Developer Puts Own Game On Torrent Sites

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
RedLynx, developer of the insanely addicting game Trials HD, actually performed a preemptive strike against pirates by putting its own game on popular torrent sites themselves. If you’ve never tried the game, I recommend downloading the PC demo or grab the demo on XBL, it is a great game.

We all know the timeless adage: "If you can't beat them, then think of cleverer ways to entice them, then break down their spirits, showing them the error of their ways, which will ultimately lead to you beating them." Developer RedLynx employed this strategy when trying to make a foothold in the piracy-riddled PC gaming market when it released its motorbike platformer, Trials, last year.
 
So if I'm not interested with the leaderboarrd feature, is it legal to download the game from torrent?
 
Damnit I wanted to be the first one to do this...
Because seriously, I'm leaking my game before it is released anywhere if it happened to be released for a price.
 
So if I'm not interested with the leaderboarrd feature, is it legal to download the game from torrent?


I think it would be very hard for them to prove they condone it, especially if its a legitimate copy and not just something that says "what the F are you doing?" the whole time.
 
I don't think it's a terrible idea.

Games like th recent Nation Red, for example, or the older Crimsonland are fun to play offline, but the whole point of those games is to get a high score. If you have no leaderboards, you can't tell if the 5 million points you're making means you're good or you're terrible.

What makes these games fun is the replayability. You're constantly trying new ways to beat your score or other people's scores. It's not a big deal in games like Halo, Call of Duty or TF2 (I play TF2 all the time, I do top the scoreboard most rounds, but I don't care about overall stats or all-time high scores in that game)...but in arcade games, leaderboards matter and online features in general are very important.

It's completely safe to assume that if someone enjoys your game and wants to play it online with friends or strangers, they'll buy it. It works - I've done it with many games and I have no regrets about supporting those developers.
 
preemptive strike against pirates

hardly pre-emptive in any sense, groups will still release it, and it is not like torrent your own game will stop or prove anything either.
 
If you can't beat them, then think of cleverer ways to entice them, then break down their spirits, showing them the error of their ways, which will ultimately lead to you beating them.

I thought it was, "if you can't beat them, join them," but I guess this works too...:p
 
You know, back in the day when people "REALLY" liked something, they'd buy it. For example, when people liked Zelda, they'd buy it, and the lunch box, and the Cereal, and Zelda chewing gum.

Today they make games like Halo 3, and they do have the Halo 3 Cereal, soda, and chewing gum. Halo 3 is an O.K. game, but it's got nothing on Zelda Link to the past.

It's like they're pumping out the merchandise before they certainly know you like their product. At least, if the game was truly good, you'd buy it at least right? Right?
 
You know, back in the day when people "REALLY" liked something, they'd buy it. For example, when people liked Zelda, they'd buy it, and the lunch box, and the Cereal, and Zelda chewing gum.

Today they make games like Halo 3, and they do have the Halo 3 Cereal, soda, and chewing gum. Halo 3 is an O.K. game, but it's got nothing on Zelda Link to the past.

It's like they're pumping out the merchandise before they certainly know you like their product. At least, if the game was truly good, you'd buy it at least right? Right?
Don't know if I really see where you are going with that...but as for the last statement, not if you can get it free. Try before you buy is how some look at it like myself, and yes, if the game is genuinely good, Mass Effect for example, I buy it. However...I haven't bought some games that I wanted to like Warhead simply because I haven't remembered at the time I had money or just don't have money. A lot of people aren't like that though.
 
Many people if they can get it for free and they wont get caught, would, i am sure even many people on here who hate pirates, would or already do download things of some sort they should otherwise pay with.

Because it happens in the comfort of your own home, it doesnt feel wrong, not like walking into a store and taking a copy of a game, worrying about camera's, and security and so on.
 
Anyone else think he's just giving himself too much credit?

Obviously. I honestly don't know what he is trying to do...allowing people to get the game easier? Lol...

Many people if they can get it for free and they wont get caught, would, i am sure even many people on here who hate pirates, would or already do download things of some sort they should otherwise pay with.

Because it happens in the comfort of your own home, it doesnt feel wrong, not like walking into a store and taking a copy of a game, worrying about camera's, and security and so on.

But...walking in the store and taking something isn't the same thing.
 
Obviously. I honestly don't know what he is trying to do...allowing people to get the game easier? Lol...



But...walking in the store and taking something isn't the same thing.

LOL exactly..

idk how anyone rationalizes DLin somthing to jacking something physical from the store
check with your local PD if you dont believe me and see if they'll arrest you for downloading a movie from teh web vs stealing one from walmart...looool
 
I would advocate more of a system where demand for the game dictates the price of the game. The more people that get the game, the more it will cost. As demand rises, so does the price. That idea is great, although I also realize there are a number of flaws with it. It's a lot like asking people to pay what they feel they should for a game, it just never quite works out the way it is supposed to. In the end, people in general are just greedy bastards and want everything for free and don't really care about the developer. Sure they might say all sorts of good things about the developer after they have pirated and played their game, but they still aren't shelling out the money to support the game.

How this relates to a developer theoretically "pirating" his own game? Perhaps he is trying to win over some of the hearts of those that download the game, like it, but just never get up the nerve to pay for it. Perhaps he feels he can convert a few of those people over and thus win some small victory out of it.
 
LOL exactly..

idk how anyone rationalizes DLin somthing to jacking something physical from the store
check with your local PD if you dont believe me and see if they'll arrest you for downloading a movie from teh web vs stealing one from walmart...looool

Actually illegally downloading something, and walking into a store and stealing something, is pretty much the same thing. Both are active acts of theft. It is simply easier to prove physically stealing something than it is to prove electronically stealing something.
 
Actually illegally downloading something, and walking into a store and stealing something, is pretty much the same thing. Both are active acts of theft. It is simply easier to prove physically stealing something than it is to prove electronically stealing something.

No, its more like walking to a black market and being given the merchandise. They won't tell the police as long as you don't. As long as you tell no one you have it and where you got it you will be most likely not get caught.

Its when you share the information back is when you will get caught. Kazaa, Napster, anyone?
 
When something is stolen (i.e. taking a physical copy from a store), the legal owner no longer has that thing. Illegal downloading copies the thing, and thus the owner does not loose the thing itself and can continue using/selling it. Since physical goods cannot be trivially copied, the analogy between stealing physical goods and illegal downloading breaks down. In both cases (theft vs. copyright infringment) the owner the potential sale price; however, in the case of theft the owner also loses the physical item itself.
 
Obviously. I honestly don't know what he is trying to do...allowing people to get the game easier? Lol...



But...walking in the store and taking something isn't the same thing.

i know it isnt, i am just saying, in your home you don't have to worry about camera's, guards and alarm machines, why many people who do it, dont feel it is wrong to download content.
 
LOL exactly..

idk how anyone rationalizes DLin somthing to jacking something physical from the store
check with your local PD if you dont believe me and see if they'll arrest you for downloading a movie from teh web vs stealing one from walmart...looool

i am vary aware of it nor was i myself rationalizing it, i know the difference between theft and copyright infringement, if they were the same thing, they would not of made seperate laws for either. Pending which dictionary you choose to believe how ever can explain theft in a manner that is obtaining something to which you otherwise would not have, but i dont think we need to get into the debate on theft vs copyright infringement, it has been covered to bloody death! over and over on [H]
 
No, no it's not.

Yes, yes it most definitely is, but thank you for sharing your insightful information on how they are different.

No, its more like walking to a black market and being given
the merchandise. They won't tell the police as long as you don't. As long as you tell no one you have it and where you got it you will be most likely not get caught.

Its when you share the information back is when you will get caught. Kazaa, Napster, anyone?

And that makes it less illegal how? They are both illegal, they are both stealing. It is amazing how warped people's morality has become in this time and age.
 
"How warped people's morality has become".. really?

I'd like you to show me any evidence that pirating has negative effects on society. There are only two possible "victims": The overpaid and undeserving artist.. or the price fixing and profiteering organizations that own the rights to the artist.
 
So has there been any study that shows if the average 'pirate' or whatever was not able to download the game, due to whatever tactics or simply he couldn't find it, that he actually goes out and buys the game? I would hazard a guess that he doesn't...and if this is actually the case, how does he cost the developer money...he wouldn't have bought the game anyway! He might just be a -try-before--he-buys person who downloads the game and plays it for a day before uninstalling it...
 
Yes, yes it most definitely is, but thank you for sharing your insightful information on how they are different.

If by "my information" you mean minor facts such as the legal or dictionary definition, or the fact that no one has ever been charged for theft in regards to piracy.

but, no, keep up that ignorance there champ. The **AA rely on the stupid masses to push their point.
 
"How warped people's morality has become".. really?

I'd like you to show me any evidence that pirating has negative effects on society. There are only two possible "victims": The overpaid and undeserving artist.. or the price fixing and profiteering organizations that own the rights to the artist.

You just proved his statement by your reply.

Stealing is stealing, just because you arn't physically taking an object doesn't make you less of a crook. He is talking about morality not legality and how people justify the stealing because in their mind they arnt hurting anyone while doing it.

Im not saying I havn't or don't pirate, im just saying that I admit that what I did was stealing while you and the others think what you are doing is fine and dandy.
 
So has there been any study that shows if the average 'pirate' or whatever was not able to download the game, due to whatever tactics or simply he couldn't find it, that he actually goes out and buys the game? I would hazard a guess that he doesn't...and if this is actually the case, how does he cost the developer money...he wouldn't have bought the game anyway! He might just be a -try-before--he-buys person who downloads the game and plays it for a day before uninstalling it...

I agree with the studies. But tell me how not costing the developer money has anything to do with stealing?

We are not debating the severity of the act, but about the act that you are doing.
 
If by "my information" you mean minor facts such as the legal or dictionary definition, or the fact that no one has ever been charged for theft in regards to piracy.

but, no, keep up that ignorance there champ. The **AA rely on the stupid masses to push their point.

Umm, that is because software piracy has its own set of laws, and yes, they are also based around theft:

Copyright Act, Title 17 of the U.S. Code
Digital Millienium Copyright Act
No Electronic Theft Act

Plus there was just a whole news report of a person being caught and facing penalties and possibly jail time for getting advanced copies of Modern Warfare 2 and selling them. So yes, your ignorance is amazing. You think just because people aren't charged with "theft" in the conventional sense that it is any less illegal, that is absurd. That is like saying it less illegal for someone to run someone over with a car than it is for them to beat them to death just because they may use different charges when taking them to court.
 
I agree with the studies. But tell me how not costing the developer money has anything to do with stealing?

We are not debating the severity of the act, but about the act that you are doing.

How about the fact that you are taking a product and using it without paying for it? That is the very definition of stealing.

steal
  /stil/ Show Spelled Pronunciation [steel] Show IPA ,verb, stole, sto⋅len, steal⋅ing, noun
–verb (used with object)
1. to take (the property of another or others) without permission or right, esp. secretly or by force: A pickpocket stole his watch.
2. to appropriate (ideas, credit, words, etc.) without right or acknowledgment.
 
How about the fact that you are taking a product and using it without paying for it? That is the very definition of stealing.

steal
  /stil/ Show Spelled Pronunciation [steel] Show IPA ,verb, stole, sto⋅len, steal⋅ing, noun
–verb (used with object)
1. to take (the property of another or others) without permission or right, esp. secretly or by force: A pickpocket stole his watch.
2. to appropriate (ideas, credit, words, etc.) without right or acknowledgment.

Wow, you don't know the meaning of the word "take"? lol.
 
Umm, that is because software piracy has its own set of laws, and yes, they are also based around theft:

Copyright Act, Title 17 of the U.S. Code
Digital Millienium Copyright Act
No Electronic Theft Act

Plus there was just a whole news report of a person being caught and facing penalties and possibly jail time for getting advanced copies of Modern Warfare 2 and selling them. So yes, your ignorance is amazing. You think just because people aren't charged with "theft" in the conventional sense that it is any less illegal, that is absurd. That is like saying it less illegal for someone to run someone over with a car than it is for them to beat them to death just because they may use different charges when taking them to court.

That's nice. Maybe you should look into what you're talking about?

An equation of copyright infringement with theft was denounced in the United States Supreme Court case Dowling v. United States

I guess we can add the Supreme Court to the list of people you know more then.
 
Wow, you don't know the meaning of the word "take"? lol.

Actually you are the one that doesn't understand the definition of the word "take". Perhaps you should look up the myriad of definitions for "take". By pirating software you are taking a product that you have not paid for, with the intent to use or distribute. You are not being given the software.

That's nice. Maybe you should look into what you're talking about?



I guess we can add the Supreme Court to the list of people you know more then.

Umm, so perhaps you need to study more on how the courts work?

An equation of copyright infringement with theft was denounced in the United States Supreme Court case Dowling v. United States (1985).

The NET act was in 1997.

Prior to the enactment of the NET Act in 1997, copyright infringement for a non-commercial purpose was apparently not punishable by criminal prosecution, although non-commercial infringers could be sued in a civil action by the copyright holder to recover damages.
[/Quote]

Yeah, I am special, I can wikipedia too, only I actually read the information and timeline... Perhaps you need to go back and look at your timeline. But then again, I guess because I actually research deeper rather than just spouting off nonsense, that makes internet wizards like you more knowledgeable than me. Also, the Supreme Court decides on issues based on specific cases and events, that doesn't mean those will always hold up in the future. The Supreme Court does NOT make laws, they interpret them. But hey, I am sure you know better right?
 
RedLynx, developer of the insanely addicting game Trials HD, actually performed a preemptive strike against pirates by putting its own game on popular torrent sites themselves. If you’ve never tried the game, I recommend downloading the PC demo or grab the demo on XBL, it is a great game.

Yeah, yeah piracy riddled PC games market...how many XBL accounts were banned recently for piracy again?

If I like the demo of a game, I buy it, if they have not provided a demo, that normally means it's crap, or they want you to buy the game that cannot be traded in or returned, so I avoid those, and there are people that will resort to downloading a pirated copy to try the game out, but that's just a minority.
 
Yeah, I am special, I can wikipedia too, only I actually read the information and timeline... Perhaps you need to go back and look at your timeline. But then again, I guess because I actually research deeper rather than just spouting off nonsense, that makes internet wizards like you more knowledgeable than me. Also, the Supreme Court decides on issues based on specific cases and events, that doesn't mean those will always hold up in the future. The Supreme Court does NOT make laws, they interpret them. But hey, I am sure you know better right?

I find it amusing that you didn't even bother to read the wiki... Or maybe you just forgot what you were arguing? I said nothing about piracy being legal and you seem to like spewing garbage about piracy laws.

What does any of that have to do with the fact that piracy is not the same as stealing or theft? Stabbing someone in the face is illegal too, does that make it stealing?

The Supreme court agreed that the goods were not "stolen, converted or taken by fraud". The fact that they also made piracy illegal has nothing to do with whether piracy is stealing.
 
what is piracy? stealing
/discussion

I think this is where we insert the joke about the Patriot Act, Wire-tapping, Information Gathering and don't admit to piracy or pro-piracy beliefs over public internet forums readable by anyone??

Piracy is 'bad' and 'wrong' and I would never ever do it, have done it or nor do I endorse it. ;)
 
You just proved his statement by your reply.

Stealing is stealing, just because you arn't physically taking an object doesn't make you less of a crook. He is talking about morality not legality and how people justify the stealing because in their mind they arnt hurting anyone while doing it.

Im not saying I havn't or don't pirate, im just saying that I admit that what I did was stealing while you and the others think what you are doing is fine and dandy.

At what point did I say I pirate? Who are you to point fingers at people as "criminals" that "steal", because they have a differing opinion than yours on a polarizing subject.

If you paid closer attention to what I had said, at no point did I argue that piracy is not "stealing". I more or less voiced my opinion that even if you were "stealing", you're "stealing" from a select group of people that haven't earned the profits they're receiving off of their "property" in the first place.
 
Actually illegally downloading something, and walking into a store and stealing something, is pretty much the same thing. Both are active acts of theft.
No, no they're not.

When you physically steal something, you're stealing it from someone who doesn't want you to have it for free. When you steal, you have the item and they do not anymore. They lose money because they wanted to sell that item.

When you download, you're downloading a copy from people who want you to have it for free, not from the original developers/publishers/owners. Also, by getting a copy of it, you do not hinder their ability to use their original copy of said file. It literally does not affect their ability to use that file in any way. It only potentially affects their possible sales numbers.

They are in no way the same. That's why downloading ANYTHING is not stealing. Just like taking a picture of a secret document is not stealing...and just like making a physical copy of a car yourself is not car theft. It's stealing someone's idea/concept, but they still have their car and they can do everything they could before with it, except now you have one too.
 
Back
Top