.
Have Children.
Buy iPhones for Children.
Precede with normal use.
 
Originally Posted by Engadget
and we've also seen a similar amount of volatility over on the PC side.

Telsa does note, however, that the battery was third-party and was bought on eBay, so it may not be an authentic IBM pack at all.
 
Man. Having one of those explode next to the boys is a scary thought indeed. :eek:
 
Doesn't seem that bad at all, atleast not that bad compared to the IBM thinkpad from 2006(looked to be around a pre-2004 model though.)
 
nvidia_tablet_jen.jpg

"But, but, but Apple technology is superior!!! This must have been caused by an Intel or ATI product!!! You wanna piece of me, biotch???!!!"
 
Damnit, why can't we edit our posts for stupid mistakes on Front Page News? My post above was supposed to be quoting IronChef's post. I'm done ranting now. :(

nvidia_tablet_jen.jpg

"But, but, but Apple technology is superior!!! This must have been caused by an Intel or ATI product!!! You wanna piece of me, biotch???!!!"
 
You can bet he carries that bottle of water around everywhere, so he can quickly extinguish his exploding Apple products.
 
Likes the OP says, its not just a Mac problem, its a problem with just about anything that uses batteries these days. I think were just demanding to much from the batteries and are paying for it with the increased risk to property damage and bodily harm.

Well, there is one aspect of this that IS a Mac problem.

If we're "demanding too much" from the batteries, then obviously the hardware wasn't designed correctly within tolerances. A battery is pretty much there to do one simple job: Hold power and discharge it according to need.

Unless that battery is defective or damaged, it will continue to do that until it can no longer hold a charge. Of the many devices I've ever seen, handled, owned, I've NEVER seen batteries behave like the bloating pillow batteries that Macs seem infested with unless they had been physically mangled... What's surprising is the number of pictures of bloated battery packs in units that look as good as new. (Ie, they never left the desk)

I still have yet for someone to tell me why it's a good thing that nearly every Apple product now has a non-user serviceable battery that requires it to be send in to be replaced in order for the warranty to be kept... especially when you consider that once a battery bloats, it's considered to be a fire hazard... and sending hazardous materials in the mail is illegal. Sure, my Sansa has a battery that can't be replaced (fuckers!), but consider the capacity and discharge potential of an 8 hour unibody MacBook battery. If a 3300mAh battery can cause a unit to burst into flames... I'd hate to see what a 6600 or higher can do to your crotch.

There's also horrible decisions to supply new laptops with power bricks that cannot provide enough power for the unit to run at full speed with the battery removed... ( http://www.engadget.com/2008/11/22/macbook-and-macbookpro-suffer-performance-anxiety-once-the-batt/ ) - Putting further unnecessary wear and tear on a battery. Yes, this means even when on AC 24/7, your battery is still being drained.

So again. How is a unibody with a battery that can't be taken out with one push of a latch a good thing? I also wonder what wonderful things will happen to the hardware itself. Bloating battery, unibody case, pressure, cracking more components because turning a laptop into a disposable product is revolutionary.

Maybe I'm just lucky, but I've never bought a product that was ever subject to a battery recall. I know the majority of the defects were due to a massive bad batch of Sony batteries, but Apple is STILL dealing with this problem? Yeah, it's something else when you can get more reliable third party knockoffs.
 
<Apple>

This was caused by a PC user. No Apple user could have had that happen. And no Apple hardware ever fails by itself. Never. So it was user error. And we're deleting this thread from our not-support forum (since nothing ever goes wrong with any Apple product, ever) so we don't have to deal with reality. So there NYAH!

</Apple>
 
I wonder if Apple threatened anyone or tried to have the product sent in for "analysis" to keep this under wraps?


Iphones batteries
Ipods batteries
MacBook batteries


Perhaps apple should find a new battery manufacturer???
 
Just want to put in my 2 cents as this happened to my non-unibody 17" MacBook Pro.

It's more of a slow bulge than an explosion. It took several months for the battery to get to the point where it was noticeably bulging and, in fact, I didn't even realize there was a problem until the computer started shutting off instead of gently reminding me to plug in my computer once the battery was low (< 10 minutes of charge).

I was still under AppleCare warranty, so once they saw the bulge they replaced my battery with no questions asked at the store. In my opinion, for a $2500+ laptop purchase, it's worth it to get some extended warranty, regardless of whether or not it's a PC or a Mac. If you're talking about desktops that's a whole other issue... Laptops are much harder to self-service due to form factor.

As far as the PC vs. Mac thing here -- this does seem to be a problem with Mac batteries. It might be a manufacturing thing, it might be an Apple thing. Who knows? I personally haven't ever seen a PC laptop battery do this, but by that same token, when my original battery was working and once I got my new replacement battery, I also haven't had a laptop battery that worked as well as my MacBook battery.

Also, I believe the non-removable batteries in the new unibody are of a different strain then the ones that are dying due to "the bulge." That said, the unibody batteries have only been out for a little while, so they may have their own set of problems. Personally, for a 6-8 hour charge I don't mind sacrificing removability. I'm sure if they can figure out a way to make the unibody laptops with a replaceable battery without fucking up the structural integrity of the chassis, they will. Especially if you guys keep bitching about it. :D

At the end of the day, if Apple is to blame for the battery dying, go to the Apple store and pick the freshest-faced looking Genius and they will be nice to you.
 
Yay.. glad to see some things never change (Apple's blowing up). Oh.. and hello again all, I'm back after an extended leave.
 
What, you really think this guy has enough of a clue to know that? By the way, he's not Chinese, he just looks that way since the 'accident'.
 
The above was meant to be in reply to "Water on an electrical/chemical fire, splendid idea". Damn, no edit!
 
Personally, for a 6-8 hour charge I don't mind sacrificing removability. I'm sure if they can figure out a way to make the unibody laptops with a replaceable battery without fucking up the structural integrity of the chassis, they will. Especially if you guys keep bitching about it. :D

At the end of the day, if Apple is to blame for the battery dying, go to the Apple store and pick the freshest-faced looking Genius and they will be nice to you.

You're over 200 miles away from the nearest Apple Store. Your battery is bulging or giving you problems, it doesn't hold a charge and there's pressure building up in your case. You have a unibody. You can't mail it in for warranty because the unit is now considered to be hazardous. What do you do?

Yeah. There is NOTHING that will ever convince me that a non user-removable battery in very high capacities (high enough to explode in fire if ruptured due to energy density, something very likely to happen if it's tightly sealed in with other components nearby) would ever be a good idea.

Apple can go fuck themselves for trying to bring the disposable products concept to something as expensive as a laptop. You paid HOW much for a system you have to mail in to get a battery swap done, keep the warranty, and you won't even get the same unit back? HELLO?

Protip: You DON'T have to sacrifice the ability to swap out battery packs to get one that will last for 8 hour batteries. I picked up a 9 cell for my netbook. Sure, it raises it a little bit in the rear, but at least I don't have to worry about losing my entire system if the battery pack starts looking a little plump.
 
You're over 200 miles away from the nearest Apple Store. Your battery is bulging or giving you problems, it doesn't hold a charge and there's pressure building up in your case. You have a unibody. You can't mail it in for warranty because the unit is now considered to be hazardous. What do you do?

You're over 200 miles away from the nearest laptop battery store. Your battery is bulging or giving you problems, it doesn't hold a charge and there's pressure building up in your case. You have a removable battery, but you can't mail it in for warranty because the unit is now considered to be hazardous. What do you do?

So, in the case of the MacBook, you... Nearest Apple store, walk in, they replace it, and you walk out. At the worst, you have to hop online or make a phone call if you can't get to a store.

In the case of most PCs you... Hop online or make a phone call, because there is no Acer store, or HP store, or Compaq store. You don't even have the option of handling this in person.

The fan in my MacBook went out the other day. Some issue with the bearings or somesuch thing. It still ran fine, but it got warm. So I called up the Apple store, walked in, and they took, and fixed it. No hassle, no charge. This isn't even a MacBook I bought new. I bought it used a few months back. No issues with getting it fixed whatsoever. The staff at the Genius Bar were nice, accommodating, and professional. It was, hands down, the best experience I've ever had with customer support from any computer manufacturer.

But hey, my MacBook has a removable battery, so maybe I have no perspective on this.
 
You're over 200 miles away from the nearest laptop battery store. Your battery is bulging or giving you problems, it doesn't hold a charge and there's pressure building up in your case. You have a removable battery, but you can't mail it in for warranty because the unit is now considered to be hazardous. What do you do?

So, in the case of the MacBook, you... Nearest Apple store, walk in, they replace it, and you walk out. At the worst, you have to hop online or make a phone call if you can't get to a store.

In the case of most PCs you... Hop online or make a phone call, because there is no Acer store, or HP store, or Compaq store. You don't even have the option of handling this in person.

The fan in my MacBook went out the other day. Some issue with the bearings or somesuch thing. It still ran fine, but it got warm. So I called up the Apple store, walked in, and they took, and fixed it. No hassle, no charge. This isn't even a MacBook I bought new. I bought it used a few months back. No issues with getting it fixed whatsoever. The staff at the Genius Bar were nice, accommodating, and professional. It was, hands down, the best experience I've ever had with customer support from any computer manufacturer.

But hey, my MacBook has a removable battery, so maybe I have no perspective on this.

In the case of an HP laptop that was affected by the warranty recall some 4 or 5 years ago... My friend called the number, they shipped him a new battery after he read off the serial on his unit, they told him to dispose of the faulty battery properly and use the new one instead.

Soooooooo.. Yeah. What good is it gonna do if you have a MacBook WITHOUT the removable battery? Put a screwdriver to that thing, you void the warranty. Can't mail it in because it's now considered hazardous materials and you could be in bumfuck middle of nowhere and not within reasonable distance to an Apple store.

Protip: The post you responded to specifically stated "You have a unibody." So thanks for your pointless response.
 
Back
Top